View Poll Results: Was Willem Dafoe Oscar worthy in Spiderman?
Dafoe deserves an Academy Award
11
10.28%
Hell no, are you nuts?
92
85.98%
Twikoff edges him out by a vote
4
3.74%
Voters: 107. You may not vote on this poll
Watching Spiderman again...does DaFoe deserve an Oscar for this?
#27
Originally posted by Goldberg74
You know I was thinking the same thing... especially because of that scene when he is talking to himself in the study and his mask is hanging on the chair... that still creeps me out.
I voted
You know I was thinking the same thing... especially because of that scene when he is talking to himself in the study and his mask is hanging on the chair... that still creeps me out.
I voted
#29
Originally posted by conscience
You guys watch Auto Focus.
If he gets nominated...it will be for that film...
...not Spider-man.
You guys watch Auto Focus.
If he gets nominated...it will be for that film...
...not Spider-man.
As it goes though he should be nominated for at least one of them. He has put in to very good performances this year. Can't say that about many actors this year.
#31
DVD Talk Special Edition
Join Date: Jun 1999
Posts: 1,848
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
There is certainly a precedent for supporting actors in genre movies that score bofo box-office to get nominations, although they never seem to win.
Off the top of my head, I recall that Alec Guinness was nominated for Star Wars back in '77.
Jack Nicholson was nominated for Batman back in 1990.
Others have cited Al Pacino in "Dick Tracy" and McKellan in "LOTR".
Tommy Lee Jones was nominated and won for "The Fugitive" (a great performance in a great movie that managed to transcend it's genre, although I still think it's fair to label it a 'genre' film).
So I wouldn't be at all surprised if Willem Dafoe gets a nomination for Spider Man, although I don't think he'd have much of a shot at winning.
Off the top of my head, I recall that Alec Guinness was nominated for Star Wars back in '77.
Jack Nicholson was nominated for Batman back in 1990.
Others have cited Al Pacino in "Dick Tracy" and McKellan in "LOTR".
Tommy Lee Jones was nominated and won for "The Fugitive" (a great performance in a great movie that managed to transcend it's genre, although I still think it's fair to label it a 'genre' film).
So I wouldn't be at all surprised if Willem Dafoe gets a nomination for Spider Man, although I don't think he'd have much of a shot at winning.
#32
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Originally posted by d2cheer
I have, your poor attempt to be-little his performance in Spider-Man notwithstanding. He is better in Spider-Man IMHO...
I have, your poor attempt to be-little his performance in Spider-Man notwithstanding. He is better in Spider-Man IMHO...
Did you read in my post that I said he was bad? I found the question asked in thread to be funny because (IMO---) he was not that good in Spider-man, and I wouldn't think he would get a nomination for that film. I never wrote that he was not good. And I found his performance in Auto Focus...to be seventeen steps above his performance as Green Goblin.
Maybe you should take your poor attempt at snide comments and pose them on someone else...someone who gives a damn.
thank you. have a nice day.
If it's anything...I hate when someone takes my words and poses them to make themselves seem smart....
#33
Originally posted by conscience
Mr/Miss Smug:
Did you read in my post that I said he was bad? I found the question asked in thread to be funny because (IMO---) he was not that good in Spider-man, and I wouldn't think he would get a nomination for that film. I never wrote that he was not good. And I found his performance in Auto Focus...to be seventeen steps above his performance as Green Goblin.
Maybe you should take your poor attempt at snide comments and pose them on someone else...someone who gives a damn.
thank you. have a nice day.
If it's anything...I hate when someone takes my words and poses them to make themselves seem smart....
Mr/Miss Smug:
Did you read in my post that I said he was bad? I found the question asked in thread to be funny because (IMO---) he was not that good in Spider-man, and I wouldn't think he would get a nomination for that film. I never wrote that he was not good. And I found his performance in Auto Focus...to be seventeen steps above his performance as Green Goblin.
Maybe you should take your poor attempt at snide comments and pose them on someone else...someone who gives a damn.
thank you. have a nice day.
If it's anything...I hate when someone takes my words and poses them to make themselves seem smart....
YAWN.........
SMART??? I don't seem smart I am smart just ask me. Your comments with your little laughing face in front of Spiderman speaks volumes. Now you try and back off of them by saying that you never wrote that he was bad??? You didn't have to your little laughing face did it for you and now you try and hide from it???
I am having a nice day, OH and by the way if you didn't give a damn you would not have to defend your comments and in the process attempt to try and make me look bad(which I don't regardless of what you think).
Dear Mr./Miss Smug.... Oh that is intelligent, and really hurts by the way. Take you awhile to think that up??
Me smug... re-read your post... can be interpreted many ways...
Write what you must I have said what I have said and will not comment on this anymore regardless of any SUPER intelligent post you may have on this.
#34
DVD Talk Special Edition
Join Date: Jun 1999
Posts: 1,848
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Since the Internet does not exist in one central location, since it exists above and below (being relative terms) the equator, I'm wondering: when a thread goes down the toilet, does the water swirl clockwise or counter-clockwise?
Children, children! Please! Let's all eat our milk and cookies and sing "John Jacob Jingleheimerschmidt" in a rondo, while hopping on one foot and picking our neighbor's nose, like the good little first-graders we all really are at heart.
Enough of this bickering! ENOUGH! Go to your rooms!
Now back to the topic-
Yes, I think Willem Dafoe should win an Oscar for Best Supporting Actor in Spider Man, because I once met Willem Dafoe and he did not have me arrested like Kate Winslet did when I broke into her house.
