View Poll Results: Would you be ok if physical media went away completely?
Voters: 85. You may not vote on this poll
If physical media went away completely, would you be ok?
#201
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
#202
DVD Talk Reviewer/ Admin
Join Date: Sep 1999
Location: Greenville, South Cackalack
Posts: 28,823
Received 1,882 Likes
on
1,238 Posts
Re: If physical media went away completely, would you be ok?
It seems so alien to me that between 2003 and 2008, three different HDTVs cycled through my living room. It's been nearly a decade (!) since I preordered my 9G Kuro Elite, and I fully expect that the OLED I'm theoretically getting later this year will probably have to carry me for the better part of a decade as well. I'll wind up getting something really nice in part because I'm into that sort of thing but also because I'll be stuck with it for a long while.
#203
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
Re: If physical media went away completely, would you be ok?
For most of the 2000s decade, I either didn't have a tv at all or I was still watching old ntsc cathode-ray-tubes which various local friends gave to me over the years.
The times I didn't have a tv at all, was due to my previous tv screen being kicked in during a party. I was too lazy to replace it, when I had a lot of other issues to deal with than watching tv.
Last edited by morriscroy; 05-20-17 at 03:43 PM.
#204
Inane Thread Master, 2018 TOTY
Thread Starter
Join Date: Dec 2003
Location: Are any of us really anywhere?
Posts: 49,443
Received 912 Likes
on
772 Posts
Re: If physical media went away completely, would you be ok?
We're talking apples and oranges here. Not everybody is a collector. Many of us enjoy the tangible nature of this hobby not just the pleasure of watching the films and shows. I nearly have an orgasm when a new steelbook arrives from Zavvi. And although I haven't even watched it yet, I couldn't wait to stop by Best Buy to lay my hands on the "La La Land" steelbook. I have showed friends the elaboate box set of "The Ten Commandments," but to them it's just a film...to me it is a treasure. Some believe it's crazy to buy these discs and rest them on a shelf. I couldn't disagree more. At the end of a long week it's nice to peruse my collection which contains a wide variety of viewing options that can satisfy any mood. Collecting blu-ray discs pleasures me and what other people choose to do is their perogative. I prefer owning something tangible ..vaporware doesn't interest me at all. So it's my hope that there will be enough people who share my enthusiasm for collecting to keep physical media alive into the next decade.
#205
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
Re: If physical media went away completely, would you be ok?
i get that, i do and used to be like that (still am, a little) but these will be obsolete before too long. i look back on my DVD collection, which are all boxed up and inaccessible. they just also feel inferior to me and hate to play one unless only option. i fear that will happen to my bluray collection soon enough. i love the convenience and ease of streaming stuff, especially from Vudu which sometimes has all the extras as the physical copy, which is why i opt for that in more cases now then ever before. physical media will, just like the mediums before it, fade away...
For example, such as the resurgence in vinyl.
In hindsight, I'm glad I didn't chuck away my old record collection back in the early 1990s. At the time, I was too lazy to sell them or give it away. (They were in storage for more than 25 years).
#206
Banned
Join Date: May 2008
Posts: 915
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: If physical media went away completely, would you be ok?
i get that, i do and used to be like that (still am, a little) but these will be obsolete before too long. i look back on my DVD collection, which are all boxed up and inaccessible. they just also feel inferior to me and hate to play one unless only option. i fear that will happen to my bluray collection soon enough. i love the convenience and ease of streaming stuff, especially from Vudu which sometimes has all the extras as the physical copy, which is why i opt for that in more cases now then ever before. physical media will, just like the mediums before it, fade away...
