Are movies like Twilight hurting the Vampire image?
#1
DVD Talk Legend
Thread Starter
Are movies like Twilight hurting the Vampire image?
So I had a debate awhile back with a fan of the Twilight books/ movies. I had read up until the scene when Edward "Sparkles" in the sun. I said how a real Vampire doesn't "Sparkle" In which she replied "The rules are different in this series". I always had the belief that there are core rules to the Vampire mythology that should stay that way. Dying by way of Sunlight being one of those rules. Blade is an exception since he's half human/half vampire and all other Vamps can die by sunlight.
With movies like Twilight and shows like Vampire Diaries, do you guys think the image of a real vampire is being tarnished? Are there any Vampire movies coming out that will go back to when Vampires were pure evil?
With movies like Twilight and shows like Vampire Diaries, do you guys think the image of a real vampire is being tarnished? Are there any Vampire movies coming out that will go back to when Vampires were pure evil?
#3
Re: Are movies like Twilight hurting the Vampire image?
I was kind of thinking the same when I seen all these gothic Tiger Beat styled Vampire movies/books popping up.
But I don't think overall it will have too big an effect. Plus, not all the old school vampire movies prior were all great.
Off top, I liked Blade I and II, Shadow of the Vampire and...can't recall any else.
Ethan Hawke has a new one that looks pretty good.
But I don't think overall it will have too big an effect. Plus, not all the old school vampire movies prior were all great.
Off top, I liked Blade I and II, Shadow of the Vampire and...can't recall any else.
Ethan Hawke has a new one that looks pretty good.
#4
DVD Talk Godfather
Join Date: Jul 2000
Location: City of the lakers.. riots.. and drug dealing cops.. los(t) Angel(e)s. ca.
Posts: 54,199
Likes: 0
Received 1 Like
on
1 Post
Re: Are movies like Twilight hurting the Vampire image?
I see you subscribe to the Joss Whedon school of vampire burning/ashes. You are wrong. even Bram Stoker's Dracula could move in the day light. Weaker, but could move during the day.
#5
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Are movies like Twilight hurting the Vampire image?
So I had a debate awhile back with a fan of the Twilight books/ movies. I had read up until the scene when Edward "Sparkles" in the sun. I said how a real Vampire doesn't "Sparkle" In which she replied "The rules are different in this series". I always had the belief that there are core rules to the Vampire mythology that should stay that way. Dying by way of Sunlight being one of those rules. Blade is an exception since he's half human/half vampire and all other Vamps can die by sunlight.
With movies like Twilight and shows like Vampire Diaries, do you guys think the image of a real vampire is being tarnished? Are there any Vampire movies coming out that will go back to when Vampires were pure evil?
With movies like Twilight and shows like Vampire Diaries, do you guys think the image of a real vampire is being tarnished? Are there any Vampire movies coming out that will go back to when Vampires were pure evil?
#6
DVD Talk Legend
Join Date: Jul 2000
Location: Sesame Street (the apt. next to Bob's)
Posts: 20,195
Likes: 0
Received 6 Likes
on
6 Posts
Re: Are movies like Twilight hurting the Vampire image?
They can't all be cool like Christopher Lee.
Pussyboy vampires aren't a new thing. Anne Rice has been mincing them up for years. And Udo Kier was the gayest Dracula ever way back in the early 70s.
Pussyboy vampires aren't a new thing. Anne Rice has been mincing them up for years. And Udo Kier was the gayest Dracula ever way back in the early 70s.
#7
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Re: Are movies like Twilight hurting the Vampire image?
I would blame "Twilight" for making vampires seem girly, but the real blame should be on the last 15 years of Castlevania games. The "Twilight" vampires look like John Wayne compared to the androgynous blood suckers in "Castlevania".
Last edited by UAIOE; 11-13-09 at 02:25 AM.
#8
Re: Are movies like Twilight hurting the Vampire image?
Different rules have always applied to the vampire mythology: the effects of sliver, a simple finger cross versus a golden cross or whether one has sufficient faith in the cross in order for it to be effective, if sunlight kills instantly, slowly, or just diminishes the vampire's powers, etc.
The problem is when you have weak material or simply go for gimmicks and/or the teen segment.
The problem is when you have weak material or simply go for gimmicks and/or the teen segment.
#9
Moderator
Re: Are movies like Twilight hurting the Vampire image?
I think that may be your problem right there.
Yeah, there are "rules" that have been established for vampires and ghosts and zombies and mummies and all of that stuff. But it can and should vary as needed for each unique mythology. In the case of vampires, some stories say a stake through the heart will do the trick while others say only sunlight will kill 'em. Garlic repels vampires in some stories, in others it's the cross and in others it's neither. If I recall Interview With the Vampire correctly, Pitt's vampire says he's rather fond of crosses. Anne Rice did a lot of vampires in the 1990s, so did she ruin the mythology or create her own?
I remember watching Shaun of the Dead right after reading The Zombie Survival Guide by Max Brooks and when Shaun and the crew pretend to be zombies to fool the real zombies I said to myself, "Well, that would never work with real zombies." Then I laughed at myself because I remembered how, when reading that book, I kept having moments of, "Ah, of course that's what someone would have to do to survive!" ... and remind myself it's just a book.
There's no Igor in the Frankenstein novel but the original film made him part of the mythology. If there's a Frankenstein story or movie without Igor does it ruin the mythology since he's become such an ingrained part of it in popular culture?
