Movies that are superior to the books upon which they're based
01-07-10, 11:45 AM
#1
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Thread Starter
Movies that are superior to the books upon which they're based
Several of the posts in the thread on Stephen King's favorite 2009 movies got me thinking about this topic. In regards to The Shining, I view the book as superior. Yes, the movie's a classic and masterpiece and so on and so forth, but I far prefer King's version of the Torrances as characters. I also think that as creepy as Kubrick's Overlook is, it doesn't hold a candle to how sinister it is in the book.
That said, I can think of three King books/stories which were made into films that actually improved on his work. Those would be The Green Mile, The Mist and, to a much smaller degree, The Shawshank Redemption. Outside of those three, I'm having a very difficult time thinking of films that improved on their source material. I'd almost be tempted to say No Country for Old Men, but it was originally written as a script instead of a novel and the book and film are so identical that it's more a case of parity than superiority.
I'm sure there are plenty of other films that have risen above their source material, but I'll be damned if I can think of any. I'm curious to see what examples others bring up.
That said, I can think of three King books/stories which were made into films that actually improved on his work. Those would be The Green Mile, The Mist and, to a much smaller degree, The Shawshank Redemption. Outside of those three, I'm having a very difficult time thinking of films that improved on their source material. I'd almost be tempted to say No Country for Old Men, but it was originally written as a script instead of a novel and the book and film are so identical that it's more a case of parity than superiority.
I'm sure there are plenty of other films that have risen above their source material, but I'll be damned if I can think of any. I'm curious to see what examples others bring up.
01-07-10, 12:25 PM
#2
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Movies that are superior to the books upon which they're based
The Last of the Mohicans -- Michael Mann, 1992.
The book is nigh-unreadable and a paradigm of coma-inducing tripe. The movie is phenomenal.
The book is nigh-unreadable and a paradigm of coma-inducing tripe. The movie is phenomenal.
01-07-10, 02:19 PM
#10
DVD Talk Legend
Join Date: Jun 2007
Location: 75 clicks above the Do Lung bridge...
Posts: 18,946
Likes: 0
Received 2 Likes
on
2 Posts
Re: Movies that are superior to the books upon which they're based
Off topic, but humour me...
I think the absolute best representation of a book in a film is Gary Sinise's 'Of Mice and Men'. It captures the book basically word for word, gets all the themes, is brilliantly acted... just an amazing adaptation.
I've read that book more times than any other work of fiction I guess, and that is one of my all time favorite films.
I think the absolute best representation of a book in a film is Gary Sinise's 'Of Mice and Men'. It captures the book basically word for word, gets all the themes, is brilliantly acted... just an amazing adaptation.
I've read that book more times than any other work of fiction I guess, and that is one of my all time favorite films.
01-07-10, 02:31 PM
#11
Re: Movies that are superior to the books upon which they're based
Jacques Tourneur's OUT OF THE PAST (1947) based on "Build My Gallows High," by Geoffrey Homes
Orson Welles' TOUCH OF EVIL (1958), based on Whit Masterson's "Badge of Evil"
Akira Kurosawa's HIGH AND LOW (1962), based on Ed McBain's "King's Ransom"
(And, yes, I've read the books.)
Orson Welles' TOUCH OF EVIL (1958), based on Whit Masterson's "Badge of Evil"
Akira Kurosawa's HIGH AND LOW (1962), based on Ed McBain's "King's Ransom"
(And, yes, I've read the books.)
01-07-10, 02:41 PM
#13
Moderator
Re: Movies that are superior to the books upon which they're based
This is what I came to say. Which is interesting because it's actually quite faithful. It just cuts out the fat that was in the novel (and there's a lot of it).The movie wasn't based on the book, they were created in parallel.
01-07-10, 02:52 PM
#15
DVD Talk Legend
Join Date: Aug 2006
Location: Behind the Orange Curtain
Posts: 20,085
Likes: 0
Received 7 Likes
on
7 Posts
Re: Movies that are superior to the books upon which they're based
Bram Stoker's Dracula
Also, I think American Psycho, while a great film, was even better as a novel.
Also, I think American Psycho, while a great film, was even better as a novel.
01-07-10, 02:52 PM
#16
DVD Talk Hero
Join Date: Dec 1999
Location: Hail to the Redskins!
Posts: 25,295
Likes: 0
Received 49 Likes
on
38 Posts
Re: Movies that are superior to the books upon which they're based
I disagree with this so much. The "fat" is just the jumble of Patrick's mind, the fat is pretty much what makes that book.
01-07-10, 02:54 PM
#17
DVD Talk Godfather
Re: Movies that are superior to the books upon which they're based
The Shawshank Redemption is the only one that comes to mind for me(aside from the Hollywood ending) and The Mist* comes damn close. While I prefer King's ambiguous ending to Shawshank to Darabont's, I think** I prefer Darabont's ending to the Mist vs. King's ambiguous one.
* The B&W version
** I haven't seen The Mist enough times to make a final ruling.
* The B&W version
** I haven't seen The Mist enough times to make a final ruling.
01-07-10, 03:05 PM
#19
Senior Member
Re: Movies that are superior to the books upon which they're based
Silence Of The Lambs. The author of the book has no business ever writing again. The books of the series got worse and worse as they went along.
01-07-10, 03:13 PM
#20
DVD Talk Legend
Join Date: Mar 2003
Location: Lyon Estates
Posts: 10,795
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Movies that are superior to the books upon which they're based
plus, it doesn't hurt when you have Demme and Fujimoto working together.
01-07-10, 03:27 PM
#23
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Join Date: Jun 2004
Posts: 6,290
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Movies that are superior to the books upon which they're based
Do explain more. I didn't know that. I did like both book and the movie - it's just that I liked the movie more.
I liked the Hobbit when I was a kid, but I couldn't get through the first chapters of the Fellowship.
I liked the Hobbit when I was a kid, but I couldn't get through the first chapters of the Fellowship.
01-07-10, 03:28 PM
#24
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Join Date: Jun 2004
Posts: 6,290
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Movies that are superior to the books upon which they're based
Did anyone ever try reading that comic book adaptation they did of the movie WATCHMEN? It was okay, but since the movie came out first, the movie is so much better.
01-07-10, 03:35 PM
#25
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
I agree with that selection, although it may not be popular with Tolkien fans. Loved The Hobbit but didn't care for Rings.
I'll suggest:
The Bourne Identity. I liked the changes made and preferred the movie to the book. I thought that making the woman who aids Bourne a German, as opposed to a Canadian, worked well.
Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix. The longest, and my least favorite, Harry Potter book worked well when abridged into the movie. By contrast, the movie version of Goblet of Fire was a travesty; it was abridged out of all recognition.
I'll suggest:
The Bourne Identity. I liked the changes made and preferred the movie to the book. I thought that making the woman who aids Bourne a German, as opposed to a Canadian, worked well.
Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix. The longest, and my least favorite, Harry Potter book worked well when abridged into the movie. By contrast, the movie version of Goblet of Fire was a travesty; it was abridged out of all recognition.