Comic Book Men - New AMC reality show set in Kevin Smith's NJ comic shop
#26
DVD Talk Legend
Join Date: Jul 2000
Location: Sesame Street (the apt. next to Bob's)
Posts: 20,195
Likes: 0
Received 6 Likes
on
6 Posts
Re: Comic Book Men - New AMC reality show set in Kevin Smith's NJ comic shop
It sounds interesting to me, and I've never been a comic book guy.
#27
DVD Talk Godfather
Re: Comic Book Men - New AMC reality show set in Kevin Smith's NJ comic shop
Here's why I won't be watching and after being a loyal listener for nearly 100 episodes, am done with the podcast. Sounds like a bunch of very sad bullies.
http://blogtown.portlandmercury.com/...hell-is-anyone
http://blogtown.portlandmercury.com/...hell-is-anyone
Smith was on Carolla's podcast earlier in the week "feuding" over a lost TV deal and playing the blame game. They both seemed like they could have done more to make it work, but Kevin just came across as a pampered baby that didn't get his way.
I dumped SMOD sometime last year (when they launched SIR) and it doesn't look like I'm missed much.
I was vaguely interested in checking out this show, but I might have to pass.
#28
Re: Comic Book Men - New AMC reality show set in Kevin Smith's NJ comic shop
Damn, that bastard's faster than Walt Flanagan's dog!
#29
Member
Re: Comic Book Men - New AMC reality show set in Kevin Smith's NJ comic shop
I quit listening to the podcast when Smith started getting high every episode. You can only hear "dude, I'm so high right now, ha ha ha ha!" so many times before it gets old. As long as the show doesn't just have boring stoned guys being stupid it might be okay.
#30
DVD Talk Legend
Join Date: Apr 2003
Location: Land of the Lobstrosities
Posts: 10,300
Likes: 0
Received 1 Like
on
1 Post
Re: Comic Book Men - New AMC reality show set in Kevin Smith's NJ comic shop
That aside, the impression I get from the Tell'em Steve Dave podcast is that Smith is a lot less involved then the promos let on. I'm a regular TeSD listener and even I'm luke warm on this show. Not that I don't think it could be good. I'll be giving it a shot, but you never know with these things.
I don't know about it being an hour long. I thought it was a half hour, to be like Pawn Stars but funnier. It being an hour lowers my expectations because I know how hit or miss the podcast can be. I thought that if they edit material down to fit in a half hour it could be pretty good, but an hour is a lot of time to fill.
As for the article posted, I wouldn't give it too much weight. First of all, the name dropping was ridiculous. Sure, there are people with better comic book credentials, but that's a very small part of it. In addition to running a comic book store for 15 years, and creating comics themselves, the TeSD crew are semi-proven performers with the podcast and live shows.
And dear god, "how much better would this show be if it was Comic Book Women?" Umm, negative better? Does this guy really think people are going to tune in every week to watch a documentary following comic creators around. Sure it sound kind of interesting, maybe once or twice, but an hour a week, times 16 episodes, times x number of seasons. Not going to happen, no matter what combination of tits and testies the cast has. For the show to survive it has to have mainstream appeal, with a comic hook sure, but it can't only be of interest to comic nerds.
As for the blog post/sexism. The guys talked about this on the podcast. Basically Kevin pitched A&E the show as Pawn Stars in a comic book shop. He used some clips from the TeSD podcast as an example of what it would be like but thought they would get in a real cast to make the show. The producers thought the TeSD crew would work themselves, but they wanted to add some "new characters", including a woman. They held auditions and had a few tryouts. A woman who auditioned but didn't get a call back then wrote a blog post saying she never had a chance because it was just a boys club. That started the back and forth. Maybe they were sexist, I don't know, but the fact is they didn't end up hiring anyone, male or female, instead they decided to stick with the original group, who were life long friends in real life.
#32
Re: Comic Book Men - New AMC reality show set in Kevin Smith's NJ comic shop
#33
Senior Member
Join Date: Jun 2001
Location: online!
Posts: 983
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Comic Book Men - New AMC reality show set in Kevin Smith's NJ comic shop
If this is how they act perhaps it'll do well then.
#34
Re: Comic Book Men - New AMC reality show set in Kevin Smith's NJ comic shop
I don't blame the guy for not wanting business disrupted for a show that will likely amount to nothing, but the whole issue could have been handled with more class than it was.
#35
DVD Talk Hero
Join Date: Jun 2000
Location: Somewhere between Heaven and Hell
Posts: 34,097
Received 724 Likes
on
529 Posts
Re: Comic Book Men - New AMC reality show set in Kevin Smith's NJ comic shop
Haven't we already seen portions of this in Mallrats, Chasing Amy and Jay and Silent Bob Strike Back?
#36
DVD Talk Legend
Join Date: Apr 2003
Location: Land of the Lobstrosities
Posts: 10,300
Likes: 0
Received 1 Like
on
1 Post
Re: Comic Book Men - New AMC reality show set in Kevin Smith's NJ comic shop
The woman quoted in article, Zoe, was the girl who got the call back. She wrote a nice post about it Jan 4.
