I saw the SE out early at Sam Goody and noticed the R rating on the packaging.
Does anyone know if this will be the uncut versionwhere the decapitation sequence is not obscured?
A nice widescreen version of the uncensored release has aired on IFC before. I hope that is the print MGM is using. The P&S version aired on the other cable channels also featured the uncut decapitation. But the old R rated video and laserdisc release had it obscured.
manicsounds
11-28-04, 10:11 PM
uncut. 100% approved by david lynch.
bluesparrow
11-29-04, 01:44 AM
Perhaps it was resubmitted to the MPAA to take advantage of the post-Tarantino levels of acceptable film violence. Violence-wise it isn't any worse than a hard R today.
Julie Walker
11-29-04, 03:07 AM
No since no new listing/rating info is listed on filmratings.com
So it is just another magically 'fake' R rated dvd;)
I was just making sure. Since while MGM releases some uncensored versions with a 'fake' rating on the packaging(fake since the verision was never resubmitted and officially rated). They have released a few censored versions only like Death Wish 2 and Dream Lover(which was available uncut on VHS & laserdisc!).
I do agree it could pass uncut with an R today(the decap is literally only a couple seconds anyway),unless the even more grotestque footage(Stantons original death scene) were included. But sadly Lynch doesn't like deleted footage being scene after being cut. Which is a shame,since Don May found the longer print a couple years ago in a vault somewhere.
scarredgod
11-29-04, 08:08 PM
mike dunn reviewed the new DVD on his lynchnet.com website, it was also posted at the dugpa.com website. though it doesnt mention it in the review, this is what he wrote on the message board regarding this DVD...
"The haze is present on the new dvd as well. They even discuss it in the making of section. It was added to allow an R rating from the MPAA."
Julie Walker
11-29-04, 09:41 PM
Well that sucks,especially after seeing its splattery outrageousness on cable!!!! :(
kane
11-30-04, 11:17 AM
That's bad news :( I've already canceled my pre-order, too many dvds to buy to spend $$$ on censored ones.
auto
11-30-04, 12:23 PM
That sucks but this is still a nice package. I'll be picking it up and putting it right next to my "blurred" Mulholland Drive DVD.
William Fuld
11-30-04, 12:39 PM
NO SPLATTERY OUTRAGEOUSNESS = NO SALE!
Geofferson
11-30-04, 12:40 PM
Too bad Blue Underground couldn't release it. :(
Apocrypha
11-30-04, 12:54 PM
While this is not good news, I suppose we are lucky to have a Reg1 release at all to throw on the old LYNCH shelf. Life is too short and Lynch's films too great to let a little blur get in the way of enjoying his work.
I am truly torn on this one as I have been anticipating this release for some time.
Anyone have any info on other Reg releases of WAH?
Josh Z
11-30-04, 05:11 PM
Originally posted by kane
That's bad news :( I've already canceled my pre-order, too many dvds to buy to spend $$$ on censored ones.
Don't be stupid. The movie isn't censored. Lynch added a smoke effect over the shot to slighly obscure the gore. It's not like there's a big black box over the shot.
The unobscured gore looks fake, anyway. The smoke effect adds an interesting texture and is consistent with the movie's recurring themes of smoking and fire. I prefer the smoky version, IMO.
matome
11-30-04, 05:16 PM
Originally posted by William Fuld
NO SPLATTERY OUTRAGEOUSNESS = NO SALE!
Buy: