Helen of Troy - 4.20.03 & 4.21.03 - USA
#1
DVD Talk Hero
Thread Starter
Helen of Troy - 4.20.03 & 4.21.03 - USA
http://www.usanetwork.com/movies/helenoftroy/
Anyone going to watch?
Here's a schedule (all times ET):
4.20 8pm, 10pm - Part 1
4.21 8am - Making of Helen of Troy
4.21 6pm - Part 1, 8pm, 10pm - Part 2
4.24 8pm - Parts 1 & 2
4.25 9am - Parts 1 & 2
4.26 6pm - Parts 1 & 2
4.27 12am - Parts 1 & 2
4.27 12pm - Parts 1 & 2
das
#3
DVD Talk Hero
Thread Starter
Yeah, I always forget about these miniseries too. They start promoting these things 4 months before they air, so I never can remember when it's actually going to be on.
das
das
#6
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
It was good enough to spend time watching. I get the feeling a lot is being left out, but it's hard to fit an epic into four hours.
Oh, and Helen is HOT!
Oh, and Helen is HOT!
#7
DVD Talk Special Edition
Join Date: Jan 2002
Location: OC, SoCal
Posts: 1,030
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
yea it isn't that bad, so far. only seen the first 50 mins so far. then again I really enjoy these type of films. yea helen is hot
Last edited by Excelesor; 04-20-03 at 10:56 PM.
#9
DVD Talk Special Edition
Join Date: Jan 2002
Location: OC, SoCal
Posts: 1,030
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
someone refresh my memory and give me a history lesson, isn't Troy the city that allowed the wooden horse into its city??
Also, I really enjoy these type of films. Does anyone have a dvd reccomendations that involves the trojan war, roman empire, greek mythology, mark anthony, pretty much, film about anceint european empires, doesn't have to be about war, but war is prefered, but dramas will do.
Also, I really enjoy these type of films. Does anyone have a dvd reccomendations that involves the trojan war, roman empire, greek mythology, mark anthony, pretty much, film about anceint european empires, doesn't have to be about war, but war is prefered, but dramas will do.
Last edited by Excelesor; 04-21-03 at 12:01 AM.
#10
DVD Talk Legend
Originally posted by MrX
I want to see how they handle the war.
I want to see how they handle the war.
Sienna Guillory... I fell in love with her a couple years back when she played Jenny Bunn in the BBC mini-movie "Take a Girl Like You".
http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/masterpiece/takeagirl/
I pulled some PR strings through a company I was writing for to get a copy of it on VHS... it has yet to come out in the U.S. on any format.
(You can order the PAL tape through PBS now)
-k
###
#12
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Join Date: May 2000
Location: Un-Happy Valley, PA
Posts: 2,718
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally posted by Excelesor
someone refresh my memory and give me a history lesson, isn't Troy the city that allowed the wooden horse into its city??
Also, I really enjoy these type of films. Does anyone have a dvd reccomendations that involves the trojan war, roman empire, greek mythology, mark anthony, pretty much, film about anceint european empires, doesn't have to be about war, but war is prefered, but dramas will do.
someone refresh my memory and give me a history lesson, isn't Troy the city that allowed the wooden horse into its city??
Also, I really enjoy these type of films. Does anyone have a dvd reccomendations that involves the trojan war, roman empire, greek mythology, mark anthony, pretty much, film about anceint european empires, doesn't have to be about war, but war is prefered, but dramas will do.
