The 86th Academy Awards — 2014 Nominations Discussion Thread
#51
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: The 86th Academy Awards — 2014 Nominations Discussion Thread
All of that love for American Hustle is baffling. Love the love for The Wolf of Wall Street though. It trumps AH in every possible way as a film.
I thought they'd think outside the box and nominate Scarlett Johansson for her performance in Her but I knew that they would overlook it.
I do like that Her was nominated in five categories but it deserved to be in three more - supporting actress, actor and director.
I thought they'd think outside the box and nominate Scarlett Johansson for her performance in Her but I knew that they would overlook it.
I do like that Her was nominated in five categories but it deserved to be in three more - supporting actress, actor and director.
#54
DVD Talk Hero
Re: The 86th Academy Awards — 2014 Nominations Discussion Thread
I love the love for Gravity, baffled by the non-acting love for Hustle.
And she'll knocked out again by a "tour de force" role, something she rarely does. She plays normal roles extremely well. At least she won a Globe finally.
Weird seeing absolutely no love for the Coen Bros.
Weird seeing absolutely no love for the Coen Bros.
#56
Re: The 86th Academy Awards — 2014 Nominations Discussion Thread
#57
Re: The 86th Academy Awards — 2014 Nominations Discussion Thread
I'm baffled by any love for American Hustle.
Gravity was okay. It's definitely a technical marvel. But outside of that, it felt very hollow to me with no substance at all. The movie definitely leaves you cold. Wolf of Wall Street is my favorite of what I've seen, but I don't think it'll have a shot at Picture since it wasn't nominated for Editing. I'm still hoping DiCaprio can finally win.
Gravity was okay. It's definitely a technical marvel. But outside of that, it felt very hollow to me with no substance at all. The movie definitely leaves you cold. Wolf of Wall Street is my favorite of what I've seen, but I don't think it'll have a shot at Picture since it wasn't nominated for Editing. I'm still hoping DiCaprio can finally win.
#59
DVD Talk Hero
Re: The 86th Academy Awards — 2014 Nominations Discussion Thread
I'm baffled by any love for American Hustle.
Gravity was okay. It's definitely a technical marvel. But outside of that, it felt very hollow to me with no substance at all. The movie definitely leaves you cold. Wolf of Wall Street is my favorite of what I've seen, but I don't think it'll have a shot at Picture since it wasn't nominated for Editing. I'm still hoping DiCaprio can finally win.
Gravity was okay. It's definitely a technical marvel. But outside of that, it felt very hollow to me with no substance at all. The movie definitely leaves you cold. Wolf of Wall Street is my favorite of what I've seen, but I don't think it'll have a shot at Picture since it wasn't nominated for Editing. I'm still hoping DiCaprio can finally win.
Wolf of Wall Street was great, infinitely more enjoyable than Hustle was. Though I'd argue that it had little additional substance over something like Gravity when you get right down to it.
#60
DVD Talk Legend
Re: The 86th Academy Awards — 2014 Nominations Discussion Thread
A month ago, I would have picked Bruce Dern - now I think McConaughey is a shoo-in...he's peaking at the right time, and it doesn't hurt that TRUE DETECTIVE is on right now, reminding us weekly what a great actor he is. I think both he and Leto are going to win the acting categories. I'm guessing Adams and Lawrence for the other two, and 12 Years a Slave for Best Picture. I think WOLF, as good as it is, might wind up getting shut-out this year.
Of course, things can change between now and March 2.
Of course, things can change between now and March 2.
#61
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: The 86th Academy Awards — 2014 Nominations Discussion Thread
I'm baffled by any love for American Hustle.
Gravity was okay. It's definitely a technical marvel. But outside of that, it felt very hollow to me with no substance at all. The movie definitely leaves you cold. Wolf of Wall Street is my favorite of what I've seen, but I don't think it'll have a shot at Picture since it wasn't nominated for Editing. I'm still hoping DiCaprio can finally win.
Gravity was okay. It's definitely a technical marvel. But outside of that, it felt very hollow to me with no substance at all. The movie definitely leaves you cold. Wolf of Wall Street is my favorite of what I've seen, but I don't think it'll have a shot at Picture since it wasn't nominated for Editing. I'm still hoping DiCaprio can finally win.
#62
DVD Talk Hero
Re: The 86th Academy Awards — 2014 Nominations Discussion Thread
Oh and Jonah Hill was excellent in this movie, I liked his character in some scenes, and wanted to knock him the fuck out in other ones. Just as intended.
