Release List Reviews Shop Join News DVD Giveaways Video Games Advertise
DVD Reviews | Theatrical Reviews | Adult DVD Reviews | Video Game Reviews | Price Search Buy Stuff Here
DVD Talk
DVD Reviews DVD Talk Headlines HD Reviews


Add to My Yahoo! - RSS 2.0 - RSS 2.0 - DVD Talk Podcast RSS -


Go Back   DVD Talk Forum > Archives > Archives

Archives Old posts on the forum. They go here to rest in peace.

View Poll Results: Whose work do you prefer?
Steven Spielberg 30 37.97%
Martin Scorsese 49 62.03%
Voters: 79. You may not vote on this poll

 
 
Thread Tools
Old 08-02-10, 01:00 AM   #1
JumpCutz
DVD Talk Legend
 
JumpCutz's Avatar
 
Join Date: Aug 2004
Location: south of heaven
Posts: 13,100
Spielberg or Scorsese?

Two of the giants in the industry...

Well?
 
Old 08-02-10, 01:01 AM   #2
RocShemp
DVD Talk Hero
 
Join Date: May 2001
Posts: 30,232
Re: Spielberg or Scorsese?

What? No poll?
__________________
So there's simultaneously a super secret team of giant robots and a super secret team of technologically enhanced super soldiers, and neither team knows about the other? The governments in these movies must be far more effective than our actual government. Well, damn it, I want some realism and mature adult themes in my giant robot and super soldier movies! - Suprmallet
 
Old 08-02-10, 01:07 AM   #3
Boba Fett
DVD Talk Reviewer
 
Boba Fett's Avatar
 
Join Date: Feb 2007
Posts: 5,758
Re: Spielberg or Scorsese?

Scorsese is the better filmmaker, Spielberg's movies are much more fun.
 
Old 08-02-10, 01:07 AM   #4
Cardsfan111
DVD Talk Legend
 
Cardsfan111's Avatar
 
Join Date: Feb 2007
Location: Indiana
Posts: 13,005
Re: Spielberg or Scorsese?

I'll go Spielberg since he's been involved with so many personal favorites...Jaws, the Indiana Jones films, Back to the Future.
__________________
DVD/BD Spending Tab: 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014
Rank 'Em As You See 'Em: 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014

"i 'm new here. most of people in here are good. but there is a miserable person. Look into your mirror. Superboy!" --New Member, robert11
 
Old 08-02-10, 01:08 AM   #5
Eva Kaine
Suspended
 
Join Date: Jul 2010
Posts: 123
Re: Spielberg or Scorsese?

Quote:
Originally Posted by Boba Fett View Post
Scorsese is the better filmmaker, Spielberg's movies are much more fun.

What a colossal, stupid statement.
 
Old 08-02-10, 01:10 AM   #6
Fist of Doom
DVD Talk Limited Edition
 
Join Date: Nov 2007
Location: Raleighwood
Posts: 6,214
Re: Spielberg or Scorsese?

Quote:
Originally Posted by Eva Kaine View Post
What a colossal, stupid statement.
 
Old 08-02-10, 01:11 AM   #7
RocShemp
DVD Talk Hero
 
Join Date: May 2001
Posts: 30,232
Re: Spielberg or Scorsese?

Quote:
Originally Posted by Eva Kaine View Post
What a colossal, stupid statement.
Why? You didn't enjoy the fun-loving family adventure that was Munich?
__________________
So there's simultaneously a super secret team of giant robots and a super secret team of technologically enhanced super soldiers, and neither team knows about the other? The governments in these movies must be far more effective than our actual government. Well, damn it, I want some realism and mature adult themes in my giant robot and super soldier movies! - Suprmallet
 
Old 08-02-10, 01:18 AM   #8
fumanstan
DVD Talk Hero
 
Join Date: Oct 2002
Location: Rancho Santa Margarita, CA
Posts: 38,460
Re: Spielberg or Scorsese?

Quote:
Originally Posted by Eva Kaine View Post
What a colossal, stupid statement.
Aren't you a ray of sunshine?
__________________
3x Sheep Champion

VG Round 1b | VG Round 7 | NFL
 
Old 08-02-10, 01:19 AM   #9
Eva Kaine
Suspended
 
Join Date: Jul 2010
Posts: 123
Re: Spielberg or Scorsese?

Quote:
Originally Posted by Fist of Doom View Post

What the fuck are you rolling your eyes for?
 
Old 08-02-10, 01:21 AM   #10
Eva Kaine
Suspended
 
Join Date: Jul 2010
Posts: 123
Re: Spielberg or Scorsese?

Quote:
Originally Posted by RocShemp View Post
Why? You didn't enjoy the fun-loving family adventure that was Munich?

heh


I was simply reacting to the statement that Spielberg's movies "are much more fun". Therefore, apparently, they aren't as worthwhile.

Last edited by Eva Kaine; 08-02-10 at 01:39 AM.
 
Old 08-02-10, 01:51 AM   #11
Travis McClain
DVD Talk Limited Edition
 
Travis McClain's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr 2008
Location: Formerly known as "MinLShaw"/The Twitterverse @TravisSMcClain
Posts: 6,827
Re: Spielberg or Scorsese?

