Dakota Fanning vs Abigail Breslin

[JeffTheAlpaca]

Who will have the longer career in hollywood?

Fanning is a little older now but she has worked with heavyweights like Sean Penn, Robert De Niro, Denzel Washington, and Tom Cruise.


Abigail Breslin has worked with Jodie Foster and Alan Arkin but her resume is not as polished as Dakota and she seems to play mostly the cute girl.


is their a potential Oscar for one of these girls?

[NiCK Crush]

Dakota Fanning. She's already proven as far as I'm concerned. Granted, she hasnt been in much lately, she still continues to deliver fantastic performances.

Abigail Breslin was great in LMS, but I have no desire to see most of the shit she has been in lately... American Girl? Nims Island? No thanks.

And yea, I think either of them are capable of an Oscar, they just need the right role.

[Patman]

I'd rather go with AnnaSophia Robb over Dakota or Abigail.

[matome]

^:up:

[chris_sc77]

Neither. Elle fanning has been in better projects than these two.

[Mr. Cinema]

I agree with post #3.

[Mercury&Solace]

AnnaSophia Robb
Dakota Fanning







That last girl

[PopcornTreeCt]

Between the two, I choose Abigail Breslin. I've never liked Dakota Fanning in anything.

[LiquidSky]

Fanning seems very robotic to me.

[LickTheABCs]

Dakota was in Man on Fire. So her.

[dx23]

Fanning seems very robotic to me.

Exactly. I remember some reviewer mentioning the same thing and comparing her to the doll that you press the tummy and spew a different emotion. Breslin on the other hand seems very natural when acting, while Dakota can turn annoying as hell, like in War of the Worlds.

By the way, Breslin was also pretty good in No Reservations.

[Rockmjd23]

Only 3 more years for AnnaSophia...

[NiCK Crush]

AnnaSophia cannot act.

[JeffTheAlpaca]

AnnaSophia Robb gave a lousy performance in Sleepwalking that movie with Charlize Theron.

Dakota is now a cheerleader for her high school

time goes by fast.

I think Dakota has the smarts to become another Jodie Foster when she gets older.

[dhmac]

is their a potential Oscar for one of these girls?
Julia Roberts won one and she can't act. So, yes, winning an Oscar is always possible no matter what the actual acting ability is. It really just takes appearing in one of those "important" message films that Hollywood loves to hand out awards to, no matter how good the resulting movie is (or isn't).

.

[dhmac]

Only 3 more years for AnnaSophia...
Actually only one more year in most states (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ages_of_consent_in_the_United_States) (although California isn't one of those states).


.

[SomethingMore]

I came to this thread expecting a video of the two actresses in a death match at some random party or something.

:(

[droidguy1119]

I think Dakota Fanning looks good in that new movie she's in, Push. But we'll see.

[LickTheABCs]

I think Dakota Fanning looks good in that new movie she's in, Push. But we'll see.

I still want to see her get raped in "Hounddog" but they keep pushing it back. :shrug:

[Kal-El]

I like both in the movies I've seen them in, but gun to my head, Breslin.

[DonnachaOne]

I still want to see her get raped in "Hounddog" but they keep pushing it back. :shrug:
http://img181.imageshack.us/img181/6417/tmihm4.gif
Too much Goddamn information.

[DRG]

I think Dakota Fanning will have a career trajectory similar to Christina Ricci.

[MinLShaw]

Predicting the careers of child actresses is not something I'll even bother doing. I will say, though, that Abigail Breslin has entirely redefined "Superfreak" for all time. I can't say that I've ever seen Dakota Fanning leave a mark like that.

[Groucho]

I still want to see her get raped in "Hounddog" but they keep pushing it back. :shrug:Here's one critic's...interesting...take:

gcYO_Q7Te4Y

[davidh777]

I like Robb too, but Kit Kittredge: American Girl is worth seeing.

[dom56]

I like to see more of Ivana Baquero. She was great in Pan's Labyrinth.

[aintnosin]

The first one to hit rehab will have a headstart on her second career. Drew Barrymore is the only model to follow.... :D

[JPRaup]

Both are pretty fucking annoying.

[zekeburger1979]

How about both at the same time?



Runs like hell.....:D

[Torchur317]

Dakota Fanning

[toddly6666]

Dakota Fanning IS the next Jodie Foster. She has been good in everything and she is going to be good looking later. Dakota Fanning's younger sister is going to be amazing as well.

Breslin is just a freaky little demon child and she is not going to age well.

[Thrush]

I still want to see her get raped in "Hounddog" but they keep pushing it back. :shrug:

http://img110.imageshack.us/img110/4237/pedogq7.png

[DVD.guy]

Abigail...was never a fan of Fanning.

[Giantrobo]

I like Robb too, but Kit Kittredge: American Girl is worth seeing.


1. Ok, I'm so embarrassed to say that i would really like to see both Kit Kittredge and Nim's Island. I always walk by them at Blockbuster but then I get weirded out. :lol: I always try to justify KK:AG by reminding my self that the gorgeous and funny Jane Krakowski(30 Rock) is in it. :lol:

2. I like both actresses.

[MR Round]

I think that Dakota Fanning is going to have the the most long standing career of the two because she hasn't stuck to just one genre of film her first major role (I am Sam) she did an amazing job while movies like Dreamer are going to go over well with family's she isn't afraid to take offbeat rolls like The Secret Life Of Bees and Houddog (both coming out on dvd Feb 3rd) they got mixed reviews but she was amazing in both. And with Push coming out soon shes going to be quite the big star in her adulthood

[coli]

Julia Roberts won one and she can't act.
.

I know this is off topic, but I agree 100% with this statement!

[hotsexyboi]

Dakota!!!!!

[RichC2]

I know this is stating the obvious, but seeing how much Breslin has grown since LMS is just weird and makes me feel old.

Of course, that's also the last thing I saw her in (she's on Leno tonight).

[golden_rod]

Breslin. Fanning tries too hard in everything she does. It's cloying to watch.

That being said, Fanning's younger sister Elle is a great little actress. She was fantastic in "Phoebe In Wonderland." It's obvious who has the talent in that family.

[MR Round]

I thought fanning was great in hounddog and the secret life of bees while Push wasn't the best she did good with what she had.Breslin was never in a movie i liked

[The Bus]

I'll pick Fanning, but I like Saoirse Ronan more.