Where the heck are the war movies?
#1
DVD Talk Legend
Thread Starter
Where the heck are the war movies?
I know a bunch have been released and I am very psyched about the Band of Brothers set. I was just looking through my collection and yes they've released Flags of Our Fathers, Black Hawk Down, Pearl Harbor (PG13 only), Sand Pebbles, We Were Soldiers, and a bunch of others.
But I am still waiting for movies like Gettysburg, Memphis Belle and Midway. These have never even had an SE release. They're still the first generation, non-anamorphic, flipper discs.
I'd love to upgrade Big Red 1, Enemy at the Gates, Platoon, Tora Tora Tora and get the R rated version of Pearl Harbor.
Saving Private Ryan can't come out soon enough. Can you imagine the landing scene in lossless? Nothing works out an audio system like a war movie. Is there still a big market for that genre?
But I am still waiting for movies like Gettysburg, Memphis Belle and Midway. These have never even had an SE release. They're still the first generation, non-anamorphic, flipper discs.
I'd love to upgrade Big Red 1, Enemy at the Gates, Platoon, Tora Tora Tora and get the R rated version of Pearl Harbor.
Saving Private Ryan can't come out soon enough. Can you imagine the landing scene in lossless? Nothing works out an audio system like a war movie. Is there still a big market for that genre?
#2
DVD Talk Legend
The titles from Fox last year were part of a Father's Day tie-in, and they've done Memorial Day tie-ins for DVD in the past. Maybe next year around that time they'll release more. I'm hoping they can reissue Patton sans DNR at some point.
Platoon might be a candidate, since Oliver Stone seems to be the leading director on Blu-ray so far. 9 of his movies will be out by the end of January.
I wouldn't count on those early titles soon, since they may not have good HD masters available. It would probably depend on whether they want to issue new SEs.
Platoon might be a candidate, since Oliver Stone seems to be the leading director on Blu-ray so far. 9 of his movies will be out by the end of January.
I wouldn't count on those early titles soon, since they may not have good HD masters available. It would probably depend on whether they want to issue new SEs.
#3
DVD Talk Limited Edition
The Blu-ray of Pearl Harbor is pretty good, but it's not the theatrical cut you mentioned. I believe there's only 20 seconds of additional footage in the Director's Cut, so it's not a big deal. The real downer is the utter lack of extras found on earlier editions.
Don't hold your breath on Saving Private Ryan. It's a Spielberg pic, and he's been pretty stingy about allowing his legacy films to be released on Blu. Only Close Encounters has made it so far, and I think it's because Sony had the distribution rights, as opposed to Spielberg himself, who retains control on most of his catalog.
Don't hold your breath on Saving Private Ryan. It's a Spielberg pic, and he's been pretty stingy about allowing his legacy films to be released on Blu. Only Close Encounters has made it so far, and I think it's because Sony had the distribution rights, as opposed to Spielberg himself, who retains control on most of his catalog.
#6
DVD Talk Legend
Thread Starter
I picked up A Bridge Too Far when that was released. That was another 1st generation piece of crap. I already have good SE's of Black Hawk Down, Platoon, Longest Day, and Glory so those are long term upgrades. Most of the others at least are anamorphic and DD 5.1 so they'll hold me over. War movies have always been a favorite so I'm anxiously waiting for the upgrades.
Saving Private Ryan I've already triple dipped. Bought the original DD release, then the DTS, then upgraded to the box set not realizing it didn't have DTS. If I find a used DTS for cheap I'll probably grab it until the BD is released.
For Pearl Harbor, if it's only 9 seconds it's the most effective 9 seconds I've seen. Really amps up the battle scene. I have the 4 disc set so I can wait for a more complete BD release.
Saving Private Ryan I've already triple dipped. Bought the original DD release, then the DTS, then upgraded to the box set not realizing it didn't have DTS. If I find a used DTS for cheap I'll probably grab it until the BD is released.
For Pearl Harbor, if it's only 9 seconds it's the most effective 9 seconds I've seen. Really amps up the battle scene. I have the 4 disc set so I can wait for a more complete BD release.
#7
DVD Talk Legend
#8
DVD Talk Limited Edition
#9
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Join Date: Dec 2001
Posts: 2,575
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
The Longest Day is kind of an odd one on Blu-ray. On the one hand, it had lots of DNR so that detail is lost similar to Patton. On the other hand, in most aspects it is far superior to the super softness of the SE DVD. The only thing I liked about the SE DVD compared to the original DVD release was that you could see the subtitles when the movie was in the proper aspect ratio. On the original non-anamorphic release you lost part of the subtitles when you used the full width of your screen in the proper AR. There are a few scenes in the Blu-ray that look kind of strange because it is so obvious they are standing in front of a screen and not the real scenery, and the smoothing of skin detail due to DNR is more troublesome to some people than others, but much of it is a great improvement. It definitely could of been better though. Seems like we never get it all with this movie.
#10
DVD Talk Legend
Pearl Harbor DC is more than just a few seconds of footage....still waiting for it. Glory's another one I'd really like... thought we'd have it by now esp since it's a Sony title.
#11
Senior Member
Join Date: Nov 2004
Location: Northern NJ
Posts: 917
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Would also love to see Blu-Rays of Glory and SPR, as well as Last of the Mohicans. We've had some pretty good offerings with Flags/Iwo, Master & Commander (video certainly could have been better though), and The Patriot amongst others. Here's to hoping.
#12
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Theatrical Cut: 183:05 (PG-13)
Director's Cut: 184:18 (R)
For my money, nothing beats the 4-disc Vista Series set with the DC, tons of extras, and a very cool collector's presentation. I'll stick with it until a BD comes out that can match it.
#13
DVD Talk Legend
Thread Starter
With limited funds these days, I'm reluctant to upgrade a decent DVD issue. Any of those original issue Sd's are goners as soon as the BD is released. The others are wait and see until the right deal comes along.
#16
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Join Date: Feb 2002
Location: On the penis chair
Posts: 5,169
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
#19
DVD Talk Legend
Well Speiberg did allow the fourth Indiana Jones film to come to blu-ray, so there might be hope for more of his films.
#21
DVD Talk Limited Edition
#22
DVD Talk Legend
Thread Starter
#24
DVD Talk Legend
#25
DVD Talk Gold Edition