Alan Moore's Promethea meets the Justice League
#1
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Thread Starter
Alan Moore's Promethea meets the Justice League
Promethea meets the Justice League
I'm not excited that DC is bringing so many of Alan Moore's characters into the regular DC Universe.
I never was crazy about Promethea's design, but she always felt like a big deal in her own book, especially the way JH Williams III illustrated her. Seeing her interact with the Justice League makes her seem small and ordinary.
I'm not excited that DC is bringing so many of Alan Moore's characters into the regular DC Universe.
I never was crazy about Promethea's design, but she always felt like a big deal in her own book, especially the way JH Williams III illustrated her. Seeing her interact with the Justice League makes her seem small and ordinary.
#2
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Alan Moore's Promethea meets the Justice League
I'd say that, between Promethea and Watchmen joining the DC universe, DC is going out of their way to spite Alan Moore, but they're also bringing Gaiman's Sandman stuff into the DCU, too, so it looks more like they're consolidating all of their corporate-owned properties under the DCU umbrella.
It's true that Sandman hasalways operated in the DCU (as the Justice Legue's ppearance in tne title's first year, and mentions of Oa and Rao in the later "Endless Nights" attests), but I believe there is some kind of gentleman's agreement in place with Gaiman where DC asks his permission to use characters like Dream and Death. I wonder if that's still the case.
It's true that Sandman hasalways operated in the DCU (as the Justice Legue's ppearance in tne title's first year, and mentions of Oa and Rao in the later "Endless Nights" attests), but I believe there is some kind of gentleman's agreement in place with Gaiman where DC asks his permission to use characters like Dream and Death. I wonder if that's still the case.
#3
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Thread Starter
Re: Alan Moore's Promethea meets the Justice League
Sandman originally was intended by Gaiman to be in the DCU. But I thought that DC was the one that had second thoughts and told Gaiman to keep Sandman separate.
I know that Gaiman's Death made an appearance in another Vertigo title, Madame Xanadu, written by Matt Wagner. Then she later appeared in Superman or something where she talks with Lex Luthor, and that was supposed to be a big deal.
Alan Moore said that DC was creatively bankrupt and that's why they were making a whole event around a back up story he had written in Green Lantern Corps Quarterly.
"Just Moore just being cranky and bitter," I thought.
Then came Before Watchmen.
Then The Doomsday Clock and the introduction of Watchmen into the DCU.
Now Promethea meets the JLA.
I know that Gaiman's Death made an appearance in another Vertigo title, Madame Xanadu, written by Matt Wagner. Then she later appeared in Superman or something where she talks with Lex Luthor, and that was supposed to be a big deal.
Alan Moore said that DC was creatively bankrupt and that's why they were making a whole event around a back up story he had written in Green Lantern Corps Quarterly.
"Just Moore just being cranky and bitter," I thought.
Then came Before Watchmen.
Then The Doomsday Clock and the introduction of Watchmen into the DCU.
Now Promethea meets the JLA.
#5
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Alan Moore's Promethea meets the Justice League
Sandman originally was intended by Gaiman to be in the DCU. But I thought that DC was the one that had second thoughts and told Gaiman to keep Sandman separate.
I know that Gaiman's Death made an appearance in another Vertigo title, Madame Xanadu, written by Matt Wagner. Then she later appeared in Superman or something where she talks with Lex Luthor, and that was supposed to be a big deal.
Alan Moore said that DC was creatively bankrupt and that's why they were making a whole event around a back up story he had written in Green Lantern Corps Quarterly.
"Just Moore just being cranky and bitter," I thought.
Then came Before Watchmen.
Then The Doomsday Clock and the introduction of Watchmen into the DCU.
Now Promethea meets the JLA.
I know that Gaiman's Death made an appearance in another Vertigo title, Madame Xanadu, written by Matt Wagner. Then she later appeared in Superman or something where she talks with Lex Luthor, and that was supposed to be a big deal.
Alan Moore said that DC was creatively bankrupt and that's why they were making a whole event around a back up story he had written in Green Lantern Corps Quarterly.
"Just Moore just being cranky and bitter," I thought.
Then came Before Watchmen.
Then The Doomsday Clock and the introduction of Watchmen into the DCU.
Now Promethea meets the JLA.
But I think last year they had Morpheus in a Justice League book.
#6
Needs to contact an admin about multiple accounts
Re: Alan Moore's Promethea meets the Justice League
Moore signed the work for hire contract knowing full well that anything he created and submitted would be property of DC. He should want his characters used to the full extent, if they get used in the movies or television shows he will get a nice residual check. Warner Brothers/DC gives nice royalty checks to modern day creators.
