Has Fables stayed good throughout it's entire run?
#1
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Thread Starter
Has Fables stayed good throughout it's entire run?
So I'm on a total comic high for the first time in years right now and just read that Fables is ending next year (I know it's old news). I think I've read through the first 50-60 issues and I always enjoyed it. In fact I bailed on the tv show Once Upon a Time after a season because I couldn't watch without constantly comparing it to (the far superior) Fables. My question for those who have stuck with it, has it stayed good? I know there have been a handful of spin-offs and mini-series. Are those essential to following the story? Knowing that it has a definitive endpoint makes me want to catch up in time for the ending.
#2
Re: Has Fables stayed good throughout it's entire run?
I read up until 100 or so, and bailed around then. But instead of different fun arcs, it was all "Prepare for WAR WAR WAR" so I got a little bored of that. I want to re-read and catch up, since I'm still interested in the characters and where they're headed.
Jack of Fables isn't essential to the story (except for during "The Great Fables Crossover" which crossed over three titles, and wasn't really that good), it was entertaining, but wasn't a favorite. More comedic, so it is a change of pace. I never got to read the Cinderella one. The book "Peter & Max" was really good though, I recommend that.
Jack of Fables isn't essential to the story (except for during "The Great Fables Crossover" which crossed over three titles, and wasn't really that good), it was entertaining, but wasn't a favorite. More comedic, so it is a change of pace. I never got to read the Cinderella one. The book "Peter & Max" was really good though, I recommend that.
#3
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Has Fables stayed good throughout it's entire run?
So I'm on a total comic high for the first time in years right now and just read that Fables is ending next year (I know it's old news). I think I've read through the first 50-60 issues and I always enjoyed it. In fact I bailed on the tv show Once Upon a Time after a season because I couldn't watch without constantly comparing it to (the far superior) Fables. My question for those who have stuck with it, has it stayed good? I know there have been a handful of spin-offs and mini-series. Are those essential to following the story? Knowing that it has a definitive endpoint makes me want to catch up in time for the ending.
#4
DVD Talk Godfather
Re: Has Fables stayed good throughout it's entire run?
As someone that's largely caught up with the main comic (haven't read any of the spinoffs), I think its still good. I would say enjoyed the main story arc of The Adversary and the homelands far more to primary story arc that followed it, mostly because I didn't care for the new villain. There are some interesting things that happen to a lot of the other characters though, particularly Boy Blue, Buffkin, and of course Bigby and Snow. All of those events were far more entertaining to me.
#6
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Re: Has Fables stayed good throughout it's entire run?
Even though the adversary storyline would have been a natural end-point, there have been some decent storylines since so I've kept reading the trades, and as it gets towards the end I've been reading them as they come out (it's up to 140 now so 10 to go). I think of the offshoots, I kind of like Fairest and Cinderella was ok. Since I disliked the Great Fables Crossover or really the character of Jack, I never bothered with Jack of Fables. I loved the Peter and Max book, I wish he'd write another one.
Last edited by Ginwen; 06-13-14 at 11:51 PM.
#7
DVD Talk Godfather
Re: Has Fables stayed good throughout it's entire run?
Wasn't really another Fables thread to bump and didn't feel like creating a new one, but anyone planning on picking up #150? I'm excited to finally read the conclusion.
#8
Challenge Guru & Comic Nerd
Re: Has Fables stayed good throughout it's entire run?
I loved Bill Willingham's work back in the 80s and 90s, mainly Elementals from Comico but there must have been other work too. I checked out Fables early in its run and knew that it was a title I'd love. I bought four random trades over the years, but I normally don't fully read anything until the run is done. I just five minutes ago bought the missing 16 collections digitally ($5 each) and plan to read the whole thing next month for the Fantasy Challenge.
#9
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Has Fables stayed good throughout it's entire run?
I have a close friend who is an inker. Back a dozen years or so ago He had a handful of comic people at his house for a group work session.
Bill Willingham was there and he was nice enough to sign a ton of books for me including Elementals and the adult book he did for a bit.
Was a nice guy, he didn't have to do it but it was his idea.
Bill Willingham was there and he was nice enough to sign a ton of books for me including Elementals and the adult book he did for a bit.
Was a nice guy, he didn't have to do it but it was his idea.
#10
DVD Talk Legend
Join Date: Apr 2002
Location: Formerly known as Groucho AND Bandoman/Death Moans, Iowa
Posts: 18,295
Received 372 Likes
on
266 Posts
Re: Has Fables stayed good throughout it's entire run?
I got to interview him (in person) a few years back and he was very nice. He also said he was going to steal my wife's name for a character. I haven't noticed it in any of his work yet, but I also don't read everything he writes.
#11
DVD Talk Godfather
Re: Has Fables stayed good throughout it's entire run?
I bought the issue today on Kindle. Looking forward to reading it tonight. Or maybe a bit on my lunch break
#13
DVD Talk Godfather
Re: Has Fables stayed good throughout it's entire run?
Looks like it. Didn't even know anything about loaning books, but i'd be happy to once i'm done reading it.
#14
DVD Talk Godfather
Re: Has Fables stayed good throughout it's entire run?
Finished reading it. It was... ok. Going along the lines of the original topic of this thread, this last arc was worse then the ones that came before it. Some light spoilers...
Still, I enjoy the series overall even if the story is a bit of a mess towards the end.
Spoiler:
Still, I enjoy the series overall even if the story is a bit of a mess towards the end.
#15
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Re: Has Fables stayed good throughout it's entire run?
Finished reading it. It was... ok. Going along the lines of the original topic of this thread, this last arc was worse then the ones that came before it. Some light spoilers...
Still, I enjoy the series overall even if the story is a bit of a mess towards the end.
Spoiler:
Still, I enjoy the series overall even if the story is a bit of a mess towards the end.
Spoiler: