question about dvd playback on PS2
#1
DVD Talk Special Edition
Thread Starter
Join Date: Mar 2000
Location: AZ
Posts: 1,816
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
question about dvd playback on PS2
How is the DVD playback on the PS2 compared to an older DVD player? I have a Panasonic A120 and if I will not lose quality I would like to replace the DVD player with the PS2. Anyone have input on this?
#3
DVD Talk Legend
My roommate has a PS2 and the DVD playback is ok - we put in The Cell and it wasn't bad quality - I think the playback is almost equivalent to a low end player that's a few years old. It'll do if you are wanting to replace what you have. You'll want to buy a remote though since using a controller to navigate a DVD menu is kinda silly and akward. Only problem is the remote receiver takes up a memory card slot.
#4
Senior Member
Join Date: Jan 2001
Location: Orlando, FL USA
Posts: 926
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally posted by Trigger
My roommate has a PS2 and the DVD playback is ok - we put in The Cell and it wasn't bad quality - I think the playback is almost equivalent to a low end player that's a few years old. It'll do if you are wanting to replace what you have. You'll want to buy a remote though since using a controller to navigate a DVD menu is kinda silly and akward. Only problem is the remote receiver takes up a memory card slot.
My roommate has a PS2 and the DVD playback is ok - we put in The Cell and it wasn't bad quality - I think the playback is almost equivalent to a low end player that's a few years old. It'll do if you are wanting to replace what you have. You'll want to buy a remote though since using a controller to navigate a DVD menu is kinda silly and akward. Only problem is the remote receiver takes up a memory card slot.
#5
DVD Talk Legend
The quality is decent and in line with most low end players I've seen. The newest version of the drivers that comes with the Sony Remote seems to have eliminated most of the problems with discs not working. All new PS2s have these drivers built in.
I've compared it to my Onkyo C600 and Sony S300 through the S-video. The C600 was much better, but is has enhanced black level and that really makes a difference. It also uses Toshiba technology and seems to have a slightly sharper picture than Sony models. It compared close to my Sony S300, but in somes scenes the S300 seemed to look better. I ocassionaly noticed what seemed like some slight artifacts on the PS2, but the differences were not anything drastic and on casual watching I may not have even noticed any difference.
I think the PS2 could be used as a DVD player, but make sure and get the Sony remote for an extra $20. Its a hassle to use a controller.
I've compared it to my Onkyo C600 and Sony S300 through the S-video. The C600 was much better, but is has enhanced black level and that really makes a difference. It also uses Toshiba technology and seems to have a slightly sharper picture than Sony models. It compared close to my Sony S300, but in somes scenes the S300 seemed to look better. I ocassionaly noticed what seemed like some slight artifacts on the PS2, but the differences were not anything drastic and on casual watching I may not have even noticed any difference.
I think the PS2 could be used as a DVD player, but make sure and get the Sony remote for an extra $20. Its a hassle to use a controller.
#7
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Join Date: Oct 1999
Location: Earth
Posts: 2,693
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
having a relatively crappy home theater system - 32" tv and 27" tv, i can't tell the difference between my toshiba, sampo and ps2 dvd players... but i'm happy w/ all 3.
#9
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Join Date: Jun 1999
Location: Export, PA
Posts: 5,589
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I think I've only ever used my PS2 to watch DVD one time. and that was the day I bought it to test it out.
For an all-in-one unit it's okay. But I'd certainly not use it for a back up if my Sony player died. I was thinking about putting my PS2 in the bedroom so I wouldn't have to use my DVD-ROM for movies but I passed on that and just bought a portable player.
Out of all 4 players the PS2 is the last on my list for a DVD player.
I would say spend the cash on a mid grade DVD player and you'll be much happier. Unless you can live with the play back since you'll also have the option to play video games. It's a toss up.
For an all-in-one unit it's okay. But I'd certainly not use it for a back up if my Sony player died. I was thinking about putting my PS2 in the bedroom so I wouldn't have to use my DVD-ROM for movies but I passed on that and just bought a portable player.
Out of all 4 players the PS2 is the last on my list for a DVD player.
I would say spend the cash on a mid grade DVD player and you'll be much happier. Unless you can live with the play back since you'll also have the option to play video games. It's a toss up.
