DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   Anime Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/anime-talk-72/)
-   -   Ghost in the Shell: Please explain (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/anime-talk/568939-ghost-shell-please-explain.html)

junglalien 02-02-10 12:41 PM

Ghost in the Shell: Please explain
 
I watched the first movie and Innocence. What are Solid State Society, SAC and 2nd gig? What order should I watch them in?

WTK 02-02-10 01:17 PM

Re: Ghost in the Shell: Please explain
 
In this order...
  1. Ghost in the Shell: Stand Alone Complex
  2. Ghost in the Shell: Stand Alone Complex 2nd GIG
  3. Ghost in the Shell: Stand Alone Complex: Solid State Society
Some would watch the first movie first and the 3 above titles, followed by Innocence. Others watches the movies first.

And in terms of what they are, that's a rather complex questions. You may want to check out the DVDTalk Reviews. If you liked the movies, there is a high chance that you would like the rest.

brayzie 02-02-10 06:09 PM

Re: Ghost in the Shell: Please explain
 
If you haven't checked out the reviews just wanted to add that SAC happens in a kind of splinter continuity, either the events of Ghost In the Shell 1 never happened or the
Spoiler:
the Major never merged with the puppeteer.


I watched Solid State Society before fully watching the tv series and while I liked it, it would have been more effective had I watched the serieses first.

junglalien 02-02-10 06:20 PM

Re: Ghost in the Shell: Please explain
 
What about Individual Eleven, The Laughing Man, and Official Log?

big e 02-02-10 06:33 PM

Re: Ghost in the Shell: Please explain
 
Individual Eleven and The Laughing Man are compilation movies of the first and second seasons of Ghost in the Shell: SAC. I'm not sure what Official Log is.

Dan 02-02-10 10:09 PM

Re: Ghost in the Shell: Please explain
 
Official Log is just a special features DVD and book. Absolutely NOT essential to anyone but collectors.

ShellBeacher 10-08-10 03:59 AM

Re: Ghost in the Shell: Please explain
 
Re: the U.S. Blu-ray of GITS 2: Innocence

Thought I'd bring this up here rather than starting a new thread...

Am a growing fan of the GITS franchise, and I just hadn't gotten around to researching or picking this up yet. I've just spent a fair amount of time internet researching Ghost in the Shell 2: Innocence, the Bandai U.S. Blu-ray/DVD version that was released back in Jan. 09, which now seems to be OOP -- ? I think I managed to find a reasonably priced one from a third-party seller, but I'm still very curious as to its (relatively) rather sudden online/retail-wide disappearance.

Can anyone enlighten me as to how or why/what the reasons are/were behind the BD version of this title coming on and off the market so quickly? Is Bandai's DVD version also OOP (though seemingly still very available)? Thanks.

WTK 10-08-10 09:11 AM

Re: Ghost in the Shell: Please explain
 

Originally Posted by ShellBeacher (Post 10418410)
Re: the U.S. Blu-ray of GITS 2: Innocence

Thought I'd bring this up here rather than starting a new thread...

Am a growing fan of the GITS franchise, and I just hadn't gotten around to researching or picking this up yet. I've just spent a fair amount of time internet researching Ghost in the Shell 2: Innocence, the Bandai U.S. Blu-ray/DVD version that was released back in Jan. 09, which now seems to be OOP -- ? I think I managed to find a reasonably priced one from a third-party seller, but I'm still very curious as to its (relatively) rather sudden online/retail-wide disappearance.

Can anyone enlighten me as to how or why/what the reasons are/were behind the BD version of this title coming on and off the market so quickly? Is Bandai's DVD version also OOP (though seemingly still very available)? Thanks.

It's not just OOP. It's also not currently licensed by anyone (at least known publicly). Originally is was under DreamWorks and then later released by Bandai Ent. BEI didn't have for that many years. That could suggest that the license probably was transferred over from DreamWorks. It remains to be seen how this movie will be handled/picked up by someone else in the future.

ShellBeacher 10-08-10 02:17 PM

Re: Ghost in the Shell: Please explain
 

Originally Posted by WTK (Post 10418611)
It's not just OOP. It's also not currently licensed by anyone (at least known publicly). Originally is was under DreamWorks and then later released by Bandai Ent. BEI didn't have for that many years. That could suggest that the license probably was transferred over from DreamWorks. It remains to be seen how this movie will be handled/picked up by someone else in the future.

Thank you for your quick response. Yes, I'm aware of the earlier Dreamworks debacle (I believe I picked up that DVD years back and returned it immediately once I looked up its 'rep' in terms of subtitles/captions/etc.). It's just interesting to me that Bandai appears to have only had the U.S. license for what, twelve months and some change? More interesting is that I can't find anyone, anywhere online actually talking about it...

WTK 10-09-10 09:58 AM

Re: Ghost in the Shell: Please explain
 

Originally Posted by ShellBeacher (Post 10419221)
Thank you for your quick response. Yes, I'm aware of the earlier Dreamworks debacle (I believe I picked up that DVD years back and returned it immediately once I looked up its 'rep' in terms of subtitles/captions/etc.). It's just interesting to me that Bandai appears to have only had the U.S. license for what, twelve months and some change? More interesting is that I can't find anyone, anywhere online actually talking about it...

Most studio don't mention anything about a license expiring. It's just not a common practice. In this case, it will discovered through RightStuf.com (commented by Shawne).

ShellBeacher 10-10-10 04:39 PM

Re: Ghost in the Shell: Please explain
 

Originally Posted by WTK (Post 10420433)
Most studios don't mention anything about a license expiring. It's just not a common practice. In this case, it will discovered through RightStuf.com (commented by Shawne).

Oh, I know. I just figured I could find someone talking about "how quickly the DVD went out-of-print," etc. But I don't frequent anime forums, so I probably just wasn't looking in the right place...

Thanks for your response(s).


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 12:29 PM.


Copyright 2018 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.