joshd2012

This will be the final thread in the Best of Penny Arcade series. It features the top rated comics from each year, as well as some of the closer second place ones (some years, the difference between first and second was very slim). So here we go. This poll will stay open for 7 days and hopefully we will have a clear winner when all is said and done.

Best of Year One

Best of Year Two

Best of Year Three

Best of Year Four

Best of Year Five

Goldberg74

My Top Three:

1) The Hitting (voted for this one)

2) Why Elves Got to be Like That

3) Shenmue: Wow

SpacemanSpiff

i think my singing is funnier than any pa cartoon

fool

also know as blackmail is my #1 tho

squi23

i'd seen references to this "penny arcade" but never knew what it was about....
this is funny stuff!!!
I liked the Elves one!

My fav site 'o funnies is homestarrunner.com!!
but i'll definitely be bookmarking this one now.

joshd2012

It was really difficult, but I had to go with "Now You Know".

"The Hitting" was a very close second.

RoQuEr

was wondering what happened to this thread...

joshd2012

Haha... yeah. I wasn't trying to hold the poll over the holidays because I figured a lot of people who would want to vote would be on vacation. So I decided to hold off, and it just slipped from memory.

fumanstan

Voted for Halo... only a few were amusing. The rest are just vintage Penny Arcade (crap )

joshd2012

Only 33 Votes? Lets get some more votes on here.

*Bump*

BigPete

I think the "Why do they call him Cheeto?" comic from a week ago is the single greatest thing they have ever done.