#10
Senior Member
Join Date: Aug 2001
Location: Berkeley, CA
Posts: 406
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Have you guys tried the component outputs for PS2? I've been wondering if I should buy the Monster Cable Component set. Right now I'm just using the standard video cable. I don't use my PS2 as a DVD player, but I'm wondering if the in-game graphics become better. Any comparisons from current users on both the DVD and in-game quality using regular AV, S-Video, and Component? Thanks.
#11
DVD Talk Legend
Originally posted by seeyouauntie
Controller slot actually.
Controller slot actually.
I knew I'd get it wrong. But doesn't it take up a controller slot but give you a slot for your controller so you don't really lose a controller slot? And doesn't it block your memory card slot because it is bulky? That's how I remember it being. Perhaps I'm wrong (of course I am...)... anyway - it's something like that. I could go in the other room and look... yup I'm wrong. The bulk goes below the controller slot leaving just enough room for a memory card so I guess you don't lose anything. Just forget I was here. (hides)
#12
DVD Talk Special Edition
Join Date: Oct 2000
Location: Toronto, Ontario, Canada
Posts: 1,297
Likes: 0
Received 1 Like
on
1 Post
Originally posted by mvc
Have you guys tried the component outputs for PS2? I've been wondering if I should buy the Monster Cable Component set. Right now I'm just using the standard video cable. I don't use my PS2 as a DVD player, but I'm wondering if the in-game graphics become better. Any comparisons from current users on both the DVD and in-game quality using regular AV, S-Video, and Component? Thanks.
Have you guys tried the component outputs for PS2? I've been wondering if I should buy the Monster Cable Component set. Right now I'm just using the standard video cable. I don't use my PS2 as a DVD player, but I'm wondering if the in-game graphics become better. Any comparisons from current users on both the DVD and in-game quality using regular AV, S-Video, and Component? Thanks.
I used my 32" Sharp for tests. But of course, depending on your monitor, YMMV.
#13
DVD Talk Special Edition
Thread Starter
Join Date: Mar 2000
Location: AZ
Posts: 1,816
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Thanks
for all the feedback. I am using the crappy cables that came with it for now but I am probably going to pick up the S-video cable here soon. I think I will just experiment with it for awhile. I have my DVD setup for video 1 and PS2 on video 2. So I think I will put my digital cable box back on analog since I really only get one HBO that is in Dolby and then I can put both my DVD and PS2 on Digital for my receiver. Then I can have both for awhile to test them out. Your comments helped though, as usual DVD talk members come through. Oh, I did go buy a mad catz dvd 2 remote. It is not bulky and it works well. The only problem I had was my vcr code isn't right. That's what I get for having an admiral vcr, yes I never use the damn thing. Only for recording Bronco games.
#14
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Thanks
Originally posted by s}{ammer
for all the feedback. I am using the crappy cables that came with it for now but I am probably going to pick up the S-video cable here soon. I think I will just experiment with it for awhile. I have my DVD setup for video 1 and PS2 on video 2. So I think I will put my digital cable box back on analog since I really only get one HBO that is in Dolby and then I can put both my DVD and PS2 on Digital for my receiver. Then I can have both for awhile to test them out. Your comments helped though, as usual DVD talk members come through. Oh, I did go buy a mad catz dvd 2 remote. It is not bulky and it works well. The only problem I had was my vcr code isn't right. That's what I get for having an admiral vcr, yes I never use the damn thing. Only for recording Bronco games.
for all the feedback. I am using the crappy cables that came with it for now but I am probably going to pick up the S-video cable here soon. I think I will just experiment with it for awhile. I have my DVD setup for video 1 and PS2 on video 2. So I think I will put my digital cable box back on analog since I really only get one HBO that is in Dolby and then I can put both my DVD and PS2 on Digital for my receiver. Then I can have both for awhile to test them out. Your comments helped though, as usual DVD talk members come through. Oh, I did go buy a mad catz dvd 2 remote. It is not bulky and it works well. The only problem I had was my vcr code isn't right. That's what I get for having an admiral vcr, yes I never use the damn thing. Only for recording Bronco games.