<iframe width="560" height="315" src="//www.youtube.com/embed/ftkhxD_85Ng" frameborder="0" allowfullscreen></iframe>
Last edited by RichC2; 01-16-14 at 08:38 AM.
#63
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: The 86th Academy Awards — 2014 Nominations Discussion Thread
This is about the only time of the year when I kind of wish I still went to see movies in the theater instead of waiting and watching them at home. I've only seen three films with nominations for anything: The Great Gatsby, Iron Man 3 and Star Trek: Into Darkness.
#64
Re: The 86th Academy Awards — 2014 Nominations Discussion Thread
What a boring list. Looks like I can skip it again this year...
This is the only one that really interests me: Matthew McConaughey (Dallas Buyers Club) not suprising but it is amazing to see where he started and is now.
This is the only one that really interests me: Matthew McConaughey (Dallas Buyers Club) not suprising but it is amazing to see where he started and is now.
#65
DVD Talk Hero
Re: The 86th Academy Awards — 2014 Nominations Discussion Thread
Boring list but fairly accurate, outside of Hustle.
I mean c'mon, we now get to say "Oscar nominated movies Star Trek Into Darkness and The Lone Ranger."
I mean c'mon, we now get to say "Oscar nominated movies Star Trek Into Darkness and The Lone Ranger."
#66
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Re: The 86th Academy Awards — 2014 Nominations Discussion Thread
Does the Academy alway nominated Merly Streep every year? She already won what three Oscar. Replaced her with Emma Thompson in Saving Mr. Banks, while I haven't seen the film words around the news that she was snubbed by the Academy.
#68
Moderator
Re: The 86th Academy Awards — 2014 Nominations Discussion Thread
Most notable omission for me was Blackfish in the Documentary category. I thought that movie was big shit.
#69
DVD Talk Hero
#70
DVD Talk Godfather & 2020 TOTY Winner
Re: The 86th Academy Awards — 2014 Nominations Discussion Thread
No Best Animated Feature nomination for Pixar. That's a first.
Glad, not surprised, to see another Adapted Screenplay nomination for Delpy, Hawke and Linklater. Still think it's weird that they're considered Adapted Screenplays because they're characters who were in another movie. If Celine and Jesse were actual historical people, I assume this would have been an original screenplay instead.
What the hell is The Grandmaster and how did it pick up a couple of mid-level nominations? Never even heard of it.
Glad, not surprised, to see another Adapted Screenplay nomination for Delpy, Hawke and Linklater. Still think it's weird that they're considered Adapted Screenplays because they're characters who were in another movie. If Celine and Jesse were actual historical people, I assume this would have been an original screenplay instead.
What the hell is The Grandmaster and how did it pick up a couple of mid-level nominations? Never even heard of it.
#72
Re: The 86th Academy Awards — 2014 Nominations Discussion Thread
I only have two horses in this race: THE WIND RISES and THE GRANDMASTER.
I only saw two nominees: THE GRANDMASTER and THE GREAT GATSBY.
@ THE BUTLER getting shut out.
I only saw two nominees: THE GRANDMASTER and THE GREAT GATSBY.
@ THE BUTLER getting shut out.
#73
DVD Talk Godfather & 2020 TOTY Winner
Re: The 86th Academy Awards — 2014 Nominations Discussion Thread
Rush was shut out too, wasn't it? Really good film with several GG nominations and spectacular cinematography.
#74
DVD Talk Hero
Re: The 86th Academy Awards — 2014 Nominations Discussion Thread
No Best Animated Feature nomination for Pixar. That's a first.
Glad, not surprised, to see another Adapted Screenplay nomination for Delpy, Hawke and Linklater. Still think it's weird that they're considered Adapted Screenplays because they're characters who were in another movie. If Celine and Jesse were actual historical people, I assume this would have been an original screenplay instead.
What the hell is The Grandmaster and how did it pick up a couple of mid-level nominations? Never even heard of it.
Glad, not surprised, to see another Adapted Screenplay nomination for Delpy, Hawke and Linklater. Still think it's weird that they're considered Adapted Screenplays because they're characters who were in another movie. If Celine and Jesse were actual historical people, I assume this would have been an original screenplay instead.
What the hell is The Grandmaster and how did it pick up a couple of mid-level nominations? Never even heard of it.
I didn't particularly care for it despite liking Wong Kar-wai's other movies. But it has Scorsese as a presenter so it gets instant academy attention.
The Butler was a pretty awful movie, so I'm not so surprised at its snubbing (Lee Daniels is NOT a good director). Steve McQueen tackling the same subject would have been interesting.