TV Guide's 100 Most Unexpected Moments List
#1
DVD Talk Legend
Thread Starter
TV Guide's 100 Most Unexpected Moments List
I won't get into the silliness of many of their picks (many weren't "unexpected" at all, since viewers knew in advance what was going to happen), but they made a flat out error in #17 on the list when they claim that Franco Harris' "Immaculate Reception" in 1972 sent the Pittsburgh Steelers to the Super Bowl.
As any NFL fan knows, the victory only sent the Steelers to the AFC Championship game, where they LOST to the Miami Dolphins - who went on to win the Super Bowl that year in the NFL's only perfect season (so far).
How the writers at TV GUIDE didn't know this, is anyone's guess!
As any NFL fan knows, the victory only sent the Steelers to the AFC Championship game, where they LOST to the Miami Dolphins - who went on to win the Super Bowl that year in the NFL's only perfect season (so far).
How the writers at TV GUIDE didn't know this, is anyone's guess!
#3
DVD Talk Legend
Can't find the complete list online, but here's the Top 10
http://www.tvguide.com/TV/CoverStory/
From sudden death to a flash of flesh, get ready to relive those super-surprising events that made stunned viewers say, "I can't believe what I just saw!" Get a taste of the 10 biggest jaw-droppers, in chronological order, below. Then see the full list in order in the Dec. 5 issue of TV Guide magazine and tune in to TV Land at 10 pm/ET, Dec. 5-9, for an in-depth look at The 100 Most Unexpected TV Moments.
The Who Blows Up on the Smothers Brothers (Sept. 17, 1967)
The Who wanted to finish with a bang after its U.S. performance of "My Generation" on the Smothers Brothers Comedy Hour, but when too many explosives were inadvertently put inside Keith Moon's drums, some band members nearly died before they got old. "I don't remember much about it," says guitarist Pete Townshend. "I was kind of in shock."
The Heidi Bowl (Nov. 17, 1968)
NBC cut away from a New York Jets-Oakland Raiders game that was running long. Why? To allow the TV-movie Heidi to start on time at 7 pm/ET. While the goat-herding girl traipsed through the Alps, Oakland scored two touchdowns in the final 65 seconds to win. Says Jennifer Edwards, who played Heidi, "My gravestone is gonna say, 'She was a great moment in sports.'"
A Dallas Dream (May 16, 1986)
How in Southfork's sake did the Dallas folks explain the resurrection of Bobby Ewing (Patrick Duffy) one year after his death? It took Bobby's wife, Pam (Victoria Principal), discovering him in the shower — hot and unbothered — to establish that the entire previous season had all been pretty Pam's dream. After the show, an incredulous nation rose from couches wondering, "Huh?"
The St. Elsewhere Finale (May 25, 1988)
This offbeat hospital drama ended its run by shaking everything up: The series was but a dream of Dr. Donald Westphall's autistic son, who in the show's final seconds held a snow globe containing a model of the Boston hospital. Snow kidding. "It sent a shock wave through the entire viewing community," says St. Elsewhere costar Howie Mandel.
The Newhart Finale (May 21, 1990)
TV legend Bob Newhart parodies — and perfects — the "dream sequence" finale when his entire Newhart series turns out to be the dream of Dr. Bob Hartley, his old Bob Newhart Show character. When a stunned Bob wakes up his first TV wife, Emily (Suzanne Pleshette), it's pure double-take genius. Says Newhart costar Tom Poston, "It has proven to be one of the great endings of all time."
Tonya Harding's Olympic Meltdown (Feb. 25, 1994)
Months before the Lillehammer Olympic games, Tonya Harding had reportedly paid a friend to try to break the leg of her rival, Nancy Kerrigan. But at the games, Harding's skate expectations were dashed when a last-minute loose lace turned her from lutzing contender to klutzy pretender.
Sudden Death on Seinfeld (May 16, 1996)
Sure, it's a show about "nothing," but is nothing sacred? When George's fiancée, Susan (Heidi Swedberg), died from licking toxic glue on the cheap envelopes he forced her to buy for their wedding invitations, it was Seinfeld at its black comic best. George never cared a lick for Susan, anyhow.
Tyson Bites Holyfield (June 28, 1997)
After repeated head butts from Evander Holyfield in their heavyweight title rematch, Mike Tyson put his career where his mouth was, taking not one but two bites of Holyfield's right ear before the fight was called. "It was such a shock," Holyfield says of Tyson's aural fixation. Recalls actor Bryan Callen (Fat Actress), "The look on Tyson's face was true madness." Eerie, even.