A couple of days later another woman who auditioned wrote a blog post saying the show wouldn't make it without a woman, they never really wanted a woman on the show, and so on. She mentioned Zoe was a friend who made the pilot but got cut.
Bryan, who is pretty sensitive to criticism, then tore into Jill on that week's podcast. I listened to the 20 minutes or so where they talked about it and I didn't hear them say that Zoe claimed she "deserved to be on the show", but I might have missed it. They really didn't talk about her much at all, except Walt making acrack about her being concerned about her image after showing up to the first day of shooting half naked.
Her full response is here.
A couple of days later another woman who auditioned wrote a blog post saying the show wouldn't make it without a woman, they never really wanted a woman on the show, and so on. She mentioned Zoe was a friend who made the pilot but got cut.
Bryan, who is pretty sensitive to criticism, then tore into Jill on that week's podcast. I listened to the 20 minutes or so where they talked about it and I didn't hear them say that Zoe claimed she "deserved to be on the show", but I might have missed it. They really didn't talk about her much at all, except Walt making acrack about her being concerned about her image after showing up to the first day of shooting half naked.
Her full response is here.
#37
DVD Talk Legend
Join Date: Apr 2003
Location: Land of the Lobstrosities
Posts: 10,300
Likes: 0
Received 1 Like
on
1 Post
Re: Comic Book Men - New AMC reality show set in Kevin Smith's NJ comic shop
The fact that she ended up near tears with the producers pushing her to fight back is probably the reason she didn't make the cut, not because Walt and Bry tricked her into wearing a skimpy costume. If Ming were that sensitive he would have hung himself years ago.
Last edited by wmansir; 02-10-12 at 07:52 PM.
#38
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Re: Comic Book Men - New AMC reality show set in Kevin Smith's NJ comic shop
What I could see as an interesting set up for a show like this is a 1/2 epsiode with 3 separate segments.
1st segment is someone bringing in rare comic book or comic related collectible. Pawn Stars style wiht a little history of it and the value.
2nd is an interview with someone in the comic related field. A writer, artist, a comic store owner with tales of weird stuff that happened in the store.
3rd: A group of guys humorusly discussing something in the comics world. Something along the lines of how stupid Wonder Woman's invisible plane is when she's visible or how does Bruce Banner afford to buy new clothes twice each episode since Hulk tears his apart.
1st segment is someone bringing in rare comic book or comic related collectible. Pawn Stars style wiht a little history of it and the value.
2nd is an interview with someone in the comic related field. A writer, artist, a comic store owner with tales of weird stuff that happened in the store.
3rd: A group of guys humorusly discussing something in the comics world. Something along the lines of how stupid Wonder Woman's invisible plane is when she's visible or how does Bruce Banner afford to buy new clothes twice each episode since Hulk tears his apart.
#39
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Comic Book Men - New AMC reality show set in Kevin Smith's NJ comic shop
What I could see as an interesting set up for a show like this is a 1/2 epsiode with 3 separate segments.
1st segment is someone bringing in rare comic book or comic related collectible. Pawn Stars style wiht a little history of it and the value.
2nd is an interview with someone in the comic related field. A writer, artist, a comic store owner with tales of weird stuff that happened in the store.
3rd: A group of guys humorusly discussing something in the comics world. Something along the lines of how stupid Wonder Woman's invisible plane is when she's visible or how does Bruce Banner afford to buy new clothes twice each episode since Hulk tears his apart.
1st segment is someone bringing in rare comic book or comic related collectible. Pawn Stars style wiht a little history of it and the value.
2nd is an interview with someone in the comic related field. A writer, artist, a comic store owner with tales of weird stuff that happened in the store.
3rd: A group of guys humorusly discussing something in the comics world. Something along the lines of how stupid Wonder Woman's invisible plane is when she's visible or how does Bruce Banner afford to buy new clothes twice each episode since Hulk tears his apart.
#40
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Join Date: Apr 2003
Location: Southside Virginia
Posts: 6,457
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Comic Book Men - New AMC reality show set in Kevin Smith's NJ comic shop
This is just another example of what I have been feeling for years...my path diverged from Kevin Smith's some time around when he started smoking reefer and building a podcasting network. Lots of luck, Kev. I think I'm out.
#42
Banned
Re: Comic Book Men - New AMC reality show set in Kevin Smith's NJ comic shop
This was kinda "meh" for me. Kinda surprised this is on at 10 pm and Talking dead is on at midnite.
CBM seems much more niche than Talking dead.
CBM seems much more niche than Talking dead.
#43
Suspended
Re: Comic Book Men - New AMC reality show set in Kevin Smith's NJ comic shop
Offering $100 for that Chucky doll? It's going for less on eBay. Pretty sure they know very little about the whole buying/reselling thing.
#44
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Comic Book Men - New AMC reality show set in Kevin Smith's NJ comic shop
The show was much more entertaining than I thought it would be, though some of the witty banter was so quick it had to have been rehearsed and written before filming. No one comes up with quip after quip like that spontaneously.