#7
DVD Talk Legend
Join Date: Apr 2002
Location: Formerly known as Groucho AND Bandoman/Death Moans, Iowa
Posts: 18,295
Received 372 Likes
on
266 Posts
Re: Alan Moore's Promethea meets the Justice League
Well, at the time he signed the contract he knew the characters would be property of Wildstorm, not DC. DC just happened to buy Wildstorm shortly after that.
Moore considered quitting then, but decided to stick with it so the artist wouldn’t be out of work. I believe he has DC pass all his residuals from other media on to the artists.
Moore considered quitting then, but decided to stick with it so the artist wouldn’t be out of work. I believe he has DC pass all his residuals from other media on to the artists.
#8
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Alan Moore's Promethea meets the Justice League
Moore signed the work for hire contract knowing full well that anything he created and submitted would be property of DC. He should want his characters used to the full extent, if they get used in the movies or television shows he will get a nice residual check. Warner Brothers/DC gives nice royalty checks to modern day creators.
#9
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Thread Starter
Re: Alan Moore's Promethea meets the Justice League
I mean, Sandman was always rooted in the DC universe. Even if you take out the initial storyline with the justice league and Dr. Destiny, you have the fact that Destiny and Cain and Abel and others were taken from old DC books, and then the whole connection with Wesley Dodds, Hector Hall and Fury, etc. The Endless just rarely appear because, well, they're god like entities.
But I think last year they had Morpheus in a Justice League book.
But I think last year they had Morpheus in a Justice League book.
Maybe it was something about DC not wanting Gaiman to bring in their mainstream DCU characters (Superman, Batman, etc) once the ball got rolling, but in return Gaiman found out that that gave him even more freedom.
This is from something I read years ago so maybe I'm remembering it wrong.
Moore signed the work for hire contract knowing full well that anything he created and submitted would be property of DC. He should want his characters used to the full extent, if they get used in the movies or television shows he will get a nice residual check. Warner Brothers/DC gives nice royalty checks to modern day creators.
#10
DVD Talk Legend
Join Date: Apr 2002
Location: Formerly known as Groucho AND Bandoman/Death Moans, Iowa
Posts: 18,295
Received 372 Likes
on
266 Posts
Re: Alan Moore's Promethea meets the Justice League
Most Image books are creator owned, but that means you don't get paid until money starts coming in, and if the book doesn't make money the creators get squat.
I'm sure Moore and the artists had to weigh between ownership or getting a page rate. For the more time-consuming work of drawing an entire book, it can be tough to work without getting paid for months at a time.
I'm sure Moore and the artists had to weigh between ownership or getting a page rate. For the more time-consuming work of drawing an entire book, it can be tough to work without getting paid for months at a time.
#11
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Thread Starter
Re: Alan Moore's Promethea meets the Justice League
Most Image books are creator owned, but that means you don't get paid until money starts coming in, and if the book doesn't make money the creators get squat.
I'm sure Moore and the artists had to weigh between ownership or getting a page rate. For the more time-consuming work of drawing an entire book, it can be tough to work without getting paid for months at a time.
I'm sure Moore and the artists had to weigh between ownership or getting a page rate. For the more time-consuming work of drawing an entire book, it can be tough to work without getting paid for months at a time.
Image originally was giving all these artists in the 90s $$$$$$. When the stores were left with tons of Wildstar, Tribe, and Shaman's Tears #1's, and the speculator market crashed, Image changed it's model.
Jim Lee, Rob Liefeld, and Todd McFarlane ended up becoming what they originally rallied against.
Jim Lee sold Wildstorm to DC Comics without even talking to Alan Moore about it.
#12
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Alan Moore's Promethea meets the Justice League
Image was originally mainly about the founders and their studios, and then branched out to other well known creators (hence Al Gordan and Ordway on Wildstar, Stroman on Tribe, Grell on Shaman's Tears, and others like Keown on Pitt and Jae Lee on Hellshock). But Wildstorm as an imprint always had the rights to what was done for them as work for hire (just like Highbrow, Top Cow, Extreme, etc.)
Here's a decent explanation:
https://www.cbr.com/dc-rights-americ...cs-alan-moore/
One thing that stands out really clearly to me though:
It's like completely missing the point. All the Wildstorm stuff which got integrated with the DC universe almost instantly lost their appeal as well, like the Authority, WildCATs, Grifter, etc., and perhaps the greatest product of that imprint, Planetary, would be absolutely hobbled if they made it part of the DC universe.
Here's a decent explanation:
https://www.cbr.com/dc-rights-americ...cs-alan-moore/
One thing that stands out really clearly to me though:
Some of the characters were based on the idea of what superhero comics would look like if Superman had never existed, so you had Tom Strong, which was a riff on the old pulp novel hero, Doc Savage.
