The Wire in HD
#1
DVD Talk Legend
Thread Starter
HBO is re-mastering 'The Wire'
http://insidetv.ew.com/2014/09/02/hb...bd2ed1b3e71908
I approve of this.
The Wire, David Simon’s critically acclaimed series, will be re-mastered in HD, HBO confirmed to EW. But as exciting as that news is, the network added that it does “not have further information regarding the timeline.” A promo claiming that a “replay marathon” of the series would start September 4 on HBO Signature ran prematurely, HBO said, and the series will not be airing this month.
That’s not to say that one couldn’t watch The Wire now: it is currently available on HBO Go, Amazon Prime, and iTunes. The show, which ran for five seasons starting in 2002 and chronicled life in Baltimore, was under-appreciated by viewers when it was on the air, but has now been deemed by many the best television show ever. Surely, someone has told you that you have to watch The Wire. EW has.
That’s not to say that one couldn’t watch The Wire now: it is currently available on HBO Go, Amazon Prime, and iTunes. The show, which ran for five seasons starting in 2002 and chronicled life in Baltimore, was under-appreciated by viewers when it was on the air, but has now been deemed by many the best television show ever. Surely, someone has told you that you have to watch The Wire. EW has.
#2
DVD Talk Hero
Re: HBO is re-mastering 'The Wire'
Yup
#3
Re: HBO is re-mastering 'The Wire'
The Wire is a show that they could just start up again if they wanted and would only take a couple episodes to establish what the last decade held for them. The Wire with truly modern surveillance could be really interesting. Wonder if it was filmed with proper framing for HD.
#5
DVD Talk Legend
Re: HBO is re-mastering 'The Wire'
There's been a thread running about this in HD Talk. Simon has been on record before saying 4:3 is the preferred ratio. I'm sure they protected for 16:9, but I am skeptical about how it will affect the feel of the show. I'll check them out before I buy anything.
#7
Re: The Wire in HD
Here's a link to David Simon's blog which answers just about any question someone might have about the conversion from 4x3 to 16x9.
http://davidsimon.com/the-wire-in-hd/
http://davidsimon.com/the-wire-in-hd/
#9
DVD Talk Hero
Join Date: Feb 2005
Location: In the straps of boots
Posts: 28,008
Received 1,186 Likes
on
837 Posts
Re: The Wire in HD
I guess I "get" why they'd want to move it into a 16:9 ratio for modern audiences... but why the hell wouldn't they keep an OAR version in HD available for the majority of fans who have been begging for it? This is just going to piss off a lot of people.
#11
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: The Wire in HD
I appreciate that David Simon was actively involved in this and isn't sugar-coating the results. It's nice to see some honesty that while the show benefits from the conversion in some instances it also suffers in others.
This. I'm not sure why they wouldn't at least make an HD version of the OAR available. What's the harm in doing that?
I think it's funny how we've sort of come full-circle in messing with aspect ratios. Years ago it was taking movies and modifying them to "full screen" which really takes away from scenes and gives you an incomplete version of the movie. I guess the reasoning was that "modern audiences" hated the bars and wanted their entire television screen to be filled with the image. And now we're moving in the opposite direction: taking things that were intended to be viewed in 4:3 and "stretching" them to fit the 16:9 aspect ratio.
I think it's funny how we've sort of come full-circle in messing with aspect ratios. Years ago it was taking movies and modifying them to "full screen" which really takes away from scenes and gives you an incomplete version of the movie. I guess the reasoning was that "modern audiences" hated the bars and wanted their entire television screen to be filled with the image. And now we're moving in the opposite direction: taking things that were intended to be viewed in 4:3 and "stretching" them to fit the 16:9 aspect ratio.
#12
Moderator
Re: The Wire in HD
Per the article, looks like it'll premiere on HBO Signature and HBO Go sometime this month. I perused the online guide through next week and didn't see anything, so presumably the latter half of the month.
#14
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Re: The Wire in HD
I just started re-watching The Wire and I'm happy with it in OAR. I have to re-buy the DVDs to hopefully the price will go down with the impending blu release.
#15
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Re: The Wire in HD
HBO Signature? So they remaster it in HD and play it on a channel Comcast customers don't get in HD? Well damn. Hopefully it goes OnDemand too, because as I just remembered, I don't get HBOGo on my Playstations (again, thanks Comcast)
#16
DVD Talk Legend
Re: The Wire in HD
I appreciate that David Simon was actively involved in this and isn't sugar-coating the results. It's nice to see some honesty that while the show benefits from the conversion in some instances it also suffers in others.
This. I'm not sure why they wouldn't at least make an HD version of the OAR available. What's the harm in doing that?
I think it's funny how we've sort of come full-circle in messing with aspect ratios. Years ago it was taking movies and modifying them to "full screen" which really takes away from scenes and gives you an incomplete version of the movie. I guess the reasoning was that "modern audiences" hated the bars and wanted their entire television screen to be filled with the image. And now we're moving in the opposite direction: taking things that were intended to be viewed in 4:3 and "stretching" them to fit the 16:9 aspect ratio.
This. I'm not sure why they wouldn't at least make an HD version of the OAR available. What's the harm in doing that?