I thought it was funny the one guy thought his movie lobby cards were so valuable he had to have them handcuffed/chained to him in a briefcase.
I thought it was funny the one guy thought his movie lobby cards were so valuable he had to have them handcuffed/chained to him in a briefcase.
#45
DVD Talk Legend
Join Date: Apr 2003
Location: Land of the Lobstrosities
Posts: 10,300
Likes: 0
Received 1 Like
on
1 Post
Re: Comic Book Men - New AMC reality show set in Kevin Smith's NJ comic shop
That was better than I expected. If they wanted to make Pawn Stars but only about comics and funnier then I think they succeeded. Although I don't know if their is an audience for that.
I don't think dialog was scripted, although obviously scenes were setup in advance and probably rehearsed or reshot. It was probably heavily edited to get it down to just the funny bits.
As I suspected, it looks like the NJ crew does all the day to day filming then some time later they get together with Kevin to film the "podcast recording" segments that are edited into the final shows. The fake podcast is an interesting way to get Kevin involved in the show since he's usually on the west coast or touring and isn't really that involved with the store or the recording of the NJ guy's podcasts.
I don't think dialog was scripted, although obviously scenes were setup in advance and probably rehearsed or reshot. It was probably heavily edited to get it down to just the funny bits.
As I suspected, it looks like the NJ crew does all the day to day filming then some time later they get together with Kevin to film the "podcast recording" segments that are edited into the final shows. The fake podcast is an interesting way to get Kevin involved in the show since he's usually on the west coast or touring and isn't really that involved with the store or the recording of the NJ guy's podcasts.
#46
DVD Talk Legend
Join Date: Apr 2003
Location: Land of the Lobstrosities
Posts: 10,300
Likes: 0
Received 1 Like
on
1 Post
Re: Comic Book Men - New AMC reality show set in Kevin Smith's NJ comic shop
As a comic shop they deal with some of this stuff but obviously these "walk ins" were setup by the producers and a lot of it is outside of what they normally deal with. If the cameras weren't there Walt probably wouldn't have even made an offer on the doll.
It also could be a setup like I've heard about Storage Wars doing, where they get people to bring collectibles on the show and have an expert make an inflated estimate on the value of the item.
#47
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Comic Book Men - New AMC reality show set in Kevin Smith's NJ comic shop
After all the bashing in this thread, the actual show turned out to be VERY entertaining. My only question is do those other three guys actually work in that store day-to-day, or are they friends of Walt who have been brought in for the show?
I did like the last line of the episode where the bearded dude asked Walt, "Does anyone ever BUY anything here?" It did seem like the only customers they got were people trying to sell stuff.
I did like the last line of the episode where the bearded dude asked Walt, "Does anyone ever BUY anything here?" It did seem like the only customers they got were people trying to sell stuff.
#48
DVD Talk Legend
Join Date: Apr 2003
Location: Land of the Lobstrosities
Posts: 10,300
Likes: 0
Received 1 Like
on
1 Post
Re: Comic Book Men - New AMC reality show set in Kevin Smith's NJ comic shop
Walt and Mike work day to day.
Bryan, with the beard, is a childhood friend of Walts. He use to work in the store, and actually ran a west coast Secret Stash for a while.
Ming is Kevin's IT guy, runs Kevin's website and podcast tech. He's been working for Kevin for 15 years, but lives in Jersey and is friends with the all the guys on the show. He works in the store in as much as they record podcasts there, but I don't think he works the retail side.
Ming has a podcast with Mike called "I Sell Comics" where I presume they talk about comics. It's relatively new and I haven't listened.
Walt and Bryan also have a podcast, along with Bryan "Q" Quinn from Impractical Jokers on TruTV, called "Tell'em Steve Dave" which they have been doing for a couple of years.
Bryan, with the beard, is a childhood friend of Walts. He use to work in the store, and actually ran a west coast Secret Stash for a while.
Ming is Kevin's IT guy, runs Kevin's website and podcast tech. He's been working for Kevin for 15 years, but lives in Jersey and is friends with the all the guys on the show. He works in the store in as much as they record podcasts there, but I don't think he works the retail side.
Ming has a podcast with Mike called "I Sell Comics" where I presume they talk about comics. It's relatively new and I haven't listened.
Walt and Bryan also have a podcast, along with Bryan "Q" Quinn from Impractical Jokers on TruTV, called "Tell'em Steve Dave" which they have been doing for a couple of years.
#49
Senior Member
Join Date: Feb 2003
Location: Texas
Posts: 630
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Comic Book Men - New AMC reality show set in Kevin Smith's NJ comic shop
Bryan ran the west coast store and he has "worked" at this one a few times. Ming doesn't work there either. It was just like a TV version of the Tell 'em Steve-Dave podcast. I was smiling during it. The people selling stuff are obviously casted to come in but the banter and comments are just like them in the podcast.
#50
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Comic Book Men - New AMC reality show set in Kevin Smith's NJ comic shop
One and done for me. I'm wasn't sure what to expect, but wow....what a bunch of stereotypical comic store d-bags.