If I ever got to the point where I had everything boxed up I would certainly begin the process of selling off a large portion of that collection. I'm constantly weeding out the titles i am unlikely to re-watch. With the introduction of each new format I hastily sold off what I had collected previously but not so with 4K UHD. Much of what I own will never make it to that format and much of what has been released I already own on Blu-ray. I simply feel no compulsion to upgrade. This topic has been discussed ad nauseam and that's just about all I want to say regarding 4K UHD. Others feel differently and all I have to say is "enjioy!" But I remain unconvinced. In fact, I'd rather start hunting down a few titles on DVD that are unlikely to be released in HD that I've desired.
I sold off my entire CD collection when i parted with my first blu-ray collection. Although I burnt every disc on to iTunes, I miss owning the physical discs. I always felt LPs were a major pain-in-the ass to playback.
Last edited by AaronSch; 05-20-17 at 09:23 PM.
#207
DVD Talk Reviewer & TOAT Winner
Re: If physical media went away completely, would you be ok?
We need more 4Kbluray porn movies!!!
Again though, it all comes down to who was around during the laserdisc era- when most new movies on that format averaged $40, it's a blessing to pay less than that for something on a higher-quality format. still can't bring myself to pay the asking prices for most 4K discs though- La-La Land and 50 Shades Darker are on my want list for that format but waiting for them to drop a bit more, considering I paid about $16 for the first 50 Shades movie on Blu-Ray. I'll still gladly throw $30 at a 3D movie though, just ordered Return of Xander Cage for that much from Target as NO stores seem to be stocking it at all and you can't find it cheaper anywhere else online. Also paid a bit for the new Underworld and Resident Evil movies in 3D via import since they aren't being released here; probably wouldn't pay more than $5 for any of those if they were in 2D!
#208
DVD Talk Legend
Re: If physical media went away completely, would you be ok?
I think most of the major porn studios offer their videos in HD quality, and a number of them in 4K even. I'm sure most people view porn for free, but the studios must still have enough paying customers as they're still in business.
#209
DVD Talk Legend
Re: If physical media went away completely, would you be ok?
I always have to shake my head when I read comments to the effect that DVDs are so distasteful in light of more current formats that the person has their DVDs boxed up sitting in their basement, like they used to keep the mentally retarded/deformed child locked up in an attic to keep them safely away from their fine sensibilities and so their neighbors won't find out.....OMG!!!
Bullshit.
I have just as much pride and respect in the DVDs in my collection, that I do my blu-rays. I display them all proudly in fine finished bookcases for any and all to see, I don't care what people think. This is my hobby, my bid to please myself. Anyone else (except my wife) can eat my shorts.
Bullshit.
I have just as much pride and respect in the DVDs in my collection, that I do my blu-rays. I display them all proudly in fine finished bookcases for any and all to see, I don't care what people think. This is my hobby, my bid to please myself. Anyone else (except my wife) can eat my shorts.
#210
DVD Talk Legend
Re: If physical media went away completely, would you be ok?
AaronSch has a point about selling off discs instead of packing them away, since once discs become too inaccessible you might as well not own them. However both methods show that ownership has limits, and if you can't reasonably own everything you want to watch, what's the point in purchasing discs of everything in the first place?
This is the appeal of streaming services for a lot of people; with subscription services you get access to a lot of content without having to physically own everything. Even with people who want to "own" something, a digital collection is easier to manage and doesn't take up physical space.
Personally, I wouldn't want physical media to go away completely, but I also use a fair amount of streaming services. I have both subscription services and "own" digital copies, although most of those were codes that came with discs or Disc-to-Digital conversions. If a digital copy purchase costs less than a rental, I may also buy that. I have pretty much run out of physical space to own discs, so I've been trying to limit physical purchases to only things I really, really, want to own.
#211
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
Re: If physical media went away completely, would you be ok?
My main disc interest is older tv shows, where a lot of it has never been released on bluray. (Never mind 4Kbluray).
#212
DVD Talk Special Edition
Re: If physical media went away completely, would you be ok?
Streaming vs. physical will always be based on one's preference.
For myself, I never bought any TV shows on DVD and therefore if I had to stream TV shows for the rest of my life, I would be perfectly happy with it.
