View Poll Results: Which is the better distributor?
Voters: 28. You may not vote on this poll
Arrow vs. Shout Factory: Which is the better distributor?
#1
DVD Talk Legend
Thread Starter
Arrow vs. Shout Factory: Which is the better distributor?
Based on title selection, features, artwork variety, audio and video transfers, which is a better distributor, Arrow or Shout Factory?
#3
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Arrow vs. Shout Factory: Which is the better distributor?
Arrow is probably better technically I agree but I think Shout/Scream gets films that are more fun. A lot of the Arrow stuff is a bit more obscure which can be hit or miss with me. I still like their releases though and think they do a top notch job.
#5
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Arrow vs. Shout Factory: Which is the better distributor?
Arrow has been releasing some very critical giallo movies that I don't think Scream would ever touch, like Your Vice Is a Locked Room and Only I Have the Key.
I do think Arrow's entry into the American market has forced Scream Factory to step up their game. Scream is now delivering better transfers than when they first got into Blu-ray.
#6
Inane Thread Master, 2018 TOTY
Join Date: Dec 2003
Location: Are any of us really anywhere?
Posts: 49,298
Received 889 Likes
on
752 Posts
Re: Arrow vs. Shout Factory: Which is the better distributor?
Both are excellent, but I have more Shout bc their collection is more my mainstream horror taste. I have a few Arrow but haven't watched any titles yet...
#7
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Arrow vs. Shout Factory: Which is the better distributor?
Agreed. It does seem like Scream has stepped up their game a bit more in term of presentation since Arrow entered the US market. Ultimately I like both companies and will support them both. I'm not really a fanboy for either.
#8
DVD Talk Legend
Thread Starter
Re: Arrow vs. Shout Factory: Which is the better distributor?
Since I posted this, I was still thinking it over as I get both Shout/Scream and Arrow titles but ultimately I leaning toward Arrow. The features alone have been incredible and you can tell there was lots of love put into them (not to downplay what Shout has done). For instance, on The Mutilator release, they got a good number of the original cast back to do new interviews which is above and beyond for a movie like that. Not to mention, going all out to release the fully uncut version.
Anyway, giving a slight edge to Arrow.
Anyway, giving a slight edge to Arrow.
#9
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Join Date: Jan 2008
Location: Farmington Hills, MI
Posts: 2,743
Likes: 0
Received 71 Likes
on
51 Posts
Re: Arrow vs. Shout Factory: Which is the better distributor?
I love both companies but I have to say that Arrow is better. However, I can fully accept that people might like Scream's titles much more than Arrow's. Both do a good job with the extras.
Just a few reasons why I like Arrow more:
Arrow is more consistent with Video/Audio.
Arrow beats them handily in packaging especially with the Steelbook releases and their limited editions.
I like their clear cases much more.
Arrow has booklets.
Just a few reasons why I like Arrow more:
Arrow is more consistent with Video/Audio.
Arrow beats them handily in packaging especially with the Steelbook releases and their limited editions.
I like their clear cases much more.
Arrow has booklets.
#10
DVD Talk Legend
Thread Starter
Re: Arrow vs. Shout Factory: Which is the better distributor?
Yeah, the booklets are nice.
#11
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Re: Arrow vs. Shout Factory: Which is the better distributor?
Arrow
I own more movies from Arrow.And I'm not even A big horror movie fan.
They also release many classic like Cinema Paradiso.
Packaging,extras and past great sales all great.
I do not care much about slip covers.But really like the slipbox covers Arrow used on first editions.Have not bought any Arrow US releases yet.
But plan to buy The Human Condition Trilogy(UK,May 2016) for sure.Already own the Criterion DVD set.Really one of my favorite sets from Criterion.
