conscience

Didn't see a thread. Can't search (only three letters)

Did anybody watch this?

Happy for Six Feet Under (although this isn't a tv thread)

Shocked Johnny Depp won the award (not saying he was bad, but just was shocked)

What did you guys think?

Goldberg74

Thanks for starting the thread.

I too was shocked that Johnny Depp (not in attendence) won over Sean Penn (who actually showed up this time).

Other winners tonight:

Rene Zellwegger - Cold Mountain - Supporting Female Actor
Tim Robbins - Mystic River - Supporting Male Actor
Charlize Theron - Monster - Best Female Actor
The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King - Best Esemble

Goldberg74

Gimli bumps Samwise off his soapbox!

(Sean was getting political on bringing the industry back to the states and getting a little too long winded when John literally bumps him out of the way to introduce the Producer of the LORT, also a SAG member.)

conscience

conscience

Only one realy suprise in the bunch.

Which is better than nothing.

Shannon Nutt

I laughed when John Rhys-Davies pushed Sean Astin! I think he did what everyone else in the theater wanted to do to him.

Hey Sean! Here's a tip: the next time you want to encourage studios to shoot their films in America, DON'T do it when you're accepting an award for a film shot in NEW ZEALAND!

zekeburger1979

I hope Johnny's win tonight translates into a Best Actor award at the Oscars next week.

Shannon Nutt

Yes, and then we can watch Sean Penn and Bill Murray tag team him in the parking lot. Penn and Murray HAD to have split the voting...that's the only way Depp could have won.

Jackskeleton

no kidding. I was surprised depp won indeed.

Cornelius1047

I'm glad.

K

Teremei

Actually he bumped him when he was about to thank the 1000's of fans (US). Which I found quite rude.

wirebendr

I agree it was rude. I think that Astin has a point, but he was getting long-winded and the network was running out of time.

onebyone

I was rooting for Murray or Depp as best actor, and was pretty shocked when Depp one. I was happy too, I can't root against Johnny. Just isn't possible. Besides, he was super in POC, so I say more power to him.

QuiGonJosh

Christ...is it really that hard to play Keith Richards with some eye makeup? nah...

RyoHazuki

Stupid Johnny Depp. He will never reach the pinnacle of acting that the Star Wars movies have acheived.

Caoimhin

As an actor and SAG member, I appreciate the number of actors opposing overseas/foreign productions. Unfortunately, I don't see very many actively turning down projects in order to do so. I just see it as so much rhetoric from someone whose biggest project to date is a three-picture epic filmed entirely in New Zealand. I'm not a big fan of the "do as I say, not as I do" philosophy.

And it pains me that Peter Dinklage didn't win.

Groucho

Interesting results to be sure. I think Depp is less of a long-shot for Oscar night now.

Supreme Sean

So, if I star in an overly cute movie, and act all fay, and wave my hands around when I speak, I can win a SAG award for Best Actor too ?

Jackskeleton

The guy has paid his dues and has been overlooked in many other films where he deserved the nod while his costars were given it. Depp deserved it. Hell Imagine how sucky Pirates would have been without him?

Kal-El

Bah. Typical post-award DVDTalk backlash. Next thing you know you're all back to lauding him when he doesn't win the Oscar and that SeanPenn's or Bill Murray's performances weren't "all that".

Jackskeleton

I would gladly welcome depp winning as a just deserved win. Bill Murray and Penn both deserve it, though much like any award, there can only be one 1st place.

raven56706

This could mean alot though......


Last time, Halle Berry won for best Actress in the SAG's and then she won in the Oscars. The SAG's makes up 1700 members of the 5800 members of the oscars.


I am telling you guys.... it makes the Best Actor category alittle bit more interesting.

Peep

Maybe I'm confused about the concept of runaway productions, but my understanding is that the chief complaint is when movies (or television shows) that are set in the United States are filmed in another country and done so solely for financial reasons. If so, "Cold Mountain" would be an example of a runaway production, whereas "Lord of the Rings" (set in Middle Earth, not the USA) would not.

Groucho

On the flip side, there have been a lot more productions set in foreign countries that were actually filmed in some studio backlot in Los Angeles.

Charlie Goose

I didn't watch, but please tell me that someone gave the standard speech of, "This is the award that means the most because it's from my fellow ACTORS!"