I guess it stems from the idea that TV shows were always "free" and came through the airwaves, so streaming is virtually identical to how I have always viewed them.
Movies on the other hand played in theatres in which you had to pay a considerable amount of money to see them and therefore I regarded them as having more value.
For me, physical discs are like an art form. The disc art, the packaging, the extras and an appreciation for the artistic efforts put into the product are what make them worth owning.
If you're old enough to remember; it's like a buddy buying an album and offering to record it on a tape for you. Yes, you had the music on a generic-looking blank tape that was identical to the record but it had no "soul", it wasn't the real thing.
For myself, I never bought any TV shows on DVD and therefore if I had to stream TV shows for the rest of my life, I would be perfectly happy with it.
I guess it stems from the idea that TV shows were always "free" and came through the airwaves, so streaming is virtually identical to how I have always viewed them.
Movies on the other hand played in theatres in which you had to pay a considerable amount of money to see them and therefore I regarded them as having more value.
For me, physical discs are like an art form. The disc art, the packaging, the extras and an appreciation for the artistic efforts put into the product are what make them worth owning.
If you're old enough to remember; it's like a buddy buying an album and offering to record it on a tape for you. Yes, you had the music on a generic-looking blank tape that was identical to the record but it had no "soul", it wasn't the real thing.
#213
Banned
Join Date: May 2008
Posts: 915
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: If physical media went away completely, would you be ok?
...I never bought any TV shows on DVD and therefore if I had to stream TV shows for the rest of my life, I would be perfectly happy with it. I guess it stems from the idea that TV shows were always "free" and came through the airwaves, so streaming is virtually identical to how I have always viewed them.
...physical discs are like an art form. The disc art, the packaging, the extras and an appreciation for the artistic efforts put into the product are what make them worth owning.
If you're old enough to remember; it's like a buddy buying an album and offering to record it on a tape for you. Yes, you had the music on a generic-looking blank tape that was identical to the record but it had no "soul", it wasn't the real thing.
If you're old enough to remember; it's like a buddy buying an album and offering to record it on a tape for you. Yes, you had the music on a generic-looking blank tape that was identical to the record but it had no "soul", it wasn't the real thing.
Last edited by AaronSch; 05-22-17 at 10:45 AM.
#214
DVD Talk Hero
Re: If physical media went away completely, would you be ok?
Yeah, packaging is huge. I mean, I have all the recent Simpsons seasons on a thumb-drive in 1080p, which is convenient as hell - it's far more convenient than having them on disc, even if you could fit it all on one disc (you can't). I can keep that thumb-drive in my pocket and stick it into any TV/smart-phone/PC/console/whatever, at any time, without wifi and have 10 seasons at my fingertips ready to go. But I would still much rather have them on discs, with cool packaging/artwork that has adorned 17 seasons, with nice informative booklets and copious extras. But no, Fox would rather me stream that stuff, so they can exert more control over me.
#215
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
Re: If physical media went away completely, would you be ok?
That is exactly what I was trying to convey but you nailed it. You know, there are those who post over at another forum who make fun of people motivated by packaging. They express how it's "all about the movie!" But put a blank disc in a plain white sleeve next to a disc with package art and which one do you think these geniuses would purchase? We are all motivated by the packaging at some level. For the most part, I prefer the original one sheet poster art with disc art as well.
I know what you mean here.
Back in the day, I use to like collecting the vinyl 12" singles and picture discs released by Iron Maiden. The 12" single versions had the full sized Eddie artwork.
It was easier to find the 7" versions of many Iron Maiden vinyl singles, but it was packaged in generic Capitol/EMI plastic sleeves without any of the Eddie artwork. In spite of having the exact same music, the 7" versions didn't seem exciting at all to me.
In principle I could have just purchased all the paper posters which had most of the Iron Maiden artwork from the vinyl albums and 12" singles. But I found it was more exciting to find and collect the less common 12" singles versions and picture discs.
