Can someone explain why did Rebecca sell for over $200????
#1
Senior Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jun 2004
Location: New York
Posts: 317
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Can someone explain why did Rebecca sell for over $200????
#4
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Easy answer. A classic case of a stubborn buyer up against a shill-bidding seller.
noitch0q8g (11) US $200.00 Dec-25-05 18:06:39
noitch0q8g (11) US $195.00 Dec-25-05 18:06:21
noitch0q8g (11) US $187.00 Dec-25-05 18:04:37
noitch0q8g (11) US $180.00 Dec-25-05 18:03:57
noitch0q8g (11) US $170.00 Dec-25-05 12:56:09
noitch0q8g (11) US $160.00 Dec-25-05 11:39:41
noitch0q8g (11) US $150.00 Dec-25-05 11:38:32
noitch0q8g (11) US $140.00 Dec-25-05 11:38:10
noitch0q8g (11) US $130.00 Dec-25-05 03:08:51
noitch0q8g (11) US $120.00 Dec-25-05 00:02:59
noitch0q8g (11) US $110.00 Dec-24-05 23:53:59
noitch0q8g (11) US $100.00 Dec-24-05 20:45:46
noitch0q8g (11) US $90.00 Dec-24-05 20:45:22
noitch0q8g (11) US $85.00 Dec-24-05 20:44:39
noitch0q8g (11) US $80.00 Dec-24-05 20:44:08
noitch0q8g (11) US $75.00 Dec-24-05 11:11:23
They couldn't have been more obvious about it. Shill bidding is agaisnt eBay rules, but I can't blame the seller. The seller pumped up the price of the item against an obviously ignorant buyer. In the words of Canada Bill Jones, it's immoral to let a sucker keep his money. And so the cookie crumbles.
Shill bidding, though, is the answer to your question.
-JP
noitch0q8g (11) US $200.00 Dec-25-05 18:06:39
noitch0q8g (11) US $195.00 Dec-25-05 18:06:21
noitch0q8g (11) US $187.00 Dec-25-05 18:04:37
noitch0q8g (11) US $180.00 Dec-25-05 18:03:57
noitch0q8g (11) US $170.00 Dec-25-05 12:56:09
noitch0q8g (11) US $160.00 Dec-25-05 11:39:41
noitch0q8g (11) US $150.00 Dec-25-05 11:38:32
noitch0q8g (11) US $140.00 Dec-25-05 11:38:10
noitch0q8g (11) US $130.00 Dec-25-05 03:08:51
noitch0q8g (11) US $120.00 Dec-25-05 00:02:59
noitch0q8g (11) US $110.00 Dec-24-05 23:53:59
noitch0q8g (11) US $100.00 Dec-24-05 20:45:46
noitch0q8g (11) US $90.00 Dec-24-05 20:45:22
noitch0q8g (11) US $85.00 Dec-24-05 20:44:39
noitch0q8g (11) US $80.00 Dec-24-05 20:44:08
noitch0q8g (11) US $75.00 Dec-24-05 11:11:23
They couldn't have been more obvious about it. Shill bidding is agaisnt eBay rules, but I can't blame the seller. The seller pumped up the price of the item against an obviously ignorant buyer. In the words of Canada Bill Jones, it's immoral to let a sucker keep his money. And so the cookie crumbles.
Shill bidding, though, is the answer to your question.
-JP
Last edited by NatrlBornThrllr; 12-31-05 at 10:36 PM.
#8
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
Originally Posted by yeldarb367
How closely does eBay monitor that?
If you look, the losing bidder bought another Rebecca on the 29th for $100 from another buyer, it may not have been a shill bidder even though it looks like it.
Nick
#9
Senior Member
Join Date: Feb 2001
Posts: 870
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I don't really see any evidence of shill bidding.
noitch0q8g really wanted this DVD and bid a maximum of $200. patricia-48 came along bidding in $5-10 increments until she went over noitch0q8g's max. A few days later noitch0q8g bid on another copy and won it for $100. Looks legitimate to me.
noitch0q8g really wanted this DVD and bid a maximum of $200. patricia-48 came along bidding in $5-10 increments until she went over noitch0q8g's max. A few days later noitch0q8g bid on another copy and won it for $100. Looks legitimate to me.
#10
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Originally Posted by gfoots
noitch0q8g really wanted this DVD and bid a maximum of $200. patricia-48 came along bidding in $5-10 increments until she went over noitch0q8g's max.
Only actual bids (not automatic bids generated up to a bidder's maximum) are shown
That's not to say that I'm not right in my assumption, though...it very well could just be a case of my skeptical nature getting the best of me. Either way, though, I feel in my "glass is half empty" heart that it was a case of deceptive bidding practices on eBay. There's no other logical explanation, in my opinion, for somebody to bid 16 times on an item that ended up selling for twice the normal going price.
-JP
Last edited by NatrlBornThrllr; 12-31-05 at 10:59 PM.
#11
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Join Date: Jan 2000
Location: Somewhere out there... YES THERE!!!
Posts: 7,936
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Think of this though. Guys has a copy of the CC. He sells it, pushing the bid to 200. He then buys one for 100 a few days later to throw off suspicion so the total = Shill seller has a copy of same movie + 100 dollars for doing nothing. He just made 100 dollars for not doing anything except bidding on his own auction.
#13
Suspended
Join Date: Dec 2005
Posts: 430
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I few days ago I was watching an auction for another sealed Criterion edition of Rebecca and the winning bidder was noitch0q8g, the same guy who sent that Rebecca criterion in the 200 dollar range.
http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll...MEWA%3AIT&rd=1
http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll...MEWA%3AIT&rd=1
#14
Premium Member
Join Date: Jan 2000
Location: Grazing in a field somewhere...
