DVD Talk Review of NIGHT WATCH
#1
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Thread Starter
DVD Talk Review of NIGHT WATCH
Is there any possibility of having the "movie ruining plot spoilers" more specifically identified within their respective paragraphs within this review? I've wanted to see this movie for decades but find it rather dismaying to be limited to just the first two paragraphs of the review simply because I haven't been fortunate enough to see the film before now. With most of the Archive-type MOD discs I buy, I enjoy reading reviews beforehand, but in the case of most Mr. Mavis' pieces, I find I'm frequently left out in the cold because of the warnings of massive spoilers and a general lack of reviews of the same discs by other DVDTalk enthusiasts. I'm just curious if ANY of the seven paragraphs that follow the spoiler warning on the NIGHT WATCH review are safe to read for their analysis, or do the all effectively ruin the film for the (many) uninitiated readers who've long waited to see? I realize it's probably some kind of signature on the part of Mr. Mavis, but it might be more considerate to readers to eliminate such spoilers altogether and instead encourage anticipation of them by simply acknowledging that they're there. I've just never seen a movie that can't be effectively researched and analyzed -- especially on a fan review site like this one -- without destroying important surprises in the process, effectively forbidding readers from enjoying a review until after they've already spent the money.
Last edited by Brian T; 11-14-11 at 11:01 PM.
#2
Re: DVD Talk Review of NIGHT WATCH
[I]Is there any possibility of having the "movie ruining plot spoilers" more specifically identified within their respective paragraphs within this review? I've wanted to see this movie for decades but find it rather dismaying to be limited to just the first two paragraphs of the review simply because I haven't been fortunate enough to see the film before now.
With most of the Archive-type MOD discs I buy, I enjoy reading reviews beforehand, but in the case of most Mr. Mavis' pieces, I find I'm frequently left out in the cold because of the warnings of massive spoilers and a general lack of reviews of the same discs by other DVDTalk enthusiasts.
The other side of that coin, Brian, is that I have many other readers who appreciate the depth I go into for the titles I review. You're the first one I've had that gave me feedback about the plot spoilers.
I've just never seen a movie that can't be effectively researched and analyzed -- especially on a fan review site like this one -- without destroying important surprises in the process, effectively forbidding readers from enjoying a review until after they've already spent the money.
But again, I think you make a good point about being more specific about where the actual spoilers are coming in the piece, Brian, so you can read more of the review, and I'll do that.