Go Back  DVD Talk Forum > Entertainment Discussions > Comic Book Talk
Reload this Page >

The First Annual DVDTalk Eisner Comic Book Challenge - February 2015

Community
Search
Comic Book Talk The Place to talk about Comics

The First Annual DVDTalk Eisner Comic Book Challenge - February 2015

Thread Tools
 
Search this Thread
 
Old 02-20-15, 09:10 AM
  #51  
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
 
Join Date: Dec 2007
Location: Houston, TX
Posts: 4,053
Received 213 Likes on 140 Posts
Re: The First Annual DVDTalk Eisner Comic Book Challenge - February 2015

February 20
Chew / Revival [one shot] – unexpected crossover that doesn't quite mesh but it's ambitious, I enjoyed the first Chew style story more.
Chew: Warrior Chicken Poyo [one shot] – getting thin, one shots are interesting but the focus on Poyo is odd.
Chew 41-45 – The last two issues are some of the best stuff I've read, really a great payoff with nice action and drama.
Batman: The Long Halloween 1 – interesting art design, weighty story so far although some of it feels cliche after movies/rehashes.

Spoiler:
February 1
Started All Star Superman (issues 1-6 so far) - weighty spin on the Superman mythos with a good balance of eccentric science fiction and drama.

February 2
All Star Superman 7-12: Satisfying read but doesn't end as strong as it starts.

February 3
Astonishing X-men 1-4: Tense effort that redefines the X-men with a novel adversary but seeing some elements in early stages that get over-exaggerated later (like Wolverine / Cyclops schism) it feels "over done" in retrospect.

February 5
Astonishing X-men 5-10: Wendon does good with dialogue and characters with Cassaday's artwork has a solemn feel that lends a good gravity to events.

February 6
Astonishing X-men 11-14: Gets almost psychedelic with surreal twists and a lot crisscrossing threads, fun stuff.

February 7
Astonishing X-men 11-25
Giant Sized Astonishing X-men 1.1-1.2 - satisfying end with a nice gut punch. Tried to read issue 26 but it seems too different than what proceeded I decided on a break.

February 8
Sex Criminal 1-5 - just the right combination of surreal, playful, "too much information," and action but risks pushing the scale too far in any one direction depending on how things proceed from here. Semi-explicit and frank but at times too hooked on that alone.

February 9
Saga 1 - nicely surreal.

February 11
Saga 2-6 - some of the set-up feels thin but characterization and atmosphere/visuals are strong.

February 12
Saga 7-12 - compelling with subtle social commentary and wild imagery.

February 13
Saga 13-22 - really compelling but stalls some towards the end of these issues with a change in direction.

February 14
Saga 23-24 - Nicely paced with a lot of cliffhangers; I think Saga might read better back-to-back rather than delays between issues... so at issue 24 will probably wait a bit to read further.

February 15
Chew 1-6 - Novel premise, I wasn't sure if they'd go for "gross out" effects but it's nicely done with a good aura of mystery and humor.

February 16
Chew 7-13 - does a good job of building on itself using established characters in new ways to advance a large scale story with a surprisingly small cast.

February 17
Chew 14-21 - builds a satisfying sense that there is an arch-nemesis but starting to feel a little worn despite the focus on character development by stalling/rehashing earlier plot points.
February 18

Chew 22-27 - stalls some to refocus more on auxiliary characters and while the change is nice it feels inconsequential to the development so far but might pay off in long run.
Batman: The Killing Joke - weighty themes with engrossing art but the immediate plot felt lacking. Great ending, boo to origin stories.

February 19
Chew: Secret Agent Poyo [one shot] – a “cute” joke that feels overdone, amusing but disposable and un-necessary expansion on a thin joke… fun but fluff.
Chew 28-40 – starts to pick back up with more mystery, nice foreshadowing, and further plot incubation getting more direction by again focusing on the main character.


Total issues: 119

Last edited by Undeadcow; 02-23-15 at 10:15 PM.
Old 02-21-15, 10:55 PM
  #52  
DVD Talk Legend
 
Join Date: Apr 2002
Location: Formerly known as Groucho AND Bandoman/Death Moans, Iowa
Posts: 18,295
Received 372 Likes on 266 Posts
Re: The First Annual DVDTalk Eisner Comic Book Challenge - February 2015

Sorry for the lack of updates the last few days. It was partly due to some work stuff and my grandma entering hopice care, partly because I was reading a Usagi book where it was hard to tell which issue was which.

Day 21
Usagi Yojimbo 32-38, and some random shorts that I'm counting as another issue.
I did read a lot of Goon today, 19-31

Total books read: 91

Previous reading
Spoiler:

Day 1

Usagi Yojimbo Mirage Series 7-12, 14

Goon 1-4, the ongoing series.

Day 2

The Goon 1-4, Dark Horse mini

Day 3

The Goon 5-6

Day 4

Usagi Yojimbo Mirage issues 13, 15–16, Dark Horse, 1–6. I actually read this over the course of a couple days while also reading The Goon, but it was tough to differentiate which stories were which issues, so I held off listing any until I was done reading.

Day 5

Usagi Yojimbo 7
The Goon 7-8

Day 6

Usagi Yojimbo 8-9

Day 7
The Goon 9-10. I like that this series is picking up some depth and character moments as it progresses. I was worried it was going to be all gags - which are very funny - it would just be hard to sustain for 40 some issues.

Day 8
The Goon 11-12
Usagi Yojimbo 10-12, Green Persimmon and Snakes & Blossoms specials

Day 9
The Goon 13
Usagi Yojimbo 13

Day 10
Usagi Yojimbo 14-15

Day 11
Usagi Yojimbo 16-17

Day 12
Usagi Yojimbo 18

Day 13
Walking Dead 137

day 13
Usagi Yojimbo 19-23

The Goon 14-18

Day 15
Usagi Yojimbo 24-30

Day 16
The Goon: Chinatown and the Mystery of Mr. Wicker. It's a 112 page graphic novel, I'm counting it as four issues.

