DUNE "Extended Edition" real or bootleg?
#1
DVD Talk Special Edition
Thread Starter
Join Date: Oct 1999
Posts: 1,168
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
DUNE "Extended Edition" real or bootleg?
Anyone know about this DVD? This seller has several other items for sale that look a little fishy, I'm guessing it's a bootleg.
http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll...tem=3345518710
http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll...tem=3345518710
#3
Member
Join Date: Nov 2000
Location: Spencer, TN. US
Posts: 184
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Thats crazy when you can buy it at Revok $35. These guys are for real I've bought Jorodowsky films there.
Here's the link to the David Lynch area.
Deleted link to bootleg seller - Static
This is the 3 hour version that had footage added for a TV run. David Lynch protested & had his name removed from this version.
Here's the link to the David Lynch area.
Deleted link to bootleg seller - Static
This is the 3 hour version that had footage added for a TV run. David Lynch protested & had his name removed from this version.
#4
DVD Talk Reviewer
Join Date: Aug 2001
Location: WAS looking for My Own Private Stuckeyville, but stuck in Liberty City (while missing Vice City)
Posts: 15,094
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Don't know about the one on eBay, but i'm willing to bet that one on Revok.com is a boot [not doubting the legitimacy of your Jorodowsky flicks jkcarter], but this is one of the things that make you go
However, I like this one too:
2) Is Revok Film Prodigies illegal pirate operation?
We are definitely not a pirate operation. The section of American copyright law known as "The Berne Act" clearly states: films unreleased in the United States, including original version of films altered and/or edited for release in the United States, are not protected by American copyright; thus, they are considered public domain. The entire purpose of our company is to provide (otherwise unavailable) films to movie fans. We do not offer videos owned by American releasing companies. If a film should become available domestically we immediately stop offering it to our clients.
We are definitely not a pirate operation. The section of American copyright law known as "The Berne Act" clearly states: films unreleased in the United States, including original version of films altered and/or edited for release in the United States, are not protected by American copyright; thus, they are considered public domain. The entire purpose of our company is to provide (otherwise unavailable) films to movie fans. We do not offer videos owned by American releasing companies. If a film should become available domestically we immediately stop offering it to our clients.
3) How good are the copies?
At the end of each description is a quality out of 10 (10 = mint, 9 = excellent, 8 = very good, 7 = good, 6 = satisfactory, 5 = fair, and we dont sell anything that is "unwatchable".) For most of the films we offer we use the original out-of-print import laserdisc or pre-record (these are the ones rated 10/10). Some of the other videos, because of their rarity, coupled with unavoidable PAL or SeCAM transfer distortions, are less than perfect. However, we guarantee the best available in North America and that our quality estimates are precise or your money back! If you have a specific question about any title contact us!
At the end of each description is a quality out of 10 (10 = mint, 9 = excellent, 8 = very good, 7 = good, 6 = satisfactory, 5 = fair, and we dont sell anything that is "unwatchable".) For most of the films we offer we use the original out-of-print import laserdisc or pre-record (these are the ones rated 10/10). Some of the other videos, because of their rarity, coupled with unavoidable PAL or SeCAM transfer distortions, are less than perfect. However, we guarantee the best available in North America and that our quality estimates are precise or your money back! If you have a specific question about any title contact us!
#5
DVD Talk Special Edition
Thread Starter
Join Date: Oct 1999
Posts: 1,168
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
That Revok place looks pretty shady, but maybe they are operating within the law. I really don't know too much about it.
On the otherhand, I ran a search of completed auctions by the person offering Dune and he has been making a killing selling what appears to be all region DVD-R rips of a bunch of Australian DVD releases, The Turning, Spellbinder, Going All the Way, Ali vs. Frazier and a few more. I can't believe ebay lets crooks like this operate! Isn't against ebay rules to sell DVD-Rs?
On the otherhand, I ran a search of completed auctions by the person offering Dune and he has been making a killing selling what appears to be all region DVD-R rips of a bunch of Australian DVD releases, The Turning, Spellbinder, Going All the Way, Ali vs. Frazier and a few more. I can't believe ebay lets crooks like this operate! Isn't against ebay rules to sell DVD-Rs?