My first Arrow buys(2012)
DVD
Horror, Sex & Violence Collection (Arrow Videos 18 disc DVD Cult Series) - Amazon Exclusive £58.33
Most if not all Blu-ray
1 x FCD454 - Arrow Video: Inferno () £7.99
1 x FCD497 - Arrow Video: The Beyond () £7.99
1 x FCD440 - Arrow Video: The Cat O' Nine Tails () £7.99
1 x FCD503 - Arrow Video: Frankenhooker () £7.99
1 x FCD442 - Arrow Video: The Bird With the Crystal Plumage () £7.99
1 x FCD433 - Arrow Video: City of the Living Dead () £7.99
1 x FCD443 - Arrow Video: Deep Red () £7.99
1 x FCD477 - Arrow Video: The Funhouse () £7.99
1 x FCD467 - Arrow Video: A Bay of Blood () £7.99
1 x FCD554 - Arrow Video: The Exterminator () £7.99
1 x FCD437 - Arrow Video: Tenebrae () £7.99
1 x FCD441 - Arrow Video: Phenomena () £7.99
1 x FCD496 - Arrow Video: Vamp () £7.99
Total Order Cost: £103.87
I own more movies from Arrow.And I'm not even A big horror movie fan.
They also release many classic like Cinema Paradiso.
Packaging,extras and past great sales all great.
I do not care much about slip covers.But really like the slipbox covers Arrow used on first editions.Have not bought any Arrow US releases yet.
But plan to buy The Human Condition Trilogy(UK,May 2016) for sure.Already own the Criterion DVD set.Really one of my favorite sets from Criterion.
My first Arrow buys(2012)
DVD
Horror, Sex & Violence Collection (Arrow Videos 18 disc DVD Cult Series) - Amazon Exclusive £58.33
Most if not all Blu-ray
1 x FCD454 - Arrow Video: Inferno () £7.99
1 x FCD497 - Arrow Video: The Beyond () £7.99
1 x FCD440 - Arrow Video: The Cat O' Nine Tails () £7.99
1 x FCD503 - Arrow Video: Frankenhooker () £7.99
1 x FCD442 - Arrow Video: The Bird With the Crystal Plumage () £7.99
1 x FCD433 - Arrow Video: City of the Living Dead () £7.99
1 x FCD443 - Arrow Video: Deep Red () £7.99
1 x FCD477 - Arrow Video: The Funhouse () £7.99
1 x FCD467 - Arrow Video: A Bay of Blood () £7.99
1 x FCD554 - Arrow Video: The Exterminator () £7.99
1 x FCD437 - Arrow Video: Tenebrae () £7.99
1 x FCD441 - Arrow Video: Phenomena () £7.99
1 x FCD496 - Arrow Video: Vamp () £7.99
Total Order Cost: £103.87
Last edited by JoeySeven; 04-23-16 at 05:26 AM.
#12
DVD Talk Legend
#15
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Re: Arrow vs. Shout Factory: Which is the better distributor?
I'm not a horror fan, so I don't have many (any?) Shout Factory titles. Arrow is my new favorite. I would love to see the poll Arrow vs. Criterion.
BTW - what is the diff between Arrow and Arrow Academy?
Edit: I actually do have a few SF titles....8 Shout vs. 18 Arrow.
BTW - what is the diff between Arrow and Arrow Academy?
Edit: I actually do have a few SF titles....8 Shout vs. 18 Arrow.
#16
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Arrow vs. Shout Factory: Which is the better distributor?
If I was region free I'm sure I would be more familiar with Arrow. But without it, Shout/Scream all the way!
#17
Re: Arrow vs. Shout Factory: Which is the better distributor?
Arrow titles typically cost about $7-$10 more than Scream/Shout...so you are "paying" more for those extras, folks.
#18
Re: Arrow vs. Shout Factory: Which is the better distributor?
and I will give my vote to Shout just to level the playing field even though I like them both equally.
I'd argue Shout has more diverse titles.. Pee-Wee's Playhouse, Decline of Western Civilzation, that's some diverse stuff as well.
I'd argue Shout has more diverse titles.. Pee-Wee's Playhouse, Decline of Western Civilzation, that's some diverse stuff as well.
#19
DVD Talk Reviewer/ Admin
Join Date: Sep 1999
Location: Greenville, South Cackalack
Posts: 28,742
Received 1,856 Likes
on
1,227 Posts
Re: Arrow vs. Shout Factory: Which is the better distributor?