Day 17
Usagi Yojimbo 31
Old 02-22-15, 09:54 PM
  #53  
DVD Talk Legend
 
Join Date: Apr 2002
Location: Formerly known as Groucho AND Bandoman/Death Moans, Iowa
Posts: 18,295
Received 372 Likes on 266 Posts
Re: The First Annual DVDTalk Eisner Comic Book Challenge - February 2015

I'm into triple digits!

Day 22
Usagi Yojimbo 39-45
The Goon 32-34

Total books read: 101

Previous reading
Spoiler:

Day 1

Usagi Yojimbo Mirage Series 7-12, 14

Goon 1-4, the ongoing series.

Day 2

The Goon 1-4, Dark Horse mini

Day 3

The Goon 5-6

Day 4

Usagi Yojimbo Mirage issues 13, 15–16, Dark Horse, 1–6. I actually read this over the course of a couple days while also reading The Goon, but it was tough to differentiate which stories were which issues, so I held off listing any until I was done reading.

Day 5

Usagi Yojimbo 7
The Goon 7-8

Day 6

Usagi Yojimbo 8-9

Day 7
The Goon 9-10. I like that this series is picking up some depth and character moments as it progresses. I was worried it was going to be all gags - which are very funny - it would just be hard to sustain for 40 some issues.

Day 8
The Goon 11-12
Usagi Yojimbo 10-12, Green Persimmon and Snakes & Blossoms specials

Day 9
The Goon 13
Usagi Yojimbo 13

Day 10
Usagi Yojimbo 14-15

Day 11
Usagi Yojimbo 16-17

Day 12
Usagi Yojimbo 18

Day 13
Walking Dead 137

day 13
Usagi Yojimbo 19-23

The Goon 14-18

Day 15
Usagi Yojimbo 24-30

Day 16
The Goon: Chinatown and the Mystery of Mr. Wicker. It's a 112 page graphic novel, I'm counting it as four issues.

Day 17
Usagi Yojimbo 31

Day 21
Usagi Yojimbo 32-38
The Goon 19-31
Old 02-23-15, 10:15 PM
  #54  
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
 
Join Date: Dec 2007
Location: Houston, TX
Posts: 4,053
Received 213 Likes on 140 Posts
Re: The First Annual DVDTalk Eisner Comic Book Challenge - February 2015

February 21
Batman: The Long Halloween 2-4 – fun to see a diverse cast of characters but some of the dramatic irony feels too obvious.

February 22
Batman: The Long Halloween 5-7 - meh, I'm committed but not grabbing me as much as I expected from it's epic reputation.

Spoiler:
February 1
Started All Star Superman (issues 1-6 so far) - weighty spin on the Superman mythos with a good balance of eccentric science fiction and drama.

February 2
All Star Superman 7-12: Satisfying read but doesn't end as strong as it starts.

February 3
Astonishing X-men 1-4: Tense effort that redefines the X-men with a novel adversary but seeing some elements in early stages that get over-exaggerated later (like Wolverine / Cyclops schism) it feels "over done" in retrospect.

February 5
Astonishing X-men 5-10: Wendon does good with dialogue and characters with Cassaday's artwork has a solemn feel that lends a good gravity to events.

February 6
Astonishing X-men 11-14: Gets almost psychedelic with surreal twists and a lot crisscrossing threads, fun stuff.

February 7
Astonishing X-men 11-25
Giant Sized Astonishing X-men 1.1-1.2 - satisfying end with a nice gut punch. Tried to read issue 26 but it seems too different than what proceeded I decided on a break.

February 8
Sex Criminal 1-5 - just the right combination of surreal, playful, "too much information," and action but risks pushing the scale too far in any one direction depending on how things proceed from here. Semi-explicit and frank but at times too hooked on that alone.

February 9
Saga 1 - nicely surreal.

February 11
Saga 2-6 - some of the set-up feels thin but characterization and atmosphere/visuals are strong.

February 12
Saga 7-12 - compelling with subtle social commentary and wild imagery.

February 13
Saga 13-22 - really compelling but stalls some towards the end of these issues with a change in direction.

February 14
Saga 23-24 - Nicely paced with a lot of cliffhangers; I think Saga might read better back-to-back rather than delays between issues... so at issue 24 will probably wait a bit to read further.

February 15
Chew 1-6 - Novel premise, I wasn't sure if they'd go for "gross out" effects but it's nicely done with a good aura of mystery and humor.

February 16
Chew 7-13 - does a good job of building on itself using established characters in new ways to advance a large scale story with a surprisingly small cast.

February 17
Chew 14-21 - builds a satisfying sense that there is an arch-nemesis but starting to feel a little worn despite the focus on character development by stalling/rehashing earlier plot points.
February 18

Chew 22-27 - stalls some to refocus more on auxiliary characters and while the change is nice it feels inconsequential to the development so far but might pay off in long run.
Batman: The Killing Joke - weighty themes with engrossing art but the immediate plot felt lacking. Great ending, boo to origin stories.

February 19
Chew: Secret Agent Poyo [one shot] – a “cute” joke that feels overdone, amusing but disposable and un-necessary expansion on a thin joke… fun but fluff.
Chew 28-40 – starts to pick back up with more mystery, nice foreshadowing, and further plot incubation getting more direction by again focusing on the main character.

February 20
Chew / Revival [one shot] – unexpected crossover that doesn't quite mesh but it's ambitious, I enjoyed the first Chew style story more.
Chew: Warrior Chicken Poyo [one shot] – getting thin, one shots are interesting but the focus on Poyo is odd.
Chew 41-45 – The last two issues are some of the best stuff I've read, really a great payoff with nice action and drama.
Batman: The Long Halloween 1 – interesting art design, weighty story so far although some of it feels cliche after movies/rehashes.


Total issues: 123
Old 02-24-15, 03:25 PM
  #55  
DVD Talk Legend
 
Join Date: Apr 2002
Location: Formerly known as Groucho AND Bandoman/Death Moans, Iowa
Posts: 18,295
Received 372 Likes on 266 Posts
Re: The First Annual DVDTalk Eisner Comic Book Challenge - February 2015

Day 23
The Goon 35-36

Total books read: 103

Previous reading
Spoiler:

Day 1

Usagi Yojimbo Mirage Series 7-12, 14

Goon 1-4, the ongoing series.