#14
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Join Date: Oct 1999
Location: Portland, OR
Posts: 8,527
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Here's a brief synopsis on how the Trojan War started from what I remember. I'll leave out how it ended because I forgot. Anyhow, the whole thing's detailed in The Iliad
It started off when King Peleus had some wedding party and didn't invite a goddess to it. I forget the goddesses name, but she's the goddess of strife, so naturally, she got left out. Anyhow, she got pissed and decided to stir up some trouble so she created a golden apple and claimed that it was a symbol for the most beautiful goddess. She tossed it out to Athena, Hera, and Aphrodite, who each really wanted it badly. So they took it to Zeus to judge who should get it. Zeus, who knew this was trouble and was wise enough to avoid it, took it to the mortal, Paris, son of King Priam of Troy, to judge who was the most beautiful. The 3 goddesses all campaigned him and tried to bribe him with various gifts and promises. Finally, Aphrodite promised him the most beautiful woman in the world. And so he gave the apple to Aphrodite. Helen is, of course, the most beautiful woman on earth, BUT she is also the wife of King Meneleus of Sparta. King Meneleus of Sparta is the younger brother of King Agamemmnon of Mycenea. Anyhow, Paris goes to visit Sparta one day and while he's there, Aphrodite plants the seed of love in Helen's heart and when she sees Paris, falls in love with him. When Meneleus goes off to wage war (I think in Crete), Helen runs off with Paris. Actually, there's disagreement among historians about this translation. Some say she went willingly, some say she was kidnapped. Anyhow, so she ends up in Troy with Paris (who has an elder brother, Hector, the baddest ass Trojan warrior). So then the Archaens (Greeks), all band together and wage war on Troy over Helen. This war goes on for 9 years. Nobody can penetrate the walls of Troy. Various stuff happens during the war. The gods all get involved and start taking sides. Hector kills some "best guy friend" (different connotation back then ) of Achilles. Achilles, is the strongest Greek warrior, but his heart really wasn't in the war, until his "best friend" gets killed. So then, he goes all apocolyptic on Hector's ass and ends up killing him and dragging his corpse back and forth in front of Troy's walls to taunt the enemy. King Priam comes out of Troy and into the Greek camps to beg Achilles to let him have the body back so that he can properly bury him. Achilles starts to come to his senses and returns the body. He actually pays respect to Hector before he returns him. He even protects Priam from the other Greeks. Of all the people, Achilles actually sees the senselessness of a 9 year war over a woman and a vendetta between 2 men. The true focus of the whole Iliad story is actually Achilles even though he's not even in it for like 2/3 of it. Anyhow, yada, yada, yada. The Greeks cleverly build the infamous wooden Trojan horse and finally manage to penetrate Troy's walls and causes their downfall. Other stuff happens in the end, but I can't remember.
Phew...I should go back and read it. One of the all time GREAT epics. Tolkien based a LOT of his writing on the Iliad. And yeah, a lot IS left out, and some is made up. I didn't really like the way they stated in the beginning "This is what REALLY happened". You can't contradict The Iliad!
It started off when King Peleus had some wedding party and didn't invite a goddess to it. I forget the goddesses name, but she's the goddess of strife, so naturally, she got left out. Anyhow, she got pissed and decided to stir up some trouble so she created a golden apple and claimed that it was a symbol for the most beautiful goddess. She tossed it out to Athena, Hera, and Aphrodite, who each really wanted it badly. So they took it to Zeus to judge who should get it. Zeus, who knew this was trouble and was wise enough to avoid it, took it to the mortal, Paris, son of King Priam of Troy, to judge who was the most beautiful. The 3 goddesses all campaigned him and tried to bribe him with various gifts and promises. Finally, Aphrodite promised him the most beautiful woman in the world. And so he gave the apple to Aphrodite. Helen is, of course, the most beautiful woman on earth, BUT she is also the wife of King Meneleus of Sparta. King Meneleus of Sparta is the younger brother of King Agamemmnon of Mycenea. Anyhow, Paris goes to visit Sparta one day and while he's there, Aphrodite plants the seed of love in Helen's heart and when she sees Paris, falls in love with him. When Meneleus goes off to wage war (I think in Crete), Helen runs off with Paris. Actually, there's disagreement among historians about this translation. Some say she went willingly, some say she was kidnapped. Anyhow, so she ends up in Troy with Paris (who has an elder brother, Hector, the baddest ass Trojan warrior). So then the Archaens (Greeks), all band together and wage war on Troy over Helen. This war goes on for 9 years. Nobody can penetrate the walls of Troy. Various stuff happens during the war. The gods all get involved and start taking sides. Hector kills some "best guy friend" (different connotation back then ) of Achilles. Achilles, is the strongest Greek warrior, but his heart really wasn't in the war, until his "best friend" gets killed. So then, he goes all apocolyptic on Hector's ass and ends up killing him and dragging his corpse back and forth in front of Troy's walls to taunt the enemy. King Priam comes out of Troy and into the Greek camps to beg Achilles to let him have the body back so that he can properly bury him. Achilles starts to come to his senses and returns the body. He actually pays respect to Hector before he returns him. He even protects Priam from the other Greeks. Of all the people, Achilles actually sees the senselessness of a 9 year war over a woman and a vendetta between 2 men. The true focus of the whole Iliad story is actually Achilles even though he's not even in it for like 2/3 of it. Anyhow, yada, yada, yada. The Greeks cleverly build the infamous wooden Trojan horse and finally manage to penetrate Troy's walls and causes their downfall. Other stuff happens in the end, but I can't remember.
