spainlinx0

I don't know if this has been done on this forum before, but I was wondering if anyone would be interested in taking a show that has already aired, and watching it with the forum, say at an episode (or 2 for the impatient) a week, and commenting on it like it has just aired.

I know we have had individual members comment on a new experience before, but this could be something fun we do. We could have weekly threads, or simply one long running thread. It could be a show we all love, and relive together, or a show that we could pan week to week.

We all love to catch shows we missed on DVD, and it would be nice if we could do that and have someone to discuss it with rather than digging up old threads.

Is there any interest in something like this? We could do a nomination/poll thread to pick the show as well.

Pointyskull

I'm interested, but I imagine the selection process will be a challenge.

Groucho

You can do this over Xbox Live if the show is available for streaming on Netflix.

spainlinx0

True, but isn't that more for actually watching together, or if we wanted to do this MST3K style? I was thinking more along the lines of "watch this episode this week, then have a discussion thread." I think that it would be too difficult to get everyone together to watch a show at a certain time.

Tracer Bullet

I approve of this idea.

Should we nominate shows and then maybe do an elimination thing? Assuming there's enough interest, of course.

WallyOPD

I think this was done with Babylon 5 a few years back. I don't recall participating at the time but I read the threads and they were enjoyable.

spainlinx0

I couldn't remember if it was done with B5, or if it was one person going through and writing long reviews. Also, I was too lazy to do a search.

I think each person gets to nominate 2 shows MAXIMUM, and also must give a reason why they chose their show. I hate it when I see threads that consist of lists. I can't think of anything that makes my eyes glaze over more.

Groucho

It's almost certain that regardless of the criteria used to choose an episode, it'll be something from Buffy or The Wire.

spainlinx0

Well I was looking to choose a series, and go through the entire series, or at least a season. I wasn't looking for haphazard episodes. I also was going to eliminate both of those shows since we hear so damn much about them on here. Am I being Groucho'ed here?

Superman07

I think this is a good idea. Finding the time to keep up and be relevant in the conversation could be hard, but still probably wroth a shot.

I was going to make the same comment, but Groucho beat me to it.

What if we did something that was shorter and wouldn't take ages to finish? UK series usually have a shorter shelf life in both episodes and series (seasons).

Another option could be do just the first season of a show and then stop; move to next show. This could be a good way to fit in more shows and expose people to a wider variety.

spainlinx0

One season is fine to me. Then after it's over, we can vote to continue to the next season, or start a new series.

Superman07

How would the logistics work though? Leave everybody to their own devices to view the season? Buy or rent? Limit to shows on free streaming sites (e.g. Hulu, WB, etc.)? That could be tricky.

Dan

Sounds interesting. I'll definitely take part if/when a show is chosen.

I already have my one and only recommendation, and it's a relatively shorter one.



As for logistics, here are a few ideas:
- 2 episodes per week, starting Sundays. People can feel free to continue watching ahead of the group, but should reserve comments until the appropriate time.
- Either one giant thread for the entire Season/Series, or separate threads for each week, but clearly labeled something like "TV Talk Rewind Week #x: [Show Name]"

My Other Self

I'd be down for this, too. Keep us posted if this comes to fruition.

Rypro 525

I'd be down for this, i'd prefer do to shows that are not from the forum's era, or shows that didn't have weekly threads when they were on

Keith6601

I've been working my way through shows that have ended or I've never seen but get good reviews so I'd be down for this.

spainlinx0

This is exactly the way I was thinking. I was leaning towards individual threads just to avoid spoilers for future episodes. I think 1-2 episodes a week is reasonable, but perhaps some members may have time constraints, and I figured one episode is not too much to ask. I would recommend not watching ahead, just to keep it like a real show, but obviously that's the honor system.

I like the idea of shows before running threads, but if we go too far back we may lose member interest. However I would be opposed to any shows that are currently airing.

spainlinx0

Logistically, I think the show needs to have been released on DVD already, and if it's available streaming even better. Also other means for those with less disposable income will not be frowned upon by me. Shows with no DVD presence just may be impractical to obtain for some members. This can also factor into people's recommendations.

spainlinx0

Well the response has been overwhelming. Should we just start nominating?

pinata242

I could use another trip through Carnivale!

Dan

Is it worth it to start a separate Nominations thread? I think so, that way it's easier to keep track of them. But first, this whole thing needs a good name.

spainlinx0

How about the "DVDTalk TV Rewind"

pinata242

Sisterhood of the Traveling Pants

WallyOPD

Groucho's House of Horrors

Rypro 525

the UK version of the Office? (as its short enough to a point where it wouldn't be too long