Make a Bold Statement About Music
#101
Re: Make a Bold Statement About Music
http://metaldescent.com/the-best-sel...s-of-all-time/
#102
Moderator
Re: Make a Bold Statement About Music
Seems to be torn opinion regarding Dave Grohl. I'll toss this one in here, too:
While I am sad it comes at the expense of someone's life and the loved ones it directly impacts, if I had the choice between Nirvana continuing or Foo Fighters ever existing, I'll take Foo Fighters.
While I am sad it comes at the expense of someone's life and the loved ones it directly impacts, if I had the choice between Nirvana continuing or Foo Fighters ever existing, I'll take Foo Fighters.
#103
Re: Make a Bold Statement About Music
Most of the new electronic music is nonsense only accessible to those on heavy doses of opioids but given importance by hipsters that read Pitchfork.
#104
Re: Make a Bold Statement About Music
Seems to be torn opinion regarding Dave Grohl. I'll toss this one in here, too:
While I am sad it comes at the expense of someone's life and the loved ones it directly impacts, if I had the choice between Nirvana continuing or Foo Fighters ever existing, I'll take Foo Fighters.
While I am sad it comes at the expense of someone's life and the loved ones it directly impacts, if I had the choice between Nirvana continuing or Foo Fighters ever existing, I'll take Foo Fighters.
#105
Re: Make a Bold Statement About Music
I don't know, a case can be made that metal artist sold more then, but I think those sales were only spread across a few bands, namely Metallica. This list kinda supports my view of the Hair Metal/Nu-Metal popularity.
http://metaldescent.com/the-best-sel...s-of-all-time/
http://metaldescent.com/the-best-sel...s-of-all-time/
And just because a band is labeled Hair or Nu doesn't mean it's not good metal. Motley Crue and Guns and Roses are hair bands through and through but they have the musical chops to back it up. There's a world of difference between them and say, Winger.
#107
Re: Make a Bold Statement About Music
Before Metallica (and the other slew of post-hardcore metal hybrids), all there was was "hair metal" and before that 70's metal. (I am speaking in generalities.)
#108
#109
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Make a Bold Statement About Music
Considering half the shirts I saw everyday in jr. high and high school between about 1980 - 1986 had Iron Maiden, Priest, Ozzy, Sabbath, Dio, and similar on them, I'd say metal was pretty damn popular. Pretty much every guy, and half the girls my age liked metal. Hair metal (as I define it) didn't really come around until the latter half of the 80's with Poison, Warrant and that stuff.
#110
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Make a Bold Statement About Music
I don't know, a case can be made that metal artist sold more then, but I think those sales were only spread across a few bands, namely Metallica. This list kinda supports my view of the Hair Metal/Nu-Metal popularity.
http://metaldescent.com/the-best-sel...s-of-all-time/
http://metaldescent.com/the-best-sel...s-of-all-time/
I would argue "real" metal is defined precisely by it not being commercially popular. There is a sensibility about metal that is not palatable for the average popular music listener. That's why a producer like Bob Rock was able to make Metallica as huge as they were - by knowing how to soften them up enough to be palatable to the masses.
#111
DVD Talk Reviewer & TOAT Winner
Re: Make a Bold Statement About Music
There is more good music being made today than ever before, you just have to go look for it.
#112
Re: Make a Bold Statement About Music
#114
Re: Make a Bold Statement About Music
#115
Re: Make a Bold Statement About Music
Thank you for that. Anyone who dismisses them as bubblegum pop (or worse, a disco band) doesn't know what they're talking about. Their music may not be to everyone's taste, but their output was far more complex, original and oftentimes dark than what they're usually ever given credit for.
#116
Re: Make a Bold Statement About Music
My bold statement:
No denying that the Beatles were great and influential. But dang if their nasal voices were oftentimes too grating to listen to.
No denying that the Beatles were great and influential. But dang if their nasal voices were oftentimes too grating to listen to.
#117
DVD Talk Legend
Join Date: Dec 2000
Location: Cape Ann, Massachusetts
Posts: 10,928
Likes: 0
Received 2 Likes
on
2 Posts
Re: Make a Bold Statement About Music
Thank you for that. Anyone who dismisses them as bubblegum pop (or worse, a disco band) doesn't know what they're talking about. Their music may not be to everyone's taste, but their output was far more complex, original and oftentimes dark than what they're usually ever given credit for.
* wrote all their own songs
* played all their own instruments
* had a totally unique sound
* sounded great live
* wrote MONSTER hooks
* I believe were very heavily involved in the production, as well
That's the whole package, IMO.
