Michael Phillips and A.O. Scott to host 'At The Movies' (goodbye Ben & Joe!)
#1
DVD Talk Special Edition
Thread Starter
Michael Phillips and A.O. Scott to host 'At The Movies'
I like to go to www.atthemoviestv.com to watch old Siskel & Ebert reviews. Upon my visit tonight, I'm pleased to see that Ben Lyons & Joseph Mankiewicz(sp?) are being replaced, by A.O. Scott & Michael Phillips. Any thoughts? (Anyone care?) I haven't any opinion on A.O. Scott but I thought Phillips did a good job when he filled in for Ebert in 2008 (and I tended to find him much more agreeable than Roeper: case in point, their review of The Happening http://bventertainment.go.com/tv/bue...bsec=Happening
Anyway, their new intro video is up on the site.
Anyway, their new intro video is up on the site.
Last edited by Living Deadpan; 05-16-10 at 11:44 PM. Reason: Deleting the "Ben & Joe" mistake from the title
#2
DVD Talk Hero - 2023 TOTY Award Winner
Re: Michael Phillips and A.O. Scott to host 'At The Movies' (goodbye Ben & Joe!)
A little late on this. This was announced a month or so ago. I think there are two threads about it; one here and one in TV Talk.
#3
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Michael Phillips and A.O. Scott to host 'At The Movies' (goodbye Ben & Joe!)
#5
DVD Talk Hero - 2023 TOTY Award Winner
Re: Michael Phillips and A.O. Scott to host 'At The Movies' (goodbye Ben & Joe!)
Just got done watching Phillips and Scott in their first episode. I posted my reaction over in the TV Talk thread:
http://forum.dvdtalk.com/tv-talk/536...nounced-4.html
http://forum.dvdtalk.com/tv-talk/536...nounced-4.html
#6
Senior Member
Join Date: Oct 2002
Posts: 437
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
#7
DVD Talk Hero - 2023 TOTY Award Winner
Re: Michael Phillips and A.O. Scott to host 'At The Movies' (goodbye Ben & Joe!)
Mankiewicz wasn't too bad. Paired with someone like Phillips he might have kept his job.
#8
DVD Talk Legend
#9
DVD Talk Hero - 2023 TOTY Award Winner
#10
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Michael Phillips and A.O. Scott to host 'At The Movies' (goodbye Ben & Joe!)
I actually only had an aversion to Lyons on ATM.
Looking forward to the new hosts.
#11
DVD Talk Special Edition
Join Date: Sep 2004
Posts: 1,008
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Michael Phillips and A.O. Scott to host 'At The Movies' (goodbye Ben & Joe!)
It doesn't matter who hosts this show, NOBODY can ever replace the awesomeness that was Gene Siskel.
Seriously, Siskel was not afraid to argue and rip up Ebert. And vice versa. He was the ultimate heel film critic, and damn it, thats what we need. Roeper was a terrible replacement. Why? Because he never had the balls to insult and disrespect Ebert's opinion. Thats what made Siskel and Ebert great. They were ruthless towards each other. These new critics are too damn nice, and because of this, its very lame. The Ben's sucked for this same reason.
Seriously, Siskel was not afraid to argue and rip up Ebert. And vice versa. He was the ultimate heel film critic, and damn it, thats what we need. Roeper was a terrible replacement. Why? Because he never had the balls to insult and disrespect Ebert's opinion. Thats what made Siskel and Ebert great. They were ruthless towards each other. These new critics are too damn nice, and because of this, its very lame. The Ben's sucked for this same reason.
#12
Re: Michael Phillips and A.O. Scott to host 'At The Movies' (goodbye Ben & Joe!)
Just got done watching Phillips and Scott in their first episode. I posted my reaction over in the TV Talk thread:
http://forum.dvdtalk.com/tv-talk/536...nounced-4.html
http://forum.dvdtalk.com/tv-talk/536...nounced-4.html
It doesn't matter who hosts this show, NOBODY can ever replace the awesomeness that was Gene Siskel.
Seriously, Siskel was not afraid to argue and rip up Ebert. And vice versa. He was the ultimate heel film critic, and damn it, thats what we need. Roeper was a terrible replacement. Why? Because he never had the balls to insult and disrespect Ebert's opinion. Thats what made Siskel and Ebert great. They were ruthless towards each other. These new critics are too damn nice, and because of this, its very lame. The Ben's sucked for this same reason.