The Dean Scream (Jan. 19, 2004)
Why did one comical scream meant to rally his supporters after finishing third in the Iowa caucus turn former Vermont governor Howard Dean from Democratic hope to enigmatic dope? Well, TV audiences found it weird ("the scream of a wounded beast," says California pol Tom Hayden) and it sounded anything but presidential. What the yell?
Janet Jackson's Wardrobe Malfunction (Feb. 1, 2004)
Never mind those erectile dysfunction commercials: After Janet Jackson's sudden exposure on the Super Bowl XXXVIII halftime show, everyone from outraged parents to Laura Bush to the FCC threw the red flag. While the moment became the stuff of late-night jokes and instant-replay legend, its effect still lingers. Says Family Guy's Alex Borstein, "[Janet] changed censorship."
The Who Blows Up on the Smothers Brothers (Sept. 17, 1967)
The Who wanted to finish with a bang after its U.S. performance of "My Generation" on the Smothers Brothers Comedy Hour, but when too many explosives were inadvertently put inside Keith Moon's drums, some band members nearly died before they got old. "I don't remember much about it," says guitarist Pete Townshend. "I was kind of in shock."
The Heidi Bowl (Nov. 17, 1968)
NBC cut away from a New York Jets-Oakland Raiders game that was running long. Why? To allow the TV-movie Heidi to start on time at 7 pm/ET. While the goat-herding girl traipsed through the Alps, Oakland scored two touchdowns in the final 65 seconds to win. Says Jennifer Edwards, who played Heidi, "My gravestone is gonna say, 'She was a great moment in sports.'"
A Dallas Dream (May 16, 1986)
How in Southfork's sake did the Dallas folks explain the resurrection of Bobby Ewing (Patrick Duffy) one year after his death? It took Bobby's wife, Pam (Victoria Principal), discovering him in the shower — hot and unbothered — to establish that the entire previous season had all been pretty Pam's dream. After the show, an incredulous nation rose from couches wondering, "Huh?"
The St. Elsewhere Finale (May 25, 1988)
This offbeat hospital drama ended its run by shaking everything up: The series was but a dream of Dr. Donald Westphall's autistic son, who in the show's final seconds held a snow globe containing a model of the Boston hospital. Snow kidding. "It sent a shock wave through the entire viewing community," says St. Elsewhere costar Howie Mandel.
The Newhart Finale (May 21, 1990)
TV legend Bob Newhart parodies — and perfects — the "dream sequence" finale when his entire Newhart series turns out to be the dream of Dr. Bob Hartley, his old Bob Newhart Show character. When a stunned Bob wakes up his first TV wife, Emily (Suzanne Pleshette), it's pure double-take genius. Says Newhart costar Tom Poston, "It has proven to be one of the great endings of all time."
Tonya Harding's Olympic Meltdown (Feb. 25, 1994)
Months before the Lillehammer Olympic games, Tonya Harding had reportedly paid a friend to try to break the leg of her rival, Nancy Kerrigan. But at the games, Harding's skate expectations were dashed when a last-minute loose lace turned her from lutzing contender to klutzy pretender.
Sudden Death on Seinfeld (May 16, 1996)
Sure, it's a show about "nothing," but is nothing sacred? When George's fiancée, Susan (Heidi Swedberg), died from licking toxic glue on the cheap envelopes he forced her to buy for their wedding invitations, it was Seinfeld at its black comic best. George never cared a lick for Susan, anyhow.
Tyson Bites Holyfield (June 28, 1997)
After repeated head butts from Evander Holyfield in their heavyweight title rematch, Mike Tyson put his career where his mouth was, taking not one but two bites of Holyfield's right ear before the fight was called. "It was such a shock," Holyfield says of Tyson's aural fixation. Recalls actor Bryan Callen (Fat Actress), "The look on Tyson's face was true madness." Eerie, even.
The Dean Scream (Jan. 19, 2004)
Why did one comical scream meant to rally his supporters after finishing third in the Iowa caucus turn former Vermont governor Howard Dean from Democratic hope to enigmatic dope? Well, TV audiences found it weird ("the scream of a wounded beast," says California pol Tom Hayden) and it sounded anything but presidential. What the yell?
