apocalypto wrong aspect ratio??

[philip74]

the apocalypto dvd backcover states the ratio as 1,85, whereas imdb lists it as 2,35.
is this just a printing mistake on the dvd cover, or are we being presented the wrong aspect ratio?

[Egon's Ghost]

Ah, the new full screen.

[Giles]

as I recall in the theatre it was 1.85

[alk3hol]

Originally Posted by Giles

as I recall in the theatre it was 1.85

You are correct.

[philip74]

so why is the trailer and the imdb lisiting 2;35 then?

[dcprules]

Yep, definitely 1.85:1 I remember being surprised by the aspect ratio when I saw it theatrically. Can't wait to get the Blu Ray

[Giles]

Originally Posted by philip74

so why is the trailer and the imdb lisiting 2;35 then?

because imdb doesn't know ALL

[philip74]

Originally Posted by Giles

because imdb doesn't know ALL

i definitely agree with you on that point, but that still doesnt explain the fact why the trailer is 2,35?
also sme european dvd releases are listed as 2,35?

[abintra]

Not sure James Berardinelli is foolproof either but his review does state 1.85:1 also.

[Mr. Salty]

Please note how aspect ratios are written ----> 2.35:1 | 1.85:1 | 4:3 | 16:9

[Julie Walker]

Originally Posted by philip74

so why is the trailer and the imdb lisiting 2;35 then?

imdb.com is not always correct. And trailers are created in different aspect ratios all the time!

A recent example I've seen is on the old Predator 2 dvd(which I just picked up). The film itself is 1.85:1 OAR, but the trailer is matted to 2.35:1.

[noahtc]

Yeah, the dvd for the good son has the trailer which is in 2:35.1 but t he film is 1:85.1

[Skoobooz]

Same with Little Shop of Horrors.

[garmonbozia]

Originally Posted by philip74

i definitely agree with you on that point, but that still doesnt explain the fact why the trailer is 2,35?

trailers are often made in different ARs to match the AR of the film they are going to be shown in front of in the theater.

[eedoon]

I have made several corrections on a few IMDb's entry - some of them are film duration (most of them being 4% shorter than actual duration, possibly due because the original entry was entered by someone with PAL DVDs), and some other stuff.

I'll try to correct the Apocalypto thing - it may take a week or two before (or if) they approve the changes. IMDb cannot always be trusted as an accurate source.

[Giles]

Originally Posted by eedoon

I have made several corrections on a few IMDb's entry - some of them are film duration (most of them being 4% shorter than actual duration, possibly due because the original entry was entered by someone with PAL DVDs), and some other stuff.

I'll try to correct the Apocalypto thing - it may take a week or two before (or if) they approve the changes. IMDb cannot always be trusted as an accurate source.

so what did you write to them about the correct aspect ratio correction - by stating the DVD is 1.85 and those (like myself) who saw it that way in the theatre, I thought imdb was kind of anal in terms of being very specific and having relient proof of corrections like this.

[Giles]

Originally Posted by garmonbozia

trailers are often made in different ARs to match the AR of the film they are going to be shown in front of in the theater.

I don't know if that always the case, I've seen movies where the feature is in 1.85 and the films/trailers that are 2.35 and shown as such (letterboxed - with those annoying black bars above and below the image ).

[eedoon]

Originally Posted by Giles

so what did you write to them about the correct aspect ratio correction - by stating the DVD is 1.85 and those (like myself) who saw it that way in the theatre, I thought imdb was kind of anal in terms of being very specific and having relient proof of corrections like this.

I just follow their update/correction procedure. I just have to fill some form with drop down box with all the aspect ratio in it. Usually they have to confirm this before they changed the information.

Here's a the copy of the email if you're interested:

Thank you for contributing to the IMDb. A detailed receipt for your update is included below. The information you supplied has been passed to the IMDb data managers for verification.

Updates normally take around 7-10 days to appear online, but depending on the type of information submitted and various internal factors, it may take longer in some cases. For example additions involving titles or names new to the database require an additional 7 days to process. If your changes still have not appeared online after 28 days, it can mean we were unable to verify the information or it was in some way ineligible for inclusion. However, you should also check the processing times page for any unusual delays, particularly if your data was in one of the following categories: awards, alternate titles.

For questions on the submission process we recommend visiting the Contributors Help message board.

The reference number for this submission is 070510-102542-901000 and it has been added to your update history.
Update summary

* Apocalypto (2006)
o Aspect Ratio - Replace

Old -
2.35 : 1
New -
1.85 : 1

[eedoon]

Update: My correction have been added.

http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0472043/technical

[garmonbozia]

Originally Posted by Giles

I don't know if that always the case, I've seen movies where the feature is in 1.85 and the films/trailers that are 2.35 and shown as such (letterboxed - with those annoying black bars above and below the image ).

i didn't say it was always the case. i said "often" not always. and it may be the case that it was something commonly done in the past and it is not bothered to be done anymore. I just saw Spider-man 3 this past weekend and after the 20 minutes of promo material was over (but before the trailers began) the screen changed size to 2.35:1 yet every single trailer shown before it was 1.85:1 (they had bars on the sides).

[harpo787]

Originally Posted by Mr. Salty

Please note how aspect ratios are written ----> 2.35:1 | 1.85:1 | 4:3 | 16:9

I've seen spelling police and grammar police...but I don't believe I've seen a "how to write the ratio in an appropriate format" police!

[Mr. Salty]

You haven't poked around these AR threads much then, have you?

[BuckNaked2k]

Originally Posted by harpo787

I've seen spelling police and grammar police...but I don't believe I've seen a "how to write the ratio in an appropriate format" police!

I see his point. It is confusing enough for some folks with all the different aspect ratio talk, letterboxed, widescreen, 16X9, etc. to introduce multipe conventions for describing these things.