SACD / DVD-A - Talk me into it (or out of it)
#1
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Thread Starter
SACD / DVD-A - Talk me into it (or out of it)
Okay, with the decently priced Pioneer player that plays both SACD and DVD-A, and some better titles now available, I am now tempted to get into this.
I have an Onkyo reciever, and JBL speakers. I have a couple of those DTS audio disks, but am only slightly impressed with them; yeah, it sounds a bit better than a regular cd, but not miles better, to my ears.
So, my question is... How big of an improvement is SACD and DVD-A over regular cds and DTS cds?
With SACD/DVD-A, will I sit back and say "Wow! this is amazing!" when I listen ?
I have an Onkyo reciever, and JBL speakers. I have a couple of those DTS audio disks, but am only slightly impressed with them; yeah, it sounds a bit better than a regular cd, but not miles better, to my ears.
So, my question is... How big of an improvement is SACD and DVD-A over regular cds and DTS cds?
With SACD/DVD-A, will I sit back and say "Wow! this is amazing!" when I listen ?
#4
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Join Date: Jan 2002
Location: Portland, Oregon
Posts: 2,847
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Are there many albums out on either of these formats that you really want? That's what it really comes down to I'd say. What's holding a lot of people back is a lack of selection that interests them, no reason to buy now if you aren't going to use it. I only own one strictly for Pink Floyds Dark Side of the Moon hehe.
#6
DVD Talk Limited Edition
For me, once I buy a nice high end player, the choice will be SACD in the end. The only downfall of DVD-A that I don't like at all is you have to have the display device/TV on to navigate through the disc. SACD you don't need a display device on, and they come with a 2 channel track so you can play it in a regular CD player as well. Both sound really good, and will be the future of home/car music. Just my $0.02.
#7
Senior Member
Join Date: Dec 2002
Posts: 269
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
the myth about having to use your display for DVD-A is just that, a myth.
use your audio button on your remote to switch audio tracks (either 2ch or multi), and 99% of the time, you just need to hit play when the disc reads.
use your audio button on your remote to switch audio tracks (either 2ch or multi), and 99% of the time, you just need to hit play when the disc reads.
#8
Senior Member
Join Date: Aug 2003
Location: Twin Cities, MN
Posts: 826
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I don't listen to music at home enough to justify buying very many SACS/DVD-A's. But the ones that I have picked up are truly amazing.
One thing that I'll mention, just to make sure you don't get caught off guard - all SACD's are not surround sound. Somewhere on the back of the case, it will mention something to the effect of "multi-channel" or "stereo" for the non multi-channel. I've read a lot of people post trying to figure out what's wrong with their setup when they simply bought a stereo SACD. Now ya know! (if you didn't already)
One thing that I'll mention, just to make sure you don't get caught off guard - all SACD's are not surround sound. Somewhere on the back of the case, it will mention something to the effect of "multi-channel" or "stereo" for the non multi-channel. I've read a lot of people post trying to figure out what's wrong with their setup when they simply bought a stereo SACD. Now ya know! (if you didn't already)
#9
DVD Talk Hero
Re: SACD / DVD-A - Talk me into it (or out of it)
Originally posted by TheMadMonk
With SACD/DVD-A, will I sit back and say "Wow! this is amazing!" when I listen ?
With SACD/DVD-A, will I sit back and say "Wow! this is amazing!" when I listen ?
Oh, and check out the Music Forum for recommendations and other threads about DVD-A and SACD.
#10
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Join Date: Jun 2002
Location: Manassas, VA
Posts: 2,550
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I got the Pio 563A before Xmas and I was blown away with the quality. Listening to DVD-A of Linkin Park, Disturbed and Phish and they all sounded amazing.. I highly recommend ti.
#11
Member
Join Date: May 2002
Location: rocky mountains, colorado
Posts: 105
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
SACD receiver question
I am considering a purchase of a pioneer player - primarily because it allows sacd playback, and just the stereo remasters on these suckers are exciting (dylan primarily) - can't wait to hear them in their full sacd glory.
My question- do i need a special receiver (and/or speakers) to really get this thing going - or will any good surround receiver work?
Can anyone recommend good - yet inexpensive receiver for surround and sacd playback?
gracias.
eddie
My question- do i need a special receiver (and/or speakers) to really get this thing going - or will any good surround receiver work?
Can anyone recommend good - yet inexpensive receiver for surround and sacd playback?
gracias.
eddie
#13
New Member
Join Date: Mar 2004
Posts: 1
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I have yet to hear any DVD-A or SACD. I was in a couple of high end audio shops today, and would you believe none had a DVD-A, or a SACD I could listen to?! I'm thinking of purchasing the Denon 2200. I've read only good reviews about it so far (some people would say it is too costly), but I would regard it as an investment if it performs as well as people are saying in both sound and picture quality. Regarding SACD sound, some people are complaining about some being recorded only for 2 channels. I would regard this as a possible plus in some cases, and as I am generally more interested in the sound than the picture I don't think it would matter much if I were listening to multi versus 2 channel playback. I would expect even a 2 channel SACD, to sound richer/better than a regular CD recording. Is this technology a preference thing (primarily)? Is there really a big difference between reguler CD and DVD-A/SACD (like a night and day kind of thing?). I am thinking of buying "Dark Side of the Moon" (SACD version) and head out to these shops again to give this technology a try. Nothing ventured nothing gained.