Arrow feels more...curated, in that Criterion sense, and their presentations are consistently phenomenal. Scream Factory is more scattershot since they cover everything from '80s slashers to bigger-budget studio releases to SyFy-original-style indies. The highs are phenomenal, but a typical release is less likely to catch my eye, and generally relying on licensor-supplied masters results in very uneven quality. I can't put into words how much I love their Army of Darkness set, their Return of the Living Dead release is one of my most anticipated titles of the year, and they're responsible for a bunch of BDs I love, love, love (The Babadook, Stung, New Year's Evil, and Final Exam are a few that spring to mind). It does seem like there aren't as many must-have Scream releases month after month the way there used to be, even though the best of what they're putting out now eclipses anything they've released in the past.
#20
DVD Talk God
Re: Arrow vs. Shout Factory: Which is the better distributor?
I'm not region free and I know Arrow is a UK company and produces mostly Region B Blu-Rays. So for the most part, their content isn't widely consumed.
I did purchase a few of their U.S. Blu-Rays recently: Pray for Death and Rage of Honor (the Sho Kosugi martial arts movies) and was really impressed with both of them. Some solid extras for really small independent movies. I really want their special edition of "The Delta Force" from Cannon Films. One of my favorite Chuck Norris action movies of all time. I saw it has a good amount of extras, but unfortunately it's part of their UK line and is region B.
I have to give the edge to Shout/Scream Factory though. Since they are a U.S. company and have more content available to U.S. consumers. Special edition BDs with lots of extras is becoming a very niche product now for BD owners, so I appreciate that they are one of the few companies who put the extra effort in them. Loved their recent Invasion USA BD.
I just don't really feel the need to go all regions. I see most region free BD players on Amazon are around $150 and I don't think I would purchase enough of to make it worth it. I use and watch mostly Region A BDs. It's too much of a niche product. The foreign BDs I do purchase are usually from HK and they're already Region A/All regions.
I did purchase a few of their U.S. Blu-Rays recently: Pray for Death and Rage of Honor (the Sho Kosugi martial arts movies) and was really impressed with both of them. Some solid extras for really small independent movies. I really want their special edition of "The Delta Force" from Cannon Films. One of my favorite Chuck Norris action movies of all time. I saw it has a good amount of extras, but unfortunately it's part of their UK line and is region B.
I have to give the edge to Shout/Scream Factory though. Since they are a U.S. company and have more content available to U.S. consumers. Special edition BDs with lots of extras is becoming a very niche product now for BD owners, so I appreciate that they are one of the few companies who put the extra effort in them. Loved their recent Invasion USA BD.
I just don't really feel the need to go all regions. I see most region free BD players on Amazon are around $150 and I don't think I would purchase enough of to make it worth it. I use and watch mostly Region A BDs. It's too much of a niche product. The foreign BDs I do purchase are usually from HK and they're already Region A/All regions.
Last edited by DJariya; 04-25-16 at 01:19 PM.
#21
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Re: Arrow vs. Shout Factory: Which is the better distributor?
I'm not region free and I know Arrow is a UK company and produces mostly Region B Blu-Rays. So for the most part, their content isn't widely consumed.
I did purchase a few of their U.S. Blu-Rays recently: Pray for Death and Rage of Honor (the Sho Kosugi martial arts movies) and was really impressed with both of them. Some solid extras for really small independent movies. I really want their special edition of "The Delta Force" from Cannon Films. One of my favorite Chuck Norris action movies of all time. I saw it has a good amount of extras, but unfortunately it's part of their UK line and is region B.
I have to give the edge to Shout/Scream Factory though. Since they are a U.S. company and have more content available to U.S. consumers. Special edition BDs with lots of extras is becoming a very niche product now for BD owners, so I appreciate that they are one of the few companies who put the extra effort in them. Loved their recent Invasion USA BD.
