Question about OTA hi-def broadcasts and HDTV tuners
#1
DVD Talk Legend
Thread Starter
Question about OTA hi-def broadcasts and HDTV tuners
I just bought a new DLP set that has a built-in HDTV tuner and gave my older DLP that didn't have a tuner to my parents. My parents are old school and don't want cable. If I get them one of those external HDTV tuners, will they be able to get those over-the-air HD broadcasts from the networks (CBS, ABC, etc.) with their roof antenna? If so any suggestions on one? Thanks
#3
DVD Talk Legend
Join Date: Nov 2001
Location: The Janitor's closet in Kinnick Stadium
Posts: 15,725
Likes: 0
Received 2 Likes
on
2 Posts
On ebay there are tons of Voom receivers. They say they are activated and good for HDTV. Does that mean you just hook it up to the TV and to the antenna and then you will get OTA HDTV for the life of the receiver? I guess I'm confused on what activated means.
#4
DVD Talk Special Edition
Join Date: Oct 1999
Location: Boston, MA
Posts: 1,674
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by matome
I just bought a new DLP set that has a built-in HDTV tuner and gave my older DLP that didn't have a tuner to my parents. My parents are old school and don't want cable. If I get them one of those external HDTV tuners, will they be able to get those over-the-air HD broadcasts from the networks (CBS, ABC, etc.) with their roof antenna? If so any suggestions on one? Thanks
#5
DVD Talk Hero
I also use a Voom box that I bought off ebay for OTA HD (I have Dishnetwork so the only way to get local HD is with OTA - at least for now).
After taking the time to do the initial set up it has the for the most part been trouble free. Some things to keep in mind,
go to antennaweb.org and see how far your signal is, type of antenna you would need, etc.
there is no HD antenna, any antenna will do, but you need to go to antennaweb for a starting point. In general for antenna's, bigger is better, higher is better
for the voom box, it must have been activated before voom went dark. Stay away from any "new in box" units. These won't work. I highly recommend e-mailing the seller and get the newest firmware possible. You cannot update firmware now. Make sure the auction or the seller states that the "unit can scan for local channels". If it is real old firmware you can't scan for channels, meaning it will only work in the area it was initially set up. You also want to make sure it comes with a remote. There are some universal remotes that will work on it, but for the initial set it, it is much easier with the OEM remote.
There is a lot of info on these boxes and it is a cheap way to get into HD
The only issue I have had with mine is the need for the occasional reset. I do this by turning off the unit and unplugging for about 5 minutes and plugging back in. This is needed perhaps once a month. But in my limited experience it happens when I don't use it for while. The more I use it, the less it needs this, or so it seems.
If you don't want to go the Voom route, there was a good deal on a refurbished LG STB with a built in DVD player. Think it was around $180, I'll see if I can find it if you are interested.
After taking the time to do the initial set up it has the for the most part been trouble free. Some things to keep in mind,
go to antennaweb.org and see how far your signal is, type of antenna you would need, etc.
there is no HD antenna, any antenna will do, but you need to go to antennaweb for a starting point. In general for antenna's, bigger is better, higher is better
for the voom box, it must have been activated before voom went dark. Stay away from any "new in box" units. These won't work. I highly recommend e-mailing the seller and get the newest firmware possible. You cannot update firmware now. Make sure the auction or the seller states that the "unit can scan for local channels". If it is real old firmware you can't scan for channels, meaning it will only work in the area it was initially set up. You also want to make sure it comes with a remote. There are some universal remotes that will work on it, but for the initial set it, it is much easier with the OEM remote.
There is a lot of info on these boxes and it is a cheap way to get into HD
The only issue I have had with mine is the need for the occasional reset. I do this by turning off the unit and unplugging for about 5 minutes and plugging back in. This is needed perhaps once a month. But in my limited experience it happens when I don't use it for while. The more I use it, the less it needs this, or so it seems.
If you don't want to go the Voom route, there was a good deal on a refurbished LG STB with a built in DVD player. Think it was around $180, I'll see if I can find it if you are interested.
#6
DVD Talk Legend
Thread Starter
Thansk for all the info guys.
It's a combo of both. They just want to watch stuff like the George Lopez Show and Dancing With The Stars.
Sdallinct, thanks for the antennaweb info. I see Crutchfield has a Samsung tuner for $250, so I may look around and go that route. I've been burned a few times on Ebay and I'm especially leery of electronics purchases through them, particularly when something needs to be set a certain way.
Originally Posted by BobDole42
That should work. Are you parents old school in not wanting cable in that they don't want to pay for it, or they aren't into new technology? If it's the latter, I would think that a cable box is MUCH easier to use to get HD channels than dealing with OTA.
Sdallinct, thanks for the antennaweb info. I see Crutchfield has a Samsung tuner for $250, so I may look around and go that route. I've been burned a few times on Ebay and I'm especially leery of electronics purchases through them, particularly when something needs to be set a certain way.
#8
DVD Talk Godfather
Originally Posted by matome
Sdallinct, thanks for the antennaweb info. I see Crutchfield has a Samsung tuner for $250, so I may look around and go that route. I've been burned a few times on Ebay and I'm especially leery of electronics purchases through them, particularly when something needs to be set a certain way.