Day 2

The Goon 1-4, Dark Horse mini

Day 3

The Goon 5-6

Day 4

Usagi Yojimbo Mirage issues 13, 15–16, Dark Horse, 1–6. I actually read this over the course of a couple days while also reading The Goon, but it was tough to differentiate which stories were which issues, so I held off listing any until I was done reading.

Day 5

Usagi Yojimbo 7
The Goon 7-8

Day 6

Usagi Yojimbo 8-9

Day 7
The Goon 9-10. I like that this series is picking up some depth and character moments as it progresses. I was worried it was going to be all gags - which are very funny - it would just be hard to sustain for 40 some issues.

Day 8
The Goon 11-12
Usagi Yojimbo 10-12, Green Persimmon and Snakes & Blossoms specials

Day 9
The Goon 13
Usagi Yojimbo 13

Day 10
Usagi Yojimbo 14-15

Day 11
Usagi Yojimbo 16-17

Day 12
Usagi Yojimbo 18

Day 13
Walking Dead 137

day 13
Usagi Yojimbo 19-23

The Goon 14-18

Day 15
Usagi Yojimbo 24-30

Day 16
The Goon: Chinatown and the Mystery of Mr. Wicker. It's a 112 page graphic novel, I'm counting it as four issues.

Day 17
Usagi Yojimbo 31

Day 21
Usagi Yojimbo 32-38
The Goon 19-31

Day 22
Usagi Yojimbo 39-45
The Goon 32-34
Old 02-24-15, 10:31 PM
  #56  
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
 
Join Date: Dec 2007
Location: Houston, TX
Posts: 4,053
Received 213 Likes on 140 Posts
Re: The First Annual DVDTalk Eisner Comic Book Challenge - February 2015

February 23
Batman: The Long Halloween 8-13 - picks up nicely in the last chapter playing with reader assumptions and redeeming some of the slower parts.

Moving on to Powers and maybe some Invincible Iron Man (2008) or Dark Horse Presents...
Spoiler:
February 1
Started All Star Superman (issues 1-6 so far) - weighty spin on the Superman mythos with a good balance of eccentric science fiction and drama.

February 2
All Star Superman 7-12: Satisfying read but doesn't end as strong as it starts.

February 3
Astonishing X-men 1-4: Tense effort that redefines the X-men with a novel adversary but seeing some elements in early stages that get over-exaggerated later (like Wolverine / Cyclops schism) it feels "over done" in retrospect.

February 5
Astonishing X-men 5-10: Wendon does good with dialogue and characters with Cassaday's artwork has a solemn feel that lends a good gravity to events.

February 6
Astonishing X-men 11-14: Gets almost psychedelic with surreal twists and a lot crisscrossing threads, fun stuff.

February 7
Astonishing X-men 11-25
Giant Sized Astonishing X-men 1.1-1.2 - satisfying end with a nice gut punch. Tried to read issue 26 but it seems too different than what proceeded I decided on a break.

February 8
Sex Criminal 1-5 - just the right combination of surreal, playful, "too much information," and action but risks pushing the scale too far in any one direction depending on how things proceed from here. Semi-explicit and frank but at times too hooked on that alone.

February 9
Saga 1 - nicely surreal.

February 11
Saga 2-6 - some of the set-up feels thin but characterization and atmosphere/visuals are strong.

February 12
Saga 7-12 - compelling with subtle social commentary and wild imagery.

February 13
Saga 13-22 - really compelling but stalls some towards the end of these issues with a change in direction.

February 14
Saga 23-24 - Nicely paced with a lot of cliffhangers; I think Saga might read better back-to-back rather than delays between issues... so at issue 24 will probably wait a bit to read further.

February 15
Chew 1-6 - Novel premise, I wasn't sure if they'd go for "gross out" effects but it's nicely done with a good aura of mystery and humor.

February 16
Chew 7-13 - does a good job of building on itself using established characters in new ways to advance a large scale story with a surprisingly small cast.

February 17
Chew 14-21 - builds a satisfying sense that there is an arch-nemesis but starting to feel a little worn despite the focus on character development by stalling/rehashing earlier plot points.
February 18

Chew 22-27 - stalls some to refocus more on auxiliary characters and while the change is nice it feels inconsequential to the development so far but might pay off in long run.
Batman: The Killing Joke - weighty themes with engrossing art but the immediate plot felt lacking. Great ending, boo to origin stories.

February 19
Chew: Secret Agent Poyo [one shot] – a “cute” joke that feels overdone, amusing but disposable and un-necessary expansion on a thin joke… fun but fluff.
Chew 28-40 – starts to pick back up with more mystery, nice foreshadowing, and further plot incubation getting more direction by again focusing on the main character.

February 20
Chew / Revival [one shot] – unexpected crossover that doesn't quite mesh but it's ambitious, I enjoyed the first Chew style story more.
Chew: Warrior Chicken Poyo [one shot] – getting thin, one shots are interesting but the focus on Poyo is odd.
Chew 41-45 – The last two issues are some of the best stuff I've read, really a great payoff with nice action and drama.
Batman: The Long Halloween 1 – interesting art design, weighty story so far although some of it feels cliche after movies/rehashes.

February 21
Batman: The Long Halloween 2-4 – fun to see a diverse cast of characters but some of the dramatic irony feels too obvious.

February 22
Batman: The Long Halloween 5-7 - meh, I'm committed but not grabbing me as much as I expected from it's epic reputation.


