Kingdoms of Amalur: Reckoning (PC, 360, PS3)
#51
Re: Kingdoms of Amalur: Reckoning (PC, 360, PS3)
Pretty nice article from Penny Arcade. For $45 I think I'll go ahead and order it.
http://penny-arcade.com/2012/01/27/amalur
http://penny-arcade.com/2012/01/27/amalur
And after reading these glowing reviews I'm curious to see how much the released game will differ from the demo.
#52
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Join Date: Jun 2002
Posts: 8,487
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Kingdoms of Amalur: Reckoning (PC, 360, PS3)
Not sure what's so hard to understand. Online passes are a consumer-screwing practice all around, for reasons discussed endlessly here and elsewhere, and I refuse to support titles that use them, at least not at full price on day one.
#53
DVD Talk Godfather & 2020 TOTY Winner
Re: Kingdoms of Amalur: Reckoning (PC, 360, PS3)
And technically $45 isn't full price anyway. But I see what you were saying.
#54
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: Kingdoms of Amalur: Reckoning (PC, 360, PS3)
I think online passes are a decent way to provide some 'value add' and motivation for buying new. Obviously there's a range there - 7 new quests out of 200 would be a 'value add', 7 new quests out of 20 would be artificially crippling the release.
I would sure rather them continue to the online pass thing, versus hardware locking, full digital download, or some of the other more anti-consumer paths they could take. My only concern is that we're still not at full broadband, or even full connectivity yet; and if they do that, either the online pass can't expire or the expiration date needs to be clearly identified on the outside of the package and the price should drop once that date is passed (which by then it probably would anyway).
I did download and play the demo, it does look like a good balance between Skyrim-type and Diablo/DMC-type games. I'll probably pick it up once it's out for a while, after a price drop - my backlog is too big right now to pay 60 or 45 for a new game.
I would sure rather them continue to the online pass thing, versus hardware locking, full digital download, or some of the other more anti-consumer paths they could take. My only concern is that we're still not at full broadband, or even full connectivity yet; and if they do that, either the online pass can't expire or the expiration date needs to be clearly identified on the outside of the package and the price should drop once that date is passed (which by then it probably would anyway).
I did download and play the demo, it does look like a good balance between Skyrim-type and Diablo/DMC-type games. I'll probably pick it up once it's out for a while, after a price drop - my backlog is too big right now to pay 60 or 45 for a new game.
#55
DVD Talk Godfather
Thread Starter
Re: Kingdoms of Amalur: Reckoning (PC, 360, PS3)
Online passes also help support the developers of games. If you generally buy new anyway, its not just about screwing consumers.
#56
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Kingdoms of Amalur: Reckoning (PC, 360, PS3)
It's free DLC for people who buy the game new. There's nothing insidious here.
#57
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Join Date: Jun 2002
Posts: 8,487
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Kingdoms of Amalur: Reckoning (PC, 360, PS3)
It's content that's ready on day 1, was originally planned and developed as part of the on-disc game, and was cut out as a way to encourage new sales. They can label it "free DLC," but that doesn't change the reality of the situation. The problem is that buyers of new copies suffer too. Sorry, not paying full price or even $45 for a gimped single-player game.
Anyway, I don't want to turn this thread into an off-topic debate that's already been rehashed a hundred times. I enjoyed the demo and look forward to playing this game in about 6 months, or perhaps sooner via Gamefly.
Anyway, I don't want to turn this thread into an off-topic debate that's already been rehashed a hundred times. I enjoyed the demo and look forward to playing this game in about 6 months, or perhaps sooner via Gamefly.
#58
DVD Talk Godfather & 2020 TOTY Winner
Re: Kingdoms of Amalur: Reckoning (PC, 360, PS3)
#59
DVD Talk Legend
#60
DVD Talk Legend
Join Date: Jun 2000
Location: NYC
Posts: 17,015
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Kingdoms of Amalur: Reckoning (PC, 360, PS3)
It annoys me, but I recognize that it's a way to drive purchases. I'll live.
#61
Re: Kingdoms of Amalur: Reckoning (PC, 360, PS3)
The combat system looks great! That's the main issue I have with wrpgs is that open world action rpgs battle system end up outdated once the next comes out. This looks like it will hold up nicely. On the subject of the dlc what will happen if in a few years the servers holding the dlc are no longer up? People that buy the game new will be screwed.
Last edited by mhg83; 01-29-12 at 08:05 AM.
