cruzness

First some Uniques: all get 0 points


Qui-Gon vs. Darth Maul
Groucho


Yoda v Dooku
Jeremy517


Obi Wan vs. Vader
achau9598


The Phantom Menace
wishbone

cruzness

Luke vs. Vader (Return of the Jedi) -2
Michael Corvin
bunkaroo




Darth Maul vs. Obi-Wan -4
cruzness
Mordred
Todd B.
SterlingBen

Obi-Wanma

Rock did his at home, but with the rate of speed and interruptions, you'd never have known he wasn't at work

Jcheckel

Almost answered Yoda/Dooku

wishbone

S: Name the best lightsaber battle in the movies.



Sorry but this question was not specific about the duelists. I don't know about Groucho's answer but I was clearly thinking about the climatic duel at the end of the movie. If clarification was needed then the Sheepmaster should have asked the players to provide an updated answer.

pinata242

It clearly says "battle".

Damfino

Yes, and I did clarify my answer and took the penalty to do it!

wishbone

I don't think the skirmish between Qui-Gon and Darth Maul counts as a "duel."

pinata242

It does not matter in the slightest. This is a SHEEP question. Not only are there no "wrong/not counting" answers, the entire goal is to match the most people as possible. If your answer is ambiguous, it won't match the way you intended it to unless everyone else went ambiguous too.

wishbone

My answer was just as ambiguous as the Sheep question.

bunkaroo

Yes, yes! To pinata242 you listen!

Really surprised more people didn't go with Luke/Vader in ROTJ. Might not have been the flashiest duel, but it was the ultimate triumph over the Sith.

wishbone

"I've never trusted Tulsans, and I never will. I can never forgive them for the death of my boy."

davidh777

Because sheep like to follow the game during the day. I'd rather SM in the evenings Pacific time but participation would be low.

Mordred

Because Wishbone obviously intended to answer Obi vs Maul I think we should give it to him guys!

Note: my answer would be different if I hadn't answered the same way.

wishbone

There is an old Vulcan proverb: Mordred is a very smart man.

pinata242

You should wait to see how the 3-way TPM battle shakes out before you agree to hitch your wagon to that secondary battle

Mordred

It's all the same battle IMO.

cnicholls44

It's kind of the same battle.

pinata242

Clearly not as judged thusfar.

Unless it's worth less than 4 points, in which case I agree.

wishbone

Don't have much of a choice there.

cruzness

If you chose



Luke versus Darth in THE EMPIRE STRIKES BACK

Michael Corvin

Damn. I had that and second guessed myself. The Jedi fight just had more emotion.

cruzness

If you chose


Obi-Wan Kenobi and Qui-Gon Jinn vs Darth Maul - Episode I

Mordred

I almost {sd}'d this question.

I was really confused why only 4 answered the way I did, but I thought QGJ died a lot earlier than he did. I just rewatched it and the fight lasts four minutes of screen time and QGJ dies at the 3 minute mark. Oops.

Damfino

Since I'm old enough to have seen this opening weekend, I can still remember the collective gasp from the audience when Vader revealed that he was Luke's father. even though it made perfect sense, it was still a big shock.