Anyone else upset that *********************** is gone from American Idol? SPOILERS!

[Y2JFan81]

I am upset that Matt is gone. His humor was awesome. I knew he wouldn't make it to the end, but I didn't except him gone this early. I really thought Camille would get the boot being down there two weeks in a row. Also, I don't care for Fantasia's voice. It sounds to much like Macy Gray with that whiney sound.

Y2JFan81

[Struz]

Already being discussed here:

http://www.dvdtalk.com/forum/showthread.php?threadid=354383&perpage=25&pagenumber=5

[Y2K Falcon]

rotfl Like he has any fans! :lol:




Also, thanks for the spoiler title. I just got home and was about to turn on the tivo... :grunt:

[Corleone]

Ever heard of time zones?

[Copenhagen]

I see his point, very similar to this (http://www.dvdtalk.com/forum/showthread.php?s=&threadid=211933).

[criptik28]

Doh! -rolleyes-

Edit: It's only 4:20 pm here!

[TwineTime]

To be fair, he could be wrong about this spoiler. He thinks Camile was in the bottom 3 last week.

[WhoGirl]

You sir, are a dirty rat bastard. :mad: Stupid spoiler title...

[waporvare]

yeah I tivoed it but hadn't watched it yet. Thanks a lot.

[RandyC]

Dude.... really now.

Edited title. Sorry for those who already saw it.

[gettinbranded]

More asterisks are needed in that thread title---he has the shortest name of the 12.

[RandyC]

rotfl

Fine. :)

[Copenhagen]

rotfl good work Randy :up:

[gettinbranded]

WOW!

[gettinbranded]

Originally posted by Y2JFan81
I am upset that Matt is gone. His humor was awesome.

His singing wasn't.

Also, I don't care for Fantasia's voice.
Y2JFan81

The pros think she's a star in the making.

AI has become a popularity contest though. It's not about the singing so much anymore.

[Deftones]

why doesn't the thread originator have that spoiler tag in their name now? I thought that was the punishment for putting spoilers in thread titles.

[big whoppa]

This doesn't deserve to be a seperate thread. After saying that, no, I'm not upset. Matt deserved the boot. The voters did something right.

[criptik28]

Damn, 3 of the posts in this thread need spoilers.

[Groucho]

Originally posted by criptik28
Edit: It's only 4:20 pm here! Hey man, it's ALWAYS 4:20 here. Heh heh heh.

[Static Cling]

Originally posted by Deftones, Esq
why doesn't the thread originator have that spoiler tag in their name now? I thought that was the punishment for putting spoilers in thread titles. It's nothing official, just something I thought of. Closing duplicate thread.