Porcupine Tree question
#1
Moderator
Thread Starter
Porcupine Tree question
I've been playing to death their song: "Lazarus"
<iframe title="YouTube video player" width="480" height="390" src="http://www.youtube.com/embed/0MrJl7DQqAE" frameborder="0" allowfullscreen></iframe>
what other songs from them are similiar?
<iframe title="YouTube video player" width="480" height="390" src="http://www.youtube.com/embed/0MrJl7DQqAE" frameborder="0" allowfullscreen></iframe>
what other songs from them are similiar?
#2
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Porcupine Tree question
That song is part of a "loose" concept album.
Honestly, as a extremely huge PT fan, I feel their music is to be experienced as full albums - Steven Wilson is adamant about that. Do yourself a favor and take some time to digest Deadwing (from which "Lazarus" comes) and In Absentia. I think you'll find there's some astonishingly beautiful and dynamic music there.
Answering the question is tough without knowing how you define "similar"? Softer songs? Songs in a major key with predominant piano parts? Deadwing itself ends with a track called Glass Arm Shattering which is fairly "light" in sound. But again it's meant as the ending of a full record.
"Trains" off In Absentia is by far their most popular song live and it is one of their best IMO as well. The beauty of PT is they are truly progressive in the sense that they are not trying to have everything they do sound similar. Their last full-length contains a 50+ minute song. That sounds daunting but it makes sense when you hear it.
I'll get off my high horse now about PT.
You may want to also look into Steven Wilson's side project Blackfield. That's in a way become his "pop song" outlet so to speak. Lots of short concise songs with insanely catchy hooks and harmonies. They have two releases out with a third coming very shortly.
Honestly, as a extremely huge PT fan, I feel their music is to be experienced as full albums - Steven Wilson is adamant about that. Do yourself a favor and take some time to digest Deadwing (from which "Lazarus" comes) and In Absentia. I think you'll find there's some astonishingly beautiful and dynamic music there.
Answering the question is tough without knowing how you define "similar"? Softer songs? Songs in a major key with predominant piano parts? Deadwing itself ends with a track called Glass Arm Shattering which is fairly "light" in sound. But again it's meant as the ending of a full record.
"Trains" off In Absentia is by far their most popular song live and it is one of their best IMO as well. The beauty of PT is they are truly progressive in the sense that they are not trying to have everything they do sound similar. Their last full-length contains a 50+ minute song. That sounds daunting but it makes sense when you hear it.
I'll get off my high horse now about PT.
You may want to also look into Steven Wilson's side project Blackfield. That's in a way become his "pop song" outlet so to speak. Lots of short concise songs with insanely catchy hooks and harmonies. They have two releases out with a third coming very shortly.
#3
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Re: Porcupine Tree question
This is no other PT song like Lazarus which makes it such a cool song. Bunkaroo provided some good info above, particularly checking out Blackfield, Steven Wilson's "other" band. I recommend picking up PT's Deadwing, In Absentia, Fear of a Blank Planet, or their latest The Incident. Each album is very different from one another. I also recommend picking up either of the two concert DVDs "Arriving Somewhere" or "Anesthetize".
#4
Moderator
Thread Starter
Re: Porcupine Tree question
This is no other PT song like Lazarus which makes it such a cool song. Bunkaroo provided some good info above, particularly checking out Blackfield, Steven Wilson's "other" band. I recommend picking up PT's Deadwing, In Absentia, Fear of a Blank Planet, or their latest The Incident. Each album is very different from one another. I also recommend picking up either of the two concert DVDs "Arriving Somewhere" or "Anesthetize".
#6
Senior Member
Join Date: May 2005
Location: Gainesville, FL
Posts: 678
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Porcupine Tree question
I'll second the recommendations for their two concert DVDs, Arriving Somewhere... and Anesthetize. I've watched both a few times since purchasing them and I'll watch them again. They're both very good.
Arriving Somewhere was actually my introduction to the band a few years ago. After I saw that, I bought almost their entire catalog, including the Blackfield stuff. There's also a Blackfield live DVD that's worth checking out, if you like their music. I'd start with Arriving Somewhere or Anesthetize, though.
Arriving Somewhere was actually my introduction to the band a few years ago. After I saw that, I bought almost their entire catalog, including the Blackfield stuff. There's also a Blackfield live DVD that's worth checking out, if you like their music. I'd start with Arriving Somewhere or Anesthetize, though.
#7
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Porcupine Tree question
I was at the show which served as the bulk of the Arriving Somewhere DVD. It was actually two nights in Chicago but they kept most of the first night I was at - even the interesting occurrence during the second encore. I was happy to see that on the DVD. It shows Wilson doesn't take himself too seriously.
#10
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Porcupine Tree question
Blackfield II is definitely my favorite of the two so far. It's already 4 years old - it came out around the same time as Fear of a Blank Planet. Blackfield I had even less fanfare. I'm hoping the new record raises their profile some more.
#11
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Re: Porcupine Tree question
Check out the whole Stupid Dream album. It's my favourite from them. The Blackfield albums are also mighty fine.
#12
Moderator
Thread Starter
Re: Porcupine Tree question
here are the dates and venues for the Blackfield Spring tour:
18th May Washington, DC, 9:30 Club
19th May Philadelphia, PA, Theater of the Living Arts
20th May New York, NY, Irving Plaza
21st May Boston, MA, Royale Boston
23rd May Montreal, QC, Le National CANADA
25th May Cleveland, OH, House of Blues
26th May Detroit, MI, St Andrew's Hall
27th May Chicago, IL, Park West
31st May Seattle, WA, Studio Seven
1st June Portland, OR, Aladdin Theater
3rd June San Francisco, CA, Great American Music Hall
4th June Los Angeles, CA, El Rey Theatre
18th May Washington, DC, 9:30 Club
19th May Philadelphia, PA, Theater of the Living Arts
20th May New York, NY, Irving Plaza
21st May Boston, MA, Royale Boston
23rd May Montreal, QC, Le National CANADA
25th May Cleveland, OH, House of Blues
26th May Detroit, MI, St Andrew's Hall
27th May Chicago, IL, Park West
31st May Seattle, WA, Studio Seven
1st June Portland, OR, Aladdin Theater
3rd June San Francisco, CA, Great American Music Hall
4th June Los Angeles, CA, El Rey Theatre
#14
Member
Join Date: May 2009
Posts: 147
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
#15
Senior Member
Join Date: Nov 1999
Posts: 399
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Porcupine Tree question
I saw Porcupine Tree at an in store acoustic performance when they were touring behind the Stupid Dream album[had the cd autographed as well as a poster promoting the album].