Bands or Musicians That Almost Everyone Seems to Like... But I Don't
#101
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Bands or Musicians That Almost Everyone Seems to Like... But I Don't
By definition, no opinion is wrong, but you know that, or ought to. Just accept that not everyone has the same stratospheric opinion of V.U. as you do. As I wrote, I greatly enjoy the first album, and the post-W.L./W.H. albums contain a few meritorious songs as well (e.g. "Pale Blue Eyes", "Stephanie Says", "Temptation Inside Your Heart", "I'm Sticking With You"). However, much of the rest is, yes, boring to me. You'll just have to deal with it.
I agree with those that said they certainly filled the role of being influential. But their actual content comes off like somebody trying to do something different, and ground breaking, and falling flat. Quite literally if you focus on the vocals. Just terrible, even for that genre.
#102
#103
Banned by request
Re: Bands or Musicians That Almost Everyone Seems to Like... But I Don't
In my opinion, The Velvet Underground is the most important American rock band of all time. The band broke so much ground musically, lyrically, and conceptually that their influence is still keenly felt today.
#104
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Bands or Musicians That Almost Everyone Seems to Like... But I Don't
Pearl Jam has always kind of been a band that people either seem to listen to or don't know much about at all. Surprised to read that some people in here actually hate them though. I'd say they're arguably one of the greatest American bands of the past twenty-five years and one of the only long-standing modern bands who have kept most of their main lineup the same (the drummers have rotated a few times but Matt Cameron has been with them a long time and the rest of the band has stayed the same).
#105
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Bands or Musicians That Almost Everyone Seems to Like... But I Don't
Pearl Jam has always kind of been a band that people either seem to listen to or don't know much about at all. Surprised to read that some people in here actually hate them though. I'd say they're arguably one of the greatest American bands of the past twenty-five years and one of the only long-standing modern bands who have kept most of their main lineup the same (the drummers have rotated a few times but Matt Cameron has been with them a long time and the rest of the band has stayed the same).
I can't explain it and I don't feel that way about any other group.
"Ten" is so great and everything else of theirs is just so "eh."
#106
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Bands or Musicians That Almost Everyone Seems to Like... But I Don't
And this comes from a guy that grew up with those guys listening to their music throughout the years. Including when they went by Green River or Mother Love Bone.
#107
DVD Talk Legend
Join Date: Dec 2000
Location: Cape Ann, Massachusetts
Posts: 10,928
Likes: 0
Received 2 Likes
on
2 Posts
Re: Bands or Musicians That Almost Everyone Seems to Like... But I Don't
I don't disagree, but I still hold that the SONGS on Cut the Crap are pretty decent--it was the terrible production with the Casio keyboards and gang-shouted choruses that really killed it.
#108
Re: Bands or Musicians That Almost Everyone Seems to Like... But I Don't
#109
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Bands or Musicians That Almost Everyone Seems to Like... But I Don't
I include Vs. and some of Vitology in there, but otherwise I agree. After those first few albums they now basically seem like a singles band. One or two great songs from each album, rest... meh.
And this comes from a guy that grew up with those guys listening to their music throughout the years. Including when they went by Green River or Mother Love Bone.
And this comes from a guy that grew up with those guys listening to their music throughout the years. Including when they went by Green River or Mother Love Bone.
As for not liking their output after a certain point I tend to find that happens with some bands. They change over the course of time but some fans just reject what a band evolves into and write them off. I can understand having favorite albums but I think not liking a band after a certain point comes down to not giving them a chance and longing for the past.
Last edited by Mike86; 03-05-15 at 12:03 PM.
#111
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Bands or Musicians That Almost Everyone Seems to Like... But I Don't
For me, an "album band" has to consistently put out releases don't feel like two or three singles completed with a lot of filler that doesn't hold up to the singles. For me Pearl Jam hit that wall partially with Vitalogy (only half of that album compares Ten and Vs. in quality, rest feels like filler) and went there full time with Yield when "Given To Fly" seemed to be purposely tailored for mainstream airplay and the rest was a big step down.
#112
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Bands or Musicians That Almost Everyone Seems to Like... But I Don't
I still wouldn't agree with calling them a singles band though. They've released singles and some have caught on but for the most part they aren't very mainstream popular with a lot of radio play or music videos.
#113
Banned by request
Re: Bands or Musicians That Almost Everyone Seems to Like... But I Don't
Pearl Jam isn't a singles band, they're just a mediocre, long in the tooth album band.
#114
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Bands or Musicians That Almost Everyone Seems to Like... But I Don't
Last edited by hdnmickey; 03-05-15 at 03:08 PM.
#115
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Bands or Musicians That Almost Everyone Seems to Like... But I Don't
I would disagree about them going from an album band to a singles band, though. The first two albums were strong overall albums with good singles on them, at which point they started moving away from singles (and videos) and started putting out weaker albums. I find most of their output from the mid 90s on to be dull and unlistenable.