Total issues: 128
Old 02-25-15, 09:24 AM
  #57  
Challenge Guru & Comic Nerd
Thread Starter
 
Trevor's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr 1999
Location: spiritually, Minnesota
Posts: 36,891
Received 678 Likes on 454 Posts
Re: The First Annual DVDTalk Eisner Comic Book Challenge - February 2015

Mainly for next year I guess, but here is a list of links to a bunch of awards. I tried to make the links go right to the lists to make them easily searchable, some are in yearly link form though. I spent some time going thru them and enjoyed the walk thru history; and finding some stuff that qualifies that I wasn't sure about.


http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alley_Award

http://www.cbgxtra.com/knowledge-bas...s-1982-present

http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Don_T...ard#Categories

http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eagle_Awards

http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_..._Award_winners The Eisners

http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bill_...ard#Recipients Finger Award for Writing

http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Glyph...Awards_winners

http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_..._Award_winners The Harveys

http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Howar...ts_and_winners

http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ignat...s_and_nominees

http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inkpo...Awards_by_year

http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joe_S...rds#Categories

http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kirby..._Award_winners

http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_..._Award_winners

http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Natio...y#Other_awards

http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reube...d#Reuben_Award

http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russ_..._Award#Winners

http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shaza...d#Shazam_Award

http://www.hahnlibrary.net/comics/awards/squid.php

http://www.ccawards.com Web Comic awards

http://www.hahnlibrary.net/comics/awards/wizard.php
Old 02-25-15, 10:18 AM
  #58  
DVD Talk Legend
 
Join Date: Apr 2002
Location: Formerly known as Groucho AND Bandoman/Death Moans, Iowa
Posts: 18,295
Received 372 Likes on 266 Posts
Re: The First Annual DVDTalk Eisner Comic Book Challenge - February 2015

Day 24
The Goon 37-39

I'm hoping to get up to 120 by Saturday. I'd like to finish off the issues of The Goon I have and read at least one more Usagi Yojimbo book.

Total books read: 106

Previous reading
Spoiler:

Day 1

Usagi Yojimbo Mirage Series 7-12, 14

Goon 1-4, the ongoing series.

Day 2

The Goon 1-4, Dark Horse mini

Day 3

The Goon 5-6

Day 4

Usagi Yojimbo Mirage issues 13, 15–16, Dark Horse, 1–6. I actually read this over the course of a couple days while also reading The Goon, but it was tough to differentiate which stories were which issues, so I held off listing any until I was done reading.

Day 5

Usagi Yojimbo 7
The Goon 7-8

Day 6

Usagi Yojimbo 8-9

Day 7
The Goon 9-10. I like that this series is picking up some depth and character moments as it progresses. I was worried it was going to be all gags - which are very funny - it would just be hard to sustain for 40 some issues.

Day 8
The Goon 11-12
Usagi Yojimbo 10-12, Green Persimmon and Snakes & Blossoms specials

Day 9
The Goon 13
Usagi Yojimbo 13

Day 10
Usagi Yojimbo 14-15

Day 11
Usagi Yojimbo 16-17

Day 12
Usagi Yojimbo 18

Day 13
Walking Dead 137

day 13
Usagi Yojimbo 19-23

The Goon 14-18

Day 15
Usagi Yojimbo 24-30

Day 16
The Goon: Chinatown and the Mystery of Mr. Wicker. It's a 112 page graphic novel, I'm counting it as four issues.

Day 17
Usagi Yojimbo 31

Day 21
Usagi Yojimbo 32-38
The Goon 19-31

Day 22
Usagi Yojimbo 39-45
The Goon 32-34

Day 23
The Goon 35-36
Old 02-25-15, 01:07 PM
  #59  
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
 
Join Date: Dec 2007
Location: Houston, TX
Posts: 4,053
Received 213 Likes on 140 Posts
Re: The First Annual DVDTalk Eisner Comic Book Challenge - February 2015

February 24

Powers (2000) #1 - I've since read more of the series and it picked up but this was a disappointing introduction; mis-directed focus on a random kid with little to establish characters. Bendis' dialogue seems hit or miss at times feeling overly crass and other times too "hip."

Spoiler:
February 1
Started All Star Superman (issues 1-6 so far) - weighty spin on the Superman mythos with a good balance of eccentric science fiction and drama.

February 2
All Star Superman 7-12: Satisfying read but doesn't end as strong as it starts.

February 3
Astonishing X-men 1-4: Tense effort that redefines the X-men with a novel adversary but seeing some elements in early stages that get over-exaggerated later (like Wolverine / Cyclops schism) it feels "over done" in retrospect.

February 5
Astonishing X-men 5-10: Wendon does good with dialogue and characters with Cassaday's artwork has a solemn feel that lends a good gravity to events.

February 6
Astonishing X-men 11-14: Gets almost psychedelic with surreal twists and a lot crisscrossing threads, fun stuff.

February 7
Astonishing X-men 11-25
Giant Sized Astonishing X-men 1.1-1.2 - satisfying end with a nice gut punch. Tried to read issue 26 but it seems too different than what proceeded I decided on a break.

February 8
Sex Criminal 1-5 - just the right combination of surreal, playful, "too much information," and action but risks pushing the scale too far in any one direction depending on how things proceed from here. Semi-explicit and frank but at times too hooked on that alone.

February 9
Saga 1 - nicely surreal.

February 11
Saga 2-6 - some of the set-up feels thin but characterization and atmosphere/visuals are strong.

February 12
Saga 7-12 - compelling with subtle social commentary and wild imagery.

February 13
Saga 13-22 - really compelling but stalls some towards the end of these issues with a change in direction.

February 14
Saga 23-24 - Nicely paced with a lot of cliffhangers; I think Saga might read better back-to-back rather than delays between issues... so at issue 24 will probably wait a bit to read further.

February 15
Chew 1-6 - Novel premise, I wasn't sure if they'd go for "gross out" effects but it's nicely done with a good aura of mystery and humor.

February 16
Chew 7-13 - does a good job of building on itself using established characters in new ways to advance a large scale story with a surprisingly small cast.

February 17
Chew 14-21 - builds a satisfying sense that there is an arch-nemesis but starting to feel a little worn despite the focus on character development by stalling/rehashing earlier plot points.
February 18

Chew 22-27 - stalls some to refocus more on auxiliary characters and while the change is nice it feels inconsequential to the development so far but might pay off in long run.
Batman: The Killing Joke - weighty themes with engrossing art but the immediate plot felt lacking. Great ending, boo to origin stories.

February 19
Chew: Secret Agent Poyo [one shot] – a “cute” joke that feels overdone, amusing but disposable and un-necessary expansion on a thin joke… fun but fluff.
Chew 28-40 – starts to pick back up with more mystery, nice foreshadowing, and further plot incubation getting more direction by again focusing on the main character.