#13
DVD Talk Legend
Join Date: Apr 2002
Location: Formerly known as Groucho AND Bandoman/Death Moans, Iowa
Posts: 18,295
Received 372 Likes
on
266 Posts
Re: Alan Moore's Promethea meets the Justice League
Originally that wasn't the case though, was it?
Image originally was giving all these artists in the 90s $$$$$$. When the stores were left with tons of Wildstar, Tribe, and Shaman's Tears #1's, and the speculator market crashed, Image changed it's model.
Jim Lee, Rob Liefeld, and Todd McFarlane ended up becoming what they originally rallied against.
Jim Lee sold Wildstorm to DC Comics without even talking to Alan Moore about it.
Image originally was giving all these artists in the 90s $$$$$$. When the stores were left with tons of Wildstar, Tribe, and Shaman's Tears #1's, and the speculator market crashed, Image changed it's model.
Jim Lee, Rob Liefeld, and Todd McFarlane ended up becoming what they originally rallied against.
Jim Lee sold Wildstorm to DC Comics without even talking to Alan Moore about it.
#14
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Alan Moore's Promethea meets the Justice League
Before Vertigo became an imprint in 1993, all of the titles were still part of the DCU -- Swamp Thing, Hellblazer, Sandman, Animal Man, Doom Patrol, and Shade The Changing Man -- even though they were tonally different from their mainstream counterparts and some carried a "Mature Readers" label.
When they got their own line, Vertigo, DC sort of mandated that they not cross over into the DC Universe proper, as they didn't want a character like Swamp Thing or Animal Man appearing in regular Code approved title and then have children pick up the Vertigo series. So it sort of became a "don't ask, don't tell" relationship between Vertigo and the DCU.
#15
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Alan Moore's Promethea meets the Justice League
Sort of, but it wasn't limited to Sandman and Gaiman.
Before Vertigo became an imprint in 1993, all of the titles were still part of the DCU -- Swamp Thing, Hellblazer, Sandman, Animal Man, Doom Patrol, and Shade The Changing Man -- even though they were tonally different from their mainstream counterparts and some carried a "Mature Readers" label.
When they got their own line, Vertigo, DC sort of mandated that they not cross over into the DC Universe proper, as they didn't want a character like Swamp Thing or Animal Man appearing in regular Code approved title and then have children pick up the Vertigo series. So it sort of became a "don't ask, don't tell" relationship between Vertigo and the DCU.
Before Vertigo became an imprint in 1993, all of the titles were still part of the DCU -- Swamp Thing, Hellblazer, Sandman, Animal Man, Doom Patrol, and Shade The Changing Man -- even though they were tonally different from their mainstream counterparts and some carried a "Mature Readers" label.
When they got their own line, Vertigo, DC sort of mandated that they not cross over into the DC Universe proper, as they didn't want a character like Swamp Thing or Animal Man appearing in regular Code approved title and then have children pick up the Vertigo series. So it sort of became a "don't ask, don't tell" relationship between Vertigo and the DCU.
#16
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Alan Moore's Promethea meets the Justice League
Yeah.
I think the Vertigo/DCU separation was mandated by Paul Levitz.
Even then, special dispensation was occasionally given when Dream appeared in Morrison's JLA and Sandman Mystery Theater crossed over with Robinson's Starman.
When "New 52" happened, Vertigo gave up all of their properties except Hellblazer and Sandman to the DCU, which, by that time, with the exception of Wagner's Madame Xanadu, was an entirely creator-owned line. Vertigo hadn't done much with Swamp Thing or Animal Man for years, and Doom Patrol had already been returned to the DCU. When Hellblazer was cancelled at #300 it was also returned to the DCU.
I think the Vertigo/DCU separation was mandated by Paul Levitz.
Even then, special dispensation was occasionally given when Dream appeared in Morrison's JLA and Sandman Mystery Theater crossed over with Robinson's Starman.
When "New 52" happened, Vertigo gave up all of their properties except Hellblazer and Sandman to the DCU, which, by that time, with the exception of Wagner's Madame Xanadu, was an entirely creator-owned line. Vertigo hadn't done much with Swamp Thing or Animal Man for years, and Doom Patrol had already been returned to the DCU. When Hellblazer was cancelled at #300 it was also returned to the DCU.
#17
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Alan Moore's Promethea meets the Justice League
Now Gaiman has announced a Sandman Universe line of comics overseen by him:
http://ew.com/books/2018/03/01/neil-...niverse-comics
http://ew.com/books/2018/03/01/neil-...niverse-comics