Blu-ray and DVD sales - We're number 2, but we try harder
#1976
DVD Talk Special Edition
re: Blu-ray and DVD sales - #2, but we try harder
Exactly. I was referring to the 100 (or so) seminal titles with the ability to drive people to the stores to buy or to upgrade. Things like Spielberg, Blade Runner, BTTF, Star Wars, Wizard of Oz, etc. have all been released. There are no such titles remaining in the studios' 'cupboard'.
The poster who cited he could "name '50....without even breaking a sweat" was referring to small batch, niche titles with little chance to move the sales needle.
The poster who cited he could "name '50....without even breaking a sweat" was referring to small batch, niche titles with little chance to move the sales needle.
I sometimes wonder if Laserdisc was actually profitable? It held on for a long time and appealed to mostly cinephiles.
I'm guessing Laserdisc was a product of a different financial era. The current corporate mentality is if you're not selling more and more after each fiscal quarter, you're losing money.
DVD sales set such an incredibly high bar that any following format would look like a failure in comparison.
Since this thread is primarily focusing on the underwhelming sales numbers for Blu-ray, I was drawing the conclusion that 'we few' who read and post on forums such as this should not conflate our proclivities to those of the larger disc-buying public. Such passions have little impact on overall sales, and will not move studios to reach deeper into their vaults and/or invest in new transfers or supplemental features.
I have many friends that, when I look at their DVD collection, all I see is every major new release from 2002-2008. That's it.
It's kind of like comparing the fact that I drive a car two hours a day, every day but I don't visit "gear-head" websites or subscribe to Car & Driver magazine. The car is important to my daily life but I'm not an enthusiast who can rattle-off all the technical specs and care that deeply about the history of the automobile.
#1977
DVD Talk Hero
re: Blu-ray and DVD sales - #2, but we try harder
Movies and shows aimed at children are showing few signs of decline. It appears that families are still willing to buy the Blu-ray or DVD for their children over streaming, since I don't think many parents want their 4-year-old messing with the streaming menus on their TVs or Rokus.
#1978
Suspended
re: Blu-ray and DVD sales - #2, but we try harder
Movies and shows aimed at children are showing few signs of decline. It appears that families are still willing to buy the Blu-ray or DVD for their children over streaming, since I don't think many parents want their 4-year-old messing with the streaming menus on their TVs or Rokus.
#1980
DVD Talk Godfather
Join Date: Oct 2003
Location: Home of 2013 NFL champion Seahawks
Posts: 52,604
Received 1,014 Likes
on
838 Posts
re: Blu-ray and DVD sales - #2, but we try harder
I'm on this forum and I have a huge collection. I bought Braveheart and Gladiator on BD. Shift forward a few years and I still haven't bought Star Wars and Raiders. I love the movies, and I'd much rather watch them on BD, but the sets aren't supercheap and I figure they will be a better deal someday. I just don't have the same passion for building my physical collection. I've bought a few digital releases, especially TV, but big stuff like Captain America I still get on BD. That's the only new theatrical I recall buying this year, though.
Including watching the latest new release?
Including watching the latest new release?
#1981
DVD Talk Limited Edition
re: Blu-ray and DVD sales - #2, but we try harder
I didn't mean that at all. I'd say people are about done upgrading. Whatever the next format turns out to be, it will get a mere fraction of the Blu-ray's share....which was itself a fraction of the DVD's share.
#1984
DVD Talk Special Edition
re: Blu-ray and DVD sales - #2, but we try harder
Blu-ray is pretty much doomed to go negative this year. The remaining new releases do not compare favorably with last year and the format is already down 3 percent. The only thing that can save it from negative growth is Black Friday week and the two weeks leading up to Christmas. If those weeks can get one more year of growth then it could be enough, since those weeks are huge and can really influence the overall YoY figures. I'm not too optimistic though, but then again I wasn't optimistic about those weeks last year and they did much better than I expected.
#1985
DVD Talk Legend
re: Blu-ray and DVD sales - #2, but we try harder
Movies and shows aimed at children are showing few signs of decline. It appears that families are still willing to buy the Blu-ray or DVD for their children over streaming, since I don't think many parents want their 4-year-old messing with the streaming menus on their TVs or Rokus.
Streaming is the future folks. Physical media is on the decline and if it sticks around, it will become what laserdisc became - a niche format for boutique labels like Criterion, Shout/Scream, etc: basically for scifi/horror and other cult/genre titles.
#1986
Suspended
re: Blu-ray and DVD sales - #2, but we try harder
It already has. People are already spending $30 for a crappy 80s films from Shout Factory just because there is nothing else to buy.
#1987
DVD Talk Hero
re: Blu-ray and DVD sales - #2, but we try harder
My 7 y.o. has been using streaming for a few years now. It's easier for him to use than discs and it's more intuitive for him to use on the iPad also.
Streaming is the future folks. Physical media is on the decline and if it sticks around, it will become what laserdisc became - a niche format for boutique labels like Criterion, Shout/Scream, etc: basically for scifi/horror and other cult/genre titles.
Streaming is the future folks. Physical media is on the decline and if it sticks around, it will become what laserdisc became - a niche format for boutique labels like Criterion, Shout/Scream, etc: basically for scifi/horror and other cult/genre titles.
#1988
DVD Talk Legend
re: Blu-ray and DVD sales - #2, but we try harder
#1989
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
re: Blu-ray and DVD sales - #2, but we try harder
consumers are absolutely streaming stuff quite a bit.
It's less a question if they are streaming the hottest biggest new release rather than buying it because there is only so much time in the day. There is plenty of subscription content they can stream to fill the empty hours...rather than buying the latest and greatest- whether its a hard copy or a download.