Phew...I should go back and read it. One of the all time GREAT epics. Tolkien based a LOT of his writing on the Iliad. And yeah, a lot IS left out, and some is made up. I didn't really like the way they stated in the beginning "This is what REALLY happened". You can't contradict The Iliad!
Last edited by hahn; 04-22-03 at 02:13 AM.
#15
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Originally posted by hahn
I didn't really like the way they stated in the beginning "This is what REALLY happened". You can't contradict The Iliad!
I didn't really like the way they stated in the beginning "This is what REALLY happened". You can't contradict The Iliad!
There is a comic book series called Age of Bronze that also tries to seperate the myth from the story and tries to show how it might have actually happened, but there are so many contradictions in the mythology because there are so many stories that tie in to the Iliad.
So, now that the second part has aired, what's the consensus? Worth watching?
#16
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Join Date: Oct 1999
Location: Portland, OR
Posts: 8,527
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally posted by MrN
The thing about the Iliad is that its sounded like it really happened, except it couldn't have because you have all these gods running around and such. I haven't seen this yet, so how much of a role do the gods play in the mini?
There is a comic book series called Age of Bronze that also tries to seperate the myth from the story and tries to show how it might have actually happened, but there are so many contradictions in the mythology because there are so many stories that tie in to the Iliad.
So, now that the second part has aired, what's the consensus? Worth watching?
The thing about the Iliad is that its sounded like it really happened, except it couldn't have because you have all these gods running around and such. I haven't seen this yet, so how much of a role do the gods play in the mini?
There is a comic book series called Age of Bronze that also tries to seperate the myth from the story and tries to show how it might have actually happened, but there are so many contradictions in the mythology because there are so many stories that tie in to the Iliad.
So, now that the second part has aired, what's the consensus? Worth watching?
I have it Tivo'd so I'm going to check it out sometime this week.
Last edited by hahn; 04-22-03 at 10:51 AM.
#17
Member
Join Date: Apr 2003
Location: North Miami, USA
Posts: 132
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally posted by Excelesor
someone refresh my memory and give me a history lesson, isn't Troy the city that allowed the wooden horse into its city??
Also, I really enjoy these type of films. Does anyone have a dvd reccomendations that involves the trojan war, roman empire, greek mythology, mark anthony, pretty much, film about anceint european empires, doesn't have to be about war, but war is prefered, but dramas will do.
someone refresh my memory and give me a history lesson, isn't Troy the city that allowed the wooden horse into its city??
Also, I really enjoy these type of films. Does anyone have a dvd reccomendations that involves the trojan war, roman empire, greek mythology, mark anthony, pretty much, film about anceint european empires, doesn't have to be about war, but war is prefered, but dramas will do.
#18
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Originally posted by hahn
Historians generally agree that the events and the characters themselves are fictional, BUT are based on a real life war between the Greeks and the Trojans. The Greeks believed that everything that happened was influenced by the Gods and so they're always 'cast' in the stories. However, the story of these characters (Paris, Helen, Meneleus, Agammemnon) IS the Iliad. Yes, these characters appear in other myths and legends, but the Iliad is the ORIGINAL story of the Trojan war (probably some of them ARE based on real people). That's why I say you can't contradict the Iliad. It's like retelling The Lord of the Rings and saying, "Here's what ACTUALLY happened..."
Historians generally agree that the events and the characters themselves are fictional, BUT are based on a real life war between the Greeks and the Trojans. The Greeks believed that everything that happened was influenced by the Gods and so they're always 'cast' in the stories. However, the story of these characters (Paris, Helen, Meneleus, Agammemnon) IS the Iliad. Yes, these characters appear in other myths and legends, but the Iliad is the ORIGINAL story of the Trojan war (probably some of them ARE based on real people). That's why I say you can't contradict the Iliad. It's like retelling The Lord of the Rings and saying, "Here's what ACTUALLY happened..."
As another example, someone could make a film about Henry V and contradict the Shakespeare version.
So, anyone else seen the whole thing yet? Opinions?