#62
DVD Talk Godfather & 2020 TOTY Winner
Re: Kingdoms of Amalur: Reckoning (PC, 360, PS3)
Here's his post in the official game forum thread discussing the Day 1 DLC:
Originally Posted by Curt Schilling
Ok, everyone take a deep breath. 48 pages, damn.
I was hoping to come in here and start this thread another way, but I can't. Anything other than "I didn't know' feels better, but is really a lie. Believe it or not in a company of 400+ I don't get the nitty gritty details of everything, and I make mistakes. I did both here, and it's on me.
Believe that or not, it's true.
Next. I honestly was wondering what the fuss was about as I woke up a bit dazed and jet lagged, to see the thread, and unlike most companies I didn't 'check in' with PR and Marketing folks, to see what was going on or if there was an 'official response', again that's totally on me.
Now if you, and we, both want to go that route we could, and that would mean I would stop posting (our community team just lept off the ground!), but I can't, it's not me.
Me making that statement though, it appears as if the TEAM, our team, is disorganized, and that is not the case, this is squarely on me, and something I should have pursued a conversation on a long time ago.
That being said, this next part is likely to piss people off, but it's a truth and it's how I feel. You can argue the merits and effectiveness of it, but right now it's how it's done and as someone that's as invested as I am in this company, I stand by what has happened.
DAY 1 DLC, to be extremely and VIVIDLY clear, is FREE, 100% totally FREE, to anyone that buys a new copy of Reckoning, ANYONE.
If you don't buy new games you buy them used, and in that case you will have to pay for the Day 1 free DLC content the new copy buyers got for free.
It's clear the intent right? To promote early adopters and MUCH MORE IMPORTANT TO ME, REWARD fans and gamers who commit to us with their time and money when it benefits the company.
Every single person on the planet could wait and not buy Reckoning, the game would hit the bargain bin at some point and you could get it cheaper. 38 Studios would likely go away.
That's just how business works. We MUST make a profit to become what we want to become. THE ONLY way we do that is to make games you CANNOT WAIT TO BUY! If we do that, and you do that, we want to reward you with some cool free stuff as a thank you.
You can TOTALLY disagree with this and I am sure many do, so we'll agree to disagree. This is not 38 trying to take more of your money, or EA in this case, this is us REWARDING people for HELPING US! If you disagree due to methodology, ok, but that is our intent.
I said earlier I did not know, truth is after a day of soul searching I do remember conversations I was on the cusp of but I, ME, never followed up and didn't ever pursue them. But damn, if EA and EAP don't step in and bet on us it would have never mattered and this game would have never been made.
The industry is in a very odd place. The data coming in on used game sales is not saying the things many thought it should, or would. But companies are still trying to figure out how to receive dollars spent on games they make, when they are bought. Is that wrong? if so please tell me how.
Again, you can argue with methods, or process, and you absolutely can bitch and gripe about ANY DAY 1 DLC you are charged for, because I think I agree with many on that, but we are trying to create something here, product and company wise, and it takes dollars to do that.
I said above but I will restate, this falls squarely on me, it is my responsibility as the leader to know of things like this and be aware that it would become an issue, I failed on both accounts. No one else is to blame, but at the same time there is no nefarious attempt to do anything under handed here, you get the content, NO MATTER WHAT PLATFORM you purchase the game for, or what outlet you buy from, FOR FREE.
I was hoping to come in here and start this thread another way, but I can't. Anything other than "I didn't know' feels better, but is really a lie. Believe it or not in a company of 400+ I don't get the nitty gritty details of everything, and I make mistakes. I did both here, and it's on me.
Believe that or not, it's true.
Next. I honestly was wondering what the fuss was about as I woke up a bit dazed and jet lagged, to see the thread, and unlike most companies I didn't 'check in' with PR and Marketing folks, to see what was going on or if there was an 'official response', again that's totally on me.
Now if you, and we, both want to go that route we could, and that would mean I would stop posting (our community team just lept off the ground!), but I can't, it's not me.
Me making that statement though, it appears as if the TEAM, our team, is disorganized, and that is not the case, this is squarely on me, and something I should have pursued a conversation on a long time ago.
That being said, this next part is likely to piss people off, but it's a truth and it's how I feel. You can argue the merits and effectiveness of it, but right now it's how it's done and as someone that's as invested as I am in this company, I stand by what has happened.
DAY 1 DLC, to be extremely and VIVIDLY clear, is FREE, 100% totally FREE, to anyone that buys a new copy of Reckoning, ANYONE.
