modern day X-Men recommendations
#1
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Thread Starter
modern day X-Men recommendations
So as I mentioned in the graphic novel thread, I basically gave up comics about 8 years ago (it was around the time of Civil War), but inspired by the new movie I started going back and re-reading Claremont's run on X-Men. X-Men was always my favorite as a kid and what I realized in re-reading is that in the early days before New Mutants and especially X-Factor, it was almost completely self contained. Even in the latter days of his run at least there were only two other series (with very distinct premises and mandates to keep them separate) to keep track of. Once the 90's hit, everything changed.
In the years since, the most enjoyment I've gotten from X-Men was the Morrison run and the Whedon run. My favorite thing about them is that they were mostly self-contained. Is there anything like that today? I don't even know what the so-called flagship title is these days. Is there one? Everything seems so splintered to me now. This book follows Cyclops and the characters that follow him, this one follows Wolverine, this one only features women who take their orders from a time displaced 1987 Magneto. Oh, and six months from now we're going to restart all the series and shuffle all of the characters/creative teams around again. Ugh.
Is there a current (since 2006) that I can pick up that is basically a continuation of the X-Men I know and love that doesn't depend on a half-dozen other books in order to get the story (and doesn't change creative teams and directions every 6 issues)? I've heard that Remender's Uncanny X-Force is great and I may give that a try. I know it doesn't follow the main team, but at least it seems self contained. Anything else?
In the years since, the most enjoyment I've gotten from X-Men was the Morrison run and the Whedon run. My favorite thing about them is that they were mostly self-contained. Is there anything like that today? I don't even know what the so-called flagship title is these days. Is there one? Everything seems so splintered to me now. This book follows Cyclops and the characters that follow him, this one follows Wolverine, this one only features women who take their orders from a time displaced 1987 Magneto. Oh, and six months from now we're going to restart all the series and shuffle all of the characters/creative teams around again. Ugh.
Is there a current (since 2006) that I can pick up that is basically a continuation of the X-Men I know and love that doesn't depend on a half-dozen other books in order to get the story (and doesn't change creative teams and directions every 6 issues)? I've heard that Remender's Uncanny X-Force is great and I may give that a try. I know it doesn't follow the main team, but at least it seems self contained. Anything else?
#2
DVD Talk Godfather
I was in the same boat as you a couple years ago trying to go back and catch up on X-Men. I highly recommend the Messiah Complex, Messiah War, and Second Coming books. The three trades are pretty well contained albeit with some mutants I didn't know or recognize, but I loved the story and i liked it as much as the older stuff.
I think that big overall arc explains Hope Summers and leads up to the current stuff following the events of House of M if you are familiar with that. After that would be Schism that deals with the Cyclops/Wolverine split and AvX. Those I found a little less interesting.
I think that big overall arc explains Hope Summers and leads up to the current stuff following the events of House of M if you are familiar with that. After that would be Schism that deals with the Cyclops/Wolverine split and AvX. Those I found a little less interesting.
Last edited by fumanstan; 06-12-14 at 01:09 PM.
#3
DVD Talk Hero
Re: modern day X-Men recommendations
I'll second the Messiah Complex/War/Second Coming recommendation... those felt a lot like really old school X-men crossovers.
Also, X-Force (Kyle/Yost) and Uncanny X-Force (Remender) is surprisingly self-contained, though really really violent. Highly recommended, though, and the first one flows pretty well into the second one (though the first one also includes the mediocre-at-best X-Necrotia)
I haven't really read much of the more recent stuff, but you'll probably have to at least read AvX to make sense of some of it.
Also, X-Force (Kyle/Yost) and Uncanny X-Force (Remender) is surprisingly self-contained, though really really violent. Highly recommended, though, and the first one flows pretty well into the second one (though the first one also includes the mediocre-at-best X-Necrotia)
I haven't really read much of the more recent stuff, but you'll probably have to at least read AvX to make sense of some of it.
#4
DVD Talk Legend
Join Date: Apr 2002
Location: Formerly known as Groucho AND Bandoman/Death Moans, Iowa
Posts: 18,295
Received 372 Likes
on
266 Posts
Re: modern day X-Men recommendations
I really like Jason Aaron's Wolverine & The X-Men series, though it started to get bogged down in crossovers in the 20ths.
#5
DVD Talk Hero
Re: modern day X-Men recommendations
Also Peter David's long run on X-Factor stands out. It does get bogged down with crossovers but David handles it pretty well.
I like Jason Aaron's Wolvie and the X-Men, but I can't make heads or tails of Bachalo's art most times.
I like Jason Aaron's Wolvie and the X-Men, but I can't make heads or tails of Bachalo's art most times.
#6
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Re: modern day X-Men recommendations
Whatever you do, I recommend Comic Vine to fill in the gaps between major arcs. Sometimes I have no idea what the hell is going on between books.
#8
DVD Talk Godfather
Join Date: Oct 2003
Location: Home of 2013 NFL champion Seahawks
Posts: 52,611
Received 1,015 Likes
on
839 Posts
Re: modern day X-Men recommendations
My last serious run on X-Men was around Days of Future Past so I was going to mention Astonishing X-Men as a "new" series but then I saw you'd already read that.
#10
DVD Talk Hero
Re: modern day X-Men recommendations
All New X-Men (that's the ones with the original X-men from the past, right?) is probably pretty good for someone who missed a lot because some of it is them reacting to all the changes.