#9
DVD Talk Hero
Looks like the LG is OOS right now, but gets pretty good review for both HD STB and DVD player. It evidently goes and comes OOS.
http://www.geeks.com/details.asp?inv...te=LST-3510A-R
http://www.geeks.com/details.asp?inv...te=LST-3510A-R
#10
DVD Talk Legend
Thread Starter
Originally Posted by Spiky
There's a $90 tuner at Radio Shack. User reports have been up and down, but not horrible.
Thanks again for everyone elses suggestions
#11
DVD Talk Hero
Great price, thought about picking one up for another room but not available in my area.
They also show a disnetwork HD DVR for $413 which is pretty darn good, but again not available in my area.
They also show a disnetwork HD DVR for $413 which is pretty darn good, but again not available in my area.
#12
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Join Date: Mar 2002
Location: Mpls, MN
Posts: 6,830
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by matome
Wow, thanks for the heads up on this. According to the RS website it's being discontinued, but is still available in some stores so I ran out and picked one up for the $90 (original sticker was still on the box for $250) and it works great! Build-wise the box is a little chintzy compared to the $500+ boxes out there and the remote has horrid range (it almost needs to be pointed directly at it), but the HD picture is actually damn good for free OTA. HDMI and gold plated connectors were a nice surprise though. I have an extra MX500 remote so I'll program that and give it to them as well.
Thanks again for everyone elses suggestions
Thanks again for everyone elses suggestions
#13
DVD Talk Legend
Thread Starter
Originally Posted by Sdallnct
Great price, thought about picking one up for another room but not available in my area.
#16
Originally Posted by Red Dog
Anyone?
That said, you can get a NEW set top box for $100-200 no problem (and I'm sure you could find cheaper used). This route seems a lot safer (and close to the same price) than hoping you get a correctly activated Voom box off eBay.
#17
DVD Talk God
Join Date: Feb 2000
Location: Directionally Challenged (for DirecTV)
Posts: 130,275
Received 616 Likes
on
495 Posts
Originally Posted by mbs
Just do a search on eBay for completed auctions. It looks like they go for $100 on average (the ones that have the OTA card).
That said, you can get a NEW set top box for $100-200 no problem (and I'm sure you could find cheaper used). This route seems a lot safer (and close to the same price) than hoping you get a correctly activated Voom box off eBay.
That said, you can get a NEW set top box for $100-200 no problem (and I'm sure you could find cheaper used). This route seems a lot safer (and close to the same price) than hoping you get a correctly activated Voom box off eBay.
The cheapest new ones I see on pricegrabber go for at least $150.
#18
Originally Posted by Red Dog
The cheapest new ones I see on pricegrabber go for at least $150.
I ended up with an RCA ATSC21 that I got from amazon for ~$125. It is now selling for $415. And there are many fewer models available. It looks like the market took a U-turn since I last looked. Guess I got lucky and bought at the right time.
#19
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Join Date: Mar 2002
Location: Mpls, MN
Posts: 6,830
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Other than the Radio Shack $90 model that is disappearing, $150 is the lowest price for new I've heard of. You must have gotten quite the deal on Amazon, or a refurb.
#20
DVD Talk Hero
Originally Posted by Red Dog
For the folks who purchased the Voom receivers off ebay, what were your winning bids (not including shipping)?
On my 2nd one, I got the unit with card (no remote, no antenna) for $35
#21
DVD Talk Legend
When I decided to get an HDTV tuner I tried for one of the $90 Radio Shack models, but they were already sold out in my area. I bought the Samsung one for $200 and really love the picture quality and the unit in general. I'm using an indoor antenna and get all the local channels in crystal clear. Considering Time Warner refuses to put Fox on in HD I was glad to finally get to watch some football in HD this season with the OTA box.
#22
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Originally Posted by mbs
Yeah, I just looked and it appears that is the going rate these days. Did manufacturers stop making OTA STBs? I ask because when I was in the market for one (middle of last year), there were many more choices.
I ended up with an RCA ATSC21 that I got from amazon for ~$125. It is now selling for $415. And there are many fewer models available. It looks like the market took a U-turn since I last looked. Guess I got lucky and bought at the right time.
I ended up with an RCA ATSC21 that I got from amazon for ~$125. It is now selling for $415. And there are many fewer models available. It looks like the market took a U-turn since I last looked. Guess I got lucky and bought at the right time.
And you did get lucky - I got an RCA ATSC11 for $122 from an eBay store a couple of months ago, but would've preferred an ATSC21 if it had been about the same price.
#23
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Originally Posted by matome
I just bought a new DLP set that has a built-in HDTV tuner and gave my older DLP that didn't have a tuner to my parents. My parents are old school and don't want cable. If I get them one of those external HDTV tuners, will they be able to get those over-the-air HD broadcasts from the networks (CBS, ABC, etc.) with their roof antenna? If so any suggestions on one? Thanks
Also, you might see some of these STB tuners list having "QAM" in addition to ATSC. QAM is what cable companies are using instead of ATSC to send Hi-Def over cable lines. However, anyone who gets cable can just get a cable box to decode this, so although having it in a STB is nice, but it's not essential and is not something I would recommend paying extra for. (IMO, that is - others may disagree.)
#24
DVD Talk Legend
Thread Starter
OK, just picked up another one of those Radio Shack tuners (floor model only at this store, but they gave me a free 2-year warranty extension) and connected it to a regular TV my parents had in the basement. Now (while it's not HD) the regular broadcast channels come in crystal clear instead of the horrid snowy mess and missing channels that was before. At that price it's a great bargain for those with no cable. My parents are in seventh heaven now!