February 20
Chew / Revival [one shot] – unexpected crossover that doesn't quite mesh but it's ambitious, I enjoyed the first Chew style story more.
Chew: Warrior Chicken Poyo [one shot] – getting thin, one shots are interesting but the focus on Poyo is odd.
Chew 41-45 – The last two issues are some of the best stuff I've read, really a great payoff with nice action and drama.
Batman: The Long Halloween 1 – interesting art design, weighty story so far although some of it feels cliche after movies/rehashes.

February 21
Batman: The Long Halloween 2-4 – fun to see a diverse cast of characters but some of the dramatic irony feels too obvious.

February 22
Batman: The Long Halloween 5-7 - meh, I'm committed but not grabbing me as much as I expected from it's epic reputation.

February 23
Batman: The Long Halloween 8-13 - picks up nicely in the last chapter playing with reader assumptions and redeeming some of the slower parts.


Total issues: 129
Originally Posted by Trevor
...here is a list of links to a bunch of awards...
Thanks, epic list. For some reason I've just focused on Eisner winners this year. I wonder if having the challenge open to EVERY award (there are 21 listed) wouldn't end up being too open ended although I haven't really done much comparison... maybe only time will tell.
Old 02-25-15, 01:32 PM
  #60  
Challenge Guru & Comic Nerd
Thread Starter
 
Trevor's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr 1999
Location: spiritually, Minnesota
Posts: 36,891
Received 678 Likes on 454 Posts
Re: The First Annual DVDTalk Eisner Comic Book Challenge - February 2015

^ Yeah, it does open things up a bit. But it still only represents a small percentage of comics.

Unless you want to get really lenient and say that any Marvel comic from 2004 qualifies because it won publisher of the year from Wizard.
Old 02-25-15, 03:32 PM
  #61  
DVD Talk Godfather
 
davidh777's Avatar
 
Join Date: Oct 2003
Location: Home of 2013 NFL champion Seahawks
Posts: 52,636
Received 1,016 Likes on 840 Posts
Re: The First Annual DVDTalk Eisner Comic Book Challenge - February 2015

I understand if a movie has won an Oscar, but comics are kind of like a TV show winning an Emmy, only worse since they can run even longer.

Again, not criticizing the challenge or the people running it or participating--just going through my own ability to figure out what to read.

Originally Posted by Trevor
Unless you want to get really lenient and say that any Marvel comic from 2004 qualifies because it won publisher of the year from Wizard.
Too much work to figure out what came out that year.
Old 02-25-15, 07:46 PM
  #62  
Challenge Guru & Comic Nerd
Thread Starter
 
Trevor's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr 1999
Location: spiritually, Minnesota
Posts: 36,891
Received 678 Likes on 454 Posts
Re: The First Annual DVDTalk Eisner Comic Book Challenge - February 2015

Originally Posted by davidh777
I understand if a movie has won an Oscar, but comics are kind of like a TV show winning an Emmy, only worse since they can run even longer.
If I'm reading you correctly, are you thinking that if Title X issues 344-348 won an award for something, then EVERY issue of Title X if eligible?

That's not what I'm thinking at least. I think you have to read the storyline that actually won or was nominated for an award.

So if The Walking Dead won an award one year for best whatever, then only that year's issues would count.

I'm probably making it sound more complicated than it is. Seems pretty straight forward to me.
Old 02-25-15, 10:41 PM
  #63  
DVD Talk Legend
 
Join Date: Apr 2002
Location: Formerly known as Groucho AND Bandoman/Death Moans, Iowa
Posts: 18,295
Received 372 Likes on 266 Posts
Re: The First Annual DVDTalk Eisner Comic Book Challenge - February 2015

My thinking is the Eisner more or less counts for the run. So if Mark Waid won for Daredevil, his run counts. But a new writer wouldn't count unless they also won. Since indie books usually have the same creative team, it covers the run.
Old 02-25-15, 11:17 PM
  #64  
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
 
Join Date: Dec 2007
Location: Houston, TX
Posts: 4,053
Received 213 Likes on 140 Posts
Re: The First Annual DVDTalk Eisner Comic Book Challenge - February 2015

Originally Posted by majorjoe23
My thinking is the Eisner more or less counts for the run. So if Mark Waid won for Daredevil, his run counts. But a new writer wouldn't count unless they also won. Since indie books usually have the same creative team, it covers the run.
I agree. Unless there are significant changes to the title or creative team the run should be included for it's duration.

For example, winning a "best new series" Eisner should only happen once but not winning "best continuing series" in my opinion doesn't necessarily mean the creative team and title elements are less "award winning." Love and Rockets: New Stories #6 winning "best single issue" to me suggests the entire run be challenge eligible since they are so similar in design qualities but that issue was a pinnacle of the series' typical high quality. It would seem difficult or even arbitrary to place rigid cut-off for only specific issues or timeframes and often the award itself is vague olabout cut-off.
Old 02-26-15, 07:13 AM
  #65  
Challenge Guru & Comic Nerd
Thread Starter
 
Trevor's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr 1999
Location: spiritually, Minnesota
Posts: 36,891
Received 678 Likes on 454 Posts
Re: The First Annual DVDTalk Eisner Comic Book Challenge - February 2015

Wow, and I thought I was the super liberal one with Challenges!

I sort of see your points, but think the cut off isn't that arbitrary in most cases.

Some of these creator runs are years long, and they only won the award once. And single issue seems obviously just that, a single issue.

Not used to being on this end of the debate. But the 'rules' are overruled by each individual's interpretation, so go for it!
Old 02-26-15, 09:52 AM
  #66  
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
 
Join Date: Dec 2007
Location: Houston, TX
Posts: 4,053
Received 213 Likes on 140 Posts
Re: The First Annual DVDTalk Eisner Comic Book Challenge - February 2015

February 25
Powers (2000) #2-6 - Nice assembly of mystery, pop culture, and social commentary told in a unique style (sort of news docudrama with muted colors and spaghetti western faces) - after a slow start I'm hooked.

Spoiler:
February 1
Started All Star Superman (issues 1-6 so far) - weighty spin on the Superman mythos with a good balance of eccentric science fiction and drama.

February 2
All Star Superman 7-12: Satisfying read but doesn't end as strong as it starts.

February 3
Astonishing X-men 1-4: Tense effort that redefines the X-men with a novel adversary but seeing some elements in early stages that get over-exaggerated later (like Wolverine / Cyclops schism) it feels "over done" in retrospect.