I think it's funny how we've sort of come full-circle in messing with aspect ratios. Years ago it was taking movies and modifying them to "full screen" which really takes away from scenes and gives you an incomplete version of the movie. I guess the reasoning was that "modern audiences" hated the bars and wanted their entire television screen to be filled with the image. And now we're moving in the opposite direction: taking things that were intended to be viewed in 4:3 and "stretching" them to fit the 16:9 aspect ratio.
#17
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Join Date: Aug 2010
Posts: 2,080
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: The Wire in HD
I think we can all agree that the people 10 years ago who wanted to fill their 4x3 screens were idiots who had no right to compromise what they watched to fill their screens but all the people who are now demanding their 16x9 displays to be filled by modified content are perfectly rational and justified in wanting their screens to be filled.
In all seriousness, if you read through Simon's blog you'll pick up on three things:
1, he thinks the show was actually shot in standard definition and is magically being converted into high definition.
2: he doesn't seem to be aware that a high definition version could be created in the original aspect ratio
3: he openly admits that there are moments where the show suffers from the new framing.
If Universal can release Galactica 1980 on Blu in both its original aspect ratio and an HDTV-friendly ratio than HBO can do the same for The Wire.
In all seriousness, if you read through Simon's blog you'll pick up on three things:
1, he thinks the show was actually shot in standard definition and is magically being converted into high definition.
2: he doesn't seem to be aware that a high definition version could be created in the original aspect ratio
3: he openly admits that there are moments where the show suffers from the new framing.
If Universal can release Galactica 1980 on Blu in both its original aspect ratio and an HDTV-friendly ratio than HBO can do the same for The Wire.
#18
DVD Talk Hero
Join Date: Feb 2005
Location: In the straps of boots
Posts: 28,008
Received 1,186 Likes
on
837 Posts
Re: The Wire in HD
Yeah. It's "opposite" in that they're now asking for OLD content to fill their new 16x9 screens, whereas in the past, they were mostly asking for NEW content to fill their older 4x3 screens.
I know you're being sarcastic, but in case it's not clear... these are all the exact same people.
Yeah, that's the exact impression I got after reading through most of it. Sadly, David Simon is a little ignorant on the specs in particular.
EXACTLY. If HBO really wanted to release it in 16x9, that's fine. But FFS... keep an OAR version for the people who actually CARE about this show. Hell, if Twin Peaks can also be released in its OAR in HD, there's no reason HBO couldn't show the same respect to The Wire.
The fact is, they went forward with it without his input from the beginning, then when he finally saw it, they said, "Oh, but look at all the HARD WORK we did! You can't just ignore that!" So he compromised, and we now have the equivalent of a 16x9 Pan-and-Scan fuck-up.
I think we can all agree that the people 10 years ago who wanted to fill their 4x3 screens were idiots who had no right to compromise what they watched to fill their screens but all the people who are now demanding their 16x9 displays to be filled by modified content are perfectly rational and justified in wanting their screens to be filled.
In all seriousness, if you read through Simon's blog you'll pick up on three things:
1, he thinks the show was actually shot in standard definition and is magically being converted into high definition.
2: he doesn't seem to be aware that a high definition version could be created in the original aspect ratio
3: he openly admits that there are moments where the show suffers from the new framing.
1, he thinks the show was actually shot in standard definition and is magically being converted into high definition.
2: he doesn't seem to be aware that a high definition version could be created in the original aspect ratio
3: he openly admits that there are moments where the show suffers from the new framing.
If Universal can release Galactica 1980 on Blu in both its original aspect ratio and an HDTV-friendly ratio than HBO can do the same for The Wire.
The fact is, they went forward with it without his input from the beginning, then when he finally saw it, they said, "Oh, but look at all the HARD WORK we did! You can't just ignore that!" So he compromised, and we now have the equivalent of a 16x9 Pan-and-Scan fuck-up.
#19
Senior Member
Re: The Wire in HD
Just over a week til we get to check this out for real.
In case y'all hadn't seen this update by David Simon with comparisons and comments on the reframing.
http://blogs.indiewire.com/theplayli...sions-20141205
In case y'all hadn't seen this update by David Simon with comparisons and comments on the reframing.
http://blogs.indiewire.com/theplayli...sions-20141205
#20
DVD Talk Hero
Re: The Wire in HD
It looks like the 4:3 versions were cropped and the 1.78:1 versions remove the mattes from the sides. How exactly was this program shot? Did the DP compose his shots with protection for an eventual widescreen release?
#23
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Join Date: Dec 2008
Location: Bay Area, California
Posts: 8,939
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: The Wire in HD
For me, the increased clarity of picture and the wider sides, even with the loss of top and bottom of the shots, is a fair trade off. I'd rather they kept the OAR, but at least they appear to have taken some care and creative input to get the best compromise they could get.
Compare it to the HD mess that is Buffy & Angel and you'll see Wire fans are pretty darn lucky.
http://www.vox.com/2014/12/12/7385261/buffy-ruined
Compare it to the HD mess that is Buffy & Angel and you'll see Wire fans are pretty darn lucky.
http://www.vox.com/2014/12/12/7385261/buffy-ruined
#25
DVD Talk Legend
Re: The Wire in HD
I think the Audience network on Directv aired all the shows in HD a couple years ago.