View Poll Results: What is the best "Mission Impossible" film?
Mission: Impossible (1996)
14
21.54%
Mission: Impossible II (2000)
6
9.23%
Mission: Impossible III (2006)
17
26.15%
Mission: Impossible - Ghost Protocol (2011)
28
43.08%
Voters: 65. You may not vote on this poll
Rate the "Mission: Impossible" films
#1
DVD Talk Legend
Thread Starter
Rate the "Mission: Impossible" films
Mission: Impossible (1996)
Mission: Impossible II (2000)
Mission: Impossible III (2006)
Mission: Impossible - Ghost Protocol (2011)
Mission: Impossible II (2000)
Mission: Impossible III (2006)
Mission: Impossible - Ghost Protocol (2011)
#2
DVD Talk Legend
Thread Starter
Re: Rate the "Mission: Impossible" films
I think "Ghost Protocol" is the best. Followed by "III", the first film and then "II" (by a long mile). "II" was not only the worst in the series. But just a terrible movie in general. I love the first a lot. But in terms of action, "III" and "Ghost Protocol" took it to a whole new level.
#3
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Rate the "Mission: Impossible" films
Didn't really care that much for any of them, but the latest one would be the one I'd recommend.
II is embarrassingly bad.
II is embarrassingly bad.
#4
DVD Talk Special Edition
Join Date: Dec 2011
Posts: 1,108
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Rate the "Mission: Impossible" films
The third was my favorite largely due to Philip Seymour Hoffman, whose portrayal of the villain, Owen Davian, is excellent. The original and the Ghost Protocol are probably tied for second place. The second installment I cannot remember too much since I only saw it once in theaters. I remember enjoying it, but not as much as the others.
#5
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Join Date: Nov 2001
Location: Guelph, Ontario
Posts: 9,921
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Rate the "Mission: Impossible" films
I voted for III - it is pure fun from start to finish, with great pacing and good villain. I think the action of Ghost Protocol tops it, but overall I still prefer III...but by a narrow margin.
#6
DVD Talk Godfather
Re: Rate the "Mission: Impossible" films
I enjoy the first one the best. The actual mystery in the plot was the most interesting to me out of all of them. Followed by 3, then 4, and 2. I've enjoyed them all, even #2.
#7
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Re: Rate the "Mission: Impossible" films
1
3
2
3
2
#9
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Rate the "Mission: Impossible" films
4
1
3
2
I still immensely enjoyed the first one, however.
1
3
2
I still immensely enjoyed the first one, however.
#11
Re: Rate the "Mission: Impossible" films
IV.
The only thing III holds over IV is the best villain of the series, but it's still a solid film. II is Woo parodying himself, possibly sub-consciously and I is a good thriller, but a bit bloated.
The only thing III holds over IV is the best villain of the series, but it's still a solid film. II is Woo parodying himself, possibly sub-consciously and I is a good thriller, but a bit bloated.
#12
Banned
Re: Rate the "Mission: Impossible" films
II is Woo parodying himself, possibly sub-consciously
and I is a good thriller, but a bit bloated.
#13
Re: Rate the "Mission: Impossible" films
No doubt, which wouldn't bother me so much if the film weren't titled Mission Impossible. Watching it again recently, it's pretty fun in places especially the OTT final half-hour, but its nearly non-existent resemblance to M:I hurts it as well as the mundane Thandie Newton nonsense. She and Cruise are simply terrible together, their first scene where they meet is flat-out preposterous even by this series' standards. Never heard of "Love at First Car Crash".
#14
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Rate the "Mission: Impossible" films
Overall, I found IV the most entertaining. I liked the team dynamics and the action sequences. I also liked that they tried a couple of cons like in the TV series.
III had a better villain, however, and I like how tongue-in-cheek a lot of the dialogue was without ever becoming cheesy/campy.
I tried to look/feel like the series (with the score and the intitial setup) but took a piss over everything that was Mission Impossible by turning a conman series into an action vehicle. I still enjoy it a great deal but it only superficially resembles the source material. At least the Langley infiltration was great, if not an actual con.
II is just crap. I probably would have hated it less if it weren't called Mission Impossible but the whole thing plays out like someone hastily re-wrote a script from an aborted Metal Gear Solid adaptation (ditching the walking tank but keeping the antagonist doppleganger and placing more focus on the virus). It's just poorly written drivel.