Not voting, but I'll tell you this: I appreciate that Scorsese is willing to do commentary tracks for his movies. It wouldn't bother me so much that Spielberg doesn't, except for all the boasting he did in his interview for Lawrence of Arabia talking about how exciting it was for him to sit next to Sir David Lean during a private screening of the movie and get a live, one-on-one commentary from Sir David throughout. Don't tell me you've gotten such a once-in-a-lifetime experience and loved it, and can't be bothered to record something for your fans!
__________________
"There's always one more way to do things and that's your way, and you have a right to try it at least once." -- Waylon Jennings
 
Old 08-02-10, 02:01 AM   #12
RocShemp
DVD Talk Hero
 
Join Date: May 2001
Posts: 30,232
Re: Spielberg or Scorsese?

Quote:
Originally Posted by Eva Kaine View Post
heh


I was simply reacting to the statement that Spielberg's movies "are much more fun". Therefore, apparently, they aren't as worthwhile.
S'okay. It's all in good fun.
__________________
So there's simultaneously a super secret team of giant robots and a super secret team of technologically enhanced super soldiers, and neither team knows about the other? The governments in these movies must be far more effective than our actual government. Well, damn it, I want some realism and mature adult themes in my giant robot and super soldier movies! - Suprmallet
 
Old 08-02-10, 02:07 AM   #13
RagingBull80
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
 
Join Date: Jul 2004
Location: OKC, OK
Posts: 4,233
Re: Spielberg or Scorsese?

Scorsese.

I love several of Spielberg's films but he did not direct Taxi Driver, Raging Bull or Goodfellas.
__________________
"Buying a fish sandwich from an Oklahoma gas station is a 'horrible decision.'" - Josh-da-man
"Everyday I discover a new reason to hate people." - whoopdido
"God, I hate people so much." - whoopdido
 
Old 08-02-10, 02:14 AM   #14
Supermallet
Time Lord
 
Supermallet's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2000
Location: Termite Terrace
Posts: 45,709
Re: Spielberg or Scorsese?

Both are iconic filmmakers, and both changed the film industry. Spielberg, along with Lucas, helped turn the tide against the personal and complex films being made by people like Scorsese. Scorsese, aside from being a great filmmaker, was instrumental in popularizing the idea of properly archiving and restoring films.

Spielberg, in my mind, is best when he's doing a thriller or an adventure. Jaws, Indiana Jones, Minority Report, Jurassic Park all play to his strengths at manipulating an audience. These techniques usually fall flat when applied to drama, and consequently, a lot of his movies are overrated. Furthermore, his continued use of the long in the tooth John Williams continues to be a weak spot. However, when he's on (such as in the aforementioned films), he's the best at what he does.

Scorsese is a living legend of film. Always busy, always creative, he's made some of the best films of the past 40 years. Even his failures are interesting. Scorsese all the way, without a doubt. Even Spielberg's best film couldn't touch Goodfellas.
__________________
"You already knew this, Mallet, but you're obviously a better man than I (expect this to be quoted in a sig). " -creekdipper
Watch me squawk on Twitter: @Supermallet
Check out my vinyl collection!
 
Old 08-02-10, 02:17 AM   #15
JumpCutz
DVD Talk Legend
 
JumpCutz's Avatar
 
Join Date: Aug 2004
Location: south of heaven
Posts: 13,100
Re: Spielberg or Scorsese?

Quote:
Originally Posted by RagingBull80 View Post
Scorsese.

I love several of Spielberg's films but he did not direct Taxi Driver, Raging Bull or Goodfellas.
OP here...yeah that about sums it up for me.

Though I would put

Jaws
Munich
CETK
Raiders of the Lost Ark
Schindler's List

on the next rung....followed by:

The King of Comedy
Casino
Duel
Saving Private Ryan
Minority Report


It's a very close match up...but Scorsese wins based on the big three.
__________________
Rock music is mostly about moving big black boxes from one side of town to the other in the back of your car.
 
Old 08-02-10, 02:24 AM   #16
Franchot
DVD Talk Gold Edition
 
Join Date: Jul 1999
Location: Signal Hill, CA
Posts: 2,726
Re: Spielberg or Scorsese?

Spielberg has directed many more "crap" films in my opinion. (Hook, Always, 1941, Crystal Skull.) Even his big hits such as Jurassic Park, E.T. Close Encounters suffer from being too "cute" for my tastes.)

I like Scorsese's more gritty style and even his lesser films have portions that I admire.
 
Old 08-02-10, 02:30 AM   #17
Supermallet
Time Lord
 
Supermallet's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2000
Location: Termite Terrace
Posts: 45,709
Re: Spielberg or Scorsese?

