Originally Posted by IBJoel
We're going to look into this! And just to be clear, you didn't see that initial email in your spam folder or anything?
Well now I feel stupid - I've been using Apple email for a while and I rarely use it outside of my phone. I logged into it from a PC today and for some reason noticed the "junk" folder for the first time. All the initial messages were in there.
My apologies for wasting your time. I'm not sure why Apple's email filters would allow reply messages to come through but not the initial email. The sender, body and subject are basically identical. I doubt I flagged it since I hardly ever got email notifications before now - I'll have to see if there's a way to change on my end.
Thanks again for your time.