Children, children! Please! Let's all eat our milk and cookies and sing "John Jacob Jingleheimerschmidt" in a rondo, while hopping on one foot and picking our neighbor's nose, like the good little first-graders we all really are at heart.
Enough of this bickering! ENOUGH! Go to your rooms!
Now back to the topic-
Yes, I think Willem Dafoe should win an Oscar for Best Supporting Actor in Spider Man, because I once met Willem Dafoe and he did not have me arrested like Kate Winslet did when I broke into her house.
#36
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jan 2001
Location: Pittsburgh, PA GO PENS!
Posts: 4,946
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally posted by bardevious
Since the Internet does not exist in one central location, since it exists above and below (being relative terms) the equator, I'm wondering: when a thread goes down the toilet, does the water swirl clockwise or counter-clockwise?
Children, children! Please! Let's all eat our milk and cookies and sing "John Jacob Jingleheimerschmidt" in a rondo, while hopping on one foot and picking our neighbor's nose, like the good little first-graders we all really are at heart.
Enough of this bickering! ENOUGH! Go to your rooms!
Now back to the topic-
Yes, I think Willem Dafoe should win an Oscar for Best Supporting Actor in Spider Man, because I once met Willem Dafoe and he did not have me arrested like Kate Winslet did when I broke into her house.
Since the Internet does not exist in one central location, since it exists above and below (being relative terms) the equator, I'm wondering: when a thread goes down the toilet, does the water swirl clockwise or counter-clockwise?
Children, children! Please! Let's all eat our milk and cookies and sing "John Jacob Jingleheimerschmidt" in a rondo, while hopping on one foot and picking our neighbor's nose, like the good little first-graders we all really are at heart.
Enough of this bickering! ENOUGH! Go to your rooms!
Now back to the topic-
Yes, I think Willem Dafoe should win an Oscar for Best Supporting Actor in Spider Man, because I once met Willem Dafoe and he did not have me arrested like Kate Winslet did when I broke into her house.
this thread really did bite it. LOL
#41
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Originally posted by d2cheer
YAWN.........
YAWN.........
Originally posted by d2cheer
SMART??? I don't seem smart I am smart just ask me. Your comments with your little laughing face in front of Spiderman speaks volumes. Now you try and back off of them by saying that you never wrote that he was bad??? You didn't have to your little laughing face did it for you and now you try and hide from it???????
SMART??? I don't seem smart I am smart just ask me. Your comments with your little laughing face in front of Spiderman speaks volumes. Now you try and back off of them by saying that you never wrote that he was bad??? You didn't have to your little laughing face did it for you and now you try and hide from it???????
The laughing face was to thought that he would get an Oscar nod. I never said he was bad. Trust me. If he were bad, I would open the flood gates and let you know. I have no problem with telling people the real deal. You just want so badly for it to be what you think. But guess what! The world does not revolve around you.
Originally posted by d2cheer
I am having a nice day, OH and by the way if you didn't give a damn you would not have to defend your comments and in the process attempt to try and make me look bad(which I don't regardless of what you think).
I am having a nice day, OH and by the way if you didn't give a damn you would not have to defend your comments and in the process attempt to try and make me look bad(which I don't regardless of what you think).
Originally posted by d2cheer
Dear Mr./Miss Smug.... Oh that is intelligent, and really hurts by the way. Take you awhile to think that up??
Me smug... re-read your post... can be interpreted many ways...
Dear Mr./Miss Smug.... Oh that is intelligent, and really hurts by the way. Take you awhile to think that up??
Me smug... re-read your post... can be interpreted many ways...
Originally posted by d2cheer
Write what you must I have said what I have said and will not comment on this anymore regardless of any SUPER intelligent post you may have on this.
Write what you must I have said what I have said and will not comment on this anymore regardless of any SUPER intelligent post you may have on this.
Have a great evening! I hope I lived up to the SUPER intelligent post, because I so want to hear more of your great comments! They make me laugh!
#42
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
Join Date: Jan 2001
Location: Inyurvyj, Eina
Posts: 4,405
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Just the other day I was watching the Willem Dafoe episode of Fishing With John, and I started thinking about his performance in Spiderman. I thought he gave the only very good performance in the movie, but nothing Oscar-worthy.
#43
Moderator
Originally posted by Dr. DVD
For Spidey, no. However, I saw Auto Focus today and think he deserves a nod for it. I haven't seen many other strong supporting performances this year (aside from Yoda), and don't know whether he deserves the win, but it gets irritating to see him nominated in that category so much and keep losing.
For Spidey, no. However, I saw Auto Focus today and think he deserves a nod for it. I haven't seen many other strong supporting performances this year (aside from Yoda), and don't know whether he deserves the win, but it gets irritating to see him nominated in that category so much and keep losing.
#46
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Originally posted by bardevious
Jack Nicholson was nominated for Batman back in 1990.
Jack Nicholson was nominated for Batman back in 1990.
Jack Nicholson wasn't nominated for an Oscar for this film. Maybe you were thinking of the Golden Globe.
#47
DVD Talk Special Edition
Join Date: Jun 1999
Posts: 1,848
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally posted by conscience
BTW,
Jack Nicholson wasn't nominated for an Oscar for this film. Maybe you were thinking of the Golden Globe.
BTW,
Jack Nicholson wasn't nominated for an Oscar for this film. Maybe you were thinking of the Golden Globe.
Ooooops! You're right, my bad. I must've been thinking about his other comic book performance from "A Few Good Men", for which he was nominated.
#48
DVD Talk Legend
Originally posted by jarofclay73
Dafoe was great in Spider-Man, but some of his best acting was in Platoon.
Dafoe was great in Spider-Man, but some of his best acting was in Platoon.