But when you add the shift to streaming in general, with a slight amount of streaming NEW, paid content- that doesn't leave that much left for hard copy sales. And that is exactly what we are seeing.
It's less a question if they are streaming the hottest biggest new release rather than buying it because there is only so much time in the day. There is plenty of subscription content they can stream to fill the empty hours...rather than buying the latest and greatest- whether its a hard copy or a download.
But when you add the shift to streaming in general, with a slight amount of streaming NEW, paid content- that doesn't leave that much left for hard copy sales. And that is exactly what we are seeing.
#1990
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
re: Blu-ray and DVD sales - #2, but we try harder
They only time they seem to 'rotate' catalog titles is to tie in with a new movie coming out, like how they just recently got The Conjuring back because of Annabelle
#1991
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
re: Blu-ray and DVD sales - #2, but we try harder
Do you really think catalog titles are going to bring that much money in for them? How many people do you really think would rent The Crying Game from Redbox?
#1992
re: Blu-ray and DVD sales - #2, but we try harder
I assume they have nation wide distribution instead of doing everything regionally.
They should try using regional managers and stocking machines with a wide variety of titles. I have 5 machines near by, but they all carry basically the same titles (for fu#king months).
Their answer to declining profits is to raise prices (currently $1.35 in my area). The same mistake made by the music industry that drove them into the ground. The same mistake made by the dumb fu#ks in the movie industry, while their sales continue to tank.
Edit: I just realized, I've enjoyed watching more movies the last few months, for free on broadcast TV, than I've seen from Redbox. They have commercials, but I would rather see "The Crying Game" with commercials, than rent "Godzilla The Talking Dog" or whatever that crap is in the redbox machine.
They should try using regional managers and stocking machines with a wide variety of titles. I have 5 machines near by, but they all carry basically the same titles (for fu#king months).
Their answer to declining profits is to raise prices (currently $1.35 in my area). The same mistake made by the music industry that drove them into the ground. The same mistake made by the dumb fu#ks in the movie industry, while their sales continue to tank.
Edit: I just realized, I've enjoyed watching more movies the last few months, for free on broadcast TV, than I've seen from Redbox. They have commercials, but I would rather see "The Crying Game" with commercials, than rent "Godzilla The Talking Dog" or whatever that crap is in the redbox machine.
Increasing prices will drive Redbox to the same fate as others who try to squeeze more profits instead of doing the work necessary to have a truly accommodating rental service.
I stopped renting from Redbox because the titles just were not there. Certain neighborhoods have certain tastes. Maybe Redbox already does this but I haven't particularly observed this when shopping in stores all over the city as I walk out observing Redbox titles.
#1993
DVD Talk Reviewer & TOAT Winner
re: Blu-ray and DVD sales - #2, but we try harder
There's a TV version of The Crying Game? How did they handle the big reveal?
#1994
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
re: Blu-ray and DVD sales - #2, but we try harder
Totally agree. Machines should be stocked locally by real marketing data acquired instead of a nationwide canvass assumption on what everyone wants to see. For example, The Crying Game would get more rents in Portland, OR than some other title. Each city--even broken down to each city's neighborhoods, rent differently.
Increasing prices will drive Redbox to the same fate as others who try to squeeze more profits instead of doing the work necessary to have a truly accommodating rental service.
I stopped renting from Redbox because the titles just were not there. Certain neighborhoods have certain tastes. Maybe Redbox already does this but I haven't particularly observed this when shopping in stores all over the city as I walk out observing Redbox titles.
Increasing prices will drive Redbox to the same fate as others who try to squeeze more profits instead of doing the work necessary to have a truly accommodating rental service.
I stopped renting from Redbox because the titles just were not there. Certain neighborhoods have certain tastes. Maybe Redbox already does this but I haven't particularly observed this when shopping in stores all over the city as I walk out observing Redbox titles.
#1995
re: Blu-ray and DVD sales - #2, but we try harder
Exactly. I can't even begin to imagine that the handful of extra rentals generated by catalog titles would even come close to paying for regional marketing or whatever.
#1996
DVD Talk Hero
re: Blu-ray and DVD sales - #2, but we try harder
Hm. I did not know that all Redboxes carried the same titles. Every time I've looked at one, the selection was absolute shit. I've never rented from one since it doesn't look like it's worth the risk of having my credit card number jacked.
#1997
DVD Talk Reviewer & TOAT Winner
re: Blu-ray and DVD sales - #2, but we try harder
I've never seen the point of renting a "crap title" (meaning low-budget, straight-to-video movies) from Redbox since I've BOUGHT many titles of the same caliber for roughly the same price as their rentals are. In fact, I've never actually paid for a Redbox rental, always got 'em when they had free codes. They used to put out one a week that you could use multiple times if you had more than one credit card, but they aren't so generous now. I think the worst movie I rented from them was National Lampoon's Cattle Call.
#1998
DVD Talk Godfather
Join Date: Oct 2003
Location: Home of 2013 NFL champion Seahawks
Posts: 52,604
Received 1,014 Likes
on
838 Posts
re: Blu-ray and DVD sales - #2, but we try harder
Yeah, I haven't used a kiosk in a while but it seems they need some kind of artwork etc. for the titles--not really something a guy with a scanner and photoshop can do. Though that brings to mind the old-time jukeboxes that sometimes had a handwritten title card for certain selections.
#1999
DVD Talk Special Edition
re: Blu-ray and DVD sales - #2, but we try harder
I'm guessing the people using Redbox aren't using it to watch deep catalog titles. They're probably just interested in new releases. That does suck the titles aren't rotated often, although I don't think loading them up with random catalog titles would help much, if any.
#2000
DVD Talk Limited Edition