LorenzoL

Now that I know how the elimination process works, you can choose the two people that you think are going home tomorrow night.

I left Ace Young and Taylor Hicks from the poll.

http://www.idolonfox.com/contestants/

Charlie Goose

I can't imagine that Kevin Covais is going to make the top 6 guys. Not nearly good enough so far.


Kevin Covais

Struz

I think the guys are a stronger group then the girls this year.
I guy will win this year.

mphtrilogy

I thought we saw 5 girls who could win it last night in Pickler, Tucker, Mcgee, Mandisa and Paris. Thats pretty strong

Other than Ace and Hicks, I don't know if we will have that depth with the guys.

But thats what makes this show fun.

Goldberg74

Simon will take an immediate liking to Elliot... he's got British teeth!

Groucho

I voted Bobby and Bucky, simply because they haven't gotten the same exposure as some of the other contestants.

SBatL8y

I like Taylor Hicks. I think he's awesome, and so original. Who cares that he isn't like everyone else. I also think Kevin Covais has an awesome voice. But I doubt either of them will win cause they're not "Idol" material.

raven56706

i hope taylor hicks does well....

Dr. Henry Jones, Jr.

who are the replacements for the twins that got kicked out?

Struz

They didn't make the top 12 for the guys. No replacement was needed.

Dr. Henry Jones, Jr.

that's a shame, they were such nice guys

raven56706

according to their jailed inmate friends

zuffy

Before this photo, I was visualizing him as a nerdier Harry Potter.

Iron_Giant

Their attitude bug me from the beginning, they thought everyone owed them something.

It was weird when someone was let go in Hollywood, then the twins told him that they would take care of him and get him into the music world - I always thought that was a strange comments from them.

Patman

Okay, time for the guys:

Patrick - not bad, definitely a little jumpy in spots for him as well. I know he's got more in the tank, and will make it through to the next week.

Patman

David - awkward performer, makes funny faces when he sings. Probably just too retro-50's for this competition.

tommyp007

David was pretty bad.

chaz k

Loved the first 4 seasons...but this show is getting tough to watch this season. Average talent....and the judges are the same for EVERY performer.

Randy...it was ok dawg not your best dude

Paula.....NEVER critisizes anyone

Simon...Hates everyone

Hopefully things will pick up

FantasticVSDoom

Um, the judges dont make a bit of sense...They say originality is the most important thing, then when someone does something out of the ordinary, they get thrown under the bus. I thought his voice is better than anyones on the show. Everyone else sounds like a billion other people out there. Granted he is pretty goofy, but his voice is pretty smooth.

Patman

Bucky - better song choice, but I thought I would hear that type of performance from a lot of garage southern rock bands.

Patman

Will - good energy, decent vocals, but a middling performance.

Patman

Sway - his falsetto is hideous. This was not the song for his vocal range.

tommyp007

So far, I'm with Simon all the way.

Mok

Sway made my ears bleed, I don't know what the judges(Paula & Randy) are smoking.
The boys have been awful so far.

aktick

Yep, me too. I thought Sway was terrible.