Seriously, Siskel was not afraid to argue and rip up Ebert. And vice versa. He was the ultimate heel film critic, and damn it, thats what we need. Roeper was a terrible replacement. Why? Because he never had the balls to insult and disrespect Ebert's opinion. Thats what made Siskel and Ebert great. They were ruthless towards each other. These new critics are too damn nice, and because of this, its very lame. The Ben's sucked for this same reason.
Last edited by calhoun07; 09-06-09 at 04:08 AM.
#13
DVD Talk Hero - 2023 TOTY Award Winner
Re: Michael Phillips and A.O. Scott to host 'At The Movies' (goodbye Ben & Joe!)
OK, just got done watching the second episode featuring Scott and Phillips in the immortal theater seats and I have to say that my initial reservations over the new casting, in particular with Scott, is starting to wane rapidly. It was a good show.
I was concerned that Scott was a better writer than a television personality, and I still feel that way, but he is doing a good job in front of the camera. I was also concerned that this tastes (and the manner in which he defends them), if his newspaper columns are a fair indication, are just a tad on the snooty side for the intended audience. I am not seeing any indication of that on the show at all thus far.
Those seeking the clash of personalities between the co-hosts, as with the old Siskel and Ebert days, will continue to be disappointed. Phillips and Scott have been very genuinely friendly to one another so far, or are putting on a very convincing act. More conflict will undoubtedly come as these two men grow into their new roles, but what they are giving off so far is working, at least for me.
Kind of a ballsy statement at the end of the show from Scott. When Phillips chose David Mamet's Homicide (1991) as his DVD pick, Scott described Mamet as "one of the most egregiously overrated figures in American literature and culture" and credited him with writing only 2 1/2 good plays and directing only 2 1/2 good movies. I am not entirely sure which 2 1/2 he was referring to (and perhaps he has previously published that list elsewhere) but it sounds like fodder for a good debate.
As it happens I agree with his general assessment of Mamet's directorial work. I am still upset about the two hours of my life I lost watching that ridiculous piece of crap Redbelt.
I was concerned that Scott was a better writer than a television personality, and I still feel that way, but he is doing a good job in front of the camera. I was also concerned that this tastes (and the manner in which he defends them), if his newspaper columns are a fair indication, are just a tad on the snooty side for the intended audience. I am not seeing any indication of that on the show at all thus far.
Those seeking the clash of personalities between the co-hosts, as with the old Siskel and Ebert days, will continue to be disappointed. Phillips and Scott have been very genuinely friendly to one another so far, or are putting on a very convincing act. More conflict will undoubtedly come as these two men grow into their new roles, but what they are giving off so far is working, at least for me.
Kind of a ballsy statement at the end of the show from Scott. When Phillips chose David Mamet's Homicide (1991) as his DVD pick, Scott described Mamet as "one of the most egregiously overrated figures in American literature and culture" and credited him with writing only 2 1/2 good plays and directing only 2 1/2 good movies. I am not entirely sure which 2 1/2 he was referring to (and perhaps he has previously published that list elsewhere) but it sounds like fodder for a good debate.
As it happens I agree with his general assessment of Mamet's directorial work. I am still upset about the two hours of my life I lost watching that ridiculous piece of crap Redbelt.
#14
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Michael Phillips and A.O. Scott to host 'At The Movies' (goodbye Ben & Joe!)
I was flabberghasted when both of these guys gave New Moon a "See It". I mean, OMG, WTF?!?!
#15
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Michael Phillips and A.O. Scott to host 'At The Movies' (goodbye Ben & Joe!)
#16
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Michael Phillips and A.O. Scott to host 'At The Movies' (goodbye Ben & Joe!)
And then both gave "The Blind Side" a "Skip it". Really, not even a "rent it"? W...T...F....!!!
#17
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Michael Phillips and A.O. Scott to host 'At The Movies' (goodbye Ben & Joe!)
#18
Banned by request
Re: Michael Phillips and A.O. Scott to host 'At The Movies' (goodbye Ben & Joe!)