#6
DVD Talk Reviewer
Join Date: Aug 2001
Location: WAS looking for My Own Private Stuckeyville, but stuck in Liberty City (while missing Vice City)
Posts: 15,094
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally posted by Tuco
I can't believe ebay lets crooks like this operate! Isn't against ebay rules to sell DVD-Rs?
I can't believe ebay lets crooks like this operate! Isn't against ebay rules to sell DVD-Rs?
See, but that's the thing...it doesn't bother me as much if they're booting something that's not readily available [Dune EE, f'rinstance], but when I see boots for Beverly Hills Cop or Lethal Weapon...that's just sad.
#7
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
The section of American copyright law known as "The Berne Act" clearly states: films unreleased in the United States, including original version of films altered and/or edited for release in the United States, are not protected by American copyright; thus, they are considered public domain.
1. There is no American law called "The Berne Act." There is an international treaty that the US has entered into that is referred to as the Berne Convention. But in the US, treaties are not law. Treaties do not bind the actions of citizens, they bind the actions of governments. Even if the Berne Convention stated what Revok claims it does, it would be irrelevant to US citizens unless Congress had passed a law enacting it.
2. The Berne Convention says no such thing, anyway. The US certainly does grant copyright protection to films (and any other works) not released in the US. A work does not have to ever actually be released to get copyright protection under US law. Imagine if they weren't protected: multinational corporations would hurry to quickly release foreign films on their own in the US before the foreign film studio had a chance to do so themselves. This would be absurd. This includes alternate versions of films, too, of course. The extended TV cut of Dune (besides having been "released" on TV in the US, anyway) is most certainly under copyright protection in the US, and it will remain so until the end of its term (presumably 95 years from its original airdate) even if it is never officially released on home video.
Revok are long-standing bootleg dealers, and their attempted legalese doesn't stand up to even basic logic. The only thing "for real" about Revok is that they sell "real" bootlegs and their explanation of the law is "real" bull*****.
DJ
Last edited by djtoell; 09-07-03 at 01:23 AM.
#9
DVD Talk Legend
Originally posted by Flave
Anyone know where I can get a legitimate copy of this version?
Anyone know where I can get a legitimate copy of this version?
#11
Member
Join Date: Nov 2000
Location: Spencer, TN. US
Posts: 184
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
My meaning of the term "For Real" was not their views on copyright laws, but based on my past dealings.
You place an order you get your product.
Revok has been around for a few years now as has other sites like Video Mayhem of Florida & Video Search of Miami. With the current load of copyright cases going to court these days I doubt these sites would still be in business without some leg to stand on, be it a loophole or what.
When/if Jodorowsky, is released on DVD in the US I'll be happy to throw out my Revok copies. In the meantime I am glad I got to see movies by someone I've heard so much about.
BTW- I do own a legitimate copy of Santa Sangre on VHS because it is available in that format in this country. El Topo & Holy Mountain is not in any format except through somewhere like revok.
I wonder if anyone thinks there is a "real" "legitimate" DUNE "Extended Edition" since Lynch did not approve this version and has disowned it. Maybe the Japan, Europe & Korean versions are boots as well.
The director does not want this version to exist & petitioned to have his name removed, but I guess that’s ok as long Universal puts out a "legitimate" DUNE "Extended Edition" on DVD. Which I'm guessing has not happened in any country will most likely never happen.
You place an order you get your product.
Revok has been around for a few years now as has other sites like Video Mayhem of Florida & Video Search of Miami. With the current load of copyright cases going to court these days I doubt these sites would still be in business without some leg to stand on, be it a loophole or what.
When/if Jodorowsky, is released on DVD in the US I'll be happy to throw out my Revok copies. In the meantime I am glad I got to see movies by someone I've heard so much about.
BTW- I do own a legitimate copy of Santa Sangre on VHS because it is available in that format in this country. El Topo & Holy Mountain is not in any format except through somewhere like revok.
