Smallville -- "Echo" -- 10/16/09
#1
DVD Talk God
Thread Starter
#2
DVD Talk God
Thread Starter
Re: Smallville -- "Echo" -- 10/16/09
Watching this right now. Surprised there are 0 comments at 1:19am PT on Saturday.
#3
DVD Talk Godfather
Join Date: Apr 1999
Location: Gateway Cities/Harbor Region
Posts: 63,270
Received 1,793 Likes
on
1,121 Posts
Re: Smallville -- "Echo" -- 10/16/09
Hear
what the...
Spoiler:
what the...
#4
DVD Talk God
Thread Starter
Re: Smallville -- "Echo" -- 10/16/09
Alright, finished watching this and thought it was good, not great.
Loved everything with Lois and Clark.
Loved how Lois was getting all hot and turned on when Clark was reading her mind & finishing her sentences along with asking her out on a semi-date.....But, of course you knew it wasn't going to happen. The scene where Clark almost heard her saying she was wearing a thong was great.
Did not like the Toyman plot at all. I thought it was a thankless return for the character. The Payoff fell flat on it's face at the end.
The mind reading ability was cute and worked well with the Lois and Clark scenes, but I really didn't understand how it fit in the grander scheme of the episode. So, he somehow was able to figure out Toyman in the crowd was an android? Tess coming into the Jail and seeking his help was a big WTF?
Getting quite tired of Oliver being on a death wish. Fake Jimmy is dead...Get over it dude. Hopefully next week's episode brings more of an end to this storyline.
Loved everything with Lois and Clark.
Loved how Lois was getting all hot and turned on when Clark was reading her mind & finishing her sentences along with asking her out on a semi-date.....But, of course you knew it wasn't going to happen. The scene where Clark almost heard her saying she was wearing a thong was great.
Did not like the Toyman plot at all. I thought it was a thankless return for the character. The Payoff fell flat on it's face at the end.
The mind reading ability was cute and worked well with the Lois and Clark scenes, but I really didn't understand how it fit in the grander scheme of the episode. So, he somehow was able to figure out Toyman in the crowd was an android? Tess coming into the Jail and seeking his help was a big WTF?
Getting quite tired of Oliver being on a death wish. Fake Jimmy is dead...Get over it dude. Hopefully next week's episode brings more of an end to this storyline.
Last edited by DJariya; 10-17-09 at 04:48 AM.
#5
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Smallville -- "Echo" -- 10/16/09
I liked the Lois & Clark stuff as well.
Glad Chloe had a smaller part this episode since she had been reaching Lana levels of being annoying.
Glad Chloe had a smaller part this episode since she had been reaching Lana levels of being annoying.
#8
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Smallville -- "Echo" -- 10/16/09
What? He got that in the first season (and even used it in this episode).
I liked the Lois and Clark stuff too, but as always we know they won't end up together during this show, so it all seems pointless.
Chloe needs a plot.
Oliver needs to either return to being the Green Arrow or get off the show. I like him as an actor and character, but he's doing absolutely nothing right now and they need to figure out what he's for these days.
And "The Blur" remains the dumbest thing they've ever come up with. They should have just started calling him Superman if they wanted him to BE Superman. I don't understand their continued devotion to "no tights, no flights." The creators said that YEARS ago, and now they've got him racing around town saving people with a big S on his chest...seriously...they aren't fooling anyone.
I liked the Lois and Clark stuff too, but as always we know they won't end up together during this show, so it all seems pointless.
Chloe needs a plot.
Oliver needs to either return to being the Green Arrow or get off the show. I like him as an actor and character, but he's doing absolutely nothing right now and they need to figure out what he's for these days.
And "The Blur" remains the dumbest thing they've ever come up with. They should have just started calling him Superman if they wanted him to BE Superman. I don't understand their continued devotion to "no tights, no flights." The creators said that YEARS ago, and now they've got him racing around town saving people with a big S on his chest...seriously...they aren't fooling anyone.