If you don't buy new games you buy them used, and in that case you will have to pay for the Day 1 free DLC content the new copy buyers got for free.
It's clear the intent right? To promote early adopters and MUCH MORE IMPORTANT TO ME, REWARD fans and gamers who commit to us with their time and money when it benefits the company.
Every single person on the planet could wait and not buy Reckoning, the game would hit the bargain bin at some point and you could get it cheaper. 38 Studios would likely go away.
That's just how business works. We MUST make a profit to become what we want to become. THE ONLY way we do that is to make games you CANNOT WAIT TO BUY! If we do that, and you do that, we want to reward you with some cool free stuff as a thank you.
You can TOTALLY disagree with this and I am sure many do, so we'll agree to disagree. This is not 38 trying to take more of your money, or EA in this case, this is us REWARDING people for HELPING US! If you disagree due to methodology, ok, but that is our intent.
I said earlier I did not know, truth is after a day of soul searching I do remember conversations I was on the cusp of but I, ME, never followed up and didn't ever pursue them. But damn, if EA and EAP don't step in and bet on us it would have never mattered and this game would have never been made.
The industry is in a very odd place. The data coming in on used game sales is not saying the things many thought it should, or would. But companies are still trying to figure out how to receive dollars spent on games they make, when they are bought. Is that wrong? if so please tell me how.
Again, you can argue with methods, or process, and you absolutely can bitch and gripe about ANY DAY 1 DLC you are charged for, because I think I agree with many on that, but we are trying to create something here, product and company wise, and it takes dollars to do that.
I said above but I will restate, this falls squarely on me, it is my responsibility as the leader to know of things like this and be aware that it would become an issue, I failed on both accounts. No one else is to blame, but at the same time there is no nefarious attempt to do anything under handed here, you get the content, NO MATTER WHAT PLATFORM you purchase the game for, or what outlet you buy from, FOR FREE.
Spoiler:
A guy that frank and honest is someone I can get behind. I'm willing to spend an extra $20 to get the game at a launch window on discount rather than waiting three months for the inevitable price drop. I hope his game is a success.
#63
DVD Talk Godfather
Thread Starter
Re: Kingdoms of Amalur: Reckoning (PC, 360, PS3)
Heh, my friend at 38 Studios was exclaiming to me how the demo was a PR thing and not a game studio thing as well when I was commenting to her about it the day it was released. Kind of neat to see Curt Schilling to open and honest about it on the forums.
And really, if anyone is ever involved with the video game industry, it gives you a different perspective on what "screws the customers." I'm biased, but the next time you see a developer get shuttered, ways to encourage people to buy new make more sense.
And really, if anyone is ever involved with the video game industry, it gives you a different perspective on what "screws the customers." I'm biased, but the next time you see a developer get shuttered, ways to encourage people to buy new make more sense.
#64
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Join Date: Jun 2002
Posts: 8,487
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Kingdoms of Amalur: Reckoning (PC, 360, PS3)
Originally Posted by Curt Schilling
That's just how business works. We MUST make a profit to become what we want to become. THE ONLY way we do that is to make games you CANNOT WAIT TO BUY! If we do that, and you do that, we want to reward you with some cool free stuff as a thank you.
Originally Posted by Curt Schilling
The industry is in a very odd place. The data coming in on used game sales is not saying the things many thought it should, or would. But companies are still trying to figure out how to receive dollars spent on games they make, when they are bought. Is that wrong? if so please tell me how.
#65
DVD Talk Godfather & 2020 TOTY Winner
Re: Kingdoms of Amalur: Reckoning (PC, 360, PS3)
So make games I cannot wait to buy then, without the need for additional scheming. You're inconveniencing me as a buyer with having to input a code and wait for a large download before I start playing (yes, I know I don't have to, but if the content was on the disc as evidence indicates it was originally intended to be, it wouldn't be an issue). Skyrim had no codes, downloads, day-1 DLC, or any other ploys and it sold just fine because it was a must-have, obviously-great game.
What I do have a problem with is when those new DLC bonus codes expire. That's just not right and not fair. If EA wants to stop adding them in the packaging after a while (like they did with Battlefield 3, Dead Space 2 and Bulletstorm) to reward those who buy the game at launch, that's fine. But to penalize folks who haven't gotten around to unwrapping the game or punching in the code yet is unnecessary and lousy. Speaking of which, their Dragon Age 2 DLC code expires in March.