#116
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Bands or Musicians That Almost Everyone Seems to Like... But I Don't
Mostly agreed. Ten and Vs were great albums; Vitology has some good songs on it, but it's also where they started down the road to wankery.
I would disagree about them going from an album band to a singles band, though. The first two albums were strong overall albums with good singles on them, at which point they started moving away from singles (and videos) and started putting out weaker albums. I find most of their output from the mid 90s on to be dull and unlistenable.
I would disagree about them going from an album band to a singles band, though. The first two albums were strong overall albums with good singles on them, at which point they started moving away from singles (and videos) and started putting out weaker albums. I find most of their output from the mid 90s on to be dull and unlistenable.
#117
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Bands or Musicians That Almost Everyone Seems to Like... But I Don't
I guess it just comes down to a matter of taste. Personally I like what they've evolved into and that they don't necessarily cater to what's popular or to the mainstream. I think they had a stretch of somewhat more experimental albums (Yield, No Code, and Binaural) that maybe turned off some people and those fans may have not gone back since. I like those albums but it's because I'm a fan of them overall and can see how some might have been turned off. I think they came back in full form with 2006's self-titled album and have had solid output since.
#118
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Bands or Musicians That Almost Everyone Seems to Like... But I Don't
Foo Fighters is another group that I feel takes a step down after every album they release. I find their recent stuff almost unlistenable. It all sounds the same and has become monotonous.
#119
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Bands or Musicians That Almost Everyone Seems to Like... But I Don't
As to Pearl Jam, I think that Yield and Backspacer are their best two albums and the only ones that I listen to more than once every five years or so. I have no interest in hearing Ten anymore as that one hasn't aged very well.
As for The Clash, I am OK with everything thru London Calling, but Sandanista is just too long with a lot of shit on it, and Combat Rock is mostly completely boring shit.
As for The Clash, I am OK with everything thru London Calling, but Sandanista is just too long with a lot of shit on it, and Combat Rock is mostly completely boring shit.
#120
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Bands or Musicians That Almost Everyone Seems to Like... But I Don't
Ten is great but I can see getting tired of it if it was overplayed. Still though there's a ton of solid songs on that album.
#121
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: Bands or Musicians That Almost Everyone Seems to Like... But I Don't
OK, I've figured out a few here:
I find Pearl Jam really boring.
I find ELO too cheesy / goofball theatrical or something.
I find "beautiful" folky indie rock like Fleet Foxes, Bon Iver, Iron and Wine, Father John Misty etc to be meandering, pointless and pretentious. I already made a thread about this.
I don't like anything Bjork has done since Homogenic. I'm not sure most people do though, so this isn't saying much.
I find Pearl Jam really boring.
I find ELO too cheesy / goofball theatrical or something.
I find "beautiful" folky indie rock like Fleet Foxes, Bon Iver, Iron and Wine, Father John Misty etc to be meandering, pointless and pretentious. I already made a thread about this.
I don't like anything Bjork has done since Homogenic. I'm not sure most people do though, so this isn't saying much.
#122
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Bands or Musicians That Almost Everyone Seems to Like... But I Don't
Where's your thread? See, while I agree that some of those bands can be like that, I think, besides being mostly acoustic, those bands are diverse and can be so different from each other, lumping them together is like saying all rock bands are pointless and pretentious.
#123
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Re: Bands or Musicians That Almost Everyone Seems to Like... But I Don't
Pearl Jam has always kind of been a band that people either seem to listen to or don't know much about at all. Surprised to read that some people in here actually hate them though. I'd say they're arguably one of the greatest American bands of the past twenty-five years and one of the only long-standing modern bands who have kept most of their main lineup the same (the drummers have rotated a few times but Matt Cameron has been with them a long time and the rest of the band has stayed the same).
#124
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: Bands or Musicians That Almost Everyone Seems to Like... But I Don't
The problem I have is multifold:
1. The songs simply aren't there with a lot of these bands and too infreqently they're not called out for it. The style can be done well (I like a lot of Kurt Vile / Steve Gunn) but too often the folky / retro trappings are covering up for some weak melodies and arrangements that go nowhere. Critics and popular sentiment seem to forgive a lot with thse bands, stuff they're more than willing to call out in, say, pop.
2. The music often seems deliberately retro and straining to be "authentic" in a way that sounds awfully inauthentic. Lots of banjos, beards and kick drums. Sometimes I feel that these bans are straight-up ripping off older artists but in a bloodless / anodyne / "let's pray the kids haven't heard 'Deja Vu'" kind of way.
3. There's a hell of a lot of bandwagoning going on here. Whenever I sense a "movement" with signifiers ('oh, they're that type of band') I start to get a little twitchy. References become shorthand. Being "influenced" by a band becomes simply stealing an earlier (and better) band's ideas.
#125
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Bands or Musicians That Almost Everyone Seems to Like... But I Don't