Spoiler:
III had a better villain, however, and I like how tongue-in-cheek a lot of the dialogue was without ever becoming cheesy/campy.
I tried to look/feel like the series (with the score and the intitial setup) but took a piss over everything that was Mission Impossible by turning a conman series into an action vehicle. I still enjoy it a great deal but it only superficially resembles the source material. At least the Langley infiltration was great, if not an actual con.
II is just crap. I probably would have hated it less if it weren't called Mission Impossible but the whole thing plays out like someone hastily re-wrote a script from an aborted Metal Gear Solid adaptation (ditching the walking tank but keeping the antagonist doppleganger and placing more focus on the virus). It's just poorly written drivel.
#16
DVD Talk Special Edition
Join Date: Nov 2000
Posts: 1,195
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Rate the "Mission: Impossible" films
III - Great villain and there seems to be a constant state of urgency throughout the film, with more personal stake to Ethan Hunt. Nice to see the IMF team actually act as a team.
IV - Incredibly entertaining as the plot, generic as it seems, propels the film like a non-stop rocket with the IMF team being more coherent.
I - Great paranoia work by Brian De Palma, marred only by revealing the mystery before the climax of the film. The intrusion to acquire the "NOC" list in the CIA HQ is already considered a classic scene.
II - Woo went so over the top considering Robert Towne (overrated writer) admittedly came up with a plot surrounding the action scenes. Not good.
IV - Incredibly entertaining as the plot, generic as it seems, propels the film like a non-stop rocket with the IMF team being more coherent.
I - Great paranoia work by Brian De Palma, marred only by revealing the mystery before the climax of the film. The intrusion to acquire the "NOC" list in the CIA HQ is already considered a classic scene.
II - Woo went so over the top considering Robert Towne (overrated writer) admittedly came up with a plot surrounding the action scenes. Not good.
#17
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Rate the "Mission: Impossible" films
In all fairness, the same is true of I. De Palma and Cruise rejected all the drafts so they began shooting without a script. De Palma came up with action sequences he wanted to shoot and had his writers come up with the scenarios for them while on the set.
#19
Re: Rate the "Mission: Impossible" films
I loved John Woo's take on the franchise. I even saw it twice in theaters. I thought Dougray Scott made a plausible, understandable villain. He was an interesting and in some ways sympathetic antagonist. I enjoyed the Cruise/Newton relationship and thought the scene where she had to get the digital card out of Scott's camera, sneak it to Cruise, who then had to copy it and get it back to her was very clever and suspenseful. I prefer scenes like that to the over-the-top action scenes. (But then no one does over-the-top action scenes better than Woo.) It's Woo's next best Hollywood film after FACE/OFF. Too bad he hasn't done anything nearly as good in Hollywood in the twelve years since. RED CLIFF, made in and by China, was pretty good, though.
#21
DVD Talk Legend
Join Date: Aug 2006
Location: Behind the Orange Curtain
Posts: 20,085
Likes: 0
Received 7 Likes
on
7 Posts
Re: Rate the "Mission: Impossible" films
III was my fav. Typical plotline, but Hoffman was a great villain and I liked the direction.
I haven't seen I in ages, but I remember being incredibly confused by the plot. I didn't even make it through II since what I did see was terrible. GP was fun, probably my second fav, but the absurdity of much of it made me grimace at times. The Burj Dubai sequences are some of the best in the series, though.
I haven't seen I in ages, but I remember being incredibly confused by the plot. I didn't even make it through II since what I did see was terrible. GP was fun, probably my second fav, but the absurdity of much of it made me grimace at times. The Burj Dubai sequences are some of the best in the series, though.
#22
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Rate the "Mission: Impossible" films
III was my favorite because the villian was awesome. IV was also great.
Honestly I'm trying to remember a time when there were 4 movies and the last 2 are considered the best of the series.
III
IV
I
II
Honestly I'm trying to remember a time when there were 4 movies and the last 2 are considered the best of the series.
III
IV
I
II
#24
DVD Talk Godfather
#25
DVD Talk God
Re: Rate the "Mission: Impossible" films
III
Ghost Protocol
II
I
I was my least favorite because the plot was so confusing and I hated that they shit on the Jim Phelps character.
Ghost Protocol
II
I
I was my least favorite because the plot was so confusing and I hated that they shit on the Jim Phelps character.