Posts: 23,638
Received 698 Likes
on
466 Posts
Originally Posted by Harry Lime
I few days ago I was watching an auction for another sealed Criterion edition of Rebecca and the winning bidder was noitch0q8g, the same guy who sent that Rebecca criterion in the 200 dollar range.
http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll...MEWA%3AIT&rd=1
http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll...MEWA%3AIT&rd=1
(PS: Sarcasm alert!)
#17
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Originally Posted by glassdragon
Think of this though. Guys has a copy of the CC. He sells it, pushing the bid to 200. He then buys one for 100 a few days later to throw off suspicion so the total = Shill seller has a copy of same movie + 100 dollars for doing nothing. He just made 100 dollars for not doing anything except bidding on his own auction.
-JP
#21
Member
Join Date: Jul 2001
Location: South Florida
Posts: 215
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
So the $23.99 I paid at Best Buy 6 months after release was a real bargin. I recall when the release was announced, that the license held by Criterion was for a limited time. So as soon as I could get the best price I pounced on it. The same thing happened to Notorious and Straw Dogs but copies of both of those can be found for $40 or less so their not nearly as scarce as Rebecca.
#22
DVD Talk Special Edition
As a veteran Ebayer of (mostly) highly collectible and often expensive items of various genres, I can attest that indeed there is a considerable amount of shilling on Ebay. Regardless of whether Ebay forbids it or not, unscrupulous sellers find a way around Ebay's 'watchful' eye, and generally without very much apparent effort. All it takes is one 'new' bidder - with no previous transaction history - and who's to say that they're not legitimate?
The dead giveaway is usually when said new bidder keeps putting in many small increment bids up to just over the current high bid, as opposed to one large bid to 'guarantee' winning a desired item (which is how most serious bidders would proceed), particularly when there are several other auctions of the same item going on at the same time and said bidder has no interest in any of those.
Experienced bidders can usually sniff out these kinds of scams. I usually drop out of an auction as close to the end of it as I can manage when I suspect this sort of thing to burn the seller, and (surprise!) often find that the current high bid is suddenly withdrawn or the item goes back up for auction again by the same seller soon after the first auction ends. I've even had sellers contact me after the auction ended to say that the winning bid was "a non-payer" or an "accidental bid" and offering to sell me the item at my last bid price.
The dead giveaway is usually when said new bidder keeps putting in many small increment bids up to just over the current high bid, as opposed to one large bid to 'guarantee' winning a desired item (which is how most serious bidders would proceed), particularly when there are several other auctions of the same item going on at the same time and said bidder has no interest in any of those.
Experienced bidders can usually sniff out these kinds of scams. I usually drop out of an auction as close to the end of it as I can manage when I suspect this sort of thing to burn the seller, and (surprise!) often find that the current high bid is suddenly withdrawn or the item goes back up for auction again by the same seller soon after the first auction ends. I've even had sellers contact me after the auction ended to say that the winning bid was "a non-payer" or an "accidental bid" and offering to sell me the item at my last bid price.
#23
Senior Member
Join Date: Apr 2005
Posts: 363
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by Sex Fiend
The dead giveaway is usually when said new bidder keeps putting in many small increment bids up to just over the current high bid, as opposed to one large bid to 'guarantee' winning a desired item (which is how most serious bidders would proceed), particularly when there are several other auctions of the same item going on at the same time and said bidder has no interest in any of those.
You'd think, however, that by the time a bidder had 11 feedbacks he/she would be experienced enough to know better. So I just don't know....
#24
DVD Talk Legend
Originally Posted by Ambassador
Except, of course, in the case of inexperienced or naive bidders. I mean, when I made my first few bids on Ebay, I wasn't entirely sure how the system worked, so I went about bidding rather stupidly. So it could just be a case of a particularly un-savvy bidder.
You'd think, however, that by the time a bidder had 11 feedbacks he/she would be experienced enough to know better. So I just don't know....
You'd think, however, that by the time a bidder had 11 feedbacks he/she would be experienced enough to know better. So I just don't know....
If anyone was unsavvy, it was patricia-48. Proxy bidding $202 early in the auction is just begging to be shilled. One look at the bidding history at the time she re-bid should've told her that. That is one of the reasons why sniping is the only way to go.
#25
Cool New Member
Join Date: Jul 2002
Posts: 41
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Hello all,
I am the seller of this item and a dvd talker...funny that you guys are discussing my auction but anyway...
There was NO shill bidding just a couple of motivated buyers, I was as suprised as you were to get that much for the DVD. But guess what, occasionally there are abberations in price and as with any auction the price is what the buyer happens to be willing to pay at the time. The buyer was willing to pay and I was willing to sell, end of story.
I think some of you guys are just a bit paranoid and more than a bit nosy, I don't appreciate being accused of running a scam in any kind of public forum especially when you have no evidence of it.
Oh well, I'm gonna go back to watching Buffy. Have a great day!
I am the seller of this item and a dvd talker...funny that you guys are discussing my auction but anyway...
There was NO shill bidding just a couple of motivated buyers, I was as suprised as you were to get that much for the DVD. But guess what, occasionally there are abberations in price and as with any auction the price is what the buyer happens to be willing to pay at the time. The buyer was willing to pay and I was willing to sell, end of story.
I think some of you guys are just a bit paranoid and more than a bit nosy, I don't appreciate being accused of running a scam in any kind of public forum especially when you have no evidence of it.
Oh well, I'm gonna go back to watching Buffy. Have a great day!