what would it be?

I have FF9, NHL2000, and Smackdown 2 and THPS1 & 2.

I am thinking of getting Silent Hill...any thoughts one way or another?

You have 3 hours to let me know what another decent choice would be.

Well if you wanted to round out your collection, I'd suggest Metal Gear Solid.

good thought...would you choose that over Silent Hill?

I've finished MGS on a rental when it first came out, but only played SH for about 1 hour....

I haven't played Silent Hill that much so I can't really comment on that. It got pretty good reviews though. Hrmm, I just thought of a game. You should rent Ape Escape and see if you like it. Great game. Also, Legend of Dragoon and Final Fantasy Tactics are both in the Greatest Hits collection, so each one will be about 20 bucks, which is pretty good. I'm gonna try to pick up Legend of Dragoon when I see it.

As for other games.... the Gran Turismo series has always been popular...
FF7 is an awesome game, and you can buy it for less than 10 bucks now...

Dragon Warrior 7, though it's not out quite yet.

Thing is, I am trading in two old my older games today to buy a new one...I'm getting rid of Nightmare Creatures 2 (I won this one from some internet site) and Vagrant Story (not as good as I was led to beleive.... So I might have to stick to the Greatest Hits games...which isn;t so bad...

Spiderman all the way!