Frankly, I think this is a case of the cool kids liking what used to be just one's own little deal, as if vampires could become "sell outs" by becoming popular with a demographic outside one's own.
Yeah, there are "rules" that have been established for vampires and ghosts and zombies and mummies and all of that stuff. But it can and should vary as needed for each unique mythology. In the case of vampires, some stories say a stake through the heart will do the trick while others say only sunlight will kill 'em. Garlic repels vampires in some stories, in others it's the cross and in others it's neither. If I recall Interview With the Vampire correctly, Pitt's vampire says he's rather fond of crosses. Anne Rice did a lot of vampires in the 1990s, so did she ruin the mythology or create her own?
I remember watching Shaun of the Dead right after reading The Zombie Survival Guide by Max Brooks and when Shaun and the crew pretend to be zombies to fool the real zombies I said to myself, "Well, that would never work with real zombies." Then I laughed at myself because I remembered how, when reading that book, I kept having moments of, "Ah, of course that's what someone would have to do to survive!" ... and remind myself it's just a book.
There's no Igor in the Frankenstein novel but the original film made him part of the mythology. If there's a Frankenstein story or movie without Igor does it ruin the mythology since he's become such an ingrained part of it in popular culture?
Frankly, I think this is a case of the cool kids liking what used to be just one's own little deal, as if vampires could become "sell outs" by becoming popular with a demographic outside one's own.
#11
Banned
Join Date: Feb 2002
Posts: 7,982
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Are movies like Twilight hurting the Vampire image?
By taking away the christian element you take away that the vampire is part of evil,hell,the devil.
But now we have vampires as superheros, teen idols, etc.,
Today's modern vampire is not scary no matter how big their cgi fangs are.
But now we have vampires as superheros, teen idols, etc.,
Today's modern vampire is not scary no matter how big their cgi fangs are.
#13
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Re: Are movies like Twilight hurting the Vampire image?
#16
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: Are movies like Twilight hurting the Vampire image?
As far as whether modern vampires are scary, it all depends on the story.
#17
Moderator
#18
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Are movies like Twilight hurting the Vampire image?
Fred Saberhagen's Dracula was a Christian. He drew back in horror from the communion wafers because von Helsing was wadding them up with spit and shoving them under the door. He wasn't horrified by the divine power of the wafers, but by the blasphemy of von Helsing's action.
#19
Senior Member
Re: Are movies like Twilight hurting the Vampire image?
After hearing from a ladyfriend that she loved this movie, and after hearing all the critique on this movie, I decided to watch it yesterday.
I'm now typing with one hand as my palm is permanently stuck to my forehead, anybody have any tips to remove it? Please?
I'm now typing with one hand as my palm is permanently stuck to my forehead, anybody have any tips to remove it? Please?
#20
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Are movies like Twilight hurting the Vampire image?
I think that the vampire myth isn't being weakened Twilight, but by social changes. An important element of the old vampire stories was that they were a metaphor for the sin of lust. A distinguished foreign gentleman, an older man with devastating charm, would talk to our women and put them under his spell. All one of our women had to do was to look into his eyes, and he would be able to have his way with her. Once he did, she would be forever tainted. But instead of being properly ashamed, she would seem happy with her new life, and try to seduce the hero into it too.
The only way to free her of the shame is to kill her. In the sanitized versions, merely the seductive man needs to be killed.
(It occurs to me that the vampire story wouldn't go over well in rural Pakistan, either. The metaphor would have no force, because they really do kill women to free them of the shame of having had sex.)
None of those ideas have the emotional pull that they did in Victorian and post-Victorian times. Lust is no longer a shameful secret. We live in a highly sexualized society. Everyday dress is provocative. All soap operas have a sex scene. There are discussions about whether blowjobs count as sex.
The only people in our society who still fear sex are pre-teen girls. So the latest vampire stories are aimed at them.
The only way to free her of the shame is to kill her. In the sanitized versions, merely the seductive man needs to be killed.
(It occurs to me that the vampire story wouldn't go over well in rural Pakistan, either. The metaphor would have no force, because they really do kill women to free them of the shame of having had sex.)
None of those ideas have the emotional pull that they did in Victorian and post-Victorian times. Lust is no longer a shameful secret. We live in a highly sexualized society. Everyday dress is provocative. All soap operas have a sex scene. There are discussions about whether blowjobs count as sex.
The only people in our society who still fear sex are pre-teen girls. So the latest vampire stories are aimed at them.
Last edited by Nick Danger; 11-13-09 at 10:30 AM.
#21
#22
DVD Talk Legend
Join Date: Aug 2006
Location: Behind the Orange Curtain
Posts: 20,085
Likes: 0
Received 7 Likes
on
7 Posts
Re: Are movies like Twilight hurting the Vampire image?
I think plenty of vamp flicks have done their part to tarnish the vampire image, as you put it. Do I think shit like Twilight is incredibly gay? Yes, but if it helps good vampire flicks (like the upcoming Daybreakers) get a greenlight then I'm willing to deal.
#25
DVD Talk Godfather
Join Date: Apr 1999
Location: Gateway Cities/Harbor Region
Posts: 63,299
Received 1,811 Likes
on
1,130 Posts
Re: Are movies like Twilight hurting the Vampire image?
Ok, I reeeeally thought you were going somewhere else with the one hand typing thing.