Spielberg's best films:
Jaws
Raiders of the Lost Ark
Jurassic Park
Minority Report

Second rung:
Temple of Doom
Last Crusade
Catch Me If You Can


Scorsese's best films:
Taxi Driver
Raging Bull
Goodfellas
The Departed

Second rung:
Mean Streets
After Hours
The Last Waltz
Casino
Shutter Island
The Age of Innocence
King of Comedy
__________________
"You already knew this, Mallet, but you're obviously a better man than I (expect this to be quoted in a sig). " -creekdipper
Watch me squawk on Twitter: @Supermallet
Check out my vinyl collection!
 
Old 08-02-10, 02:31 AM   #18
costanza
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
 
Join Date: Mar 2000
Location: somewhere in between
Posts: 4,395
Re: Spielberg or Scorsese?

Quote:
Originally Posted by Suprmallet View Post
Both are iconic filmmakers, and both changed the film industry. Spielberg, along with Lucas, helped turn the tide against the personal and complex films being made by people like Scorsese. Scorsese, aside from being a great filmmaker, was instrumental in popularizing the idea of properly archiving and restoring films.

Spielberg, in my mind, is best when he's doing a thriller or an adventure. Jaws, Indiana Jones, Minority Report, Jurassic Park all play to his strengths at manipulating an audience. These techniques usually fall flat when applied to drama, and consequently, a lot of his movies are overrated. Furthermore, his continued use of the long in the tooth John Williams continues to be a weak spot. However, when he's on (such as in the aforementioned films), he's the best at what he does.

Scorsese is a living legend of film. Always busy, always creative, he's made some of the best films of the past 40 years. Even his failures are interesting. Scorsese all the way, without a doubt. Even Spielberg's best film couldn't touch Goodfellas.
You talk good.
 
Old 08-02-10, 02:34 AM   #19
JumpCutz
DVD Talk Legend
 
JumpCutz's Avatar
 
Join Date: Aug 2004
Location: south of heaven
Posts: 13,100
Re: Spielberg or Scorsese?

Quote:
Originally Posted by costanza View Post
You talk good.
You should hear him write.
 
Old 08-02-10, 03:03 AM   #20
Eva Kaine
Suspended
 
Join Date: Jul 2010
Posts: 123
Re: Spielberg or Scorsese?

Quote:
Originally Posted by Suprmallet View Post
Spielberg's best films:
Jaws
Raiders of the Lost Ark
Jurassic Park
Minority Report


Obviously you aren't familiar with some of Spielberg's best films. I take it you haven't yet seen ET: the Extra Terresatrial, The Sugarland Express, Close Encountters of the Third Kind, Duel, Empire of the Sun, or AI: Artificial Intelligence.
 
Old 08-02-10, 03:15 AM   #21
Supermallet
Time Lord
 
Supermallet's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2000
Location: Termite Terrace
Posts: 45,709
Re: Spielberg or Scorsese?

I have unfortunately seen ET, Close Encounters, Empire of the Sun, and AI. I like Sugarland and Duel, but not enough to call them Spielberg's best. I would count ET and Close Encounters among his worst, though.
__________________
"You already knew this, Mallet, but you're obviously a better man than I (expect this to be quoted in a sig). " -creekdipper
Watch me squawk on Twitter: @Supermallet
Check out my vinyl collection!
 
Old 08-02-10, 03:21 AM   #22
Fist of Doom
DVD Talk Limited Edition
 
Join Date: Nov 2007
Location: Raleighwood
Posts: 6,214
Re: Spielberg or Scorsese?

Quote:
Originally Posted by Eva Kaine View Post
You are a fcking idiot.
Nice knowing ya!
 
Old 08-02-10, 03:25 AM   #23
JumpCutz
DVD Talk Legend
 
JumpCutz's Avatar
 
Join Date: Aug 2004
Location: south of heaven
Posts: 13,100
Re: Spielberg or Scorsese?

Quote:
Originally Posted by Eva Kaine View Post
You are a fcking idiot.

Whoa. Not cool. Personal attacks like that will get you banned.
 
Old 08-02-10, 03:27 AM   #24
Supermallet
Time Lord
 
Supermallet's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2000
Location: Termite Terrace
Posts: 45,709
Re: Spielberg or Scorsese?

Mod Note: Eva, I know you are new here, but before you signed up you had to agree to our terms and conditions, which includes no personal attacks. Further, you may want to learn the structure of the site, as while personal attacks are not allowed against anyone, it is especially poor form to level them against moderators.
__________________
"You already knew this, Mallet, but you're obviously a better man than I (expect this to be quoted in a sig). " -creekdipper
Watch me squawk on Twitter: @Supermallet
Check out my vinyl collection!
 
Old 08-02-10, 04:57 AM   #25
Yeti4623
Senior Member
 
Join Date: Dec 2004
Posts: 900
Re: Spielberg or Scorsese?

Scorsese a better director, but Spielberg makes better movies.
 
Sponsored Links
 

Thread Tools

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is On
Trackbacks are Off
Pingbacks are Off
Refbacks are Off


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 04:45 PM.

Rules - DVD Talk - Archive - Privacy Statement - Top

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.7.2
Copyright ©2000 - 2014, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Content Relevant URLs by vBSEO 3.2.0
Copyright 2011 DVDTalk.com All Rights Reserved. Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.