Black Book - Sony US Edition Vs. Tartan Uk Edition [Archive]

Black Book - Sony US Edition Vs. Tartan Uk Edition [Archive] - DVD Talk Forum


Best Sellers
1.	Man With The Plan
2.	Something New
3.	Nightmare in Silver
4.	Watershed
5.	Whines By Wives
6.	Dexter: The Seventh Season Buy: ~~$54.99~~ $24.99
7.	And Straight On 'Til Morning Buy: ~~$54.99~~ $24.99
8.	The Longest Day Buy: ~~$54.99~~ $24.99
9.	Man With The Plan [HD] Buy: ~~$54.99~~ $24.99
10.	For Immediate Release Buy: ~~$54.99~~ $24.99

DVD Blowouts
1.	Downton Abbey Seasons 1 & 2 Limited Edition Set - Original UK Version Buy: ~~$59.99~~ $44.99
2.	Saving Private Ryan (Sapphire Series) [Blu-ray] Buy: ~~$24.99~~ $16.91
3.	Anchorman: The Legend of Ron Burgundy (Unrated Widescreen Edition) Buy: ~~$12.98~~ $7.83
4.	Swamp People: Season 1 Buy: ~~$24.98~~ $5.99
5.	The Odd Life of Timothy Green Buy: ~~$29.99~~ $17.99
6.	Bambi (Two-Disc Edition) Buy: ~~$29.99~~ $18.33
7.	Alien [Blu-ray] Buy: ~~$19.99~~ $9.99
8.	Gi Joe: The Rise of Cobra [Blu-ray] Buy: ~~$22.98~~ $12.99
9.	Brazil (Criterion Collection) [Blu-ray] Buy: ~~$49.95~~ $27.99
10.	American Beauty (Widescreen Edition) Buy: ~~$12.99~~ $9.99

PDA

DVD Reviews

View Full Version : Black Book - Sony US Edition Vs. Tartan Uk Edition

ilan

07-24-08, 07:31 AM

Sorry if there's an open thread already.

Does anyone knows which version is better - the Sony US edition or the Tartan (out of print) edition?

Thanks!

Adam Tyner

07-24-08, 07:37 AM

I wrote a comparison review (http://www.dvdtalk.com/reviews/30911/black-book-tartan-uk/), if you're interested.

My vote is for the Sony release, personally, although the difference really only comes down to extras, and they're not that different even there.