mhg83

So Gamespot just announced there Game Of The Year

Shadow Of Mordor

I've been playing this since yesterday and the Nemesis system is something I've never seen implemented. Not sure yet if it's GOTY material though.

Michael Corvin

I've probably only played a few new games this year but Mordor wins, hands down.

Also, where's Mario Kart & Infamous? I had a blast with Infamous and while the series continues to regress, MK still has its fans.

The Questyen

Tales from the Borderlands and Game of Thrones only had 1 episode released how could those be game of the year?

fumanstan

Of the games on the list, i've only played Titanfall, Call of Duty, and Destiny. I don't feel strongly enough about any of them to make them my Game of the Year. I'm honestly not sure what I would put as my GOTY, there doesn't seem to be as many standouts as there were last year when there was GTA5, Last of Us, Tomb Raider, Bioshock Infinite, Link Between Worlds. I think I spent most of my gaming year playing Wolf Among Us, Walking Dead Season 2, and Diablo 3.

I really need/want to play Dragon Age and to a lesser extent, Mordor as those seem to be the leading candidates.

I was actually thinking about starting a GOTY thread the last few days, but wasn't sure what titles to put in the poll. I think i'd drop the episodic games and put in Mario Kart 8 or Bayonetta 2, or possibly Diablo 3 Reaper of Souls/Ultimate Evil Edition. Or maybe even South Park.

shizawn

I guess a toss up between Divinity: Original Sin and Wasteland 2. Both games are flawed, but they're probably the best I've played this year.

mhg83

That's why I put other in the poll. 25 is the limit.

Michael Corvin

I get that, I just think those two games stand out over more than a few in the poll.

Maxflier

For the second straight year, my game of the year is Grand Theft Auto 5.

Decker

Sunset Overdrive should have also been a finalist. That's a fun game.

My pick : DriveClub. j/k

I went with Far Cry 4 since it's probably the most fun I've had with a game this year, but it's a soft choice as GotY. It does nothing remarkable or that original and the story sucks. I was tempted to pick Forza Horizon 2 which I also really liked. Thought Shadow of Mordor was quite good but too repetitive in mission structure for GotY.

starseed1981

Personal top 10

1 The Simpsons: Tapped Out (iOS)
2 Clash Of Clans (iOS)
3 South Park: The Stick Of Truth (PS3)
4 The Walking Dead Season Two (PS3)
5 Shovel Knight (WiiU)
6 The Wolf Among Us Season One (PS3)
7 Destiny (PS4)
8 Call Of Duty: Advanced Warfare (PS4)
9 Guacamelee: Super Turbo Championship Edition (X-Box One)
10 Hotline Miami (PS4)

cleaver

I've played most of these and I'll go with Sunset Overdrive aka other.

maxfisher

Of the games that I’ve played, I’d go with Far Cry 4, but I still need to crack open Dragon Age, Super Smash Brothers, Call of Duty AW, The Evil Within, Alien Isolation and Captain Toad.

I’m surprised Sunset Overdrive and South Park: Stick of Truth aren’t options, as those would be my 2 & 3 behind Far Cry.

Of what’s on the list, Shadow of Mordor, Wolfenstein and Titanfall were all great. Watch Dogs was fun, but got old. Destiny & Assassins Creed Unity were huge disappointments.

K&AJones

I had a great time with Infamous Second Son...the lighting with the neon really showed what the PS4 could do. And I love Far Cry 4 but while it's a blast the thorn in the side with it is the co-op rewards or lack of. It should encourage players to play together and not do things twice. Heard good stuff from Dragon's Age but not played. If anything I'm glad Shadow of Mordor is getting the recognition and praise. it came as an underdog against a decent lineup and surprised a lot of people. Good to see something beside COD, BF and GTA....

On a side note I did enjoy Wolfenstein as I think it was better than critics gave it. And Diablo III Reaper of Souls for the PS4 was a leap above the 360 and Blizzard helped with players keeping all their work, time and effort in place which was worthy of notice.

chuckd21

Voted Other for South Park: The Stick of Truth.

fumanstan

I imagine some of those technically shouldn't count since they came out awhile ago and not this year, particularly those top two

starseed1981

I know. I know.

I'm just kind've dismayed by all the AAA strike outs this fall. It was a bloodbath out there.

Noonan

My favorite new game of the year was South Park (can't believe I'm saying that but the game deserves it). The best game release of this year is Suikoden II on PSN. Nothing else comes close.

Groucho

So far, I've gotten the most enjoyment out of Dragon Age: Inquisition in terms of games released this year.

cleaver

You have Destiny as your #7 game to what AAA strike outs are you referring (please don't say driveclub)?

Dan

Sounds like I really need to check out Shadow of Mordor and Far Cry 4. I never really had any interest in it.

For me, GOTY is probably Forza Horizon 2, although I really haven't played a ton of the titles on the list.

Music

My thoughts exactly.

This and South Park (among others).


I also enjoyed and completed AC: Unity, but the issues with the mobile app integration keeps it from GOTY for me.

chess

Weak year overall, and I haven't bought much. I've spent the most time with Warframe (technically out of beta this year) and Destiny (which I have a love-hate relationship with...but seriously, fuck that game).

I'd echo that Infamous deserves a mention, but it's not a traditional "GOTY" by any stretch. It remains the best looking game I've ever seen on any platform, and it's actually a lot of fun.

I think it's probably about time we started giving more games outside of the big AAA releases a fair look, because for my money, smaller games have been killing it. I look at something like Transistor, Shovel Knight, Hearthstone or Velocity and wonder why they can't get some consideration.

I think the best traditional AAA games released this year were re-releases from 2013 (Last of Us, GTA5, TR) and most everything else has been underwhelming.

Voted other.

Deftones

Hands down South Park. This was such an unmemorable year for games. Could've had Batman and a bunch of other titles that were delayed.

starseed1981

Just in general I thought the fall had al ot of good but not many great games. I had issues with the initial version of AC: Unity, AC: Rogue (which was basically a Black Flag clone), Master Chief Collection (which is still broken), The Crew (which still has network issues), Far Cry 4 (which initially had network issues), The Evil Within, Etc. I just personally feel like I've played alot of good games this fall but nothing that I'd come back to or feel the need to keep in my collection. Imho, it was a very weak year for gaming.

discostu1337

Really bad gaming year, nothing worthy of a GOTY tag really.

I guess South Park and Sunset Overdrive are the two best, most refreshing options. GTA V can't count again.