Bands whose founding members are all dead
#1
DVD Talk Hero
Thread Starter
Bands whose founding members are all dead
The recent passing of Tommy Ramone spurred a discussion with one of my friends to day. With Tommy gone, all four original members of the Ramones are now dead.
My friend and I tried to think of any other prominent bands whose founding/original members are deceased and were unable to think of any.
The Who, The Beatles (not counting Stuart Sutcliffe or the conspiracy theories about Paul McCartney), and The Doors are both down to two surviving members. Zeppelin still has Page, Plant, JPJ still alive and kicking, and the Rolling Stones have only lost Brian Jones. All four original members of Black Sabbath are still around.
The only one I can come up with is the Jimi Hendrix Experience, with all three original members, Hendrix, Redding, and Mitchell, being dead, though to me, Jimi Hendrix always felt more like a solo artist than a member of a band called The Jimi Hendrix Experience.
My friend and I tried to think of any other prominent bands whose founding/original members are deceased and were unable to think of any.
The Who, The Beatles (not counting Stuart Sutcliffe or the conspiracy theories about Paul McCartney), and The Doors are both down to two surviving members. Zeppelin still has Page, Plant, JPJ still alive and kicking, and the Rolling Stones have only lost Brian Jones. All four original members of Black Sabbath are still around.
The only one I can come up with is the Jimi Hendrix Experience, with all three original members, Hendrix, Redding, and Mitchell, being dead, though to me, Jimi Hendrix always felt more like a solo artist than a member of a band called The Jimi Hendrix Experience.
#2
Re: Bands whose founding members are all dead
The Flying Burrito Brothers have 1 of 4 original members
The Stooges have 1 of 4 original members
The Temptations have 1 of 5 original members
The New York Dolls have 2 of 5 original members.
The Band has 2 of 5 original members.
Lynyrd Skynyrd has 2 of 6 original members.
The Bee Gees have 1 of 3 original members.
I can't think of a band thats members are all dead. Unless you count The Carter Family as a band.
The Stooges have 1 of 4 original members
The Temptations have 1 of 5 original members
The New York Dolls have 2 of 5 original members.
The Band has 2 of 5 original members.
Lynyrd Skynyrd has 2 of 6 original members.
The Bee Gees have 1 of 3 original members.
I can't think of a band thats members are all dead. Unless you count The Carter Family as a band.
#3
Re: Bands whose founding members are all dead
The original members of the Duke Ellington, Count Basie, Paul Whiteman and Fletcher Henderson jazz bands are all dead.
#4
Re: Bands whose founding members are all dead
Sad thing is, that within the next couple years this list is going to grow by leaps and bounds. Depressing to think of. I'm a huge Stones fan, but I know the time is coming. Probably not too far off.
#5
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Join Date: Jul 2004
Location: Tokyo, Japan
Posts: 2,609
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Bands whose founding members are all dead
Here's a bigger question: A band whose original members are all dead, but subsequent members are still continuing the band. (No, factory-made revolving door boy bands don't count)
#6
DVD Talk Hero
Thread Starter
Re: Bands whose founding members are all dead
It's rather rare for bands to go on without any founding members, whether they're all dead or not. There was an English pop group that eventually lost all of its original members, and the original line-up reformed under a different name.
And Quiet Riot, for a while, was recording and touring without any of the founding members. Actually, they did this twice. In the late 80s, they fired vocalist Kevin DuBrow before recording their fifth album. DuBrow was, by that time, the only band member who was in the original line up. He rejoined the band several years later until his death a few years ago. The band has since reformed with no original members; Frankie Banali, the drummer, is the closest thing to an original member. He joined the band with their fourth album.
Last edited by Josh-da-man; 07-13-14 at 10:29 AM.
#7
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Bands whose founding members are all dead
Quiet Riot, for a while, was recording and touring without any of the founding members. Actually, they did this twice. In the late 80s, they fired vocalist Kevin DuBrow before recording their fifth album. DuBrow was, by that time, the only band member who was in the original line up. He rejoined the band several years later until his death a few years ago. The band has since reformed with no original members; Frankie Banali, the drummer, is the closest thing to an original member. He joined the band with their fourth album.
That point also brings up the point of when a band is fist considered the band in discussions like these? Those first two QR albums weren't even originally released in the US.
#8
DVD Talk Hero
Thread Starter
Re: Bands whose founding members are all dead
Generally, I'd say that the 'original line- up' and 'founding members' would be the line-up on a group's first album. Which would exclude guys like Neil Peart of Rush and Dave Grohl of Nirvana, but it seems like the best yard stick available.
