Is there a Widescreen HSM2?
#1
Guest
Thread Starter
Join Date: May 2007
Posts: 53
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Is there a Widescreen HSM2?
This may be a stu-ped ?, but I just got back from wal-mart and all the copies of High School Musical 2 were FULL SCREEN!!! WTF! Please tell me that my Wal-mart sucks.......and that I am not gona be force to watch a full screen movie on my wide-screen tv!!!!!
Thanks-a-bunch......
Thanks-a-bunch......
#5
Cool New Member
Join Date: Jul 2007
Posts: 37
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by amd555
it is a tv progra, and was likely shot in FS. They might have to stretch it for blu ray. Just a thought.
#7
DVD Talk Legend
From the look of it, I wonder if it was shot in Full Screen and then matted for widescreen... I noticed that there was quite a bit of space during some scenes on the top and bottom.
#8
DVD Talk Legend
Originally Posted by amd555
it is a tv progra, and was likely shot in FS. They might have to stretch it for blu ray. Just a thought.
Anyway, from the review:
The film is presented in a 1.33:1 full screen format, maintaining its original standard TV broadcast. "HSM 2" was filmed in a 1.78:1 aspect ratio for hi-def viewing yet was framed for standard screens, so both viewing formats appear to be "correct." No cropping of any kind is evident here, and I wouldn't call this a pan-and-scan release so much as the Blu-ray version is something of a widescreen open matte.
#9
Senior Member
Join Date: Oct 2007
Location: Tennessee
Posts: 524
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Nope, no widescreen available on DVD just crappy fullscreen which is really not a surprise considering it is Disney. The movie was shot in a aspect ratio of 1.78:1 so go figure
#11
Banned
Join Date: Mar 2004
Location: Pacific Northwest
Posts: 925
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by Mr. Salty
But, as was written above, it was framed for 4:3.
This is nothing more that Disney figuring the average SD customer wants 4x3 and the average BR customer would never buy a 4x3 BR title filmed in WS. Sadly they are right about the typical average foolscreen SD audience.
#12
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
Even if HSM2 (can't believe I actually clicked on this thread) had been released in widescreen, Wal*Mart would most likely have all fool screen copies. They love the full screen at Wal*Mart, and that's because the demographic at Wal*Mart are the "why isn't the picture filling my whole screen?!" folks.
I don't think 10 year olds really care whether it's in full screen or widescreen, also.
I don't think 10 year olds really care whether it's in full screen or widescreen, also.
#13
Banned
Join Date: Mar 2004
Location: Pacific Northwest
Posts: 925
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by nateman241
Even if HSM2 (can't believe I actually clicked on this thread) had been released in widescreen, Wal*Mart would most likely have all fool screen copies. They love the full screen at Wal*Mart, and that's because the demographic at Wal*Mart are the "why isn't the picture filling my whole screen?!" folks.
I don't think 10 year olds really care whether it's in full screen or widescreen, also.
I don't think 10 year olds really care whether it's in full screen or widescreen, also.
#14
Emeritus Reviewer
Join Date: Jan 2006
Posts: 434
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by cardaway
4x3 is still not the OAR.
I'd say both are correct, since the director shot the film with both formats in mind.
#15
Banned
Join Date: Mar 2004
Location: Pacific Northwest
Posts: 925
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by David Cornelius
Actually, it is. It was premiered as 4x3 for standard TV viewing. A 16x9 version came later for HD viewing. If you want to get technical, 4x3 is the original ratio.
I'd say both are correct, since the director shot the film with both formats in mind.
I'd say both are correct, since the director shot the film with both formats in mind.
It's there for the BR version because that IS the OAR.
The foolscreen 4x3 showed on the Disney Channel is just that, the dumbed down, basic cable, TV version. If there was a HD Disney channel I'm sure they would have shown the 16x9 that's on the BR disc.
Makes me wonder if the original was also shot in 16x9 and it will someday make a 16x9 appearance as well.
#16
Originally Posted by cardaway
No such thing as something coming later... can't add what isn't there.
It's there for the BR version because that IS the OAR.
The foolscreen 4x3 showed on the Disney Channel is just that, the dumbed down, basic cable, TV version. If there was a HD Disney channel I'm sure they would have shown the 16x9 that's on the BR disc.
Makes me wonder if the original was also shot in 16x9 and it will someday make a 16x9 appearance as well.
It's there for the BR version because that IS the OAR.
The foolscreen 4x3 showed on the Disney Channel is just that, the dumbed down, basic cable, TV version. If there was a HD Disney channel I'm sure they would have shown the 16x9 that's on the BR disc.
Makes me wonder if the original was also shot in 16x9 and it will someday make a 16x9 appearance as well.
Theoretically, the 1.78:1 ratio designed for the Blu-Ray version is intended, obviously, to create the same effect as the FS version is for standard TVs in that it will fill the entire frame without any black bars. It's ironic that the WS version that people are in a fuss over is really sort of designed to ape the full-screen version, just for people who have HDTVs.