Last edited by Draven; 10-17-09 at 01:37 PM.
#9
DVD Talk Hero
#10
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Smallville -- "Echo" -- 10/16/09
Sweaty Tess was the highlight this week.
I thought we already had an Oliver intervention last week? Didn't they show him pouring out the bottle?
I thought we already had an Oliver intervention last week? Didn't they show him pouring out the bottle?
#11
Member
Join Date: Mar 2009
Posts: 213
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
#12
DVD Talk Hero
Join Date: Aug 2000
Location: Bartertown due to it having a better economy than where I really live.
Posts: 29,834
Received 18 Likes
on
12 Posts
Re: Smallville -- "Echo" -- 10/16/09
he poured it out in order to light his green arrow costume on fire
edit: and it looks like I had the window open too long between refreshes
edit: and it looks like I had the window open too long between refreshes
#14
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Smallville -- "Echo" -- 10/16/09
And "The Blur" remains the dumbest thing they've ever come up with. They should have just started calling him Superman if they wanted him to BE Superman. I don't understand their continued devotion to "no tights, no flights." The creators said that YEARS ago, and now they've got him racing around town saving people with a big S on his chest...seriously...they aren't fooling anyone.
#15
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Smallville -- "Echo" -- 10/16/09
I don't see any way the creators could put the two of them together if they want to stick to the most common telling of his story. They are going to have to have Clark go into some Kryptonian capsule and come out looking like Brandon Routh to make it work.
I suppose they could just say "fuck it" and couple them up, but if they are going to do that I wish they wouldn't get so stuck on other things.
#16
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Join Date: Apr 2004
Location: San Leandro/San Francisco
Posts: 7,422
Likes: 0
Received 1 Like
on
1 Post
Re: Smallville -- "Echo" -- 10/16/09
I have seen the...I can hear people's thoughts plot device done much better on other shows.
I did like the Oliver/Tess stuff though.
I did like the Oliver/Tess stuff though.
#17
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Join Date: Mar 2009
Location: Hollywood Ca
Posts: 2,471
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Smallville -- "Echo" -- 10/16/09
i enjoyed the episode in large part to the chemsitry between lois and clark.
they really do need to get the ball rolling on him actually being superman allready though.
the show has some really great things and the fact that we get so many dc comics superheros as supporting and guest characters on the show is very cool.
as for the costume they should lose the jacket and just go with the black superman suit (like the one seen in the reign of the supermen storyline in the comics.
I think a lot of fans would be ok with that outfit here.
they really do need to get the ball rolling on him actually being superman allready though.
the show has some really great things and the fact that we get so many dc comics superheros as supporting and guest characters on the show is very cool.
as for the costume they should lose the jacket and just go with the black superman suit (like the one seen in the reign of the supermen storyline in the comics.
I think a lot of fans would be ok with that outfit here.
#19
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: Smallville -- "Echo" -- 10/16/09
I thought this was a good episode. I'm a sucker for everything that is Lois and Clark. I agree the sailor and thong bits were great.
I'm okay with the Oliver plot and think it adds to the story. I especially find it interesting when you can tell Tess is being interesting, but then the continual jibes between Tess and Oliver lead back to square one.
I wonder how Oliver starting to see Lex will play out. Our assumption has been Oliver's issue has been with Jimmy, but now the "ghost" of Lex is creeping up.
I do wish the CW held off on airing episodes until baseball is over. The ratings are not being helped at all.
I'm okay with the Oliver plot and think it adds to the story. I especially find it interesting when you can tell Tess is being interesting, but then the continual jibes between Tess and Oliver lead back to square one.
I wonder how Oliver starting to see Lex will play out. Our assumption has been Oliver's issue has been with Jimmy, but now the "ghost" of Lex is creeping up.
I do wish the CW held off on airing episodes until baseball is over. The ratings are not being helped at all.