Forgive me if this has already been answered or talked about.
Does Vader ever realize that Leia is his daughter? B/c in ROTJ all he says to Luke is that he realizes that he has a twin sister and to "Tell your sister you were right." Neither he or Luke ever bring up Leia's name. so does he die not knowing who his daughter is or does he realize it before?
And also wouldn't it be difficult for Luke and Leia to trace themselves back to Padme? During her funeral she was buried as pregnant to keep the twins safe i suppose. So everyone there would think that she died pregnant. If the twins came back to Naboo everyone would be in the dark aobut their birth even her parents since it was kept secret.
Groucho
05-22-05, 06:39 PM
And what's the deal with Padme's shitty OB-GYN? They can fly at light speed but they can't figure out she's having twins?
daddydaryl
05-22-05, 06:48 PM
And what's the deal with Padme's shitty OB-GYN? They can fly at light speed but they can't figure out she's having twins?
Ultrasound wasn't invented until ESB if I remember correctly :scratch2: :wacko:
silentbob007
05-22-05, 08:39 PM
Even in the womb, Luke's abilities overshadowed Leia's ....
Jackskeleton
05-22-05, 08:46 PM
Wow, we really are reaching for the questions, aren't we?
And also wouldn't it be difficult for Luke and Leia to trace themselves back to Padme?
What's the point? Luke knows his father is Vader. Trace back who Anakin was with and bam! Besides that, spirit obi could have very well told him that.
EvilEyes
05-25-05, 04:29 PM
Hey after ROTJ spirit Ani might tell him ........
Daytrip
05-25-05, 05:00 PM
if Vader knows that Luke has a TWIN sister that kind of tells me he knows it's his daughter.....call me crazy
Josh H
05-25-05, 05:04 PM
Vader sensed Luke thinking about her during their duel in ROTJ. He tells him something like "So, you have a twin sister. You're feelings have betrayed you...."
Josh H
05-25-05, 05:04 PM
And what's the deal with Padme's shitty OB-GYN? They can fly at light speed but they can't figure out she's having twins?
Maybe since she was keeping it a secret she didn't even to go an OB-GYN.
Fok
05-25-05, 06:52 PM
What's more disturbing is didn't Luke have the hots for Leia in Ep4?
bboisvert
05-25-05, 07:21 PM
if Vader knows that Luke has a TWIN sister that kind of tells me he knows it's his daughter.....call me crazy
That wasn't the question. Obviously Vader knows Luke's sister is Vader's child as well...
The question was does he know that this 'sister' in question is Leia. And we don't have a definitely answer... although I'd say the odd point to 'yes'. Vader taunts Luke that his feelings for his 'friends' are strong. Luke then thinks of Leia. Vader then learns that Luke has a twin sister. Luke obviously isn't thinking in generic terms -- he's thinking speicifically of Leia. I have to believe that Vader picked up on that.
Although, obviously this is guesswork. Anakin/Luke never refer to her by name within each other's company.
Giles
05-26-05, 12:52 PM
Forgive me if this has already been answered or talked about.
Does Vader ever realize that Leia is his daughter? B/c in ROTJ all he says to Luke is that he realizes that he has a twin sister and to "Tell your sister you were right." Neither he or Luke ever bring up Leia's name. so does he die not knowing who his daughter is or does he realize it before?
And also wouldn't it be difficult for Luke and Leia to trace themselves back to Padme? During her funeral she was buried as pregnant to keep the twins safe i suppose. So everyone there would think that she died pregnant. If the twins came back to Naboo everyone would be in the dark aobut their birth even her parents since it was kept secret.
ya know they always say that women shouldn't fly in planes where they pregnant... sheesh -ohbfrank- ... ;)
beatccr
05-29-05, 05:00 PM
have there been any expanded universe novels about either luke or leia or anyone for that matter going back to naboo? i know that in "Tatooine Ghost" leia goes back to tatooine and finds about anakin as a young boy.
Buy: