Do the Star Trek movies stand alone from the TV series?
#1
Banned
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jan 2006
Posts: 6,584
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Do the Star Trek movies stand alone from the TV series?
Believe it or not, but I have never seen any of the Star Trek TV shows or movies. For some unexplainable reason, I just decided that I want to get into them. Do I need to watch the TV shows in order to understand the movies, or can I just jump straight into the movies? Looking on wikipedia, I see that there are four or five different TV series. Are they all good, or are there some to avoid?
#3
DVD Talk Legend
The first 6 movies definitely take place after the series. The original series was a five-year mission, and with the first ST movie, James Kirk is now an admiral stationed on Earth...and all the subsequent movies go from there.
I assume the Next Generation movies also take place after the series.
It's not absolutely imperative to watch the different series first, but it would definitely help, if for nothing else than to introduce you to the characters. There's also lots of references in the movies to the original series they were spawned from, so that's another reason to watch the series first. For example, the movie Star Trek II: The Wrath of Khan will make more sense if you go back and watch the original episode to find out what happened to Khan.
I assume the Next Generation movies also take place after the series.
It's not absolutely imperative to watch the different series first, but it would definitely help, if for nothing else than to introduce you to the characters. There's also lots of references in the movies to the original series they were spawned from, so that's another reason to watch the series first. For example, the movie Star Trek II: The Wrath of Khan will make more sense if you go back and watch the original episode to find out what happened to Khan.
#4
DVD Talk Godfather
Join Date: Apr 1999
Location: Gateway Cities/Harbor Region
Posts: 63,126
Received 1,748 Likes
on
1,093 Posts
And you have to watch DS9 to figure out why the 60's TV Klingons look so different from Klingons in the movies and the ones on all the recent Trek Series.
#5
DVD Talk Gold Edition
My general answer would be yes. However, Star Trek II: The Wrath of Khan and Star Trek: First Contact are sequels of sorts to episodes from their respective series. However, my enjoyment of TWOK was not hampered by the fact that I had never seen "Space Seed", the episode that introduced Khan.
#6
DVD Talk Legend
My exposure to Star Trek started with The Motion Picture in 1979, but it was Star Trek II that made me a lifelong fan and got me to go back and watch all the episodes.
So Star Trek II is a GREAT starting point for "newbies". The fact that it remains the best of the 10 motion pictures, doesn't hurt, either.
So Star Trek II is a GREAT starting point for "newbies". The fact that it remains the best of the 10 motion pictures, doesn't hurt, either.
#7
Originally Posted by Cartload
My general answer would be yes. However, Star Trek II: The Wrath of Khan and Star Trek: First Contact are sequels of sorts to episodes from their respective series. However, my enjoyment of TWOK was not hampered by the fact that I had never seen "Space Seed", the episode that introduced Khan.
#8
DVD Talk Legend
Originally Posted by The_Infidel
The first 6 movies definitely take place after the series. The original series was a five-year mission, and with the first ST movie, James Kirk is now an admiral stationed on Earth...and all the subsequent movies go from there.
I assume the Next Generation movies also take place after the series.
I assume the Next Generation movies also take place after the series.
That's actually a good thing and a bad thing IMHO, in that you don't have to have watched all the previous stuff to understand, but then after you do watch it, you may find yourself going "well, why didn't they...?" more than once.
#9
DVD Talk Special Edition
I would say if possible track down "Space Seed" from the original series, then watch movies II-IV as they demonstrate the epic storytelling that Trek was capable of in its heyday. After that go straight to VI; you can go back and watch the motion picture and star trek V after you've seen the best of the best.
I enjoyed Generations but never enjoyed the next generation movies after that at all (not even fan favorite 'first contact'). To me, they lacked the grand sweeping storytelling of the original cast when they made the jump from tv to the big screen. While I enjoyed Generations, it's not a fan favorite at all and I would never recommend the ones after it.
Michael
I enjoyed Generations but never enjoyed the next generation movies after that at all (not even fan favorite 'first contact'). To me, they lacked the grand sweeping storytelling of the original cast when they made the jump from tv to the big screen. While I enjoyed Generations, it's not a fan favorite at all and I would never recommend the ones after it.
Michael
#10
DVD Talk Special Edition
Join Date: Jul 2000
Location: Central Jersey
Posts: 1,195
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by brainee
Ironically, I would say that the 2 movies that are sequels to episodes are the best places for newbies to start. Because they work so well as flat-out exciting sci-fi adventures. Sure you'll be missing the depth of the characters that fans had, and gave some moments greater emotional impact. But it's a good litmus test - if you watch these 2 movies and remain unimpressed, it's safe to say that the Star Trek universe is not for you. If you do like them, then you have hundreds of hours of ST to dive into afterward (with the understanding that, like everything, there are ups and downs along the way).
Last edited by DarthMarino; 02-19-07 at 04:58 PM.
#11
DVD Talk Legend
Originally Posted by fiver
I would say if possible track down "Space Seed" from the original series, then watch movies II-IV as they demonstrate the epic storytelling that Trek was capable of in its heyday. After that go straight to VI; you can go back and watch the motion picture and star trek V after you've seen the best of the best.
#12
DVD Talk Hero
If you can track down some of the best of the tv show that have been released recently, (esspecially the borg best of) you'll enjoy it more and won't have to spend hundreds of dollars on these sets.
#13
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Originally Posted by starman9000
I wish I would've tried this. I got all the movies for cheap, but hadn't seen the show. I found the first movie tedious (and I usually like even bad sci-fi) so I just sold everything. I guess I should've watched the second one.
If you're going to start watching the movies cold, Star Trek II: The Wrath of Khan isn't just the best place to start, it's the only place to start.
#14
Originally Posted by DarthMarino
I've seen some of the Next Generation but it didn't really grab me so a friend has lent me a few of the movies. When I finish the original series I'll check a few out.
#15
DVD Talk Special Edition
Join Date: Jul 2000
Location: Central Jersey
Posts: 1,195
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by brainee
ST:TNG doesn't hit its stride few a couple of seasons. Some of the early episodes are actually quite bad - some stories directly ripping off a ST:TOS episode, and they hadn't quite figured out what the new characters are about. The second season introduces the Borg, and in the 3rd season is when consistently good episodes are made (culminating in the incredible "Best of Both Worlds", of the "First Contact" movie is a sequel to). Have patience with it.
Last edited by DarthMarino; 02-19-07 at 06:01 PM.
#16
Originally Posted by DarthMarino
But if I check out a few of the Next Generation movies first (maybe Generations as a way to hand the torch off or First Contact which seems to get the best reviews) would that be a good indication of the quality of the series? The original series and its set of movies do feel different but I felt right at home jumping in after seeing the six films. I don't think I actually know anybody who owns the Next Generation seasons and I'm not sure I would risk just buying it. I suppose there are other means to acquiring the episodes but I can't really get into something when I'm watching it on my computer.
#18
DVD Talk Legend
I have to warn you: By the third movie, almost everything is in Klingon without subtitles. You see, Trekoids (the official term for Star Trek enthusiasts) are very hardcore, and virtually all Trekoids know how to speak Klingon.
Most of TNG is in a new form of English that was made exclusively for the series.
Most of TNG is in a new form of English that was made exclusively for the series.
#19
DVD Talk Legend
Join Date: Jun 2000
Location: NYC
Posts: 17,015
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Taffer, you don't need to watch the series. Just start with Star Trek: The Motion Picture and go from there. Star Trek II, IV, VI, and First Contact are the highlights of the series (II is a dramatic improvement over the first one), but watch them all, in order.
#20
Cool New Member
Join Date: May 2006
Posts: 34
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by al_bundy
just watch the even numbered movies
Hell, it's probably my second-favourite TOS film.
#21
DVD Talk Legend
Originally Posted by Ian Whitcombe
No. Star Trek III is the integral second part of the trilogy that is Star Trek II, III and IV. Besides, the movie is also the significant exception when it comes to the "odd-numbered curse".
Hell, it's probably my second-favourite TOS film.
Hell, it's probably my second-favourite TOS film.
"Kirk, you do this and you'll never sit in a captain's chair again..."
"Warp Speed!"
I would also suggest the odd-numbered Star Trek: Generations is underrated (the seventh film). It's choppy, but Shatner gives one hell of a good performance.
#22
DVD Talk Hero
my review
1 - OK but a little long. basically made for TV movie
2 - awesome
3 - OK but the plot is a little way out there with the planet healing spock
4 - fun movie but the worst even numbered one
5 - only watch it since you have to as part of the series. first part is OK, killing God with a photon torpedo is not
6 - great movie second only to #2
this is where the odd/even thing ends. after this they are worse than the odds
7 - OK but too much hype of passing the torch and not really doing it. like a lot of NG a lot of the dialogue is forced like picard telling data every little thing to look at to find the heaven thing
8 - was this insurrection? i forget
9 through whatever. don't even remember the names
1 - OK but a little long. basically made for TV movie
2 - awesome
3 - OK but the plot is a little way out there with the planet healing spock
4 - fun movie but the worst even numbered one
5 - only watch it since you have to as part of the series. first part is OK, killing God with a photon torpedo is not
6 - great movie second only to #2
this is where the odd/even thing ends. after this they are worse than the odds
7 - OK but too much hype of passing the torch and not really doing it. like a lot of NG a lot of the dialogue is forced like picard telling data every little thing to look at to find the heaven thing
8 - was this insurrection? i forget
9 through whatever. don't even remember the names
#23
DVD Talk Legend
TNG movies
7/Generations: The passing of the torch. It's kinda shaky, but it's still got some fun bits to it.
