The Man with the Golden Doujinshi

Since we have a horror and holiday movie challenge already, I was wondering if anyone would be interested in doing a Sci-Fi movie challenge.

I'm planning on basing the rules around the horror challenge where it's movie only. No tv shows(Outer Limits, Twilight Zone) since it is a movie challenge but movies from tv shows are ok, like the Futurama movies. If there's too much confusion over this we can just not allow movies based off tv shows unless they've had a theatrical run.

Movies need to be the standard length for movies which is around 45 minutes.

Movies have to be labeled sci-fi from either imdb.com or allmovie.com

I'm also planning on some sci-fi related prizes aka sci-fi stuff I have sitting around. No cash, nothing expensive, just some fun stuff.

The main question, other than if people want to do it, is if we should do it June or July. If you have any other suggestions, post them.

chris_sc77

I would suggest July if this is to be done. In honor of X-FIles II, Hellboy II, and Space Chimps (just kidding on that last one.). Also the release on DVD of Dark City: Director's Cut,. Thats just my opinion though.

starman9000

I'd be interested, though I'd rather have TV shows included, maybe there can be a sub-contest.

OldBoy

i'd be interested if we also included action/adventure, horror, comedy, drama, and tv shows

Drexl

Have a separate TV-only challenge then.

TomOpus

Should've made it a poll

I might be interested. June would work out better for me since Comic-Con is in July

The Man with the Golden Doujinshi

scott1598, it's time to put you on my enemies list

If we included tv shows, what if we made it so you had to watch an entire season for it to count and that season would count for one entry?

RobCA

I'd defiintely be more likely to participate if TV shows were included, since I don't own a lot of sci-fi movies. Plus, it would give me a chance to get all those seasons of The Twilight Zone and The X-Files off of my unwatched list. But counting an entire season as only one entry? How about counting each disc (excluding extras-only discs) as one entry instead?

Rob

The Man with the Golden Doujinshi

I guess include TV shows and each show counts as an entry. Counting discs wouldn't work if people watched shows on TV.

If I go ahead with the prizes, I think instead of going by number of items watched, since tv shows could quickly add up, people would need to keep track of running times. Something like I'm doing here: http://forum.dvdtalk.com/showpost.ph...40&postcount=2

chris_sc77

I would also include TV shows but only Count each disk as One OR One season as One entry. Counting/listing each episode wouldn't be sufficient.

terrycloth

Id be interested in this despite my failed attempt at the holiday challenge...as i have about 10--15 sci fi movies unopened awaiting attention...might even encourage me to finally watch the star wars movies

The Man with the Golden Doujinshi

That makes sense to me.

TV shows are the problem now. If we did it where each disc of a tv series was an entry then all the shows would have to be on DVD. Otherwise we'd have to figure out a whole new set of rules for dealing with people watching single episodes of something on TV or watching a show that's not out on DVD.

If we did it by counting individual episodes, I'd want to figure out who watched the most by also having everyone include and keeping track of running times. Keeping track of running times was something that some people wanted to do with the horror challenge due to the large amounts people were watching in a day.

Counting a season as one entry would be the easiest but you might have a 10 hour season only count as one. Again, we could also keep track of running times.

Joe Molotov

I'd be interested.

As far as TV shows go, if we're counting them, I say two hour-long shows or four half-hour shows equals a movie.

The Man with the Golden Doujinshi

That works for me too. What does everyone else think?

RobCA

I think that's a great idea. Wish I'd thought of it!

If you do it that way, you can definitely count me in. I vote for July, BTW.

Rob

The Man with the Golden Doujinshi

It looks like we figured it all out. Thanks for the help.

I'll start a discussion page on the 1st June and we'll start the show in July.

caligulathegod

I'd be interested. If we're going to include TV shows with a caveat that multiple shows count as one movie, then the 45 minute rule should probably go. SF films tend to be longer than Horror, anyway. We should encourage the viewing of SF epics like The Abyss and avoid the rancor that came of that rule in the Horror challenge.

I propose we include Fantasy genre. SF is really just a subset of Fantasy, anyway. It would forestall questions on cross-genre films like Star Wars.

The Man with the Golden Doujinshi

I agree

I'm not sure about adding Fantasy. Going by what I said earlier, Star Wars shouldn't have any questions since there's a sci-fi tag at imdb.com and allmovie.com.

Any cross-genre films that include sci-fi should have the sci-fi tag and imdb or allmovie which I think would be easy enough to go by. I think it'd solve problems of some people saying a certain movie is sci-fi and others not agreeing.

RobCA

Have you thought about having it run longer than a month? I noticed you're calling it the "Summer Sci-Fi Challenge", how about July and August? Personally, I could use the extra time to get through all those seasons of The X-Files.

Rob

Darth Maher

For me, this would definitely be a challenge as lately, I haven't been able to watch diddly.

But, I fully support this idea and would try to participate as often as possible.

The Man with the Golden Doujinshi

The only reason why I wouldn't want to do it in August at all is because we'd only get one month off before we started the October one. After that last Horror challenge, I took a couple months off before I could watch as much as I normally do.

If anyone else wants to do it though, speak up and I'll probably make it happen.

InnocentBlood

great idea - i'll play

caligulathegod

A film challenge is more about encouraging the watching of many different films, rather than just spending a certain number of hours in front of a TV watching something genre-related. I would hope that participants don't blow the whole challenge on multiple episodes of one or two TV shows. To each his own, I suppose.

The Monkees

I usually partake in all of the challenges (regardless of the fact that I run 2 of the 3) but I will be passing on this, simply because I don't have many Sci-Fi movies at all, plus I'm not a huge fan of Sci-Fi. But I hope everyone else has fun with it.

RobCA

I don't have many sci-fi movies either, as I'm also not a big fan of the genre. That's why I'm glad TV shows are included. While I won't "blow the whole challenge on multiple episodes of one or two TV shows", I am planning to blow most of it on them.

Rob