magiccmom

When It Isn't Like It Should Be

fresh Wednesday, Apr 5 8/7c

Rachel (Danneel Harris) invites the gang to her family's cabin for a weekend getaway. Lucas (Chad Michael Murray), Brooke (Sophia Bush) and Nathan (James Lafferty) conspire to surprise Haley (Bethany Joy) while Peyton (Hilarie Burton) receives an unexpected visitor (guest star Wentz) at the cabin. Mouth (Lee Norris) harbors resentment towards Rachel, and a game of "I Never" reveals a secret. Meanwhile, Karen (Moira Kelly) confronts Dan (Paul Johansson) about Keith's (Craig Sheffer) death. Barbara Alyn Woods and Barry Corbin also star.


Come on! I just had to comment about the "doing a Brooke" and the whole masturbating theme. I was def. about that one!

Gizmo

Lets all have fun after Keith got killed! Awesome!

Red Dog

The "Brooke" comments were great.

So what's Rachel's family secret?

Doughboy

I was thinking there were sex toys in there or something. They've already kinda done the "Rachel has a secret" subplot with her confession to Mouth, so I hope they don't go down that road again.

As for the episode, it was one of the better ones this season(not that that's saying much). I do wish they'd keep things lighter on this show and tonight was a good start(Karen's scene with Dan notwithstanding). The shot of the girls and Fall Out Boy dude putting on makeup was classic.

I'll dock them a few points though for having Rachel in the hot tub and not giving us a decent look at her. She was either in the water or had Mouth in the way.

Ayre

Seeing Brooke in a bikini, made me want to Brooke myself.

Fall Out Boy needs to fall out of the show.

Nice eyecandy episode. Not a lot plot-wise. Oh yipee a wedding *yawn*. I agree that the show takes itself too seriously, but at least it has something going on. This episode could easily not have existed. It served only as a reset button.

Doughboy

I don't know about that. For Rachel and Mouth maybe. But there's still plenty of tension between Karen and Dan. You know by season's end, either she or Deb will be pointing a gun at the dude.

No argument on Fall Out Boy. That band and Sunkist need to go now!

boogieman03

Loved seeing Karen go off on Dan. Dan's eyes got HUGE when Karen said, "you killed Keith, you may have not pulled the trigger....". I thought it was hilarious.

Brooke in bikini....very nice.

Patman

Brooke did everything to not show her bikini top. Wassup wid dat?