Um, you already do receive those dollars when the game you made is bought the first time. After that, it's out of your hands and quite frankly none of your business what happens to the product you already sold, just as is the case with every other resellable product in the history of mankind.
Last edited by Decker; 01-29-12 at 10:50 AM.
#66
gamer for life
Re: Kingdoms of Amalur: Reckoning (PC, 360, PS3)
If I really believed for one second that online passes...and codes for Sp content was going to stop here...that this was the end of their way of trying to control the used market..I might not have as much of a problem with it...
I for one second don't think it stops here...
Greed...
A digital release of a game should be cheaper than a physical copy..it is not. (sticking with console here) In fact it is almost comical how much higher they are.
Used is a part of life for many people. I know that the government has defined ownership of media differently than a car...but that is to make sure I don't buy a cd of Metallica and then take that music and use it freely in movies or my own music....not to take away your right to sell that record..
Just about everything I buy, I have a right to give it away or sell it. They want to take that away from you with console games. They did this with PC games to fight piracy (while in their minds also thinking it would help profits) and while PC game is NOT dead (far from it)...games don't sell as well on pc as they do console...outside PC exclusives of course...
What it really boils down to...next generation if my xbox/ps4 requires a code to play my game...if I can no longer let my kids play my copies of games on their systems...if I can no longer go into a store in the mall and browse thousands of games I don't need but will end up buying....if I can no longer sell my games for no reason other than to get rid of my mess...if I can no longer talk my friends who are low on money into going into Gamestop and trading Rainbow Six Vegas 1 and 2 so he can get this new Left 4 Dead Game to play....I AM JUST GOING BACK TO PC GAMING!
Seriously...When the next xbox comes out it is STILL going to be weaker than my current 5970 computer...I will finally take the time to put my pc in my room...hook up my xbox controller to it...get a casual keyboard/mouse for other games...and play my games in higher quality...Besides Kinect/Move...what the fuck will the next xbox offer at that point? Xbox live? My friends and I connect just fine on our PCs right now.....
Some people have predicted next gen will be the last gen...and funny enough Microsoft/EA/Sony...might be helping it happen..
I for one second don't think it stops here...
Greed...
A digital release of a game should be cheaper than a physical copy..it is not. (sticking with console here) In fact it is almost comical how much higher they are.
Used is a part of life for many people. I know that the government has defined ownership of media differently than a car...but that is to make sure I don't buy a cd of Metallica and then take that music and use it freely in movies or my own music....not to take away your right to sell that record..
Just about everything I buy, I have a right to give it away or sell it. They want to take that away from you with console games. They did this with PC games to fight piracy (while in their minds also thinking it would help profits) and while PC game is NOT dead (far from it)...games don't sell as well on pc as they do console...outside PC exclusives of course...
What it really boils down to...next generation if my xbox/ps4 requires a code to play my game...if I can no longer let my kids play my copies of games on their systems...if I can no longer go into a store in the mall and browse thousands of games I don't need but will end up buying....if I can no longer sell my games for no reason other than to get rid of my mess...if I can no longer talk my friends who are low on money into going into Gamestop and trading Rainbow Six Vegas 1 and 2 so he can get this new Left 4 Dead Game to play....I AM JUST GOING BACK TO PC GAMING!
Seriously...When the next xbox comes out it is STILL going to be weaker than my current 5970 computer...I will finally take the time to put my pc in my room...hook up my xbox controller to it...get a casual keyboard/mouse for other games...and play my games in higher quality...Besides Kinect/Move...what the fuck will the next xbox offer at that point? Xbox live? My friends and I connect just fine on our PCs right now.....
Some people have predicted next gen will be the last gen...and funny enough Microsoft/EA/Sony...might be helping it happen..
Last edited by foxdvd; 01-29-12 at 12:15 PM.
#67
DVD Talk Godfather
Thread Starter
Re: Kingdoms of Amalur: Reckoning (PC, 360, PS3)
I wonder how much profit is required for it to no longer become just a profitable business, but a greedy one.
#68
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Kingdoms of Amalur: Reckoning (PC, 360, PS3)
Used is a part of life for many people. I know that the government has defined ownership of media differently than a car...but that is to make sure I don't buy a cd of Metallica and then take that music and use it freely in movies or my own music....not to take away your right to sell that record..
Just about everything I buy, I have a right to give it away or sell it. They want to take that away from you with console games. They did this with PC games to fight piracy (while in their minds also thinking it would help profits) and while PC game is NOT dead (far from it)...games don't sell as well on pc as they do console...outside PC exclusives of course...