Yours truly,
the dude
Yours truly,
the dude
Last edited by dudefromspanish; 03-17-04 at 09:06 PM.
#16
DVD Talk Reviewer
I've been wanting to get into DVD-Audio and SACD for awhile now (hence the thread resurrection ), but I still need talked into it, too. Specifically, what's the most versatile player at the best price right now?
#17
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Join Date: Mar 2002
Location: Mpls, MN
Posts: 6,830
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Pioneer 588A. Assuming you meant inexpensive. Best all-around DVDp is still the Denon 2900, no longer made. Could possibly find one in the $500 range open box or something.
If you don't have the processor-amp-speakers to benefit, well, there's not much benefit. But the wonderful, full-range surround sound of either of these is just engulfing when it's good.
If you don't have the processor-amp-speakers to benefit, well, there's not much benefit. But the wonderful, full-range surround sound of either of these is just engulfing when it's good.
#18
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Originally Posted by Randy Miller III
I've been wanting to get into DVD-Audio and SACD for awhile now (hence the thread resurrection ), but I still need talked into it, too. Specifically, what's the most versatile player at the best price right now?
#19
DVD Talk Reviewer
Dead format or not, there are a few SACD/DVD-Audio compatible discs in my collection that I'd love to hear---and having a backup DVD player wouldn't hurt either.
#20
Senior Member
Join Date: May 2004
Posts: 610
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I'm a fan of early Elton John. I've been listening to the SACD reissues of "Elton John," "Tumbleweed Connection," and "Madman Across the Water," which are available from Yourmusic.com for $5.99 each.
The sound is stunning. It's not just the surround, although opening up the sometimes dense mixes of these songs reveals an awful lot that used to be buried. It's the detail -- the reproduction of the original sound just as it sounded in the studio, exactly as it was captured on the master tape -- that removes the patina of decades and makes it all sound brand new.
And the dynamic range. My God, you'd never have known just how compressed even the remastered CDs were until you hear mixes designed for a medium that has almost no limitations on headroom. These are intricately layered arrangements, and Paul Buckmaster's orchestrations have a weight and density that has never been appreciable before, because they always had to be pushed back into the mix.
No more. If things need to get louder, they can get louder. If they need to be so soft as to be almost inaudible, they can be.
The clarity, dynamics, immersiveness, detail and drama of these recordings are miraculous. And it's really too bad that more people will never get to hear it.
RichC
The sound is stunning. It's not just the surround, although opening up the sometimes dense mixes of these songs reveals an awful lot that used to be buried. It's the detail -- the reproduction of the original sound just as it sounded in the studio, exactly as it was captured on the master tape -- that removes the patina of decades and makes it all sound brand new.
And the dynamic range. My God, you'd never have known just how compressed even the remastered CDs were until you hear mixes designed for a medium that has almost no limitations on headroom. These are intricately layered arrangements, and Paul Buckmaster's orchestrations have a weight and density that has never been appreciable before, because they always had to be pushed back into the mix.
No more. If things need to get louder, they can get louder. If they need to be so soft as to be almost inaudible, they can be.
The clarity, dynamics, immersiveness, detail and drama of these recordings are miraculous. And it's really too bad that more people will never get to hear it.
RichC
#21
Senior Member
Join Date: Jul 2003
Posts: 541
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Those $99 players at BB were probably the Samsung 8xx... I bought one and it was awful. Returned it and got the Pioneer 5xx from Circuit City, also $99 range. GREAT player.
And I don't think either format is dead, but could be a niche player. Hell, the new Beck CD just came out in SACD. How dead is that?
I've only got a few compatible discs so far, but the difference is incredible, and if you have the receiver, etc., you should definitely do it. All I've got so far are:
Flaming Lips : Yoshimi vs. the Pink Robots (DVD-A)
Pink Floyd: Dark Side of the Moon (SACD) (remember, this was originally recorded in quadraphonic)
Bjork : Verpertine (DVD-A)
And I don't think either format is dead, but could be a niche player. Hell, the new Beck CD just came out in SACD. How dead is that?
I've only got a few compatible discs so far, but the difference is incredible, and if you have the receiver, etc., you should definitely do it. All I've got so far are:
Flaming Lips : Yoshimi vs. the Pink Robots (DVD-A)
Pink Floyd: Dark Side of the Moon (SACD) (remember, this was originally recorded in quadraphonic)
Bjork : Verpertine (DVD-A)
#22
Senior Member
Join Date: May 2004
Posts: 610
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
That Flaming Lips disc is wild. There's one track where the entire 5-channel soundfield slowly rotates around the room. They also included the original CD as a separate disc, mostly because the Dualdisc format wasn't ready. I wonder if they'll re-release it on DD?
RichC
RichC
#23
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Originally Posted by gorgo99
Those $99 players at BB were probably the Samsung 8xx... I bought one and it was awful. Returned it and got the Pioneer 5xx from Circuit City, also $99 range. GREAT player.
And I don't think either format is dead, but could be a niche player. Hell, the new Beck CD just came out in SACD. How dead is that?
SACD and DVD-A have been abandoned and the new darling of the music industry is dual-disc. They love dual-disc because there is no content standard for the dvd side and the cd side doesn't meet CD specifications and cannot be labeled a CD. What a horseshit deal that is!