-edit- actually, with this it's the whole package:
Spoiler:
Last edited by Ky-Fi; 10-20-14 at 05:32 PM.
#118
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Make a Bold Statement About Music
Provide the RIAA platinum lists to which you refer.
As far as the link beavis69 provided, that's a best selling list of all time. A lot of those sales likely happened years and years after the record's release.
Are you suggesting Black Sabbath was commercially popular at the time of its release?
And I don't doubt collaz's anecdote about how many people wore Maiden, Priest and Ozzy t-shirts. That still doesn't mean they were commercially popular. I'm not saying bands like Ozzy, Priest and Maiden aren't metal - I'm saying they weren't as commercially popular as people think.
#119
Re: Make a Bold Statement About Music
Ozzy Osbourne: Blizzard of Oz - Platinum in 1982, 4x Platinum by '98 (what's your cut off for Metal popularity?) #21 Billboard, #7 UK
Judas Priest: Screaming for Vengeance - Platinum in 1982, #17 Billboard #11 UK
Iron Maiden: The Number of the Beast - Platinum in 1986, #33 Billboard #1 UK. And I love this quote on Wikipedia: "The Number of the Beast met with considerable critical and commercial success and was a landmark release for the band", but that's impossible, a Metal album can't be commercially successful at the time of it's release.
Please.
Last edited by covenant; 10-20-14 at 07:10 PM.
#121
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Make a Bold Statement About Music
#122
DVD Talk Legend
Join Date: Dec 2000
Location: Cape Ann, Massachusetts
Posts: 10,928
Likes: 0
Received 2 Likes
on
2 Posts
Re: Make a Bold Statement About Music
"How can I say? I've never seen it."
-edit- Here it is, at about the 1:00 mark:
<object width="420" height="315"><param name="movie" value="//www.youtube.com/v/ruTe8GCSfqc?hl=en_US&version=3"></param><param name="allowFullScreen" value="true"></param><param name="allowscriptaccess" value="always"></param><embed src="//www.youtube.com/v/ruTe8GCSfqc?hl=en_US&version=3" type="application/x-shockwave-flash" width="420" height="315" allowscriptaccess="always" allowfullscreen="true"></embed></object>
#123
Re: Make a Bold Statement About Music
Iron Maiden has sold 85 million records worldwide, according to the New York Times. Clearly not popular at all.
As a conciliatory gesture I'll readily admit Metal sales completely pale in comparison to pop sales. Case in point: Thriller, 20x Platinum in '84!
Last edited by covenant; 10-20-14 at 07:40 PM.
#124
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Make a Bold Statement About Music
This will be easy. One band at a time.
Ozzy Osbourne: Blizzard of Oz - Platinum in 1982, 4x Platinum by '98 (what's your cut off for Metal popularity?) #21 Billboard, #7 UK
Judas Priest: Screaming for Vengeance - Platinum in 1982, #17 Billboard #11 UK
Iron Maiden: The Number of the Beast - Platinum in 1986, #33 Billboard #1 UK. And I love this quote on Wikipedia: "The Number of the Beast met with considerable critical and commercial success and was a landmark release for the band", but that's impossible, a Metal album can't be commercially successful at the time of it's release.
Please.
Ozzy Osbourne: Blizzard of Oz - Platinum in 1982, 4x Platinum by '98 (what's your cut off for Metal popularity?) #21 Billboard, #7 UK
Judas Priest: Screaming for Vengeance - Platinum in 1982, #17 Billboard #11 UK
Iron Maiden: The Number of the Beast - Platinum in 1986, #33 Billboard #1 UK. And I love this quote on Wikipedia: "The Number of the Beast met with considerable critical and commercial success and was a landmark release for the band", but that's impossible, a Metal album can't be commercially successful at the time of it's release.
Please.
So what we have here is three examples over a span of several years. Maybe we just have a disconnect on what "popular" means. I would take that as meaning metal was one of the dominant music genres on the charts at any given time. I don't think that it was. Do you?
#125
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Make a Bold Statement About Music
That doesn't count. Remember, according to bunkaroo, those sales have to happen right when each album is released, not years and years after. Because reasons...
As a conciliatory gesture I'll readily admit Metal sales completely pale in comparison to pop sales. Case in point: Thriller, 20x Platinum in '84!
As a conciliatory gesture I'll readily admit Metal sales completely pale in comparison to pop sales. Case in point: Thriller, 20x Platinum in '84!
Check my previous post - sales within 12-18 months is IMO a fair indicator of how much a record caught on with people. After that it's largely just catalog sales for existing artists.