8/First Contact: Pretty much the best of the Next Gen bunch. Picard as Ahab vs The Borg.
9/Insurrection, starts to go downhill here. A retelling of Who Watches the Watchers? from the series, but not nearly as good.
10/Nemesis: even I have seen this one. Apparently deals with Romulan vampires or something.
7/Generations: The passing of the torch. It's kinda shaky, but it's still got some fun bits to it.
8/First Contact: Pretty much the best of the Next Gen bunch. Picard as Ahab vs The Borg.
9/Insurrection, starts to go downhill here. A retelling of Who Watches the Watchers? from the series, but not nearly as good.
10/Nemesis: even I have seen this one. Apparently deals with Romulan vampires or something.
#24
DVD Talk Legend
My take:
1 - Quickly throw together because Paramount needed a Star Wars clone. For a production plagued with problems, it's better than it has any right to be. The DVD cut is the best version yet.
2 - The true highpoint of not only the Trek movies, but the entire Trek universe. Tight SPFX, good story, lots of action, and real character development. Not just a good sci-fi movie, but a good movie.
3 - An odd followup to Khan, but worthwhile. They had to bring Spock back, and it's better than some kind of parallel universe/time travel/all a dream story.
4 - Another good movie, although it's mostly an excuse to have fun with the characters.
5 - Garbage.
6 - A solid story and a nice way to wrap up the series. They could have easily done two or three more movies like 5 to cash in, but they took the classy route and retired gracefully. Well, most of them did anyhow.
7 - I've always thought that the entire TNG movie arch was done more out of a sense of obligation than anything else. After all, the original cast got to do movies, why not these guys? Never mind that TNG had a full seven seasons to tell their stories. That said, the idea to tie the two series together was handled fairly well.
8 - The obligatory Borg movie was pretty good, but tying in yet another historical figure (especially one that contradicts canon) may have been overkill. The character development was much clunkier than the TOS movies, but so are the characters themselves.
9 - Garbage.
10 - Good movie with an interesting villian, but the ending seemed tacked on simply to finish the franchise, as opposed to 6, where the entire story dealt with endings and change. And no sign of the promised naked Deanna
1 - Quickly throw together because Paramount needed a Star Wars clone. For a production plagued with problems, it's better than it has any right to be. The DVD cut is the best version yet.
2 - The true highpoint of not only the Trek movies, but the entire Trek universe. Tight SPFX, good story, lots of action, and real character development. Not just a good sci-fi movie, but a good movie.
3 - An odd followup to Khan, but worthwhile. They had to bring Spock back, and it's better than some kind of parallel universe/time travel/all a dream story.
4 - Another good movie, although it's mostly an excuse to have fun with the characters.
5 - Garbage.
6 - A solid story and a nice way to wrap up the series. They could have easily done two or three more movies like 5 to cash in, but they took the classy route and retired gracefully. Well, most of them did anyhow.
7 - I've always thought that the entire TNG movie arch was done more out of a sense of obligation than anything else. After all, the original cast got to do movies, why not these guys? Never mind that TNG had a full seven seasons to tell their stories. That said, the idea to tie the two series together was handled fairly well.
8 - The obligatory Borg movie was pretty good, but tying in yet another historical figure (especially one that contradicts canon) may have been overkill. The character development was much clunkier than the TOS movies, but so are the characters themselves.
9 - Garbage.
10 - Good movie with an interesting villian, but the ending seemed tacked on simply to finish the franchise, as opposed to 6, where the entire story dealt with endings and change. And no sign of the promised naked Deanna
Last edited by Jason; 02-24-07 at 10:15 AM.
#25
DVD Talk Hero
Originally Posted by DarthMarino
But if I check out a few of the Next Generation movies first (maybe Generations as a way to hand the torch off or First Contact which seems to get the best reviews) would that be a good indication of the quality of the series? The original series and its set of movies do feel different but I felt right at home jumping in after seeing the six films. I don't think I actually know anybody who owns the Next Generation seasons and I'm not sure I would risk just buying it. I suppose there are other means to acquiring the episodes but I can't really get into something when I'm watching it on my computer.