February 5
Astonishing X-men 5-10: Wendon does good with dialogue and characters with Cassaday's artwork has a solemn feel that lends a good gravity to events.

February 6
Astonishing X-men 11-14: Gets almost psychedelic with surreal twists and a lot crisscrossing threads, fun stuff.

February 7
Astonishing X-men 11-25
Giant Sized Astonishing X-men 1.1-1.2 - satisfying end with a nice gut punch. Tried to read issue 26 but it seems too different than what proceeded I decided on a break.

February 8
Sex Criminal 1-5 - just the right combination of surreal, playful, "too much information," and action but risks pushing the scale too far in any one direction depending on how things proceed from here. Semi-explicit and frank but at times too hooked on that alone.

February 9
Saga 1 - nicely surreal.

February 11
Saga 2-6 - some of the set-up feels thin but characterization and atmosphere/visuals are strong.

February 12
Saga 7-12 - compelling with subtle social commentary and wild imagery.

February 13
Saga 13-22 - really compelling but stalls some towards the end of these issues with a change in direction.

February 14
Saga 23-24 - Nicely paced with a lot of cliffhangers; I think Saga might read better back-to-back rather than delays between issues... so at issue 24 will probably wait a bit to read further.

February 15
Chew 1-6 - Novel premise, I wasn't sure if they'd go for "gross out" effects but it's nicely done with a good aura of mystery and humor.

February 16
Chew 7-13 - does a good job of building on itself using established characters in new ways to advance a large scale story with a surprisingly small cast.

February 17
Chew 14-21 - builds a satisfying sense that there is an arch-nemesis but starting to feel a little worn despite the focus on character development by stalling/rehashing earlier plot points.
February 18

Chew 22-27 - stalls some to refocus more on auxiliary characters and while the change is nice it feels inconsequential to the development so far but might pay off in long run.
Batman: The Killing Joke - weighty themes with engrossing art but the immediate plot felt lacking. Great ending, boo to origin stories.

February 19
Chew: Secret Agent Poyo [one shot] – a “cute” joke that feels overdone, amusing but disposable and un-necessary expansion on a thin joke… fun but fluff.
Chew 28-40 – starts to pick back up with more mystery, nice foreshadowing, and further plot incubation getting more direction by again focusing on the main character.

February 20
Chew / Revival [one shot] – unexpected crossover that doesn't quite mesh but it's ambitious, I enjoyed the first Chew style story more.
Chew: Warrior Chicken Poyo [one shot] – getting thin, one shots are interesting but the focus on Poyo is odd.
Chew 41-45 – The last two issues are some of the best stuff I've read, really a great payoff with nice action and drama.
Batman: The Long Halloween 1 – interesting art design, weighty story so far although some of it feels cliche after movies/rehashes.

February 21
Batman: The Long Halloween 2-4 – fun to see a diverse cast of characters but some of the dramatic irony feels too obvious.

February 22
Batman: The Long Halloween 5-7 - meh, I'm committed but not grabbing me as much as I expected from it's epic reputation.

February 23
Batman: The Long Halloween 8-13 - picks up nicely in the last chapter playing with reader assumptions and redeeming some of the slower parts.

February 24
Powers (2000) #1 - I've since read more of the series and it picked up but this was a disappointing introduction; mis-directed focus on a random kid with little to establish characters. Bendis' dialogue seems hit or miss at times feeling overly crass and other times too "hip."


Total issues: 135

Last edited by Undeadcow; 02-28-15 at 11:26 AM.
Old 02-26-15, 09:57 AM
  #67  
Challenge Guru & Comic Nerd
Thread Starter
 
Trevor's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr 1999
Location: spiritually, Minnesota
Posts: 36,891
Received 678 Likes on 454 Posts
Re: The First Annual DVDTalk Eisner Comic Book Challenge - February 2015

Eh, the more I think about it the more I agree with you guys.

I've been reading Bone and Nexus and while both have received a bunch of awards, it'd be a pain to have to search the award databases and make sure that every issue qualifies.

I still think that some discretion is appropriate though. For example, I guess it'd be 'safe' to count the entire original run of Bone, but I'd take a look at the actual awards before counting one of the follow up minis.

And if something won best individual issue or best storyline, I personally wouldn't count any other issues unless the series itself (or creator that year for that series) had awards.
Old 02-26-15, 02:09 PM
  #68  
DVD Talk Godfather
 
davidh777's Avatar
 
Join Date: Oct 2003
Location: Home of 2013 NFL champion Seahawks
Posts: 52,636
Received 1,016 Likes on 840 Posts
Re: The First Annual DVDTalk Eisner Comic Book Challenge - February 2015

I was also thinking it was the whole run, but (1) I haven't really dug into eligible titles and (2) I don't know a whole lot about the Eisner awards.

E.g., I know some people have been reading Saga, and I have the new TPB I want to read, but I hadn't really thought about whether these specific issues counted (or what issues they were reading). I just figured what was good enough for them was good enough for me.
Old 02-27-15, 11:09 AM
  #69  
DVD Talk Legend
 
Join Date: Apr 2002
Location: Formerly known as Groucho AND Bandoman/Death Moans, Iowa
Posts: 18,295
Received 372 Likes on 266 Posts
Re: The First Annual DVDTalk Eisner Comic Book Challenge - February 2015

Day 26
The Goon 40-44. With that, I've finished off my Goon backlog, other than The Goon Noir, which I'll read some other time. I think I should still be able to get to 120 by the end of the day tomorrow.

Total books read: 111

Previous reading
Spoiler:

Day 1

Usagi Yojimbo Mirage Series 7-12, 14

Goon 1-4, the ongoing series.

Day 2

The Goon 1-4, Dark Horse mini

Day 3

The Goon 5-6

Day 4

Usagi Yojimbo Mirage issues 13, 15–16, Dark Horse, 1–6. I actually read this over the course of a couple days while also reading The Goon, but it was tough to differentiate which stories were which issues, so I held off listing any until I was done reading.

Day 5

Usagi Yojimbo 7
The Goon 7-8

Day 6

Usagi Yojimbo 8-9

Day 7
The Goon 9-10. I like that this series is picking up some depth and character moments as it progresses. I was worried it was going to be all gags - which are very funny - it would just be hard to sustain for 40 some issues.