#9
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: Bands whose founding members are all dead
Some months ago a friend and I were trying to think of long running bands that never deviated from the original lineup. The exact same guys on every single recording. Thought of starting a thread but decided too narrow for the thread to go anywhere. Came up with ZZ Top and U2.
#10
Re: Bands whose founding members are all dead
Some months ago a friend and I were trying to think of long running bands that never deviated from the original lineup. The exact same guys on every single recording. Thought of starting a thread but decided too narrow for the thread to go anywhere. Came up with ZZ Top and U2.
Creedence Clearwater Revival.
The Bee Gees
ABBA
The Highwaymen
The Travelling Wilburys
The White Stripes
#11
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Re: Bands whose founding members are all dead
Some months ago a friend and I were trying to think of long running bands that never deviated from the original lineup. The exact same guys on every single recording. Thought of starting a thread but decided too narrow for the thread to go anywhere. Came up with ZZ Top and U2.
#12
DVD Talk Reviewer/ Admin
Join Date: Sep 1999
Location: Greenville, South Cackalack
Posts: 28,823
Received 1,882 Likes
on
1,238 Posts
Re: Bands whose founding members are all dead
Some months ago a friend and I were trying to think of long running bands that never deviated from the original lineup. The exact same guys on every single recording. Thought of starting a thread but decided too narrow for the thread to go anywhere. Came up with ZZ Top and U2.
Sloan has had the same lineup for more than 20 years (with a touring keyboardist caveat).
#13
DVD Talk Legend
#14
DVD Talk Godfather
Re: Bands whose founding members are all dead
Yeah, and CCR lost a Fogerty or two along the way and spawned lawsuits and fun stuff like that because of it.
How about the Eagles? Did they ever have fill ins during the "we hate each other" years or did they make a clean break and reunite years later?
How about the Eagles? Did they ever have fill ins during the "we hate each other" years or did they make a clean break and reunite years later?
#15
Re: Bands whose founding members are all dead
well, technically the Wilburys only ever had original members record, it just happened that Roy Orbison died. But a founding member was never replaced.
And Creedence Clearwater Revival was only ever John Fogerty, Tom Fogerty, Stu Cook and Doug Clifford. Stu Cook and Doug Clifford later started what basically amounts to a tribute band under the name "Creedence Clearwater Revisited". So technically it was never Creedence Clearwater Revival. And besides, I'm pretty sure everyone knows that CCR was 100% John Fogerty anyhow.
And Creedence Clearwater Revival was only ever John Fogerty, Tom Fogerty, Stu Cook and Doug Clifford. Stu Cook and Doug Clifford later started what basically amounts to a tribute band under the name "Creedence Clearwater Revisited". So technically it was never Creedence Clearwater Revival. And besides, I'm pretty sure everyone knows that CCR was 100% John Fogerty anyhow.
#16
Mod Emeritus
Join Date: Oct 1999
Location: Outside of the U.S.A.
Posts: 10,674
Likes: 0
Received 1 Like
on
1 Post
Re: Bands whose founding members are all dead
As of February, Bill Haley & The Comets have all ceased to be.
Michelle Phillips has made it to 70 years of age and is the last remaining of the Mamas & the Papas.
Michelle Phillips has made it to 70 years of age and is the last remaining of the Mamas & the Papas.
#17
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
Re: Bands whose founding members are all dead
After they reformed in 1994, I gave up even pretending to care.
#18
DVD Talk Legend
The following users liked this post:
jpcamb (05-04-20)
#22
#23
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Bands whose founding members are all dead
Now that I look at that post more closely the poster mentioned those as "long-running bands" and most of them wouldn't really be defined as "long-running".
#24
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: Bands whose founding members are all dead
I mean long running bands, 20 years+. A lot of bands have lastest that long or longer but with replacements. What about Bon Jovi? They're all the original guys? Petty has done outside stuff, but are The Heartbreakers the exact same guys from day one? What about Crazy Horse? It's on and off, but when Neil Young gets together with Crazy Horse, exact same guys for 40+ years?
#25
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Bands whose founding members are all dead
I mean long running bands, 20 years+. A lot of bands have lastest that long or longer but with replacements. What about Bon Jovi? They're all the original guys? Petty has done outside stuff, but are The Heartbreakers the exact same guys from day one? What about Crazy Horse? It's on and off, but when Neil Young gets together with Crazy Horse, exact same guys for 40+ years?
Heartbreakers - one of them died
Crazy Horse - not even close, multiple deaths and revolving door members.