Janet Jackson's Wardrobe Malfunction (Feb. 1, 2004)
Never mind those erectile dysfunction commercials: After Janet Jackson's sudden exposure on the Super Bowl XXXVIII halftime show, everyone from outraged parents to Laura Bush to the FCC threw the red flag. While the moment became the stuff of late-night jokes and instant-replay legend, its effect still lingers. Says Family Guy's Alex Borstein, "[Janet] changed censorship."
#10
DVD Talk Legend
Originally Posted by Michael Corvin
What was so special about it? I watched it but don't recall anything rememorable.
Spoiler:
Edit: obviously, I should've spoilerized that. Just in case.
Last edited by Chew; 11-30-05 at 08:19 AM.
#11
Moderator
Originally Posted by Michael Corvin
What was so special about it? I watched it but don't recall anything rememorable.
Spoiler:
Last edited by Groucho; 11-30-05 at 03:27 PM.
#16
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Join Date: Apr 2003
Location: Seattle
Posts: 2,712
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by flagstone
Well, I haven't seen the whole list, but I would've thought Henry Blake's fate on MASH would be in the top ten.
Here's the whole list:
Spoiler:
Last edited by the big train; 11-30-05 at 02:29 PM.
#18
DVD Talk Legend
What about Jack Ruby shooting Lee Harvey Oswald?
The second plane flying into the WTC?
The Challenger exploding?
Didn't all those things happen live on TV?
Oh and they forgot Lace: "Which one of you bitches is my mother?"
The second plane flying into the WTC?
The Challenger exploding?
Didn't all those things happen live on TV?
Oh and they forgot Lace: "Which one of you bitches is my mother?"
Last edited by Jadzia; 11-30-05 at 02:44 PM.
#19
DVD Talk Legend
Pretty weak list. There are a lot of things that were more unexpected on Twin Peaks than a dancing midget. As a matter of fact, there is nothing unexpected about that at all.
#20
DVD Talk Legend
Originally Posted by cdollaz
Pretty weak list. There are a lot of things that were more unexpected on Twin Peaks than a dancing midget. As a matter of fact, there is nothing unexpected about that at all.
Out of all the things on Twin Peaks, they chose the dancing midget as unexpected? I would have thought that maybe Laura's killer would have been more unexpected.
Why not the dancing baby on Ally McBeal? That was more unexpected than anything on Twin Peaks.
I didn't see Rosalind Shays falling down the elevator shaft on LA Law on the list either. That should definitly be on there.
What happened during the finale of I Married Dora? I thought I was the only person who remembered that show.
#21
DVD Talk God
Join Date: Feb 2000
Location: Directionally Challenged (for DirecTV)
Posts: 130,277
Received 616 Likes
on
495 Posts
Originally Posted by Jadzia
I didn't see Rosalind Shays falling down the elevator shaft on LA Law on the list either. That should definitly be on there.
Nothing tops that as far as I'm concerned. The Dallas dream and Newhart endings are as close as it gets.
#23
DVD Talk Legend
Thread Starter
I would have thought JR getting shot would have been more unexpected than Bobby showing up in the shower.
What about when Fox Mulder "committed suicide"?
Or when Bobby Simone died on NYPD Blue?
Heck...seems to me that LOST has already had a half-dozen or so moments that top most on this list!
And as already pointed out, there are dozens of live TV moments and events that qualify as "Unexpected".
My biggest gripe was the one about Muhammad Ali...not that that wasn't a great TV moment...but EVERYONE knew he was going to be carrying the torch!!! So how exactly was that "unexpected"?!
Anyway - every time TV GUIDE does one of these "TOP LISTS" it only goes to show how young and uninformed their writers are.
What about when Fox Mulder "committed suicide"?
Or when Bobby Simone died on NYPD Blue?
Heck...seems to me that LOST has already had a half-dozen or so moments that top most on this list!
And as already pointed out, there are dozens of live TV moments and events that qualify as "Unexpected".
My biggest gripe was the one about Muhammad Ali...not that that wasn't a great TV moment...but EVERYONE knew he was going to be carrying the torch!!! So how exactly was that "unexpected"?!
Anyway - every time TV GUIDE does one of these "TOP LISTS" it only goes to show how young and uninformed their writers are.
#24
DVD Talk God
Join Date: Feb 2000
Location: Directionally Challenged (for DirecTV)
Posts: 130,277
Received 616 Likes
on
495 Posts
Originally Posted by Shannon Nutt
Or when Bobby Simone died on NYPD Blue?