Day 8
The Goon 11-12
Usagi Yojimbo 10-12, Green Persimmon and Snakes & Blossoms specials

Day 9
The Goon 13
Usagi Yojimbo 13

Day 10
Usagi Yojimbo 14-15

Day 11
Usagi Yojimbo 16-17

Day 12
Usagi Yojimbo 18

Day 13
Walking Dead 137

day 13
Usagi Yojimbo 19-23

The Goon 14-18

Day 15
Usagi Yojimbo 24-30

Day 16
The Goon: Chinatown and the Mystery of Mr. Wicker. It's a 112 page graphic novel, I'm counting it as four issues.

Day 17
Usagi Yojimbo 31

Day 21
Usagi Yojimbo 32-38
The Goon 19-31

Day 22
Usagi Yojimbo 39-45
The Goon 32-34

Day 23
The Goon 35-36

Day 24
The Goon 37-39
Old 02-27-15, 12:37 PM
  #70  
Challenge Guru & Comic Nerd
Thread Starter
 
Trevor's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr 1999
Location: spiritually, Minnesota
Posts: 36,891
Received 678 Likes on 454 Posts
Re: The First Annual DVDTalk Eisner Comic Book Challenge - February 2015

Really enjoyed Spider-Man: Blue, a first time read. Hate it when comics make me cry.
Old 02-28-15, 08:02 AM
  #71  
DVD Talk Legend
 
Join Date: Apr 2002
Location: Formerly known as Groucho AND Bandoman/Death Moans, Iowa
Posts: 18,295
Received 372 Likes on 266 Posts
Re: The First Annual DVDTalk Eisner Comic Book Challenge - February 2015

Day 27
Daredevil 13
47 Ronin 1-3. I'm changing things up a bit here with a different award, the Inkwell Award for excellence in comic tracing, er, inking.

Total books read: 115

Previous reading
Spoiler:

Day 1

Usagi Yojimbo Mirage Series 7-12, 14

Goon 1-4, the ongoing series.

Day 2

The Goon 1-4, Dark Horse mini

Day 3

The Goon 5-6

Day 4

Usagi Yojimbo Mirage issues 13, 15–16, Dark Horse, 1–6. I actually read this over the course of a couple days while also reading The Goon, but it was tough to differentiate which stories were which issues, so I held off listing any until I was done reading.

Day 5

Usagi Yojimbo 7
The Goon 7-8

Day 6

Usagi Yojimbo 8-9

Day 7
The Goon 9-10. I like that this series is picking up some depth and character moments as it progresses. I was worried it was going to be all gags - which are very funny - it would just be hard to sustain for 40 some issues.

Day 8
The Goon 11-12
Usagi Yojimbo 10-12, Green Persimmon and Snakes & Blossoms specials

Day 9
The Goon 13
Usagi Yojimbo 13

Day 10
Usagi Yojimbo 14-15

Day 11
Usagi Yojimbo 16-17

Day 12
Usagi Yojimbo 18

Day 13
Walking Dead 137

day 13
Usagi Yojimbo 19-23

The Goon 14-18

Day 15
Usagi Yojimbo 24-30

Day 16
The Goon: Chinatown and the Mystery of Mr. Wicker. It's a 112 page graphic novel, I'm counting it as four issues.

Day 17
Usagi Yojimbo 31

Day 21
Usagi Yojimbo 32-38
The Goon 19-31

Day 22
Usagi Yojimbo 39-45
The Goon 32-34

Day 23
The Goon 35-36

Day 24
The Goon 37-39

Day 26
The Goon 40-44
Old 02-28-15, 10:17 AM
  #72  
DVD Talk Godfather
 
davidh777's Avatar
 
Join Date: Oct 2003
Location: Home of 2013 NFL champion Seahawks
Posts: 52,636
Received 1,016 Likes on 840 Posts
Re: The First Annual DVDTalk Eisner Comic Book Challenge - February 2015

2/27
Saga 19-20
Old 02-28-15, 11:25 AM
  #73  
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
 
Join Date: Dec 2007
Location: Houston, TX
Posts: 4,053
Received 213 Likes on 140 Posts
Re: The First Annual DVDTalk Eisner Comic Book Challenge - February 2015

February 26
Powers (2000) #8-11 - Stylized series with good atmosphere but this story arc seems a bit anti-climatic, clever plot that develops some of the series mythos.

February 27
Powers (2000) #7, 12-14 - Issue 7 seemed strangely inconsistent seemingly an inside Warren Ellis joke, the Little Deaths story arc was good and surprisingly seedy with a unique approach but a bit of filler.

February 28
Powers (2000) Annual 1, 15-20 - The annual was slow with an experimental approach using court transcripts. Powers' docudrama approach with procedural and focus on the media is interesting but just when it seemed to wear thin the Supergroup arc redeemed the series. Issues 17-20 were highlights of the challenge.

Spoiler:
February 1
Started All Star Superman (issues 1-6 so far) - weighty spin on the Superman mythos with a good balance of eccentric science fiction and drama.

February 2
All Star Superman 7-12: Satisfying read but doesn't end as strong as it starts.

February 3
Astonishing X-men 1-4: Tense effort that redefines the X-men with a novel adversary but seeing some elements in early stages that get over-exaggerated later (like Wolverine / Cyclops schism) it feels "over done" in retrospect.

February 5
Astonishing X-men 5-10: Wendon does good with dialogue and characters with Cassaday's artwork has a solemn feel that lends a good gravity to events.

February 6
Astonishing X-men 11-14: Gets almost psychedelic with surreal twists and a lot crisscrossing threads, fun stuff.

February 7
Astonishing X-men 11-25
Giant Sized Astonishing X-men 1.1-1.2 - satisfying end with a nice gut punch. Tried to read issue 26 but it seems too different than what proceeded I decided on a break.

February 8
Sex Criminal 1-5 - just the right combination of surreal, playful, "too much information," and action but risks pushing the scale too far in any one direction depending on how things proceed from here. Semi-explicit and frank but at times too hooked on that alone.

February 9
Saga 1 - nicely surreal.