I just don't really feel the need to go all regions. I see most region free BD players on Amazon are around $150 and I don't think I would purchase enough of to make it worth it. I use and watch mostly Region A BDs. It's too much of a niche product. The foreign BDs I do purchase are usually from HK and they're already Region A/All regions.
I did purchase a few of their U.S. Blu-Rays recently: Pray for Death and Rage of Honor (the Sho Kosugi martial arts movies) and was really impressed with both of them. Some solid extras for really small independent movies. I really want their special edition of "The Delta Force" from Cannon Films. One of my favorite Chuck Norris action movies of all time. I saw it has a good amount of extras, but unfortunately it's part of their UK line and is region B.
I have to give the edge to Shout/Scream Factory though. Since they are a U.S. company and have more content available to U.S. consumers. Special edition BDs with lots of extras is becoming a very niche product now for BD owners, so I appreciate that they are one of the few companies who put the extra effort in them. Loved their recent Invasion USA BD.
I just don't really feel the need to go all regions. I see most region free BD players on Amazon are around $150 and I don't think I would purchase enough of to make it worth it. I use and watch mostly Region A BDs. It's too much of a niche product. The foreign BDs I do purchase are usually from HK and they're already Region A/All regions.
Add in that their titles are almost always part of some amazon.co.uk deals (2 for 10 or 3 for 20 etc) and this narrows the gap between Arrow and SF considerably. Oh and I think you can play all the extras as well with the Panasonic bluray player.
#22
Re: Arrow vs. Shout Factory: Which is the better distributor?
and that's the "Trick" with Arrow but they sure do a good job with it. "Contamination" may just be the worst title from both parties (at least to me) but Arrow sure sells it like it's some important milestone in Euro Horror history.
#23
DVD Talk Reviewer & TOAT Winner
Re: Arrow vs. Shout Factory: Which is the better distributor?
Arrow has messed up fewer titles than Shout has (going by both DVD and Blu-Ray), but they've released relatively fewer titles overall in comparison also.
#24
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Arrow vs. Shout Factory: Which is the better distributor?
Shout/Scream Factory to me is maybe a slight step below in terms of presentation. The key with them to me though like I said earlier is that the films they release are more to my liking or are films that I know of or have at least heard of. Not that because I don't know a lot of the Arrow releases makes them less but I tend to not be as interested unless I see or read great reviews. I tend to think that Shout/Scream does a good job as far as things like extras and artwork too.
#25
Re: Arrow vs. Shout Factory: Which is the better distributor?
Shout Factory has interesting covers for the cases...but that's kinda where they stop being cool.
SF does have some quality releases, but every time I buy something it's like it's missing something. With Arrow releases, I get a better sense of completion.
Arrow has been putting out some really fabulous releases, and I'm not just talking about their impressive image quality along with original mono tracks if available.
Arrow's booklets are really a true gem to just sit back with a favorite drink, and take about 20 minutes to read all the information in them.
Books that come along with editions like Hellraiser Scarlet Box is rather amazing. I actually ordered this edition mostly because of the book.
Maybe I just don't have as many SF releases. I think I have about 10. They are quality releases, but the prices are just outrageous, and would it be too much to ask to either get some unique Blu-ray cases and create some inserts to at least make me THINK I have something special. At least try.
Arrow tries...and they go beyond.
SF does have some quality releases, but every time I buy something it's like it's missing something. With Arrow releases, I get a better sense of completion.
Arrow has been putting out some really fabulous releases, and I'm not just talking about their impressive image quality along with original mono tracks if available.
Arrow's booklets are really a true gem to just sit back with a favorite drink, and take about 20 minutes to read all the information in them.
Books that come along with editions like Hellraiser Scarlet Box is rather amazing. I actually ordered this edition mostly because of the book.
Maybe I just don't have as many SF releases. I think I have about 10. They are quality releases, but the prices are just outrageous, and would it be too much to ask to either get some unique Blu-ray cases and create some inserts to at least make me THINK I have something special. At least try.
Arrow tries...and they go beyond.
Last edited by DVD Polizei; 04-25-16 at 09:03 PM.