Also, PC gaming revenue is actually increasing, as an industry, while console game revenue has been flat the past few years:
http://www.extremetech.com/gaming/97...rtake-consoles
http://www.tomshardware.com/news/nvi...ing,13499.html
What it really boils down to...next generation if my xbox/ps4 requires a code to play my game...if I can no longer let my kids play my copies of games on their systems...if I can no longer go into a store in the mall and browse thousands of games I don't need but will end up buying....if I can no longer sell my games for no reason other than to get rid of my mess...if I can no longer talk my friends who are low on money into going into Gamestop and trading Rainbow Six Vegas 1 and 2 so he can get this new Left 4 Dead Game to play....I AM JUST GOING BACK TO PC GAMING!
Seriously...When the next xbox comes out it is STILL going to be weaker than my current 5970 computer...
Some people have predicted next gen [console] will be the last gen...
#69
DVD Talk Godfather
Thread Starter
Re: Kingdoms of Amalur: Reckoning (PC, 360, PS3)
The current rumor for the next XBox is something comparable in the ATI 6000 series, so it might not be weaker then your existing system.
Its funny, people seem pretty happy with Steam given the steep discounts that are frequently offered, despite the inability to resell games. As long as an avenue for bigger discounts is there, the used game market and recouping money would be less of a big deal sans all the cheap ass gamers I guess this would need to be a change in mindset, but for the most part playing a game through once is the experience i'm paying for, not much different from spending money to watch a movie in the theater. I don't mind the inability to not get an additional return on my time and entertainment after the fact.
Its funny, people seem pretty happy with Steam given the steep discounts that are frequently offered, despite the inability to resell games. As long as an avenue for bigger discounts is there, the used game market and recouping money would be less of a big deal sans all the cheap ass gamers I guess this would need to be a change in mindset, but for the most part playing a game through once is the experience i'm paying for, not much different from spending money to watch a movie in the theater. I don't mind the inability to not get an additional return on my time and entertainment after the fact.
#70
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Kingdoms of Amalur: Reckoning (PC, 360, PS3)
For example, a lot of people see day-one DLC and think, "this content is stuff that was in the full game that they then cut out in order to make buy new or pay extra for with a used copy." This is in contrast to DLC that comes out later and is viewed more often as optional bonus content you can buy or not.
So, is Kingdoms of Amalur a game with 7 of its quests cut out to make for day-one DLC, or is it a complete game on disc, with a 7 quest DLC added as a free bonus for anyone buying new?
http://videogamewriters.com/clarific...ass-dlc-37578/
http://www.analoghype.com/video-game...nd-loads-more/
#71
gamer for life
Re: Kingdoms of Amalur: Reckoning (PC, 360, PS3)
Also, PC gaming revenue is actually increasing, as an industry, while console game revenue has been flat the past few years:
http://www.extremetech.com/gaming/97...rtake-consoles
http://www.tomshardware.com/news/nvi...ing,13499.html
.
and my point about pc games and DRM...one of the reasons I got back into console gaming was how easy it was to buy games at a store and not mess with DRM...I do buy games on steam...but usually when it is a great deal..when the 360 came out the games looks very good compared to my pc..and it was just easier...once they take away that and make my xbox into a pc...I am going back to pc..
and yes my pc cost a lot more than my xbox...but I put this pc together 2 years ago...and it is still going to be stronger than the next gen of consoles 3 years from now...
I also think you are going to see more gaming pc's target the casual consumer...
#72
gamer for life
Re: Kingdoms of Amalur: Reckoning (PC, 360, PS3)
#73
DVD Talk Godfather
Thread Starter
Re: Kingdoms of Amalur: Reckoning (PC, 360, PS3)
Why would it be a 70 dollar card? Not if its closer to a 6970 in performance, and even then consoles have always offered the ability for far more optimization.
#74
gamer for life
Re: Kingdoms of Amalur: Reckoning (PC, 360, PS3)
of course...no one knows for sure what card they will have...IGN started a shit storm when they said it would be like a 6670...
#75
DVD Talk Godfather
Thread Starter
Re: Kingdoms of Amalur: Reckoning (PC, 360, PS3)
6970 is a 300 dollar card...I think they are talking 6670 here...if they can get a 6970 into the next xbox...and sell it for 299...Sony might as well give up now...
of course...no one knows for sure what card they will have...IGN started a shit storm when they said it would be like a 6670...
of course...no one knows for sure what card they will have...IGN started a shit storm when they said it would be like a 6670...