#17
Banned
Join Date: Mar 2004
Location: Pacific Northwest
Posts: 925
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by droidguy1119
Theoretically, the 1.78:1 ratio designed for the Blu-Ray version is intended, obviously, to create the same effect as the FS version is for standard TVs in that it will fill the entire frame without any black bars. It's ironic that the WS version that people are in a fuss over is really sort of designed to ape the full-screen version, just for people who have HDTVs.
But the rub is that intent for the BR makes the 16x9 the intended version whether they cut it down for standard 4x3 TV or not. Additionally, there will be more "made for TV movies" that will made to be shown on both HD and convnetional 4x3 TV's.
IMO the correct call here, until 4x3 is totally gone, is the HD (16x9) verison is the OAR. Otherise, most of the primetime TV we watch these days also do not have a 16x9 OAR since they are filmed with 4x3 in mind. In fact, in this case, that extra area is not likely dead space. You likely get more of the performances and backgrounds in the 16x9 HSM2.
Lastly, people were upset that other TV releases (that were shot in 16x9) were released in 4x3. People did not accept that 4x3 was the OAR because they were broadcast in 4x3. They wanted the ORIGINAL 16x9.
Last edited by cardaway; 12-13-07 at 01:15 PM.
#18
DVD Talk Special Edition
Join Date: May 2003
Posts: 1,186
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by hotsexyboi
Nope, no widescreen available on DVD just crappy fullscreen which is really not a surprise considering it is Disney.
#19
DVD Talk Legend
Originally Posted by cardaway
But the rub is that intent for the BR makes the 16x9 the intended version..
You're deducing this from.. what, again?
#20
Banned
Join Date: Mar 2004
Location: Pacific Northwest
Posts: 925
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by PixyJunket
Wow. Just.. wow.
You're deducing this from.. what, again?
You're deducing this from.. what, again?
Last edited by cardaway; 12-13-07 at 01:27 PM.
#21
DVD Talk Hero
You know, there are plenty of couter-examples to this. Plenty of "widescreen" movies that are shown open matte on SD. Does that mean that they were intended to be 4x3 the entire time because they were going to SD?
#22
Banned
Join Date: Mar 2004
Location: Pacific Northwest
Posts: 925
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by Amel
I'm not postive but I think Disney releases all of their dvd's in "family friendly OAR". They seem to be doing the same here as the SD version shown on SD tv was 4:3 and the HD version shown on HDTV was widescreen. Therefore, SD dvd = 4:3 and the BRD = 16x9.
It's not like I'm looking to buy HSM2, but personally I am concerned that Disney (and it would appear many others) think it's acceptable to release something clearly filmed in HD 16x9 in cropped 4x3 simply because that's where they broadcast it first. What if it had premiered in HD on ABC during primetime? (which IMO would have been a better idea)
#23
Banned
Join Date: Mar 2004
Location: Pacific Northwest
Posts: 925
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by pinata242
You know, there are plenty of couter-examples to this. Plenty of "widescreen" movies that are shown open matte on SD. Does that mean that they were intended to be 4x3 the entire time because they were going to SD?
#24
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Join Date: Jun 1999
Location: Part of the Left-Wing Conspiracy
Posts: 7,535
Received 202 Likes
on
117 Posts
I am of the belief that in this case, EITHER version is "correct". They shot it in advance knowing it would be shown both ways, and it premiered in 4x3 and then in HD 16x9. Either one "works" Both are "correct".
BTW, I hate it when people throw around "Foolscreen" like it's some insult to anyone that buys 4x3. I have been a OAR fan since Laserdisc was around, but don't assume that just because it's 4x3 it's somehow stupid or incorrect. In this case it's fine. I'm sure they filmed it KNOWING it would be shown both ways and made the choice to frame it accordingly.
BTW, I hate it when people throw around "Foolscreen" like it's some insult to anyone that buys 4x3. I have been a OAR fan since Laserdisc was around, but don't assume that just because it's 4x3 it's somehow stupid or incorrect. In this case it's fine. I'm sure they filmed it KNOWING it would be shown both ways and made the choice to frame it accordingly.
#25
Banned
Join Date: Mar 2004
Location: Pacific Northwest
Posts: 925
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by Chrisedge
I am of the belief that in this case, EITHER version is "correct". They shot it in advance knowing it would be shown both ways, and it premiered in 4x3 and then in HD 16x9. Either one "works" Both are "correct".
BTW, I hate it when people throw around "Foolscreen" like it's some insult to anyone that buys 4x3. I have been a OAR fan since Laserdisc was around, but don't assume that just because it's 4x3 it's somehow stupid or incorrect. In this case it's fine. I'm sure they filmed it KNOWING it would be shown both ways and made the choice to frame it accordingly.