#216
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
Re: If physical media went away completely, would you be ok?
For example if Marvel titles were just a blank cover + generic bluray disc, most likely nobody would care about buying it. (ie. Tumbling into dump bins within 6 months).
#217
DVD Talk Legend
Re: If physical media went away completely, would you be ok?
#218
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
Re: If physical media went away completely, would you be ok?
This is the primary reason why I always purchased my own records (and later cds). I never taped off a friend's vinyl copy.
#219
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
Re: If physical media went away completely, would you be ok?
For that matter, when prerecorded VHS movies were finally inexpensive back in the day, I insisted on buying a factory sealed new copy for movies that I wanted to watch again.
(In principle it would have been easier to just get a rental copy and do a vhs->vhs machine dub).
(In principle it would have been easier to just get a rental copy and do a vhs->vhs machine dub).
#220
DVD Talk Legend
Re: If physical media went away completely, would you be ok?
For that matter, when prerecorded VHS movies were finally inexpensive back in the day, I insisted on buying a factory sealed new copy for movies that I wanted to watch again.
(In principle it would have been easier to just get a rental copy and do a vhs->vhs machine dub).
(In principle it would have been easier to just get a rental copy and do a vhs->vhs machine dub).
#221
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
Re: If physical media went away completely, would you be ok?
Or the weird guys in the dorms, who had four vhs machines running all day.
Even more creepy were the guys who would order electronics which attempted to "scrub" the macrovision copy protection on some prerecorded vhs tapes in those days.
Even more creepy were the guys who would order electronics which attempted to "scrub" the macrovision copy protection on some prerecorded vhs tapes in those days.
Last edited by morriscroy; 05-22-17 at 12:29 PM.
#222
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: If physical media went away completely, would you be ok?
Well that percentage is a bit disingenuous at best.
#223
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
Re: If physical media went away completely, would you be ok?
How many of these 4Kbluray players are actually being used to watch actual real 4Kbluray discs?
As opposed to these players being mostly used for stuff like Netflix streaming, youtube, etc ...
As opposed to these players being mostly used for stuff like Netflix streaming, youtube, etc ...
#224
DVD Talk Reviewer/ Admin
Join Date: Sep 1999
Location: Greenville, South Cackalack
Posts: 28,823
Received 1,882 Likes
on
1,238 Posts
Re: If physical media went away completely, would you be ok?
Why, because it doesn't include video game consoles? As for media, from that same source:
. . .
Considering that streaming apps are already built into most smart TVs, as well as other STBs, plug-and-play devices, video game consoles, etc., I'd imagine the number of people who buy a UHD BD player with no intention of playing UHD BDs approaches zero. It's possible that someone might start streaming through their smart TV, buy a UHD BD player, and not really play that many UHD BDs, but I would assume that those people would primarily stream the way they had before (TV, Roku, whatever) rather than switch to the UHD BD player as a primary source of streaming.
Buoyed by consumer adoption of 4K television and increased content selection, about 8.4 million 4K UHD Blu-ray Discs will be sold in 2017, according to new data from Futuresource Consulting.
The London-based research firm said the 4K tally would represent 4% of global Blu-ray Disc sales.
The London-based research firm said the 4K tally would represent 4% of global Blu-ray Disc sales.
Considering that streaming apps are already built into most smart TVs, as well as other STBs, plug-and-play devices, video game consoles, etc., I'd imagine the number of people who buy a UHD BD player with no intention of playing UHD BDs approaches zero. It's possible that someone might start streaming through their smart TV, buy a UHD BD player, and not really play that many UHD BDs, but I would assume that those people would primarily stream the way they had before (TV, Roku, whatever) rather than switch to the UHD BD player as a primary source of streaming.
Last edited by Adam Tyner; 05-22-17 at 01:24 PM.
#225
Political Exile
Re: If physical media went away completely, would you be ok?