I'm surprised people still watch these type of shows anymore. With Rotten Tomatoes and Metacritic allowing you a wealth of opinions, complete with aggregate score, the need to see two individuals talk generically about movies seems rather archaic.
#19
Inane Thread Master, 2018 TOTY
Join Date: Dec 2003
Location: Are any of us really anywhere?
Posts: 49,443
Received 912 Likes
on
772 Posts
Re: Michael Phillips and A.O. Scott to host 'At The Movies' (goodbye Ben & Joe!)
i still love watching this show and the new two aren't bad. i always think Phillips is going to spit food out his mouth when he talks though.
#20
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
Re: Michael Phillips and A.O. Scott to host 'At The Movies' (goodbye Ben & Joe!)
Looks like it's "The End" for At The Movies.
Thumbs down to Disney.
Long-running review show 'At the Movies' canceled
The balcony is closed.
This is the last season of "At the Movies," the long-running syndicated review show made into a hit in the 1980s by dueling Chicago critics Gene Siskel and Roger Ebert.
The show's roots go back to 1975's "Sneak Previews."
Here's a statement from distributor Disney-ABC Domestic TV:
After 24 seasons with us in national syndication, the highly regarded movie review show "At the Movies" (formerly known as "Siskel & Ebert" and "Ebert & Roeper") will air its last original broadcast the weekend of August 14, 2010.
This was a very difficult decision, especially considering the program's rich history and iconic status within the entertainment industry, but from a business perspective it became clear this weekly, half-hour, broadcast syndication series was no longer sustainable. We gratefully acknowledge the outstanding work of the program's current co-hosts A.O. Scott and Michael Phillips and top-notch production staff, and it is with heartfelt appreciation that we extend very special thanks to the two brilliant, visionary and incomparable critics that started it all, Roger Ebert and the late Gene Siskel.
Online reviews and aggregators like Rotten Tomatoes and Metacritic have made finding knowledgeable opinions movies easier than ever for fans, yet have also evolved the consumption of criticism in such a way that made the half-hour review show seem dated. "At the Movies" also never again found a critic pairing with the chemistry that matched the breakout pairing of Siskel and Ebert.
Tweeted Ebert: "RIP At the Movies."
Thumbs down to Disney.
Long-running review show 'At the Movies' canceled
The balcony is closed.
This is the last season of "At the Movies," the long-running syndicated review show made into a hit in the 1980s by dueling Chicago critics Gene Siskel and Roger Ebert.
The show's roots go back to 1975's "Sneak Previews."
Here's a statement from distributor Disney-ABC Domestic TV:
After 24 seasons with us in national syndication, the highly regarded movie review show "At the Movies" (formerly known as "Siskel & Ebert" and "Ebert & Roeper") will air its last original broadcast the weekend of August 14, 2010.
This was a very difficult decision, especially considering the program's rich history and iconic status within the entertainment industry, but from a business perspective it became clear this weekly, half-hour, broadcast syndication series was no longer sustainable. We gratefully acknowledge the outstanding work of the program's current co-hosts A.O. Scott and Michael Phillips and top-notch production staff, and it is with heartfelt appreciation that we extend very special thanks to the two brilliant, visionary and incomparable critics that started it all, Roger Ebert and the late Gene Siskel.
Online reviews and aggregators like Rotten Tomatoes and Metacritic have made finding knowledgeable opinions movies easier than ever for fans, yet have also evolved the consumption of criticism in such a way that made the half-hour review show seem dated. "At the Movies" also never again found a critic pairing with the chemistry that matched the breakout pairing of Siskel and Ebert.
Tweeted Ebert: "RIP At the Movies."
#21
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Re: Michael Phillips and A.O. Scott to host 'At The Movies' (goodbye Ben & Joe!)
Too bad. I thought the new hosts were doing a good job and I regularly watched the show...that is until the local station switched their time from 6:30 on Sunday to 4:00 on Saturday.
(Yeah, I know I could have recorded it, but...)
(Yeah, I know I could have recorded it, but...)
#22
Banned
Re: Michael Phillips and A.O. Scott to host 'At The Movies' (goodbye Ben & Joe!)
#24
DVD Talk Hero - 2023 TOTY Award Winner
Re: Michael Phillips and A.O. Scott to host 'At The Movies' (goodbye Ben & Joe!)
That's a frigging shame. The new hosts were very good.