I wonder if anyone thinks there is a "real" "legitimate" DUNE "Extended Edition" since Lynch did not approve this version and has disowned it. Maybe the Japan, Europe & Korean versions are boots as well.
The director does not want this version to exist & petitioned to have his name removed, but I guess that’s ok as long Universal puts out a "legitimate" DUNE "Extended Edition" on DVD. Which I'm guessing has not happened in any country will most likely never happen.
#12
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Originally posted by jkcarter
Revok has been around for a few years now as has other sites like Video Mayhem of Florida & Video Search of Miami. With the current load of copyright cases going to court these days I doubt these sites would still be in business without some leg to stand on, be it a loophole or what.
Revok has been around for a few years now as has other sites like Video Mayhem of Florida & Video Search of Miami. With the current load of copyright cases going to court these days I doubt these sites would still be in business without some leg to stand on, be it a loophole or what.
I wonder if anyone thinks there is a "real" "legitimate" DUNE "Extended Edition" since Lynch did not approve this version and has disowned it. Maybe the Japan, Europe & Korean versions are boots as well.
The director does not want this version to exist & petitioned to have his name removed, but I guess that’s ok as long Universal puts out a "legitimate" DUNE "Extended Edition" on DVD. Which I'm guessing has not happened in any country will most likely never happen.
The director does not want this version to exist & petitioned to have his name removed, but I guess that’s ok as long Universal puts out a "legitimate" DUNE "Extended Edition" on DVD. Which I'm guessing has not happened in any country will most likely never happen.
DJ
#14
DVD Talk Legend
Originally posted by jkcarter
I wonder if anyone thinks there is a "real" "legitimate" DUNE "Extended Edition" since Lynch did not approve this version and has disowned it. Maybe the Japan, Europe & Korean versions are boots as well.
The director does not want this version to exist & petitioned to have his name removed, but I guess that’s ok as long Universal puts out a "legitimate" DUNE "Extended Edition" on DVD. Which I'm guessing has not happened in any country will most likely never happen.
I wonder if anyone thinks there is a "real" "legitimate" DUNE "Extended Edition" since Lynch did not approve this version and has disowned it. Maybe the Japan, Europe & Korean versions are boots as well.
The director does not want this version to exist & petitioned to have his name removed, but I guess that’s ok as long Universal puts out a "legitimate" DUNE "Extended Edition" on DVD. Which I'm guessing has not happened in any country will most likely never happen.
#15
Member
Join Date: Nov 2000
Location: Spencer, TN. US
Posts: 184
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Very well, I stand corrected on Dune then.
However I pose a question to you guys. If as with Jodorowsky you had heard about his films for years but were never able to see them. Were dying to see what all the fuss was about.
Would you as in my case use sites such as these? This is of course after trying everything else 1st.
I am a big fan of strange & surreal movies, believe me they are hard to find. Jodorowsky is not the 1st time I've had to resort to "shady" websites.
I do not want to seem as if I am promoting copyright infringement. I just want to enjoy movies I read & hear about in a category I truly love. As I said before when there are legitimate releases in this country, I'll be there to buy a copy and throw out the boot.
Sorry for the hijack.
However I pose a question to you guys. If as with Jodorowsky you had heard about his films for years but were never able to see them. Were dying to see what all the fuss was about.
Would you as in my case use sites such as these? This is of course after trying everything else 1st.
I am a big fan of strange & surreal movies, believe me they are hard to find. Jodorowsky is not the 1st time I've had to resort to "shady" websites.
I do not want to seem as if I am promoting copyright infringement. I just want to enjoy movies I read & hear about in a category I truly love. As I said before when there are legitimate releases in this country, I'll be there to buy a copy and throw out the boot.
Sorry for the hijack.
#16
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Originally posted by Josh Z
The director's approval has nothing to do with whether the release is legal. Universal owns the film and can do with it as they please. They have indeed licensed fully legal copies for release in Europe, Japan, and Australia.
The director's approval has nothing to do with whether the release is legal. Universal owns the film and can do with it as they please. They have indeed licensed fully legal copies for release in Europe, Japan, and Australia.
DJ