February 11
Saga 2-6 - some of the set-up feels thin but characterization and atmosphere/visuals are strong.

February 12
Saga 7-12 - compelling with subtle social commentary and wild imagery.

February 13
Saga 13-22 - really compelling but stalls some towards the end of these issues with a change in direction.

February 14
Saga 23-24 - Nicely paced with a lot of cliffhangers; I think Saga might read better back-to-back rather than delays between issues... so at issue 24 will probably wait a bit to read further.

February 15
Chew 1-6 - Novel premise, I wasn't sure if they'd go for "gross out" effects but it's nicely done with a good aura of mystery and humor.

February 16
Chew 7-13 - does a good job of building on itself using established characters in new ways to advance a large scale story with a surprisingly small cast.

February 17
Chew 14-21 - builds a satisfying sense that there is an arch-nemesis but starting to feel a little worn despite the focus on character development by stalling/rehashing earlier plot points.
February 18

Chew 22-27 - stalls some to refocus more on auxiliary characters and while the change is nice it feels inconsequential to the development so far but might pay off in long run.
Batman: The Killing Joke - weighty themes with engrossing art but the immediate plot felt lacking. Great ending, boo to origin stories.

February 19
Chew: Secret Agent Poyo [one shot] – a “cute” joke that feels overdone, amusing but disposable and un-necessary expansion on a thin joke… fun but fluff.
Chew 28-40 – starts to pick back up with more mystery, nice foreshadowing, and further plot incubation getting more direction by again focusing on the main character.

February 20
Chew / Revival [one shot] – unexpected crossover that doesn't quite mesh but it's ambitious, I enjoyed the first Chew style story more.
Chew: Warrior Chicken Poyo [one shot] – getting thin, one shots are interesting but the focus on Poyo is odd.
Chew 41-45 – The last two issues are some of the best stuff I've read, really a great payoff with nice action and drama.
Batman: The Long Halloween 1 – interesting art design, weighty story so far although some of it feels cliche after movies/rehashes.

February 21
Batman: The Long Halloween 2-4 – fun to see a diverse cast of characters but some of the dramatic irony feels too obvious.

February 22
Batman: The Long Halloween 5-7 - meh, I'm committed but not grabbing me as much as I expected from it's epic reputation.

February 23
Batman: The Long Halloween 8-13 - picks up nicely in the last chapter playing with reader assumptions and redeeming some of the slower parts.

February 24
Powers (2000) #1 - I've since read more of the series and it picked up but this was a disappointing introduction; mis-directed focus on a random kid with little to establish characters. Bendis' dialogue seems hit or miss at times feeling overly crass and other times too "hip."

February 25
Powers (2000) #2-6 - Nice assembly of mystery, pop culture, and social commentary told in a unique style (sort of news docudrama with muted colors and spaghetti western faces) - after a slow start I'm hooked.


Total issues: 141

Last edited by Undeadcow; 02-28-15 at 08:31 PM.
Old 03-01-15, 06:47 AM
  #74  
Challenge Guru & Comic Nerd
Thread Starter
 
Trevor's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr 1999
Location: spiritually, Minnesota
Posts: 36,891
Received 678 Likes on 454 Posts
Re: The First Annual DVDTalk Eisner Comic Book Challenge - February 2015

Almost forgot about the cross-Challenge double counting possibilities! Sorry all, should mention that in the OPs from now on. I wake up hours before sunrise, and remembered, so read a few double qualifiers this morning.

Finally starting reading the digital Preacher series that I bought all of last year. I had read the first issue before, and loved it, but keep putting off the entire series for some reason. Maybe this month.

Then, since I began the Challenge with the great Will Eisner, I finished with him as well, reading a couple issues of The Spirit. Seems weird counting it as DC, but I guess they publish/distribute it now. Love each one I read, debating whether to finish my hardcover collection of just go digital on it.
Old 03-01-15, 07:46 AM
  #75  
DVD Talk Legend
 
Join Date: Apr 2002
Location: Formerly known as Groucho AND Bandoman/Death Moans, Iowa
Posts: 18,295
Received 372 Likes on 266 Posts
Re: The First Annual DVDTalk Eisner Comic Book Challenge - February 2015

Day 28
47 Ronin 4-5
Usagi Yijimbo 46-47

Total books read: 119

I didn't quite make it to 120.

Previous reading
Spoiler:

Day 1

Usagi Yojimbo Mirage Series 7-12, 14

Goon 1-4, the ongoing series.

Day 2

The Goon 1-4, Dark Horse mini

Day 3

The Goon 5-6

Day 4

Usagi Yojimbo Mirage issues 13, 15–16, Dark Horse, 1–6. I actually read this over the course of a couple days while also reading The Goon, but it was tough to differentiate which stories were which issues, so I held off listing any until I was done reading.

Day 5

Usagi Yojimbo 7
The Goon 7-8

Day 6

Usagi Yojimbo 8-9

Day 7
The Goon 9-10. I like that this series is picking up some depth and character moments as it progresses. I was worried it was going to be all gags - which are very funny - it would just be hard to sustain for 40 some issues.

Day 8
The Goon 11-12
Usagi Yojimbo 10-12, Green Persimmon and Snakes & Blossoms specials

Day 9
The Goon 13
Usagi Yojimbo 13

Day 10
Usagi Yojimbo 14-15

Day 11
Usagi Yojimbo 16-17

Day 12
Usagi Yojimbo 18

Day 13
Walking Dead 137

day 13
Usagi Yojimbo 19-23

The Goon 14-18

Day 15
Usagi Yojimbo 24-30

Day 16
The Goon: Chinatown and the Mystery of Mr. Wicker. It's a 112 page graphic novel, I'm counting it as four issues.

Day 17
Usagi Yojimbo 31

Day 21
Usagi Yojimbo 32-38
The Goon 19-31

Day 22
Usagi Yojimbo 39-45
The Goon 32-34

Day 23
The Goon 35-36

Day 24
The Goon 37-39

Day 26
The Goon 40-44

Day 27
Daredevil 13
47 Ronin 1-3.

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is On
Trackbacks are Off
Pingbacks are Off
Refbacks are Off



Archive - Advertising - Cookie Policy - Privacy Statement - Terms of Service -

Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.