I didn't really see the point of Schism. It was like a shortened mutant Civil War, but kinda pointless, especially with AvX following.
I didn't really see the point of Schism. It was like a shortened mutant Civil War, but kinda pointless, especially with AvX following.
#11
DVD Talk Legend & 2021 TOTY Winner
#12
Challenge Guru & Comic Nerd
Re: modern day X-Men recommendations
I must confess that I've tried to hate the X-men comics all of my life. I briefly bought it at various times since the 70s, most notably around the time of New Mutants; but I always try to wash my hands of it, even selling all my Dark Phoenix era issues once (doh!). But now that I'm back into comics and have sampled various story arcs thanks to Comixology freebies and sales (including some big collection sales right now btw), I'm liking almost every run I've read.
#13
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Thread Starter
Re: modern day X-Men recommendations
Thanks for all of the recs guys. I'm probably going to do a month or two of Marvel Unlimited and try to plow through some of this. I'll probably start with Messiah Complex and see how that goes.
I do own and remember enjoying the first year or so of the X-Factor reboot. I also remember being annoyed when it got caught up in all of the House of M/M-Day stuff.
But that's exactly the kind of thing I'm trying to avoid!
I'm currently trying to work my way through Claremont's entire run right now. I've read most of it over the years, but never chronologically. Because these were the first comics that I really read and loved, to me this is what comics "should" be like. Claremont certainly has his tics (too much exposition, dozens of open plot threads which may or may not be resolved down the line), but that's part of what I love about him. I remember after drifting away from the hobby in the late 90's, I came back when he started X-Treme X-Men and despite the series being only ok, I got really excited because they felt so much like the classics that I loved. I will say this though, the first year or so of the Kitty Pryde era (DoFP excluded) really got on my nerves as I was re-reading. I know the character is pretty beloved now, but boy do I find her early appearances grating.
I must confess that I've tried to hate the X-men comics all of my life. I briefly bought it at various times since the 70s, most notably around the time of New Mutants; but I always try to wash my hands of it, even selling all my Dark Phoenix era issues once (doh!). But now that I'm back into comics and have sampled various story arcs thanks to Comixology freebies and sales (including some big collection sales right now btw), I'm liking almost every run I've read.
#14
DVD Talk Hero
Re: modern day X-Men recommendations
I thought David's (most recent) run of X-Factor started with House of M. Well, it really started with the Madrox mini and him forming the detective agency, but I could've sworn Layla Miller was a part of the team from the start, and she came from House of M. That's one of the things I liked about David's run, besides the humor; he really integrated the crossovers with the storyline. For instance, Messiah Complex changes some key things about the team. I have no idea if it was an editorial mandate or his decision, but he did a great job.
I still enjoy Claremont's run (and the art), but it has aged. The wall of exposition does get annoying. As for Kitty, I think she was supposed to be the kid character you could relate to... someone new to the mutant world, with a fresh perspective, a rebellious and prideful attitude and a teenaged crush. I remember thinking how spoiled she was when she insisted on not going to the New Mutants. But then as you grow older those traits becomes less endearing and less relatable; or we become old fogeys. All I know is that the kid characters in most cartoons and movies are usually the most annoying ones.
I still enjoy Claremont's run (and the art), but it has aged. The wall of exposition does get annoying. As for Kitty, I think she was supposed to be the kid character you could relate to... someone new to the mutant world, with a fresh perspective, a rebellious and prideful attitude and a teenaged crush. I remember thinking how spoiled she was when she insisted on not going to the New Mutants. But then as you grow older those traits becomes less endearing and less relatable; or we become old fogeys. All I know is that the kid characters in most cartoons and movies are usually the most annoying ones.
#15
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Thread Starter
Re: modern day X-Men recommendations
I thought David's (most recent) run of X-Factor started with House of M. Well, it really started with the Madrox mini and him forming the detective agency, but I could've sworn Layla Miller was a part of the team from the start, and she came from House of M. That's one of the things I liked about David's run, besides the humor; he really integrated the crossovers with the storyline. For instance, Messiah Complex changes some key things about the team. I have no idea if it was an editorial mandate or his decision, but he did a great job.
As for Kitty, I think she was supposed to be the kid character you could relate to... someone new to the mutant world, with a fresh perspective, a rebellious and prideful attitude and a teenaged crush. I remember thinking how spoiled she was when she insisted on not going to the New Mutants. But then as you grow older those traits becomes less endearing and less relatable; or we become old fogeys. All I know is that the kid characters in most cartoons and movies are usually the most annoying ones.
#16
DVD Talk Hero
Re: modern day X-Men recommendations
Is there a current (since 2006) that I can pick up that is basically a continuation of the X-Men I know and love that doesn't depend on a half-dozen other books in order to get the story (and doesn't change creative teams and directions every 6 issues)? I've heard that Remender's Uncanny X-Force is great and I may give that a try. I know it doesn't follow the main team, but at least it seems self contained. Anything else?
It's self-contained, mostly the same creative team, the only back-story you really need is stuff from the '80s, and all 35+ issues are conveniently collected in one handy Omnibus book:
Wolverine and the X-men by Jason Aaron is more lighthearted and deals with the X-school, and while it fizzles out towards the end, it's pretty good overall.